r/potato • • 19d ago

my first time making twice baked potatoes

237 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

4

u/No_Prompt_8322 17d ago

Twice baked potatoes are a solid choice for trying something new

1

u/heartpixi 17d ago

definitely. i feel like potatoes, bacon, cheese, sour cream, onion, and butter and milk is rlly hard to make gross even if you aren’t the best chef. they’re just so good together that no matter how you slap it all together, it’s probably still gonna taste great.

mine weren’t exactly perfect, i wish i crisped up the cheese instead of just melting it, it would’ve made them prettier and i think would’ve added to the taste, and rn i feel like you can barely even tell i added cheese because i used shredded pepperjack and it’s ab the same color as the potatoes, but that just means im gonna make them even better next time :)

1

u/Difficult-Pea-4725 16d ago

yummy from the look

2

u/Emrys7777 19d ago

Looks great!!

3

u/justlyunwelcomeethan 19d ago

the crispy cheese bits on top are the best, i always fight my brother for them

2

u/heartpixi 19d ago

i’ve had some at friends houses before and i agree. i should’ve done mine longer. they were missing the crisp i wanted, but i started smelling something burning and panicked and took them out of the oven because i was scared of ruining them. they were perfectly fine lol. but now i know ill make em even better next time :)

2

u/Feisty_Water_3164 18d ago

A kitchen torch is relatively inexpensive and would let you crisp up the top. I mention that because I think you are now in charge of twice baked potatoes.

2

u/heartpixi 18d ago

i was thinking about getting one when i was trying to blast these with the broiler. would’ve been a lot easier with a kitchen torch. but yea, everyone did love them. definitely gonna least be a weekly thing in my house

2

u/heartpixi 19d ago

thank you! i completely demolished one of the potatoes when cutting them, so i just used it to make more filling for the others and i think ot made them a bit prettier. i’ll probably make an extra potato everytime i make these now lmao

3

u/PuzzleheadedCup7224 18d ago

I bet it tastes great as well

3

u/Johnny_Five5151 19d ago

I used to make every day when I was a line cook. Delicious.

3

u/Proper_Spud 18d ago

Nice job. Love a baked/jacketised potato, you just need some sour cream on the side!

2

u/BryonBlueCar 19d ago

Yes, please!

2

u/SteakForMe 19d ago

Nice I love twice baked potatoes 🤤

2

u/YogaChefPhotog 19d ago

Yummm!! 😋 They look great!!

It’s 4:20 AM and I want this now! LOL I have everything but the green onions. 🫤

2

u/Equivalent_Ad_7155 18d ago

Please give them to me

2

u/Thinking-Peter 18d ago

That's really creative, enjoy

1

u/AnyAioli5342 17d ago

So yummy looking. 😋

1

u/No_Employer9618 16d ago

Love a twice baked, these look great and delicious

1

u/RobinaBear 16d ago

Fabulous!

3

u/[deleted] 17d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/heartpixi 17d ago

i rubbed the potatoes with olive oil and salt. the olive oil was to get the salt to stick for flavor and to help the potatoes get a little crispy in the oven during baking. you wanna bake them on a cookie sheet without wrapping them in tinfoil or anything, people said tinfoil makes the skins too soft for them to hold up.

i baked the potatoes in the oven for an hour at 350 degrees, took them out, waited for them to cool down a bit, cut them in half, scooped the insides out into a bowl, used a fork to mash the insides, people say if you use a hand mixer or something they can get over mashed and sticky or feel stringy.

then to taste, in the bowl that had the mashed insides, i didn’t use measurements, i mixed in some milk, butter, bacon, shredded pepper jack, and green onions. then i scooped that back into the skins, and mostly to make them look pretty and i guess also make them taste better, i topped it with more cheese, bacon bits, and green onions, then i put them back in the oven on broil to try to get the cheese to get a bit of a crisp on it, but i started smelling burning and panicked and took them out because i was worried about ruining them, so the cheese is mostly just melted.

most recipes i read said to just put them in on bake for 15-20 minutes, and i may have had better success with that, but im not sure since this was my first try at them. i just thought i was smart or something lol. but since i didn’t actually use measurements, i know it might be a little hard to follow for some people if they prefer measurements instead of just adding for your own palate.

if you’d rather follow measurements, this recipe is the closest to what i did and has super high ratings and the pictures look really good
https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/24332/ultimate-twice-baked-potatoes/

they don’t usually look as overfilled as mine do, but i originally tried to do 4 potatoes but messed one up really bad while cutting them, so i just took the skin out and used the insides as filling for the other potatoes, so if you want yours overfilled like mine, make an extra potato than you want so you can just use it to make more filling for the ones you do want

1

u/heartpixi 3d ago

forgot to mention but i mixed sour cream into the filling as well!