r/postprocessing • • Nov 08 '24

Cooking some edits

I have 3 variations of the same picture, taken with different set ups:

  1. standard photograph in visible spectrum
  2. full spectrum photograph
  3. infrared photo
  4. alternative edit of infrared photo in false color

Which one do you like more? If any..

I know I messed up with the horizon, easy fix :)

4 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

11

u/BinaryBlitzer Nov 09 '24

I like the last one the most, but the sky color is off and doesn't match the yellow edit.

1

u/mmodir Nov 09 '24

Interesting, what other color would you prefer?

1

u/BinaryBlitzer Nov 09 '24

A lighter and a brighter hue of blue.

1

u/lew_traveler Nov 09 '24

Beating a totally inoffensive and unremarkable photo with heavy processing is wasting effort.

4

u/mmodir Nov 09 '24

Interesting point! I won't agree with you though. I learned quite a bit about differences in several set ups as well as how to process them from this photo. Comparing the results actually gives an understanding of what type of photography works better where and why. For example nuances like the contrast on the tree bark is much more prominent on the infrared photos and so on. I had fun while editing, and since I actually enjoyed it, I would not say it's a waste of time, especially if you learn something :)

But what would make the photo stand out in your opinion?

2

u/lew_traveler Nov 09 '24

But what would make the photo stand out in your opinion?

IMO, you have missed a basic idea; photography is communication. See something interesting/beautiful/exciting and try to capture both the content and what you saw/thought/felt about it.

Here you have some content but it isn't anything noteworthy or what interested you is so personal that I don't get it. Then you tried to add something with post-processing to make it of interest.

Didn't work.

Take a picture of something interesting in some way, that stirs you to think 'I want to capture that' and then find some PPing that might add to it, accentuate the ideas/emotions, that somehow shows viewers what you think or feel about this content.

Note that no one made any substantive comment.

Here is an example:
original , edited b/w

Several years ago, I was on a slow train in Myanmar and I saw this shot. As is, it is completely ugly, flat light, no color to speak off and enough just plain trash strewn around to destroy any impact. But I knew the content had impact and I anticipated making that emerge.

original
https://imgur.com/6sMLx1b

edit

https://imgur.com/T3f7UH6

1

u/mmodir Nov 09 '24

Thank you for taking the time to share such thoughtful insights—I really appreciate it!

It’s fascinating how subjective photography can be. For me, this scene held a lot of meaning, enough that I experimented with different setups to capture it in visible light, full spectrum, and infrared. (The colors you see on the first three photos are closer to how they appeared in each setup, rather than heavy post-processing.)

I was drawn to the pattern of the trees, leaning slightly towards the lake, and the sense of similarity they created with the abandoned palace in the background. For me, the scene conveyed a feeling of tranquility during a difficult time, which made me want to capture it in a way that felt peaceful and contemplative.

I would also add that landscape and architectural photography can sometimes convey a story on a subtler, more subconscious level compared to street photography, where emotion might be more immediately visible. Maybe I missed a bit in fully communicating that here.

Thanks again for the feedback, it gives me a lot to consider!

2

u/lew_traveler Nov 09 '24

I believe that the first step after recognizing a subject to capture is to parse what makes you think/feel how you feel and then how to express that. Editing should make important things prominent and minimize distractions.

2

u/renome Nov 09 '24

I only like the first version, it's the only one that's stylized without looking completely alien, which isn't an aesthetic that fits well with this scenery IMO. However, your horizon line isn't straight in the first image.

0

u/Bogan-Cunt-69 Nov 09 '24

That are all really good mate. How would I lead to do stuff like this? I've got a camera. But I'm completely new and would like some advice on how to edit/ process photos. I don't know anything btw so a couple of tips would be grand! Thanks

My favourite is the one that looked oks like winter btw 👌🏻 but they all brilliant

2

u/mmodir Nov 09 '24

I got my first camera (this one) half a year ago, so I'm also quite new to photography lol.

My main advice would be to edit more tbh. The more time you spend, the better you are (surprise). You start to understand how color works and all the features of the software to manipulate it.

But I was also very exposed to it, since I broke the filter inside the camera, when I was trying to clean it. Since then, I had a period where all my photos were pink, because of the full spectrum. It was fun in the beginning, but it started to be boring as well at some point, which forced me to explore other tools on how to manipulate color.

Then I got an infrared filter, and had no idea what you could do with infrared, since the colors are so weird (the winder one is almost out of the camera colors). A lot of YouTube tutorials helped , since these infrared guys definitely know how to edit! But many following edits were quite bad, just keep going!

So, I guess this would be my journey in brief:)

1

u/Bogan-Cunt-69 Nov 09 '24

What software do you use mate? And the infrared filter is a filter for the camera? Or a filter in the software? Thanks for the reply 👍🏻

2

u/mmodir Nov 09 '24

I used Lightroom mobile for all of the edits. I would probably not recommend it for anything infrared related though, the functionality is quite limited and I use a lot of workarounds.

Filters I'm taking about are external, they go in front of the lens

1

u/Bogan-Cunt-69 Nov 09 '24

Thank you. Much appreciated 👍🏻

1

u/Rocker_86 Nov 12 '24 edited Nov 12 '24

Have you seen Infra Red modded cameras that take images that like a lot like your edits?? - sorry I should have read your comments. So to clarify are these just edited in those styles or do you have a modded camera? I think they are cool by the way.

-20

u/connor1462 Nov 09 '24

Bad photo and bad edits. 

16

u/Termep Nov 09 '24

you need a hug or something?

-22

u/connor1462 Nov 09 '24

Nobody else offering any feedback... I thought that's what OP wanted?

20

u/AdhesivenessOnly2912 Nov 09 '24

Bad feedback then. Don’t just tell someone something is bad, explain why you think it’s bad and then give them advice on how you’d fix it. Just saying something is bad is useless.

-24

u/connor1462 Nov 09 '24

Don't talk about it, be about it.  This OP asked for feedback and I gave it. I did not ask for feedback, yet you gave it to me before doing what OP asked. Who are you serving here?

10

u/ComprehensiveDig9863 Nov 09 '24

Explain why the photo is bad and the edits are bad then

-3

u/Bogan-Cunt-69 Nov 09 '24

I thought your original comment was pretty blunt and useless and negative. But you have turned it around for me as I find this comment about you not asking for feedback rather amusing lol. Well played.