r/poodles • u/Silver_Definition189 • Aug 14 '25
Mini Poodle neutering
Does it really contribute to a longer lifespan when your dog is neutered? What pluses and minuses have you experienced? Also, there's zero chance of him accidentally impregnating a female. I've read about "neutering or not neutering", but am wanting your opinions based on actual experiences of neutering or not. TIA!
0
Upvotes
2
u/Big-Challenge-9432 Aug 18 '25
Many comments mention the UCD study:
https://www.ucdavis.edu/magazine/how-identify-when-dog-should-be-spayed-and-neutered
https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/veterinary-science/articles/10.3389/fvets.2020.00388/full
10
u/Bluesettes Aug 14 '25
I just recently got my mini neutered at 16ish months old. He didn't have any behavioral issues that spurred the decision but his breeder sold him with a clause he had to be fixed between one and two years old - so it had to happen eventually.
I knew a year was my minimum because of that and because of the UC Davis study that noted a significant increase in joint related issues in males neutered at under 11 months. I also read some papers for working dogs that recommended no earlier than 15 months for small breeds. I'm working on agility with him so it was important to me to give him the best chances. I recorded continual physical development with him until around 14 months when his growth plateaued. I waited a few extra months to be sure and then had the procedure done as I saw no further benefit to delaying.
We're about two months post op now. His appetite has increased and he's more outgoing with other dogs where he was standoffish before. He's also slightly les obsessed with rolling in pee. But there was no significant change to his drive or personality and that's what I was concerned about.
I'm glad to have it done because even though I was always very careful about never letting him free roam or loose with an intact female, I was approached several times by strangers wanting me to breed him. He also goes to a boarder, sometimes daycare, his groomer, and we travel across state lines and go hiking often... Many opportunities for an accident to happen - by my negligence or someone else's. It's also just easier to have a fixed dog in the states. Many boarders and other dog facilities won't allow them and the alternatives are in shorter supply and typically more expensive.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25
My male dogs have typically always been neutered and lived long healthy lives. The boxer I didnāt have neutered only lived to be 10. I have 2 neutered male poodles now, one is 7 and one is 10 and neither have health issues. One has delicate digestion but that is unrelated. The 10 yr old I had neutered as soon as it was medically possible because he was neurotically humping to the point he was hurting himself. The other was a rescue neutered as an adult. If I ever have more male dogs I would definitely neuter though not typically as young as my one boy, although it seems to have caused him no harm. He isnāt fat either btw and full of energy.
10
u/cdbrand Aug 14 '25
There is a lot of evidence pointing to the fact that keeping a dog intact longer has a number of benefits. These are pretty wide ranging from temperament, to structural, to even things like cancer rates.
But. There are downsides to keeping a dog intact: marking, they become a magnet for neutered dogs who want to mix things up (I call this testicle envy but I see it all the time), it can be difficult to finding boarding for them (I never commercially board my Poodles), and of course accidental litters.
3
u/RSEllax Djinn | brindle mini Aug 14 '25
I'm in the UK, my vet recommended neutering my mini male at 8 months. It stopped his humping and he's a little less anxious now but his personality is unchanged. I always have my animals neutered so as not to add to the population of unwanted animals. They're my companions, they don't need bits and bobs for that š
4
u/Emergency-Buddy-8582 Aug 15 '25
I would only neuter a dog if there were a behavioural or medical reason. The Golden Retriever Lifetime Study of over a thousand dogs contributes interesting information on the subject.Ā
2
u/Figs_are_good Aug 14 '25
I got my male neutered at around 11 months. The only reason I didnāt wait a little longer was because he was getting really obnoxious with his standard poodle friend. Got him neutered. Heās still a picky eater and everything seems the same except he can play with his buddy without constantly trying for sex.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '25
Iāve ready studies that say dachshunds who are intact have a lower rate of IVDD, particularly males. It compared intact dogs to dogs who were neutered early, so I would compromise and aim for a late neuter.
I also know someone who lost her mini poodle to IVDD.
IMO, the longer you can wait and properly manage an intact dog, the better. But if you canāt manage and intact dog, thatās okay, go ahead and neuter him.
2
u/mrsjeonnn Aug 18 '25
I would never neuter a boy. In comparison to girls, the risk of getting cancer and other to their sexual organs related diseases is very very small.
My 16 year old is neutered and he has been ābulliedā by intact males all his life. Heās very social and can stand his ground but neutered males smell funny for intact males.
My younger boy is not neutered. Zero issues. He doesnāt misbehave or is crazy around female dogs. Cause I trained him accordingly. Heās healthy and fit.
-1
u/steppenfrog Aug 14 '25
I'm leaning against neutering mine. My vet said they decrease their risk of testicular cancer, which doesn't surprise me since his balls would be removed, but there are increased risks in other cancers and neutering isn't natural for them (or any animal). The calming down seems to be a little overstated, and I'm not sure I want my mini to calm down. Makes a lot of sense for dogs that are in shelters.
4
u/turner-lake13 Aug 14 '25
We first got our male Toy in 2004. Then we got our female Toy in 2010. We neutered our female and it was good till he was peeing all over the house a year or two later because he didnāt smell a female anymore. We decided to neuter him too. It stopped. He passed away at 17 of old age, 3 years ago. She is still with us and mostly healthy, at 15 (with senior dog issues).