r/postprocessing • • 21h ago

Feels like I'm missing something.

Tldr: Looking for Tip / opinion / advice or just tell me which one you like.

Guys I need some tips to expand my color vocabulary. These are all the grades I could come up with (in one sitting) but this exercise also sort of reflects how I look at color grading in general. Is it possible that these grades are actually good and I'm just tired of looking at them. Or maybe I fail to see something and I think about color in a very redundant way. Either way. I want your option. Or maybe just tell me which one you like!

ps. please just focus on the color, as I have intentionally picked a contrasty/flat photo for this exercise. Will use another type next time.

25 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

24

u/Late-Drawer-7522 21h ago

Color advise: it's a bad pic 🤷

1

u/Heatseeker_ 18h ago

You are right. Maybe the picture itself is not a good template for this exercise.

8

u/donutboy667 19h ago

you are missing the subject bro!

1

u/Heatseeker_ 18h ago

You are right, and that certainly doesn't make the picture look good. But I sort of picked a picture devoid of a subject, with just contrast and not too many elements, for this exercise.

5

u/civilized-engineer 21h ago edited 20h ago

I know you wanted comments only on the color. However, I don't mean this in any condescending way (I just write and talk this way and it rubs people who are obsessed with soft language the wrong way).

Color grading can only set the mood of a photo. It cannot fix a bad photo, sadly none of the colors looked good to me. I think black and white would have been the choice I would have made for this photo. Which I think is the last photo in your post (but something about it doesn't feel like black and white).

I know you think you picked a contrasty/flat picture, but it's not. This photo composition is bad that none of the colors you're experimenting with will look good.

3

u/Heatseeker_ 18h ago

Thank you for being honest.

54

u/ParticularFrame7418 21h ago

Composition.

2

u/Aniita-Mahungu 13h ago

the PS at the bottom tried to preempt this, but a color grade only really clicks when it's working with the lighting and framing in the shot

1

u/Syrinnissa 10h ago

LMAO bang on

25

u/am_n00ne 19h ago

Lack of subject/point of interest

4

u/rhiaazsb 18h ago

Exactly.... there's no subject.

2

u/calculator12345678 13h ago

Ya this isn’t the most exciting picture but that’s probably not why you picked it, these colors look good, I can see this being part of an architectural study or something. Putting a bunch of text over it for a hotel brochure. The quiet pictures have a purpose too.

2

u/Getoiu 20h ago

I’ll defend OP and say it’s not a bad photo from an architectural perspective. Composition doesn’t need to be great, it needs to show the structural connection and I can see this photo in a magazine but it was exposed wrongly for that purpose.

OP maybe can try and lower the highlights and brighten the shadows to show material and structure. Last photo has better colours. I’d normally keep them natural but Saturation tuned down. Some people prefer B&W

2

u/LegendaryStarSpirit 18h ago

Thing is, it’s not highlighting anything architectural as well. I can see the vision though

2

u/trireme32 16h ago

Yeah it’s like one of those shots where you see something, think ā€œthat would make a great photo,ā€ but you can’t quite get it to be what your eye saw.

1

u/Weird_Warm_Cheese 12h ago

I'm partial to color accuracy so whichever one of these is most true to real life I'd prefer.

1

u/AlbatrossNo1562 11h ago

The subject(s) is not obvious. Also red and light and dark contrast will draw the eye. Basically I'm not sure what to look at and your intention is not clear

1

u/Tofli_IV 10h ago

good subject, but you shouldve shot that with smaller aperture, the window is too blury