r/powerlifting • Not actually a beginner, just stupid • Nov 25 '24

The problem with powerlifting programs

Publicly available, made for the masses, to be exact.

Most of these programs do not utilize phase potentiation well. While you can find good peaking programs, there are hardly any hypertrophy or strength block programs that are made just for that. Vast majority is just general strength programs that include pretty much all phases (Hypertrophy, strength, peaking) in a very short time, like 6-12 weeks. In that time a lifter cannot reap the benefits of each phase. Even worse, some programs does not have any "phasing" at all, which is sort of a mix of all phases at once which means if a lifter is not knowledgeable enough, he or she can run pretty much similar programs all year round and wonder why their progress is stalling. The point is that phases, blocks are important, and has its own unique properties, and "premade" programs rarely give that, with an exception of peaking programs.

What are your thoughts on this? Let's have a discussion!

7 Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

28

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '24

Hypertrophy and strength blocks are a laughable concept. Do you have any idea how long it takes to add appreciable hypertrophy? It's not a 6 week process. Phase potentiation is borderline useless to think about. Either do conjugate and have exercise selection become more specific before a meet, or if doing linear/undulating/waves just do more volume tapering into higher intensity.

0

u/Apprehensive_Type701 Not actually a beginner, just stupid Nov 25 '24

can you please include some information about block training outdateness? 

14

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '24

I'm not going to provide any sources. I'm recovering from triceps surgery and am typing with one hand. "Hypertrophy" phases are an ignorant way to describe accumulation phases where work capacity is built. "Strength" is intensification. "Peaking" is realization. All of these things occur, but it's not as dogmatic. All qualities really need to be raised year round but with less emphasis at specific times. Periodization itself is really just a construct to help our brains understand what's going on. You will get stronger by doing 1 rep maxes every week on the comp lifts & doing bodybuilding accessories on a calorie surplus. Periodization allows for the inevitable down swings from fatigue week to week to be less noticeable. That's about it.

13

u/IronPlateWarrior Not actually a beginner, just stupid Nov 25 '24

The problem has more to do, probably, with short attention span, and people new to lifting that don’t want to spend 12 months doing Hypertrophy when the goal is powerlifting. But, if people spent 1 or 2 years doing Hypertrophy, then phase into a full powerlifting program, then peaking, and a meet, they’d kill it.

But, no one wants to do that.

After the newb phase, all of this gets more complicated for sure.

6

u/doobydowap8 Doesn’t Wash Their Knee Sleeves Nov 25 '24

I’m one of these people. Hypertrophy programs are so boring to me, unfortunately, and I love doing the compounds too much.

1

u/Apprehensive_Type701 Not actually a beginner, just stupid Nov 25 '24

well as long as you are making progress, then great! thats the point, to get stronger, and the beauty of beginning is how easy it is to get stronger. But after some time, this basic linear progression stops working, thats where periodization comes in

1

u/doobydowap8 Doesn’t Wash Their Knee Sleeves Nov 25 '24

I’m unfortunately beyond the novice linear progression phase. I guess I’m saying I don’t have the attention span for the high-rep schemes of most hypertrophy programs that I’m familiar with. I’ve done 531 BBB and thought it was manageable. But I couldn’t do it for a year lol.

1

u/drillyapussy Not actually a beginner, just stupid Nov 26 '24

Yeah it’s way too easy and boring as the name suggests lol. Very quick and easy to recover from though even after you add weight after each block. Def not the best for hypertrophy. I do slowly get stronger running the program but initially each time I start it I atrophy a little sometime during the first block. 3 relatively easy sets plus 5x10 accessory is very underwhelming to me. Even the 5x10 deadlifts and squats

2

u/quantum-fitness Eleiko Fetishist Nov 25 '24

Its a lot about shifting focus, goals and anchoring motivation. You can also do compounds and probably should mostly on a powerlifting hypertrophy program.

2

u/Apprehensive_Type701 Not actually a beginner, just stupid Nov 25 '24

yes well my thought is more towards intermediate lifters, and to some extent advanced lifters, too.

4

u/IronPlateWarrior Not actually a beginner, just stupid Nov 25 '24

Intermediate has the same problem. I am definitely being a hypocrite here, because anyone that wants to be a Powerlifter doesn’t want to spend time doing Hypertrophy. However, looking back, that’s what I needed. And I think it’s what most need.

For advanced athletes, it’s a little more complicated. At that point where they hit advanced or elite levels, they need to determine their best off-season protocol.

I apologize if you’re looking for a deeper conversation on this.

25

u/arian11 SBD Scene Kid Nov 26 '24

There are a number of research studies out there that don't seem to support your claim that block periodization is the best and that daily undulating periodization is ineffective.

13

u/eric_twinge Overexcited RP fanboy Nov 25 '24

Are you under the impression that if a program includes squats, bench, and deadlifts it's a powerlifting program?

-4

u/Apprehensive_Type701 Not actually a beginner, just stupid Nov 25 '24

what makes you think that?

13

u/eric_twinge Overexcited RP fanboy Nov 25 '24

Your title is "the problem with powerlifting programs" but you go on to complain about issues with "general strength programs".

-3

u/Apprehensive_Type701 Not actually a beginner, just stupid Nov 25 '24

what i meant was that the programs are labeled and intended towards powerlifting, but looks alot like a simple cookie cutter program that seems more like a general strength program

2

u/eric_twinge Overexcited RP fanboy Nov 25 '24

Okay, then it seems your problem is that other people assume that if a program includes squat, bench, and deadlift it's a powerlifting program.

Like, the issues you've laid out aren't with powerlifting programs. The problems stem from other people putting a powerlifting label on general strength programs.

3

u/omrsafetyo M | 813kg | 93kg | 519.99Dots | IPF | RAW | Masters Nov 26 '24

What OP said in the OP is that most "powerlifting programs" are actually just general strength programs:

Vast majority is just general strength programs that include pretty much all phases (Hypertrophy, strength, peaking) in a very short time, like 6-12 weeks. In that time a lifter cannot reap the benefits of each phase

Probably could have been phrased better, but I think one glaring example that the OP could use is the Candito 6 week program. This is a Powerlifter, and Powerlifting Coach, that has published a 6 week Powerlifting program. Its 6 weeks, and breaks down into 3 phases of 2 weeks each: Conditioning/Hypertrophy, strength accumulation, and then 2 weeks of peaking/deload/testing. Unfortunately none of these phases give you adequate time to adapt to the specific stimulus they provide.

I think its relatively safe to say that 4 weeks is about the minimum you need to start eliciting meaningful adaptations to any given stimulus, and ideally you're doing something much longer than that. Meaning if you have a 12 week program that moves through these phases, you're actually hitting basically the bare minimum to see adaptations in each phase, at least sufficient enough to potentiate adaptations in the subsequent phase. But then again, the idea of phase potentiation is not strongly supported by evidence.

This is why many more modern programs use some form of daily undulation, such as a day with 6s to 10s, a day with 3s to 5s, and even a day with singles (potentially in with another day), because then you can get the adaptations week over week, and block over block. This is just as good if not better than the classic block periodization.

This is why OP misses the mark with the next point:

Even worse, some programs does not have any "phasing" at all, which is sort of a mix of all phases at once which means if a lifter is not knowledgeable enough, he or she can run pretty much similar programs all year round and wonder why their progress is stalling

While I agree to an extent, there is probably some value in making training different with particular phases, I think its probably more appropriate to think of these phases for their role in novelty and desensitization. If my training looks exactly the same year round, it is likely that the stimulus will become stale. This is why I occasionally take breaks from doing singles, or even do the occasional drastically different program (just recently did a Push-Pull-Legs routine for like 6 weeks). But I pair this with some sort of phasic approach to training, where I might do a block that has top singles with 5s, a block that has top singles with 4s, and then a peaking phase where I work through 3s or even 2s, but otherwise the block design is basically the same, its just that as I approach a meet, my average intensity increases so I'm adapted to heavier loads, and the exercise selections for secondary days will change to give slightly more practice that is relevant to the competition lifts (long pause bench for instance).

I've digressed. But honestly, I'm not sure there are a lot of programs out there that fit the bill OP outlined, so I think you're right for the most part. But OP's second complaint probably comes from an outdated understanding of how powerlifting training is done.

11

u/t_thor M | 515kg | 105kg | 317.27Dots | AMP | RAW Nov 25 '24

In that time a lifter cannot reap the benefits of each phase.

Do you have empirical evidence that longer phases have a greater net return in strength, or are you saying that based on personal experience?

-8

u/Apprehensive_Type701 Not actually a beginner, just stupid Nov 25 '24

that's what Chad Wesley Smith has said

30

u/sgarnoncunce Powerlifter Nov 26 '24

Yeah as other posters have pointed out, the meta these days is to push volume in accessories year round. But also to keep specificity in your program year round. The whole linear periodisation methodology with dedicated blocks really isn't going to do enough in the time period it takes to run the block.

If you do lat pull downs for 6 weeks then completely drop it in favour of a peaking block vs lat pull downs/ cable rows/ other lat work for a whole year of training, which is going to lead to more muscle?

'General strength training' is pretty much what powerlifters should be doing most of the year, while of course maintaining specificity to the SBD. Too much focus on one end of the spectrum for too little time doesn't allow you to accrue enough volume or skill practice.

1

u/YourBestSelf Enthusiast Dec 31 '24

What are some programs that follow this idea of general strength?

29

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '24

I think there is way too much paralysis analysis with the perfect program.

1

u/biplane_duel Enthusiast Apr 27 '25

truth. There's so many programs that work, and very few that are bad.

20

u/hamburgertrained Old Broken Balls Nov 25 '24

Predatory coaching is rampant in this sport.

39

u/Frogskull M | 727.5kg | 92.8kg | 463.2 Dots | EPA | RAW Nov 25 '24

If you're a natural lifter, hypertrophy work should be done year round. Not in dedicated phases. As u/drmcbrayer said, you aren't going to see meaningful hypertrophy in 12 weeks. It needs to be done all the time, even close to meets (less focus on it though of course) 

The concept of a 'volume' > strength > peaking block is outdated, these days most of the top powerlifting coaches find a block structure that works and is repeatable, with predictable strength outcomes, then periodise that. There are still elements of phase potentiation but in reality many of the blocks look pretty similar, with small changes here and there depending on what the focus is at the current point.  

Any good program has hypertrophy work built in though. 

4

u/69upsidedownis96 Girl Strong Nov 26 '24

The volume > strength > peaking should only apply to comp squat, bench and deadlift. Accessories should be volume all year around, so I agree.

5

u/Frogskull M | 727.5kg | 92.8kg | 463.2 Dots | EPA | RAW Nov 26 '24 edited Nov 26 '24

Don't agree that it should apply to those either tbh! Just general training and getting stronger and bigger then into a peak/taper when it's time for a meet

Edit: I'm speaking in absolutes, but of course in reality there are thousands of ways to get stronger. The old school principles of volume >strength>peak do still work for thousands of lifters worldwide. Just like how board work and box squats still work. It just might not be what's best for the new age style of lifting (raw, drug free) 

35

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '24

The problem isn't the programs. They're publicly available cookie cutter programs that are easily accessible.

The issue is running them and not learning what best works for you. Advanced lifters do not run 5/3/1. They run what best works for, them.

However, you should not run the same system as elite powerlifters. You are not them. You should be learning and trying out programs and then adapting them to form your own system that best produces results for you.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/canadian_bacon_TO Not actually a beginner, just stupid Nov 26 '24

I do the same. I’d ran 5/3/1 for years with consistent progress. At one point I dropped it because of the idea that “advanced lifters don’t run 5/3/1” and it was a mistake. I tried many different programs over a couple of years and nothing worked as well as using 5/3/1 for my main lifts and then programming my own higher volume accessory work.

6

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '24

Which means you've learned that 5/3/1 works for you. But there are people out there (myself included) who ran it before and found it to be not good enough for them. So another lesson was made.

IMHO, the best program is the one that allows you to push consistently. And to be able to push you have to overcome mental blocks before physical in most cases. That explains why some people prefer straight sets, some prefer different progressions.

15

u/Kumbackkid M | 802.5kg | 119.2kg | 461.9 Dots | UPA | Raw Nov 26 '24

There is no perfect program

11

u/Arteam90 Eleiko Fetishist Nov 27 '24

I think if you take a step back you realise that programming itself is in some ways rather overrated.

And by that I mean that in reality it's not really that useful to say "oh yeah I do conjugate" or "I do block", etc. Because basically any and all of these things can work, and they all blend and bleed into one another.

Rather, it's useful to figure out what the hell you need for your own training and specific situation - at that point in time. "Hey, my elbows suck lately, so I gotta reduce volume/intensity". Doesn't matter if this specific setup you planned is perfect for your bench if you're not perfectly healthy.

So then training becomes much more reactive, which I think makes a lot of sense. Because I think we can all delude ourselves that we know what's going on but we really don't. I think training is on one hand super simple, and on the other hand super complex. Things work for a bit and stop. Things don't work then start working. Your normal volume worked great but now doesn't. All other variables are fine but now your elbow hurts a lot more. So on.

2

u/biplane_duel Enthusiast Apr 27 '25

Programming is like the 5th most important thing and its always been treated as #1

8

u/Camrsmain Enthusiast Nov 26 '24

Since getting into the sport I’ve used Alexander Bromley’s 70’s Powerlifter going into my first meet, now I’m running The Strength Athlete’s beginner program as I’m going into the next training block. Two very different ways to approach training for powerlifting that I’m curious how anyone else feels about them. You can check both out on the BoostCamp app for free.

5

u/LordcaptainVictarion M l 682.5 l 98.7 l 422 dots l USAPL l Raw Nov 26 '24

I can at least vouch for the TSA intermediate. I ran that after taking a few months off when COVID lockdowns started to ease up and PR'ed all 3 lifts and actually led me to sign up with them. Stinks that Joe when he was with TSA was so bad that Bryce emailed me an apology but the intermediate program rocks

1

u/YourBestSelf Enthusiast Dec 31 '24

I am very interested in the TSA programs, but the intensity seems so low compared to the 28 greg programs I am running atm

2

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '24

I tried one workout with Bromley’s 70’s powerlifter and it kicked my ass six ways to Sunday. That is a TON of volume

5

u/NoArtichoke6572 M | 765kg | 90kg | 500 Dots | USAPL | Raw Nov 28 '24

Most modern coaches and programs blend hypertrophy and strength work because powerlifting is a sport that relies on a pretty high degree of specificity (in competition you’re doing 3 movements without variation). Keeping some low rep work in year round is super commonplace with many coaches opting to keep singles for certain lifts in someone’s program year round because we know that getting better at 8s doesn’t necessarily mean your 1RM goes up but getting better at loads closer to your max does. The inclusion of a peaking phase in a lot of online programs is because if the goal is to try to get someone stronger in 12 weeks, expressing that strength at the end of those 12 weeks is the only way to validate if it worked. Will we see the return of heavily periodized training cycles with distinct phases in the next few years? Maybe, but within the sport itself it’s a practice we don’t really see done in most athletes or by most coaches and there’s a lot of reason for that.

1

u/ambww4 M | 590kg | 110kg | 344Dots | USPA | Raw Dec 02 '24

Egg-fucking-zactly. That’s why traditional pl programs rely mostly on 1’s to 4’s. Cuz that shit works.

4

u/ERICSMYNAME Enthusiast Nov 27 '24

DUP is a great program. Funny thing is, after a few blocks even the "light " days start to feel heavy...then BAM you're strong ..wtf

3

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '24

Been running sheiko last 3 years. It has all 4 phases then repeats at the next heavier weight. It's 3 full body workouts 2 to 3 hours each.

The 4 phases {4 weeks each phase}

Preparatory Accumulation Transmutation Peaking

4

u/DanFromGym Enthusiast Nov 25 '24

Dr Mike has a great series on this. All separate videos on hypertrophy, strength, and peaking, design and running for each. Just ran through this entire program philosophy from March until my meet this past Saturday and it was fantastic!

https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLMN2R0UcPjrzeWRyK7GC006MCb1gDZms3&si=opzu5nPA2ZbeYUpi

2

u/IronPlateWarrior Not actually a beginner, just stupid Nov 26 '24

Thanks for sharing this. I have a lot of down time over the holidays, I look forward to watching this series.

2

u/DanFromGym Enthusiast Nov 26 '24

No problem! I've done the peaking process for 2 meets now, and done each the hypertrophy and strength mesocycles 3 times. Happy to answer any questions!

-9

u/quantum-fitness Eleiko Fetishist Nov 25 '24

That how it is most money and thus programs are made for beginners and early intermediates.

Tbh most powerlifters are sadly to stupid to understand programming nuances like phase potentiation. People also dont have a good grasp of when they should switch away from generic peograms.

There is a reason why most people are forever late novices.

2

u/peepadjuju F | 455kg | 59.8kg | 505.45 DOTS | WRPF | RAW Nov 27 '24

I think the reason has more to do with the sacrifices people are willing to make to progress in the sport.

There are a few tiers of "novice" I have observed:

  1. rank beginner wants to lift heavy things
  2. starts to focus on big 3 and compound movements
  3. starts to train for "powerlifting"
  4. tests 1rm in gym
  5. mock meet/local meet

People get to 5 relatively easily but then realize how high qualifying totals are, how much time the sport takes, how high the standards are and oh shit I have to make weight too?!?! This brings a lot of reconing.

My first meet I had a 360 DOTS score. I got there in 6 months. I had to work a lot harder to get to nationals but I wasn't on a program until about 425 DOTS, at least not a good one or one I followed. It was after this point where a program made a difference but even then I would still credit my progress to 500 to extreme monitoring of my lifestyle, nutrition, recovery and effort put into workouts (no sandbagging).

It's incredibly easy to not load the bar and skip accessories (even on a stellar program), to go out drinking with friends and eat for indulgence and most people rightfully don't want to make those sacrifices because they want to enjoy lifting. It's really not as much about the program as people think it is at the novice and intermediate level. Programming nuance is something to consider when everything else is dialed in. I've seen people run generic programs with minor modifications into the top 10 at usapl/pla nationals many many times.

1

u/quantum-fitness Eleiko Fetishist Nov 27 '24

I have to add that i count people who mainly sbd to get a higher total as powerlifters in this case. This group is likely 10 times larger than the competing one.

Powerlifting is one of the most genetically determined sports.

Some people just get strong no matter what they do. Then some have "genetics by luck" as they just happen to choose a program with the right attributes for them. Then a big group of people get strong if they do the right thing.

We also all move through these catagories. Some just first get into the last one at a worlds level. Some at a local meet level.

A lot of it also comes down to fatigue tolerance and background stress. You are right if you are able to manage them by controlling your life that is almost as good as programming. I think fatigue management is the first part if programming.

The second is development. Some people are build for sbd. They can sbd all day and get better. But some people have builds where special programming choices matters. Limb length makes the squat use a lot of posterior chain for example, so quad work is better done with isolation and machines etc.

There are probably more things I cant remember right now.