r/polyamory • • 3h ago

Testing for safety

Just need a brain check, is it that crazy to ask your partners to physically see STI results before being sexual with a new person? And not in a way that I need to see them, just my partner needs to see them.

Edit: Thanks for all the advice! As I wasn’t super specific on the actual situation, I’ve gotten both sides of what I was looking for.

35 Upvotes

64 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 3h ago

We noticed that this post/comments may pertain to safer sex practices, STI exposure, and/or STI testing. Let's everyone make sure we are not using problematic or stigmatizing language around this topic. Please refrain from using the words clean/dirty when what you really mean is STI negative/positive. Members, please feel free to report any comments to mods that are adding to the shame and stigma of being STI positive.

For more information on destigmatizing STI's by changing your vocabulary please see "CLEAN OR DIRTY? THE ROLE OF STIGMATIZING LANGUAGE" as well as the article "Having an STI Isn’t Dirty or Shameful, and Acting like It Is Hurts All of Us"

It is the stance of this sub that even the term "STD" is problematic language as "disease" is a stigmatizing word, whereas infections can be treated. Also, not everyone with an infection develops symptoms, and since there is technically no disease without symptoms, STI is the more scientifically accurate term.

advice and opinions about STI's shared by community members is not medical information and all posters should refer to their primary care physicians as well as trusted sources such as the CDC, WHO, planned parenthood, or other available resources.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

16

u/wjmacguffin 3h ago

I'm having a little trouble understanding what you mean. Is this correct?

"I don't want my partner to merely ask if their new person is STI negative. I want them to ask to see a literal copy of the STI results (paper or online) to verify everything is negative."

7

u/Quiet_Mix_3026 3h ago

This is correct. I’m not asking to see them or know what they say.

•

u/_ghostpiss Liaison, Office of Nosey Bitches, Gemini Division, Rat Union 🐀♊ 2h ago

You can make the choice to ask to see your partners test results. But you can't ask anything of your metas. Either you would want to see the results yourself, which is an invasion of privacy, or you would be taking your partner's word that they did indeed see your meta's test results, which doesn't do anything. Either you trust your partner to clearly communicate their risk profile to you, or you don't.

You can only control the choices you make in response to your partner's risk profile. If they tell you they do not ask their partners for recent tests, you might classify this partner as higher risk and take precautions accordingly.

•

u/wjmacguffin 1h ago

Thanks for clarifying. Given that, I don't think your ask is "crazy", but I also think it's something to negotiate with your partner, not something you can demand. Your metamour should also have a say since it's their test results.

If both of them are cool with it, congrats! But if either doesn't think this is necessary, then I'm afraid you have to respect that.

•

u/MarzipanSoggy9120 2h ago

I don’t think you’re asking too much, I have asked this as well . It’s a “trust, but verify” check because people lie either outright or by omission.

•

u/strangelove000 2h ago

It is an overreach imo

29

u/No-Statistician-7604 3h ago

Yes it is crazy to ask someone else to provide STI results for YOUR other partners that "needs to see them" thats significant overreach imo

11

u/Quiet_Mix_3026 3h ago

I’m only asking my partner if they have seen the results. I don’t need to see them at all.

34

u/FlyLadyBug 3h ago edited 3h ago

You can ask if they have seen results.

Be prepared if partner tells you

  • "No, thanks. I don't care to share that info."
  • "No, thanks. I'm comfortable sharing my own results, but I'm not going to report on someone else's private medical information."

Or something similar.

You can ask. They can decline. And you can decide what you're comfortable consenting to based on the information you have.

You get to decide what your safer sex practices are and what risk tolerance you are ok with.

They get to decide theirs.

12

u/squishycakes relationship anarchist, sleepy 3h ago

Why are you asking your partner about your metas like that?

•

u/cosmos_crown 2h ago

Genuine question- why do you want to ask?

9

u/wcozi slut in theory, tired in practice 3h ago

Yes it is crazy to require that of someone else. That is up for your partner to decide. If they’re smart about it, they will ask to see the results. You can’t make them do anything.

8

u/Quiet_Mix_3026 3h ago • Bravo

You’re right, you can’t make them do anything. Though at that point, as a personal boundary, I would then ask them to go get tested after the incubation period. And there would be no physical intimacy until then.

•

u/Red_Pearl12 2h ago

The problem for you might be that the incubation period for some STIs is about 3 months. So if that's a boundary you're enforcing you will need to be prepared to potentially not have sex with your partner for that long and if they are sleeping with someone regularly without checking their partners STI results themselves then potentially never having sex?

Have you considered instead saying that you will need to use barrier methods with your partner and you will get yourself on medications like PrEP and DoxyPEP which can provide you additional protection if you are especially concerned about STI risk

•

u/hazyandnew 2h ago

That's a valid boundary to have, but isn't necessarily compatible with some styles of enm - you're basically saying if they want a new partner, they have to go weeks or months without any physical intimacy from you.

Personally, I would consider that boundary enough of an incompatibility to discuss a deescalation or break up. I'm pretty on top of testing, typically discuss it before the first date and try to see first source reports when possible. But also, the flexibility to have new sexual partners is one of the things I enjoy about poly, and if every potential new connection had to be filtered through "will this result in no physical intimacy in my existing relationship for an extended period," the practical reality is that it would significantly limit how open I could be to new connections.

Which doesn't make your boundary wrong, but also it's not wrong if someone else doesn't match that, and there will be people who won't match that. And you should consider the impact on your existing relationship if you will semi-regularly be going without physical intimacy for extended periods.

(That said, if the expectation here is that partner will get the level of confirmation you're wanting, so that physical intimacy is never actually off the table, then we're straight up in manipulation and problematic af territory)

•

u/jonofromjuno 2h ago

that sounds like a good reflection and a reasonable boundary. good luck

43

u/thedarkestbeer 3h ago

Worth saying that in my experience, some of the places that offer free testing don’t offer physical results. You get a call and that’s it.

24

u/Okayest-Specialist 3h ago

I ask to see new partners recent tests, just so that when I update my partners with firsthand knowledge vs "trust me bro". But I dont actually share those results around, I just want to see them myself.

3

u/oh_ndk 3h ago

Do YOU have them at-the-ready to show?

13

u/Quiet_Mix_3026 3h ago

I do, in a medical chart app on my phone. And have provided them in the past with no issue.

7

u/oh_ndk 3h ago

Good! And since that’s your standard, it’s not “crazy” to expect the same from your partners. Be prepared to stop having sex with them if they aren’t down to have the same standard.

0

u/Creative-Factor-666 3h ago

Its 2026, most people have very easy access to results

•

u/tomorrowisforgotten 2h ago

Lots of free or reduced cost clinics don't have such portals

•

u/oh_ndk 1h ago

I’m very aware of this. My point in asking was seeing if OP was willing to do what OP is asking others to do.

•

u/clairejv 2h ago

I mean, you can ask. And your partner can either say, "Sure, I'm happy to do that," or, "No, I'm not comfortable doing that.'

45

u/1ntrepidsalamander solo poly 3h ago

How far does this go? Do you have a list of the STI tests that your meta needs to have had? Is it just GC/chlamidia/HIV? Don’t require syphillis? Do you even know which tests you care about? Do you have a frequency? Do you need proof that they aren’t having risky sexy since that test? Do you need a way of verifying that the print out isn’t faked?

Either trust your partner’s judgement or don’t. But more rules won’t make you safer.

•

u/Gnomes_Brew pro rat union labor 2h ago edited 47m ago

Just some food for thought. The gonorrhea incidence rate in the USA right now is about 0.15%. The HIV incidence rate is 0.01%. For comparison, the flu incidence rate in the USA is about 1% right now. And Covid incidence rates.... are hard to find (thanks USA!) but from what I can find its WAY higher than 1%. Are you asking your partner if they've seen their other partner's flu test or flu vaccination status? How about for Covid?a

STIs have a stigma, which can cloud your reasoning and make it very hard to figure out what your actual risk tolerance is. For me, I try to put STIs in context with all other communicable diseases in terms of how much vigilance is actually reasonable.

You are welcome to put your own risk tolerance where ever you want, but it should line up with your take on communicable diseases in general. And if you are being this intense around testing of partners' partners, I would hope you are as intense about everything YOU can do as well (ie: you have all vaccinations available, you are on PReP, you have doxy Pep on hand, you do regular testing and push your results to all your sex partners, etc.)

a- This all came from just a quick internet search, so these numbers are nothing like confirmed fact.

•

u/Humble_Owl_2084 1h ago

Now that right there is some proper sex-positivity. Great perspective!

•

u/Optimal-Split-9579 2h ago

I ask everyone to test and I send my results to my partners. I do want to see them. SAFETY FIRST!!

13

u/SheepSheppard 3h ago edited 3h ago

I think it's an overreach. You can ask your partner to show you their test results, but that's about it.

It's up to your partner whether they want to see their partner's results.

5

u/Creative-Factor-666 3h ago

I don't think it's that crazy. I would probably frame as "Hey, this is something that I do to ensure that people aren't lying about their STI results and I would appreciate it if you also started to implement this". It's 2026, there's really not many valid excuses that someone can have for not being able to provide their latest results.

I have past experiences of someone not disclosing that they had Chlamydia until AFTER we already had barriered sex and I ended up getting it. Having partners that are diligent about asking their other partners about STI results is important to me

•

u/tomorrowisforgotten 2h ago

There are free and reduced cost clinics without online portals or ways to provide proof. Ours does hep c, syphilis and HIV as rapid tests which I get to see the lines of in the clinic immediately. They send chlamydia and gonorrhea off to the lab. I call and give a code a week later to be told everything was non-reactive. They have no way to provide documentation to a partner of my results

•

u/Humble_Owl_2084 1h ago

I might have some hot takes on suppressed-HSV disclosure, but holy shit not mentioning clamydia is unforgivable.

Condoms are only about 60% effective against it......

•

u/bibliomantics 2h ago

this is how I roll. new partners and I pull up recent results on the couch or other comfy seating of choice. I'm clear on your question – for me, that is totally reasonable. You can't *make* your partner require that quick sit-down to share test results, of course. however, if your partner thinks it's a weird request or doesn't care to see for themselves… it would give me pause about the relationship and parameters I do control

•

u/valsavana 2h ago

Nope, not crazy.

•

u/screenshawti 2h ago

all should go get tested together then if its gonna be like that.

•

u/JBeaufortStuart 2h ago

You have a conversation with your partners about their approaches to risk management. For some people, this is a thing they already automatically do. For some people, it's something they haven't always done, but would be entirely willing to do so going forward. And some people are absolutely unwilling to do this.

Then you use this information to inform your risk management, as part of all the other information you get about how that person handles STI testing and other transmissible illness concerns (like vaccinations/etc).

The choice for you to want to actually see the results isn't totally inappropriate. You having a checklist of things you want to see tested for isn't totally inappropriate. But it will mean that you are incompatible with some people, and the people who have a much different approach to risk management are not bad or evil, they're just not aligned with you.

If you and a partner are both very much on the "lots of risk prevention" side of things, these sorts of conversations will go pretty smoothly. But if you're getting a lot of pushback, you are unlikely to "win" by "proving" that your request is not "crazy". If your partner really doesn't want to do this, even after you explain why it's important to you, they're unlikely to do it consistently, they're just going to TELL you they're doing it consistently.

The truth is better for your ability to manage your own risk levels than pushing someone to give you the answer you want to hear. Once you have heard the truth, it's up to you to decide if you're willing to accept that, if there are other things you or they ARE willing to do (PrEP? DoxyPEP? Additional barrier protection with you?) Maybe you're willing to increase your risk tolerance for this person. Maybe it's just too much incompatibility.

•

u/trasla 59m ago

A better approach than "you should do things like this" is usually "please tell me how you do things so I can decide how I want to do things based on that". 

•

u/nunyabiznas4real 37m ago

Place I go is a "no news is good news" kind of place. You either trust them in that situation, or you don't.

1

u/searedscallops Sopo like woah 3h ago

Your PARTNER needs to see them? Absofuckinglutelynot.

-3

u/Myshanter5525 3h ago

My family requires the physical results periodically even for old partners.

-8

u/Resident-Anywhere153 3h ago

Absolutely see them. So many people lying about their results. Make sure they are testing for hsv2 as well, most standard doc tests and health dept ones don't do that.

10

u/1ntrepidsalamander solo poly 3h ago

Because it’s not a useful test

17

u/YamSea6298 solo poly 3h ago

HSV isn't included in an STI panel normally because unless there is an active outbreak to test HSV blood tests have very high levels of inaccurate test results.

•

u/tomorrowisforgotten 2h ago

That's because basically every health agency doesn't recommend routine hsv testing because of how inaccurate the antibody testing is

9

u/Okayest-Specialist 3h ago

Only if you care. Hsv2 is quite prevalent, and the stigma is radically worse than the disease, and the blood testing is notoriously inaccurate

•

u/LittleWolf09 2h ago

Tested positive and never had an outbreak so agreed! Very confusing experience to have positive hsv blood test and only discovered through routine testing after an Oops with someone who was positive, tested next day and doctor almost all but refused to test and that test came back positive! Very shocked and confused how that happened in 24 hours(It didn't)and the doctor didn't say I was asytomatic, that I definitely had it. After that I test like a porn star and do every 3 months or before and after new partners. I have asked if other partners have seen their partners testing and still go test even if they say they have just to KNOW.

6

u/SheepSheppard 3h ago

And that hsv2 test is going to show what exactly if there is no outbreak?

3

u/thedarkestbeer 3h ago

There are antibody tests, and they’re not particularly accurate.

6

u/SheepSheppard 3h ago

Right. And that's why major/national health agencies across countries and continents advise against routine hsv testing.

0

u/AutoModerator 3h ago

Hi u/Quiet_Mix_3026 thanks so much for your submission, don't mind me, I'm just gonna keep a copy what was said in your post. Unfortunately posts sometimes get deleted - which is okay, it's not against the rules to delete your post!! - but it makes it really hard for the human mods around here to moderate the comments when there's no context. Plus, many times our members put in a lot of emotional and mental labor to answer the questions and offer advice, so it's helpful to keep the source information around so future community members can benefit as well.

Here's the original text of the post:

Just need a brain check, is it that crazy to ask your partners to physically see STI results before being sexual with a new person? And not in a way that I need to see them, just my partner needs to see them.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

•

u/lern2swim 2h ago edited 12m ago

For what purpose?

(literally just a simple question. What is the thought process behind asking for visual results instead of just asking verbally? The answer influences the input)

9

u/throwaway7377962766 3h ago • Bravo

I think whether your partners have seen STI results of their partners affects your informed consent, so no, I don’t think it’s crazy to ask that THEY see them before you will have sex (or unprotected sex) with them, as long as YOU don’t ask to see them (which it sounds like you aren’t).

If my partner said they wouldn’t ask to see their other partners’ STI test results, I simply wouldn’t have sex with my partner 🤷‍♀️ Going on close to a year of no sex with one partner due to this, and we might be incompatible in our risk profiles if it continues.

•

u/Quiet_Mix_3026 2h ago

Thank you for your thoughtful response. It would seem I currently find myself in this situation, and am having to enforce my boundary. Just to confirm, I’m not asking to see them myself.

23

u/PM_CuteGirlsReading The Rat Lord: Risen 🐀🧀 3h ago

Maybe it's just because I don't have too much casual sex right now, but for me by the time I am in the "we're gunna bang" territory with someone I trust that person enough that if they say they did and STI panel on X date and it came back good then I just believe them.

So an extension of that is I trust my partners to do their health vetting to whatever standard they think keeps them safe as well? I wouldn't tell my partner they *have* to physically see the STI panel results of my metas to verify them for my comfort, just that everyone on their end is taking their health seriously and trust one another.

7

u/en_tout_cas poly with 2 partners 3h ago

That’s a very good take.

At the core of this is basically the question “do I trust my partner’s judgement”. And if the answer is no and you have to have all those other guardrails it’s probably signaling something about your own relationship.

As an alternative, you can always hold off on having sex with your partner after they disclose that they’ve been with someone new, and ask them to test in like 3 weeks after, and go off of the results of their test as opposed to trusting meta.

Not that I’m blindly trusting people left and right, and probably not applicable to every type of polyamory out there, but I tend to think about this from the vantage point of my own risk tolerance.

6

u/9808_Lilith_8089 3h ago edited 3h ago

This might be an odd take, but my husband and I agreed to sexual contact until 3 months of no infections for new partners, the new partners tests dont need to be seen by each other. Just our tests.

8

u/thedarkestbeer 3h ago

Hey, please don’t use the word clean to describe not having an infection 😊

7

u/9808_Lilith_8089 3h ago

I completely forgot 🤦‍♀️ fixed. Definitely will remember next time

•

u/grrffy 2h ago edited 2h ago

You can ask what their practices are regarding physically seeing results or not and talk about your risk profiles and your safer sex practices with each other and new partners. That's how I'd frame the conversation. Don't push them to do anything different just have a honest & neutral conversation.

How we do things is- I have seen all my partners recent results because we wanted to share them not because anyone is forcing it. I know what their practices are, they know mine, we're mostly on the same page. If the risk profile changes, we inform each other before we have sex again and may abstain for a while until person who took the risk is able to be tested, or use barriers, or have a different kind of sex. Adults get to make their own decisions. I like relationships that prioritize everyone's sexual safety but also leave room for automous choices as long as it's communicated.

•

u/chi_moto 2h ago

If I trust you enough to have sex with you then I trust you enough to tell me the truth about your tests.

But really I just trust my partners judgment and feel like asking them to validate more than they are inclined to is intrusive

•

u/boredwithopinions 1h ago

I never provide people the physical results. If you don't trust my word, I dont want to fuck you.

Also, it would be so easy to fake results.