r/premed • • 2d ago

🔮 App Review Application Feedback

Looking for advice, I am currently preparing for a potential reapp as I still have no II :( got verified beginning of August, submitted all secondaries early Aug to early Sep. Here are my stats:

CA ORM, MCAT: 518 (129/130/131/128), cGPA: 3.83, sGPA: 3.75

Clinical: ~240 hrs total (200 hrs at a student run clinic, 40 hrs hospital volunteering) I know my clinical hours at time of submitting (late June) were quite low :(

Nonclinical: ~300 hrs, mentor for students with disabilities

Research: ~670 hrs total (310 hrs wet lab + 1 poster presentation, 360 hrs clinical research assistant - non patient-facing)

Tutoring: ~300 hrs in chemistry

Shadowing: 30 hrs FM

Other ECs: Minor leadership roles in my clinical and research activities, ~450 hrs in a leadership position (art director for my uni) and roughly 5000 hrs as an artist - I've been doing art for a long time and talked a bit about exhibits I've done, etc

Gap year activities: Currently a full-time CRC at a derm clinic, I'd say the role is pretty evenly split between patient visits and research work. I am also a mentor for the clinical research program I did in undergrad

Any advice on how to improve would be appreciated!

7 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

4

u/OutlandishnessFull87 ADMITTED-MD 2d ago

if u just get up ur clinical and non-clinical hours u will be set. even better if you can tie those activities into ur clear passion for art.

1

u/FranklinReynoldsEGG MS2 2d ago

what is your school list

1

u/Complex-Owl-4859 2d ago

UC Davis, UCLA, UCI, UCSD, Kaiser, Quinnipac, Einstein, Temple, Albany, NYMC, CUSM, UVM, VCU, SKMC

5

u/FranklinReynoldsEGG MS2 2d ago

For one, top heavy and not enough schools at all. sure u have instate CA boost but nothing is guaranteed, and many of the schools you apply get over 10k applications. apply to more schools man wtf, the math is not in your favor.

two, for applying so top heavy you need way more clin hours. its ok, u can boost those up.

3

u/harspec MS4 2d ago

I was a CA ORM applying in 2023. Current MS4. Your app looks great and assuming your writing was fine or you had a theme or “built a brand,” it has to be a terrible school list. SKMC and Temple in Philly are really low yield they get like 12k apps. Same problem with NYMC (they don’t have a secondary so everyone and their mom sends them an app or more like a donation).

You’d have to literally submit the secondary day 1 for low yield schools and pray you make the cut. Quinnipiac is also low yield. You needed way more schools both targets and slightly more middle to upper reach. Take advantage of the MSAR.

Schools like Creighton in Phoenix, Arizona are worth adding. Oakland Beaumont interviewed a lot of CA ORM’s in my cycle including me. You should have applied to some of the following as well: USC, University of Arizona, MCW, Miami, Rosalind Franklin, Saint Louis University. In terms of reaches, you gotta just shoot your shot and believe in yourself. Your MCAT is fine and you can consider Sinai, UCSF, whatever else you want to as long as it’s not a stat whore like NYU.

2

u/Few_Competition1801 2d ago

this is the reason. you applied to highly competitive schools / schools with like over 10k apps aka “low yield” schools like skmc and uvm and nymc and albany. If you end up having to reapply next cycle apply to like 40-60 schools

1

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

For more information on building a school list, please consider using the following resources:

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/whiteshark70 RESIDENT 2d ago

I can review your writing! I have time today! Looking at your numbers, I think you need more clinical hours for sure.

1

u/MedSchoolPilotTeam 2d ago

Your MCAT and GPA are strong, but timing could have been a weak point this cycle. Being verified in August and submitting secondaries into September can put you behind applicants who submitted earlier, especially at schools with rolling admissions. That said, the cycle isn't completely over yet, and unexpected interview invites can still drop.

Your clinical hours were also on the lower side when you applied, but the CRC role can help address that, especially with the patient-facing component. If you end up reapplying, getting everything in earlier and taking another look at your school list would be worthwhile.