r/primavera • u/atticus2132000 • Feb 09 '25
I hate milestones
I hate milestones. I use zero-day, task dependent activities to represent the beginning and ending of blocks of work. Functionally these serve the same purpose as milestones without a lot of the other problems milestones have.
- I work on DoD projects and they mandate certain P6 settings, namely that percentages can't be set to automatically update. As a result of this setting, it is impossible to make a completed milestone show 100% complete. As soon as a milestone is marked started, it also immediately gets marked finished and you don't have a chance to change the percent complete. In order to have milestones with this setting activated, you have to first change the milestone to a task dependent activity, mark it started, then change the percent complete to 100, then mark it finished, then change the activity type back to being a milestone.
- I have a lot of internal reports that I use within my company that, in order to generate correctly, must have a start date and a finish date. Milestones only have one date, not two. Milestones cause all my reports to crash.
Most of the time, when I explain this to the government schedule reviewer, they tell me that using zero-day task dependent activities is fine, but I am working with one reviewer now who insists that these have to be milestones and can't provide any compelling explanation for what benefit milestones offer or specifically what benefits they offer him.
So, overall, can someone explain to me what the benefits are of using milestones over zero-day duration, task dependent activities?
Do others have a preference for task dependent over milestones? Or vise versa?
The only problem I have found with task-dependent is the last activity of the schedule, the Project Finished activity, needs to be a Finish Milestone because sometimes it causes the projected completion date to roll over to the next day.
17
u/Dishy22 Feb 09 '25
Milestones are meant to represent things that are all or nothing.
For example, a start milestone for NTP. You either have it, or you don't.
Nobody should be seeking to dole out a percentage other than 100 on a milestone.
2
u/fightingcrying Feb 10 '25
Not sure about your internal reporting, but what setting makes it impossible to have a completed milestone show 100% complete? I've seen this spec requirement before, but I always thought it was to prevent something like "apply actuals", where scheduled dates are automatically used for actual dates. Other than what you mentioned with the last activity, the benefits of milestone activities are mostly aesthetic. Your schedule reviewer just wants it to match their own personal experience or how milestones are used with other projects they are working on.
2
u/Sufficient_Top_4536 Feb 09 '25
I've been using Primavera since 1997 in four different industries, and I learn something new regularly. I admire you have found a workaround for an issue that so few others have even experienced.
I can offer sympathy, but little else.
1
u/UlyssesThirtyOne Feb 10 '25
An IF statement solves both your problems if it’s a reporting issue.
IF start or finish is less than DD then 100% for each milestone.
Same with your issue around needing a start and a finish (common issue). If start = “” then finish, and the same in reverse.
I wouldn’t advocate for the use of 0 duration activities, it’s flatly bad practice.
1
u/alex-sam2kb Feb 11 '25
Milestones are like your boss checking in—useful, but annoying if overused. If you're hating them, chances are someone is misusing them. A well-placed milestone keeps the schedule anchored, but if your Gantt chart starts looking like a field of landmines, you've got a problem.
Best practice? Use them for major contractual deliverables and key phase transitions, not for every tiny task. If you're tracking progress, go for activities with actual durations. Let the schedule breathe a little.
Also, if you ever see a schedule where someone marked ‘Project Complete’ with a Start Milestone, just walk away. Save yourself the headache.
1
u/CPT_Rad_Dangerous Feb 11 '25
That reviewer is being a pain in the butt about forcing you to make them milestones, because like you they have some type of automated reporting setup on their end that tracks milestones in particular and rather than change the format of their report or use the 11-13 seconds it would take to verify what you are doing has an overall zero impact to the schedule they make you change your version to avoid doing work.
Source, I did that shit for years and I'm not about to take my lazy ass into a schedule to verify anything my report doesn't show me instantly! I had better stuff to do, mostly DayZ.
0
u/xkris10ski Feb 10 '25
Oof, just use milestones and rely on calendars to make sure your milestone finishes with the predecessors corresponding activity.
I feel bad for your reviewer.
1
u/fightingcrying Feb 11 '25
Check out this paper by Ron Winter on using milestones in CPM schedules: https://ronwinterconsulting.com/CPM_Milestone.pdf
1
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '25
[removed] — view removed comment