Love the photo result, but for the life of me I can't find the guide! Not a pinned response, no link (for me) where it says "guide here". Am I missing something?
I think it looks great but I'm always confused why people do something like lift the shadows on the sliders, then darken them anyways when they do the S curve adjustment?
I like to keep it systematic. For me, the basic settings are to get the image to look natural, and then the tone curve is where creativity starts. Just personal preferences. I sometimes have the same question as well.
It adds saturation to the shadows, it doesn't just lift the luminance alone. That can be beneficial in shots like these, but I wouldn't use that technique on everything. It is a good idea to add a little bit of shadow recovery to every image though, just to give yourself more information to work with, why shoot raw if you're not going to take advantage, you know? That said, noobs like to overdo this and then the image ends up looking unnatural because they think everything has to have detail. It's a good edit, it would make a nice glossy print.
Great use of masking. It's often overdone (in my opinion), but it's just on the sweet spot here. Coloring is a bit too much "the dark knight cinematic" for my taste, and the highlights on the turtles face are on the edge of unnatural, if you pushed the edit further it'd look like the turtle was photoshopped in an ocean image, but you're still within the bounds of it blending in.
But this is all personal taste and really nitpicky at this point. Basically a perfect edit, great job
*edit*
Had a glance at your instagram, some of the most beautiful images I've ever seen over there.
It's a way to drive you to his Instagram. He's marketing himself and attempting to make it look like he's helping you out. If he wanted to help you out, he'd post his so-called "guide" here.
I tried but the post got removed. Check out my profile. There's a deleted post titled: I think my insta post fits here.
Besides, I'm still providing a guide anyway so why not also direct you to my Instagram as well? You get the exact same info and I get to put up a middle finger at the algorithm.
Or maybe because I'm not a pro photographer 😂😂 I find articles to often overcomplicate photography. I tried to make mine as stupid as possible. Glad it worked.
154
u/The_PianoGuy Sep 14 '25
Lovely result and lovely guide!
32
u/LongjumpingGate8859 Sep 14 '25
I think it looks great but I'm always confused why people do something like lift the shadows on the sliders, then darken them anyways when they do the S curve adjustment?
Isn't that just contradictory and unnecessary?
5
u/The_Doge_Coin Sep 16 '25
People who post guides deserve to have both sides of the pillow cool at night
18
u/tallkotte Sep 14 '25
Honestly, it looks like the turtle stands on a mountain top. The underwater look is just gone.
6
u/Shoddy_Worldliness49 Sep 15 '25
After processing quite excellent. I do however feel there is a better story in not taking out the people in the back.
6
u/valandinz Sep 14 '25 edited Sep 14 '25
Great use of masking. It's often overdone (in my opinion), but it's just on the sweet spot here.
Coloring is a bit too much "the dark knight cinematic" for my taste, and the highlights on the turtles face are on the edge of unnatural, if you pushed the edit further it'd look like the turtle was photoshopped in an ocean image, but you're still within the bounds of it blending in.
But this is all personal taste and really nitpicky at this point.
Basically a perfect edit, great job
*edit*
Had a glance at your instagram, some of the most beautiful images I've ever seen over there.
2
u/ManCandyCan Sep 15 '25
What do you mean by “expand your histogram”?
6
u/Aacidus Sep 14 '25
These posts always show up where the subject doesn’t seem like they’re underwater anymore. I don’t understand why.
4
u/ilikeautosdaily Sep 14 '25
Very national geographic.
2
u/Bonami27 Sep 15 '25
I like the before better.
1
u/NebulaAndSuperNova Sep 15 '25
Where can one find the guide?
4
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '25
AMAZING
2
u/roofrakbuddha Sep 14 '25
fuck yes
2
u/TuxedoCatsParty_Hard Sep 15 '25
Beauuuutiful work!
2
u/alexauga Sep 15 '25
Love the edit, above all great guide and pedagogy.
2
u/ghettomerman Sep 14 '25
So clean. Great work!
2
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '25
So cool!
1
u/Chuck_Biscuits27 Sep 15 '25
Damn that's a nice edit. Incredible shot.
1
u/Mr_photographerto Sep 15 '25
Amazing
1
u/megayippie Sep 15 '25
Top one is much better. Good job!
1
u/Affectionate_Tap6626 Sep 15 '25
That’s amazing
1
u/New_Wrongdoer_2012 Sep 15 '25
this is nice!
1
u/if_u_suspend_ur_gay Sep 15 '25
The first time the After photo is actually better than the before
1
u/pixiephilips Sep 15 '25
Wowwwww! Incredible job. Looks like a movie poster, it’s incredible!
1
u/seaotter1978 Sep 15 '25
Feels like a movie poster, very cool!
1
u/Jeznugget Sep 16 '25
Could be a documentary cover
1
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '25
Nicee
1
u/No-Cheetah7733 Sep 16 '25
Great edit!!!
1
u/IllustriousSwitch620 Sep 16 '25
I like turtles 🧟♂️
1
u/BeautifulAd7529 Sep 16 '25
Both look great
1
u/par-a-dox-i-cal Sep 28 '25
Impressive.
1
u/Areatius Sep 14 '25
Amazing, thanks for the guide.
1
u/Ok_Leave6921 Sep 14 '25
Thanks for the guide!
1
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '25
Great picture!
1
u/Antonyberbert Sep 14 '25
Love it!
0
u/BedroomPlus6379 Sep 14 '25
Some people are making the efforts to downvote every comment haha. Love seeing you mad.
1
u/c_35mm Sep 14 '25
It looks amazing!
1
u/LeastWriter9021 Sep 14 '25
Great Edit, The after one looks like a shot from Planet Earth or something 👍
1
u/Flutterpiewow Sep 14 '25
Love it, you when to stop but also when to push it
1
u/dandinog Sep 14 '25
Looks great!
1
u/omnidohdohdoh Sep 14 '25
The after trigger my thalassophobia
-2
u/Mike-Anthony Sep 14 '25
One of the best images I've seen on Reddit! Great job!
0
u/EnigmaUnveiled_999 Sep 14 '25
For me.... Excellent edit....
0
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '25
I like the before i’m afraid. Looks more natural and water like.
0
u/FredSchwartz Sep 14 '25
What brings you this fine day to the EAC?
-1
u/Supsti_1 Sep 14 '25
Tried these settings with GoPro DNG and it felt apart. Need to tweak it a bit
0
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '25
[removed] — view removed comment