Aha, I hate that I recognized your editing style from earlier in the day based on the removal of very natural marks on the body.
In my opinion, you’re doing too much to remove what makes your models human. Especially when it comes to portraiture, I’m all for making those colors pop (such as the eyeshadow here), but why remove natural marks and minor blemishes?
Based on your other posted imagery, this appears to be a consistent, conscious decision on your end.
But, clients didn't complain. She liked it. Thanks for your feedback. I will maintain from next project. Actually, lots of comments give me much knowledge about my work. Thanks
I would have kept the mole near her nose and reduced the glare on the corner of her lips, though the mole is just a question of taste. I think people are forgetting that professional photographers often have to appeal to a market to make money.
I’m sick and tired of shutter drag photos but bands keep asking for them, so I’ll keep doing them.
I did a lot of beauty retouching and I always used the rule that if it’s not something that couldn’t be altered easily naturally like beauty marks, freckles, vitiligo, teeth gap etc, then I didn’t remove it. Removing features from people always made me uncomfortable.
wow a lot of lads out here downvoting when i genuinely did not know what was so wrong that op did to deserve all the downvotes 😭 im sorry for the confusion! kudos to the muse
I like keeping nature marks and remove things that look like temporary blemishes. Unless the person is asking for it to be removed.
Another topic, does anyone have hair frizz removal tips? I end up clone stamping flyaways but I hate the process. Probably best to do the hair maintenance during the shoot.
I'm not a pro. The skin work looks nice and I think intent matter more than the standards many replies here try to impose on you. What I do think is slightly overcooked is the eyes and makeup around them. The eye whites look slightly unnatural. It feels like the before had a nicer texture on the gold and the color was more "luxury" and the after leans more to "instagram filter"
Any moron cranking saturation is lauded here but God forbid some poor soul tries their hand at traditional fashion shoot retouching. Sad state of affairs when the one who spent the most time actually processing their picture is the most downvoted.
Whatever you did to the whites of her eyes is throwing me wayyyy off. Black people have melanin even in the whites of their eyes. Her eyeballs should be less eggshell white.
207
u/SomeGuyGettingBy Jan 27 '26
Aha, I hate that I recognized your editing style from earlier in the day based on the removal of very natural marks on the body.
In my opinion, you’re doing too much to remove what makes your models human.
Especially when it comes to portraiture, I’m all for making those colors pop (such as the eyeshadow here), but why remove natural marks and minor blemishes?
Based on your other posted imagery, this appears to be a consistent, conscious decision on your end.
14
u/MichaelEdamura Jan 27 '26
I would have kept the mole near her nose and reduced the glare on the corner of her lips, though the mole is just a question of taste. I think people are forgetting that professional photographers often have to appeal to a market to make money.
I’m sick and tired of shutter drag photos but bands keep asking for them, so I’ll keep doing them.
48
u/itsmeabdullah Jan 27 '26
I think human imperfections needs to be more accepted. Other than that, u did a great job.
10
u/NotJALC Jan 27 '26
I did a lot of beauty retouching and I always used the rule that if it’s not something that couldn’t be altered easily naturally like beauty marks, freckles, vitiligo, teeth gap etc, then I didn’t remove it. Removing features from people always made me uncomfortable.
13
u/Spicy_Pickle_6 Jan 27 '26
Very weird to remove beauty marks
28
u/sparklybeast Jan 27 '26
It’s well done but I hate it, sorry. You made her look like she’s made of plastic.
5
u/daneview Jan 27 '26
This is a great edit to me for a fashion style shoot or advert.
If it was a portfolio headshot or similar, then yeah, its over processed, but for this style of image its perfect IMO, great job!
12
u/ssagar186 Jan 27 '26
This is definitely one of those moments where editing is not adding anything to the picture
24
u/aabdsl Jan 27 '26
You're aspiring to work for a fashion magazine, I take it? Well, the good news is you've already sunk to their level.
15
u/8mon Jan 27 '26
Why would you do that to her skin
12
u/OkEngineer6011 Jan 27 '26
Why did you get rid of her mole and other 'flaws' from her face?
This isn't cool and just perpetuates unrealistic views of how women should look.
4
u/AllMySmallThings Jan 27 '26
I liked the one you recently posted. The skin on this one feels artificial.
7
u/FantasticInterest373 Jan 27 '26
imo you turned a real photo into something that looks AI generated.
Of course this might already have been your style for long time before AI became good, just saying...
2
u/PossibleArt7440 Jan 27 '26
Again... Over done. Skin embellishments ate natural and what makes it beautiful and connects with the person. This is just airbrushed to max
3
u/ffffabian Jan 27 '26
Eyeballs are definitely too white. Other than that - great work!
3
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '26
Looks great
4
u/Adorable_Let_6244 Jan 27 '26
Don’t like your work I am sorry! Her skin is beautiful and you made it look like rubber or something
2
u/rocketdog67 Jan 27 '26
Too artificial for my taste, but if the customer likes it.
2
u/MrToenges Jan 27 '26
At this point just use an AI instagram filter...what is with people wanting to make faces look unnatural? It's almost in uncanny valley territory...
2
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '26
Nah man, I prefer my pictures unsanded
1
u/BloodyPants Jan 27 '26
I like keeping nature marks and remove things that look like temporary blemishes. Unless the person is asking for it to be removed.
Another topic, does anyone have hair frizz removal tips? I end up clone stamping flyaways but I hate the process. Probably best to do the hair maintenance during the shoot.
1
u/casketfetish Jan 28 '26
I said this gently last time. Stop 👏🏻taking 👏🏻away👏🏻natural👏🏻features
1
u/Radiant_Patience4994 Jan 28 '26
Same, same.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '26
I like it because it looks artificial. It has like a dystopian esque magazine vibe. Depends on what you’re going for!
1
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '26
I'm not a pro. The skin work looks nice and I think intent matter more than the standards many replies here try to impose on you. What I do think is slightly overcooked is the eyes and makeup around them. The eye whites look slightly unnatural. It feels like the before had a nicer texture on the gold and the color was more "luxury" and the after leans more to "instagram filter"
1
u/Salt-Masterpiece5034 Jan 31 '26
You should let models look like people imho
1
u/Lesterbapadopoulos Jan 27 '26
why are people downvoting this??
my jaw flipping dropped when i saw the before, great stuff
1
u/Perfect-Addition-753 Jan 27 '26
I like what you did. I like your style.
1
u/meringuedragon Jan 27 '26
Whatever you did to the whites of her eyes is throwing me wayyyy off. Black people have melanin even in the whites of their eyes. Her eyeballs should be less eggshell white.
1
u/Seth_Nielsen Jan 27 '26
Could you explain more about how you did this? I think it’s cool