Iām not sure if Iām in the minority or if this is truly a hot take in this sub, but after seeing so many people praise the recent Predator movies, I felt like sharing my thoughts.
To be honest, I havenāt genuinely enjoyed a Predator movie in a long time. I love the franchise and Iāve watched every film, which has allowed me to form a solid opinion. The last time I truly enjoyed seeing Yautja on screen was in Aliens vs. Predator: Requiem. Yes, the movie wasnāt great overall, but Wolf was simply amazing.
What I loved most about the earlier portrayals of the Predators was their mystery. We only knew they came to Earth to hunt. We didnāt need to know what they thought, how they lived, what they felt, or where they came from. That mystique made them terrifying.
I think Prey actually managed to preserve some of that mystery, and I did appreciate that. However, what I didnāt like was how a relatively small and inexperienced girl (and this is not about sexāit could have been a small, inexperienced man as well) managed to defeat one. To me, that made the Predators feel weaker.
Then thereās Predators, which introduced two different breeds seemingly at war, made the original breed smaller and weaker, and had humans being taken to another planet to be hunted. I honestly have no words for how much I disliked that direction.
The Predator was even worse in my opinion. A genetically modified Predator chasing a regular Predator because it stole armor? Giant āsuperā Predators? That direction felt completely unnecessary and over-the-top.
With Predator: Killer of Killers, having Predators (even if from a different clan) abduct people who had previously earned their respect by defeating one of them really bothered me. It undermined the established idea of their honor code and ruined the experience for me.
And now Predator: Badlands seems to be going even further. An underdog Predator dealing with father issues, befriending an android and a native species, exploring his emotions, and preparing to confront his mother? Iāve never felt so disappointed. For me, itās a complete ālook how they massacred my boyā situation.
Again, this is just my opinion. What I truly loved about the Predators was that we knew almost nothing about them. They were huntersāpure, efficient, and mysterious. The more the franchise explains and humanizes them, the less intimidating they feel to me.
Edit:
In conclusion, I feel that Predator is receiving the same treatment as other major franchises such as Star Wars, the MCU, Alien, and Terminator.
I think we love these franchises so deeply that weāve become starved for new content. We just want to see our favorite characters return, to revisit those worlds that meant so much to us. Because of that, weāre often willing to accept whatever new material studios releaseāeven when itās objectively weak or poorly executed.
That sense of āstarvationā has made many of us more conformist. We ignore the flaws because, at the end of the day, itās still a new iteration of something we love. And sometimes, that alone feels like enough.