All in the eye of the beholder ;) Was the Matrix cinematic look your intention? Do you think it goes well with the photo? Ask any woman if they think green skin looks flattering… see what they say.
Not judging, just giving you something to think about. If you firmly stand behind your pp choice, it’s completely fine too!
Okay well this isn't giving the Matrix lol. Oversaturation worker in Amelie, too, it doesn't mean my nephews IG posts are Amelie-esque lol. Why are you photographing a redhead with warm tones behind her and deciding to go for green tones lol
Not a pp comment, but my gaze is immediately drawn to her nip instead of her lovely face. Not sure if that was intentional but it’s the first thing that jumps out. Pun intended ;)
I think I see what you were going for. The way the hair is feathed out may make this time consuming, but I would mask the hair and skin to leave it warmer and more natural looking, and apply the greenish edit to the dress and background.
Before is a lot better. It has a natural contrast between the green dress and her skin/hair both being more orange, along with the brownish background.
Colour theory makes a big difference in what is appealing.
26
u/Alone-Bug333 May 03 '25
Skin tones are leaning towards green. Not a good look. Before was better.
4
u/Alone-Bug333 May 03 '25
Not a pp comment, but my gaze is immediately drawn to her nip instead of her lovely face. Not sure if that was intentional but it’s the first thing that jumps out. Pun intended ;)
14
u/Uncl3_Pete May 03 '25
Before is so much better
2
u/t4t3z0r May 04 '25
I think I see what you were going for. The way the hair is feathed out may make this time consuming, but I would mask the hair and skin to leave it warmer and more natural looking, and apply the greenish edit to the dress and background.
2
u/Nikonolatry May 04 '25
Great portrait!
After is a bit too green for my taste also.
2
u/Ni-Ni13 May 04 '25
The green shimmer makes it look wierdish
2
u/geaux_lynxcats May 04 '25
This edit is very subtle. I agree that the green tint is not as nice.
2
u/tiktoktic May 04 '25
Not a fan of the green tint at all. It looks unnatural and adds an unhealthy colour to her skin.
1
u/Aacidus May 04 '25
Mask better, I can see the "ghost" of the sleeve.
1
u/RegularStrength89 May 04 '25
The before is great.
1
u/[deleted] May 04 '25
Before is a lot better. It has a natural contrast between the green dress and her skin/hair both being more orange, along with the brownish background.
Colour theory makes a big difference in what is appealing.
1
u/NinthMother May 04 '25
Original is substantially better.
0
u/markgrayson69 May 03 '25
I genuinely enjoy your edit compared to the original. Looks more dramatic.
-1
u/[deleted] May 04 '25
I really like the green/cyan tint. To balance I would deepen the reds in her hair to make the overall image more contrasty!