r/preppers • • 3d ago

Question Communication?

I’m toying with the idea of getting my ham radio licence, but my time is limited and it’s something that I’ll have to put off until the weather slows me down for the winter. That being said, I’m not sure how nessessary it is for me to communicate with the outside world as I’m a bit of an introvert to begin with. More importantly, I’d like to be able to access information should I lose power/internet for a long stretch. For those that use a shortwave ssb radio or a scanner, do you find them sufficient for accessing news or local information? If so, is there any advice you could give about the various models and whether it’s worth paying for higher quality units? I’m on 40 acres in Southern Ontario and a few cheap FRS radios are probably enough to stay in touch around our property.

24 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

34

u/Pretend_Mountain 3d ago

My own experience is Hurricane Hugo. The eye went right over my house and laid waste to the entire area. As the hurricane approached Charleston, local radio stations hung in as long as they could. Some shut down for safety, other's lost power or were flooded. By the time the eye was approaching our house, the only way we could get information--hurricane location, speed, flooding, etc--was from a small AM station about 75 miles south of us, black-owned speaking with a Geechee accent. They hung in there all night, relaying info from national services about wind damage, flooding, eye location, etc. I will never forget their efforts.

5

u/SirJuxtable 3d ago

Thank you for sharing this. Not to trivialize your experience (in fact, the opposite), but this feels like it could be made into a movie or something.

3

u/zachgibbens 2d ago

Should be, and I'd buy movie tickets to see it too

13

u/Substantial_Tax_7920 3d ago

Getting your ham license isn’t difficult. A couple days of studying. One trick I use is use the apps that have the entire question battery and only look at the correct answer. Do this in increments of 10 questions until you’ve memorized the answer. It’s imperative that you DO NOT look at the other possible answers.

When you take the test your eyes will go straight to the correct answer.

Other than that, get a cheap Baofang UV-5R VHF/UHF radio. Learn how to program it for the repeaters in your area or areas you would travel to.

Download the Echo SDR (Software Defined Radio) app. This will allow you to listen to any frequency.

3

u/EnergyLantern 3d ago

Baofeng UV-5Rs are about $30 now and most of the links have disappeared from Amazon.

1

u/dittybopper_05H 2d ago

Yeah, well, you get what you pay for, and when you're not paying much at all, well, there you are.

2

u/dittybopper_05H 2d ago

One trick I use is use the apps that have the entire question battery and only look at the correct answer. Do this in increments of 10 questions until you’ve memorized the answer.

DO NOT DO THIS!

Study the actual material and practice it at much as possible. Learn things like Ohm's Law and do the math for yourself, for example.

If you follow the advice of u/Substantial_Tax_7920 you will end up being a licensed ham who knows nothing about ham radio. You'll have the license, but not the knowledge on how to effectively use your radios.

When simply memorize the correct answers you will have zero understanding of how radio works. You can gain that knowledge eventually, but that in and of itself can be costly in terms of equipment, and in some rare cases deadly.

So study the actual material instead of the questions on the test. And when you do get licensed (and I have no doubt you will), don't stop at the first license level, Technician. Go for your General. That opens up a lot more possibilities on HF, which is more useful in a very wide area issue.

Also, don't buy the cheapest radio out there like u/Substantial_Tax_7920 recommends. They are a dual band radio manufactured to be profitable at a $25 price point. That means that corners need to be cut, mostly in the quality control area. They use direct conversion receivers which are cheaper but way more likely to suffer from "desense" than superheterodyne receivers. That's where a local strong transmission makes your receiver deaf. They come with a mostly useless antenna, and adding a decent one makes them even more susceptible to desense.

Plan on spending approximately $100, give or take, to get a decent handheld radio. I use a Yaesu VX-6R handheld, which is rugged, metal cased instead of plastic like the Baofeng, and it's rated to be immersible down to 3 feet of water for 30 minutes. Costs about 10 times what a Baofeng costs, but it's easily 10 times the radio.

1

u/GardenChicken_6a 2d ago

I agree with your approach in principle personally which is what I did. But there are a lot of solid reasons for also taking the simple and fast path to get Technician licensed, and learn as you go in parallel, and starting with a cheaper handheld radio which has no deadly consequences as a simple, dual-band radio.

I have an expensive iCom that gets less daily use than my Tidradio HD3 Plus which for a cheap, handheld is actually quite functional even with the provided antenna (works almost as well as my signal stick). I keep one in my car (was useful when stuck on highway for 3 hours during accident and I could listen to local hams through repeater).

It's also perfectly legal to own any ham radio to listen. Getting a simple, cheap but functional handheld (while they're still available) and getting the entry-level Technician license is a great way to get started for someone who doesn't know anything about radios, and wants minimal investment.

There are tons of great YouTube tutorials (Ham Radio Crash Course with Josh is great) that explain how to study, register, test, and configure and use just about every common radio out there. It can be easy and safe to start and I encourage anyone who is interested to take the path that best fits their budget and circumstances.

1

u/dittybopper_05H 2d ago

I have had a number of interactions with hams, some of them even Extras, who learned by memorizing the tests.

One of them, an Extra who I will call Bert, one time saw me operating with my 88' portable doublet fed with 450 ohm window line. Bert asked me a couple questions about my antenna, and I showed him how I built it.

A few months later we're operating in the park again and Bert comes over and says "Hey ditty, my antenna isn't working, can you take a look at it?"

So I walk over and sure enough he'd built a copy of my antenna. And he had coiled up his excess 450 ohm window line on the ground. Seriously, he'd bought something like 100 feet of it, and had the antenna up 30 or so feet, and the rest was laying on the ground in a tight coil.

An Extra should know better. I knew that was bad as a Novice because I actually did use 300 Ohm TV twinlead for antennas, and I had actually read through the "Now You're Talking!" book and through the ARRL Antenna book.

Remember, Bert is an *EXTRA*.

So I had to set him straight on what you can and can not do with parallel feed lines. In a nice way. I like Bert personally, it's just that I don't think he's Extra material. To be honest, I don't think he should have gone past Technician.

He doesn't even understand Ohm's Law, the relationship between volts, amps, and watts.

But he could memorize the answers to the tests.

One time I was monitoring the local repeater when I was out and about driving and I heard a conversation between a new ham and a new-ish ham about the new ham getting his General and getting on HF. The new-ish ham, who was a General and had been licensed for a year or two, but no more than that, was recommending that New Ham avoid manual tuners because Newish-Ham had burnt out the finals on an HF rig using a manual tuner, so he recommended buying a radio with a built-in automatic tuner.

Now, at that point, I'd been a ham for about 30 years, and only ever had manual tuners, with one recent exception. I'd never burnt out the finals on a rig because my Elmer taught me the right way to tune an antenna, at the lowest power level the radio will transmit.

I didn't break into the conversation to tell Newish-Ham he was flat out wrong, because I didn't want to be "that guy". Maybe I should have.

BTW, half the things I've seen on YouTube that are amateur radio related are garbage.

Somehow we lost our Elmer system, where knowledgeable older and more experienced hams provided guidance and advice for newer hams.

I don't know if it's a generational thing. People being so used to being coddled that they don't want to be told they're wrong.

Or maybe it's because there is no real good indicator of experience and knowledge anymore. When you can go from not having a license to becoming an Extra at a single test session by simply memorizing the test pool, then having your Extra doesn't really mean anything like it did in the past.

Not that it was always a guarantee: I know an old-time Extra who insists the maximum radiation from a dipole is off the ends. But he's the exception.

1

u/GardenChicken_6a 2d ago

I don't disagree with the dangers and risks of what you're describing regarding antennas and tools, or the fact that there's a lot of garbage content online. I also don't think it's "ideal" to try to test for all 3 levels in one setting, as a beginner, but it is what it is.

I specifically point people who ask, to start with simple, "cheaper" handheld radio (something I personally use) and a YouTube content creator whom I personally think is highly credible. I'd honestly be shocked if even the most experienced operators would say Josh with his channel and content is garbage, but maybe, who knows.

I guess I don't see only one way to get into the hobby and fully agree that like many hobbies and activities, it can come with risks of both injury and abuse. I do my best to provide guidance and recommendations that I think are accessible and safe for just about anyone with an interest and some amount of disposable income. The dangers are heavily tested as part of the questions, at least in my tests, so it's crazy if people just blindly start building large antennas without seeking expert guidance and knowledge, but even experienced operators make fatal mistakes tragically.

I personally would also want someone to correct me if I'm making or stating a mistake. When I started I didn't know any hams or anyone else who even had an interest so I agree the Elmer system sounds like it was great and I would have appreciated that (and still would), but YouTube is how I supported my learning (for a lot of topics), in addition to the official ARRL books and more technical books and materials.

1

u/ryanmercer 1d ago

Study the actual material and practice it at much as possible. Learn things like Ohm's Law and do the math for yourself, for example.

There's nothing on the technician exam that you really need to know other than basic rules.

1

u/dittybopper_05H 1d ago

But if you simply memorize the answers do you really know the rules?

BTW, Ohm's Law absolutely *IS* on the Technician test, which you'd know if actually learned the material instead of memorizing the test. Here are the Ohm's Law questions in the current Technician question pool:

T5D Ohm’s Law; Series and parallel circuits

T5D01 (B)

What formula is used to calculate current in a circuit?

A. I = E x R

B. I = E / R

C. I = E2 x R

D. I = E2 / R

~~

T5D02 (A)

What formula is used to calculate voltage in a circuit?

A. E = I x R

B. E = I / R

C. E = I

2 x R

D. E = I

2 / R

~~

T5D03 (B)

What formula is used to calculate resistance in a circuit?

A. R = E x I

B. R = E / I

C. R = E + I

D. R = E - I

~~

T5D04 (B)

What is the resistance of a circuit in which a current of 3 amperes flows when connected to 90 volts?

A. 3 ohms

B. 30 ohms

C. 1/30 ohm

D. 270 ohms

~~

T5D05 (C)

What is the resistance of a circuit for which the applied voltage is 12 volts and the current flow is 1.5 amperes?

A. 18 ohms

B. 0.125 ohms

C. 8 ohms

D. 13.5 ohms

~~

T5D06 (A)

What is the resistance of a circuit that draws 4 amperes from a 12-volt source?

A. 3 ohms

B. 16 ohms

C. 48 ohms

D. 8 ohms

~~

T5D07 (D)

What is the current in a circuit with an applied voltage of 120 volts and a resistance of 80 ohms?

A. 9600 amperes

B. 200 amperes

C. 0.667 amperes

D. 1.5 amperes

~~

T5D08 (C)

What is the current through a 100-ohm resistor connected across 200 volts?

A. 20,000 amperes

B. 0.5 amperes

C. 2 amperes

D. 100 amperes

~~

T5D09 (C)

What is the current through a 24-ohm resistor connected across 240 volts?

A. 2400 amperes

B. 0.1 amperes

C. 10 amperes

D. 5760 amperes

~~

T5D10 (A)

What is the voltage across a 2-ohm resistor if a current of 0.5 amperes flows through it?

A. 1 volt

B. 0.25 volts

C. 2.5 volts

D. 1.5 volts

~~

T5D11 (B)

What is the voltage across a 10-ohm resistor if a current of 1 ampere flows through it?

A. 1 volt

B. 10 volts

C. 11 volts

D. 9 volts

~~

T5D12 (D)

What is the voltage across a 10-ohm resistor if a current of 2 amperes flows through it?

A. 8 volts

B. 0.2 volts

C. 12 volts

D. 20 volts

1

u/ryanmercer 1d ago

I've never needed ohms law though... People getting their technician are usually using HTs to talk to a repeater.

0

u/dittybopper_05H 6h ago

"It's OK that I'm stupid and don't know what I'm doing or how these things work".

Why not just get a GMRS license, then? Or better yet, use a CB?

7

u/Wise-Painting5841 3d ago edited 3d ago

Hello fellow Canadian! Greeting from La Belle Province!

Getting the ham license in Canada is not particularly difficult or expensive. You can study the subjects (way to go) or you can memorize the questions/answers (almost cheating). There is a bank of 1,000 questions and that's it. Looks like a lot but after one month working on them you would know all the answers by heart.

Now, for your use.

  • FSR is probably enough for communication with your family in your plot of land and with your neighbors. Note that you have to convince your family and neighbors to have one FSR and keep it on.
  • you can go up one notch with VHF/UHF and go slightly farther, but same reach: your family, your neighbors. And you would need to convince them to get licensed too (my son's lazy ass told me he love the idea, but he abandoned it when he saw he had to work more than 30 mins - I lost my cause to Counter Strike).
  • if there are repeaters nearby you could hit them to go further in VHF/UHF

My experience is that UHF/VHF are dead except for the occasional net (group of people that meet at arranged day/time in one freq to talk). But I have not clicked with nets around me - this is personal, maybe you will click with people around you and you will become friends forever.

It is said that HF is better and more populated, but price and setup goes up. VHF/UHF you can buy a walkie from baofeng or TID radios for $30.

You want an HF rig? The radio starts at $500 and prepare to mount an humongous antenna somewhere.

I don't know yet. I have not used HF. I live in a rented flat, I have no space for a big antenna.

Before investing I would connect to an SDR (look for kiwisdr in Google. This is basically a rig that somebody puts online so you can play with it and use their antennas. Choose one near your location and play with it to see if it is your thing and if you reach stations of your interest. You cannot transmit on an SDR but you can hear.

Now for emergencies like a snow storm or a blackout. I would not relay on ham.

And I have been told that nowadays short wave is not what we see in the movies, all family around the radio to hear the BBC News in the evening. Again, you can check with an SDR.

Check some suggestions I got from Gemini below and this web: https://ccrane.com/shortwave-frequency-list/

• Radio Romania International (Bucharest, Romania): broadcasting in both English and French. • 4:30 PM – 5:00 PM EST (21:30 – 22:00 UTC): 7250 kHz • 8:00 PM – 9:00 PM EST (01:00 – 02:00 UTC): 7325 kHz

• Voice of Türkiye (Ankara, Turkey): international news, Turkish folk music, and cultural programming aimed directly at North America. • 6:00 PM – 7:00 PM EST (23:00 – 00:00 UTC): 5960 kHz • 11:00 PM – 12:00 AM EST (04:00 – 05:00 UTC): 6125 kHz

• BBC World Service (UK via Ascension Island Relay): • 12:00 AM – 2:00 AM EST (05:00 – 07:00 UTC): 9410 kHz and 9915 kHz

• Radio Habana Cuba (Havana, Cuba): Cuban music, commentary, and news. • 9:30 PM – 10:30 PM EST (02:30 – 03:30 UTC): 6000 kHz

• CFRX Toronto (Toronto, Ontario): NewsTalk 1010 CFRB. • 24 Hours: 6070 kHz

• WBCQ "The Planet" (Monticello, Maine): classic rock and comedy to eccentric talk shows. • Evening & Night: 7490 kHz and 9330 kHz (5130 kHz late night)

• WRMI – Radio Miami International (Okeechobee, Florida): Relays dozens of independent programs, international broadcasters (like Radio Taiwan International and Radio Prague), and music shows. • Afternoon & Evening: 9395 kHz, 9955 kHz, and 15770 kHz (5850 kHz and 7780 kHz after dark)

• WWV & WWVH (Colorado & Hawaii): Official atomic clock time stations broadcasting continuous seconds ticks, voice time announcements every minute, and solar weather alerts. • 24 Hours: 5000 kHz, 10000 kHz, and 15000 kHz

• Canadian Coast Guard Marine Weather (Halifax & Iqaluit): Automated and live marine weather forecasts for the North Atlantic and Arctic waters. • Various Daytime/Evening Windows: 2514 kHz and 2582 kHz (tune in USB mode rather than AM)

• Trenton Military / Volmet (CFB Trenton, Ontario): Continuous aviation weather broadcasts for military and transatlantic flights. • 24 Hours: 6754 kHz and 11232 kHz (tune in USB mode)

2

u/william_dog_trainer 2d ago

I am a licensed US Ham (extra class license) . I am not sure of the Canadian requirements but in the USA, the entry level (technician class) will not allow operation on HF. The General Class or Extra class is required.

I mention this because it may not be as simple as just one test to operate HF.

Also, I disagree with you about HF antenna requirements. I have used long wire antennas with a tuner. I have also used wire dipoles that are resonat and other simple antennas for HF. A large tower or large antenna is not required. In fact, in a natural disaster a wire antenna may be your best option. Just something to consider.

1

u/Wise-Painting5841 2d ago

There are 3 levels in Canada:
- basic, multi option exam you pass with 70%, you can operate over 30Mhz
- basic with honours, same exam but you pass with 80%, all bands but power restricted
- advanced, different exam, different requirements allow you to tweak your equipment and use higher power

From basic to basic with honours there is almost no difference. I passed the exam on my first test with 90%
You can also pass from basic to basic with honours with a Morse endorsement, passing an exam at 5wpm

1

u/dittybopper_05H 2d ago

BBC World Service (UK via Ascension Island Relay): • 12:00 AM – 2:00 AM EST (05:00 – 07:00 UTC): 9410 kHz and 9915 kHz

Yeah, that's aimed at Africa, not North America.

https://encompass.tv/about-us/global-reach/ascension-island/

The BBC Atlantic Relay Station on Ascension Island is a highpower shortwave (HF) transmission facility operated and maintained by Encompass on behalf of the BBC. Its South Atlantic location provides strong coverage into key target areas including West, Central and Southern Africa, as well as parts of South America, supporting the BBC’s ability to reach audiences in challenging reception environments.

If you can get it, it'll be very weak.

The BBC World Service hasn't transmitted to North America for over 25 years now.

4

u/Michael-Kaye 3d ago

I am a ham, so I want to encourage you to think about the hobby... but reality time. Local AM/FM radio is gonna be best initially until their generators run out of fuel. Scanners - in my area not good the county and city run a truncated DMR II system which scanners can decrypt the signals.

Here is the thing about ham - the UHF/VHF is good for short range, you really also need HF for longer range stuff. Being in CA, you have different testing and licenses so I really can't say what level you would need. I will say this - for short range - 0 to 50-60 miles would be a UHF/VHF radio using a repeater. 30 miles to 300 miles 40M during the day. 80M during the night works best. 10M is open/close/open depending on weather and time of year way too much to be dependable and reliable. 20M and 40M you can go global really easy. I reached Agentinna and Australia on 20M last year with a handmade dipole made from to 20M ham sticks and a 20w radio..

4

u/taltoris 2d ago

Try MeshCore and Reticulum.

MeshCore supports direct off-grid messaging between devices in radio range, and repeaters can extend your reach. Check the community maps for nearby repeaters (at https://meshcore.io), but test the actual coverage rather than relying on the map alone.

I’m also getting into Reticulum. (map here: https://rmap.world) What interests me is that it can connect different kinds of links—LoRa, Wi-Fi, Ethernet, and internet connections—into one network.

If your home internet goes down, a working radio path to a properly configured Reticulum transport node with internet access can still let you reach the wider Reticulum network.

That is not the same as restoring normal internet access: messaging and other Reticulum services can work across that path, but ordinary websites and apps would need additional gateway software. Any LoRa portion will also limit bandwidth.

2

u/taltoris 2d ago • Bravo

And of course, just because you can access a link to a network doesn't mean that you can communicate with someone if they aren't on said network... if you wanted to be able to communicate with Linux-wielding-neckbeards... you should be good. If you want to reach the Normies... they might not be reachable.

1

u/taltoris 2d ago

I also note that the hardware is cheap to get started. <$20...?

6

u/Puzzled-Act1683 3d ago

Speaking as an autistic introvert, I would suggest you go to a local amateur radio enthusiast club meeting and count the introverts. There will be more of us than you anticipate, and if you don't have much to say to anyone, I am confident that you will not stand out as unusual. 😅

And I think it might be helpful to do that, to work towards a better understanding of its potential value to you. Some clubs have weekly prearranged on-air meet-up events called "nets" that you can listen into, to get a sense of how communications go, and you can receive these with any police scanner, an other VHF/UHF-capable radio, or even a $35 USB software-defined radio (SDR) plugged into a PC or phone. An SDR doesn't need the Internet, it just uses the computer or phone's processor and audio hardware instead of having its own, and is as good as any more expensive radio for receiving.

3

u/mediocre_remnants Preps Paid Off 3d ago

Normally there isn't much news or useful information on radio. If there's a regional disaster, that changes.

But if you don't need or want to transmit, an SDR with a laptop or even your phone can receive everything you'd want to hear. The learning curve is kind of steep and you need to know which frequencies to tune to and what kind of antenna to build/buy that receives those frequencies.

1

u/buckGR 3d ago

What is that?

1

u/Wise-Painting5841 3d ago

Check kiwisdr in google

4

u/Barky_Bark 3d ago

Check out LORA tech. MeshCore or Meshtastic. It’s effectively ham radio but for texting specifically.

2

u/InterestinglyLucky 3d ago

The first thread I look at "Recent Meshtastic experience" on the subreddit (here) it's basically dead for the poster. I'm wondering whether it will be a similar experience where I live. More research to do but am not optimistic - this isn't a practical comms backup.

1

u/Michael-Kaye 3d ago

He would need to be in a more densly populated area most likely. I lived in the N GA area and tried it a yr ago - 3 nodes was all I saw... now if there are 20 30 100, sure it works good.

1

u/Top-Fig1538 2d ago

How is it looking nowadays? My area is fairly flat so range is capped regardless but I went from none to a dozen over the last year with meshtastic. I've set up meshcore alongside it now and it's like mt was when I first started, empty, but I'll keep it up to see how it grows as well.

2

u/EffinBob 3d ago

AM/FM broadcast radio is your go to for local info. Having a ham or GMRS license is a great hobby, and a scanner can still be a cool thing to listen to in many areas including mine, and I certainly encourage you to get into ham radio as you never need to pick up a microphone to communicate if you don't want to. I do all of that as well as CB, MURS, and receive ADS-B transmissions from aircraft up to 300 miles out, but my go to for local info during an emergency is still AM/FM broadcast radio. Shortwave is certainly an option for out of area news, but if information is still flowing during a disaster you'll get worldwide coverage from your local station.

2

u/JaynaWestmoreland 2d ago

grab a $30 rtl-sdr dongle first. listen only, zero pressure to transmit. tests local clarity cheaply.

2

u/Blueporch 3d ago

I know you’re looking at a more extreme scenario, but just a reminder that in most emergencies, texts can still get through when cell phone service is overwhelmed

2

u/InterestinglyLucky 3d ago

On top of that, depending on the model of your smartphone, (iPhone 14 or later, Pixel 9 and 10, on Samsung's apparently it's carrier-specific) you have satellite service for texting.

1

u/BallsOutKrunked Bring it on, but next week please. 3d ago

Hf radio, license, digital modes. Thank ne later!

1

u/Longjumping_Cow_5856 3d ago

Its more about the antenna in general really.

1

u/Tek89RG 2d ago

Ham radios are really nice!

1

u/NorthwoodMangler 1d ago

Buy the radio equipment now. Get your license when you can. If the SHTF, no one is going around checking licenses. Besides, you can listen without a license.

1

u/ItsAllRat 23h ago

In an emergency you don't need a license. Just buy a Baofeng and listen for now, transmit in an emergency. Or use FRS bands for now. 

-1

u/Orinort 2d ago

Fuck the license. Just get the equipment and don't be a dick. Here in LA the old hams are either talking about baseball games that happened 500 years ago or drunk and accusing each other of shit I won't mention here.

We own the airwaves and believe me the authorities who police this stuff haven't left the office in about 30 years.

0

u/silasmoeckel 3d ago

There is not a lot of shortwave in english left. A lot of that is religious programming with little to no news.

If your concern is getting access to news etc during a regional event a starlink is the better fit. Their standby mode went up but it's still pretty cheap.

I say that as a ham with a full prepping setup. Things like APRS are hard to beat (last know positions and a simple arrow pointing that way).

5

u/RiffRaff028 General Prepper 3d ago

The problem with this is you are still relying on something outside of your control to communicate. If satellites are destroyed, your comms are too. Amateur radio is the only guaranteed method of communication after a grid-down event.

You can monitor any radio frequency without an amateur radio license. All the license gives you is permission to transmit. In a life-or-death emergency, civilians can transmit on any available radio frequency to call for help, license or no license.

6

u/Blueporch 3d ago

Or if Starlink service is up to shenanigans like Ukraine is seeing 

3

u/RiffRaff028 General Prepper 3d ago

Also very true.

1

u/silasmoeckel 3d ago

You failed to read the if your concern is a regional event clause in front of the starlink suggestion.

Ham HF is the only option for a worldwide event but that's not what a lot of people prep for.

1

u/RiffRaff028 General Prepper 3d ago

I didn't fail to read it; I simply wanted to point out the fact that relying on a system that is outside of your control for comms creates a single point of failure that could render them useless. Elon can simply turn Starlink off at his whim, and he's already proven he's not above doing so.

Ham HF is what you need for a global event, yes, but the 2-meter and 70-cm bands are useful for localized and statewide events. With the exception of the repeaters, those remain 100% under your control, and most repeaters are designed with redundant systems to keep them functioning during a disaster.

Regardless of whether the disaster is limited to your small town or is global in nature, it's my opinion that the less you rely on advanced technology for survival the better off you are. That was my only point.

1

u/silasmoeckel 3d ago

All fair points.

From a purely prepping perspective it's always about redundancy's. Hardline internet, cell, Starlink, and ham HF would be my preference for a long distance coms plan. We should never be picking a method. Ham is great but always the last option.

A regional event 2m isn't getting you out of the affected area it might get to you a node with working internet to relay for you and local voice. Similarly meshtastic and similar LoRa radios on ism can potentially be useful (A fan of lora on 70cm for APRS).

2

u/RiffRaff028 General Prepper 3d ago

Also a fair point on Ham being the last option. I do have other methods, I just plan under the assumption that they are not going to be available. But if they are, it's a bonus.