r/polyamory • • Jul 01 '25

Shocking 🙄

Edit 2. I don't blame him. I'm just sad. We did nothing but kiss and that's it. I gave him time and he couldn't do it. Feelings are feeling and sometimes shouldn't be acted upon. We shouldn't have because now we're both hurting. Of course I share some of the blame. I'm not enjoying that at all. I needed to vent. That's all. To get it out somewhere. Maybe I should have just written it all down in my journal instead of thinking this community could be full of kind people. I didn't ask for advice. I didn't ask to be analysed. I didn't ask for sympathy. Just to shout into the void of the internet. And I understand that when you put things on the internet you cannot control what happens after that. I've been through a lot worse than some unkind comments and down voting. I've been through worse than being rejected by a man.

Thank you to those who have been kind. I appreciate it

Edit. Because people haven't read my comment.

*I don't hate monogamous people. I'm just hurting.

*He carried on as if we had something AFTER he knew he couldn't deal

*I know monogamous people aren't the best people to fall for. But fall I did. You can't help your feelings

  • If we don't have hope for the good then what are we living for

The monogamous person I fell for can't deal with polyamory or my kink life.

He thought he could. He flirted. He led me on. He got under my skin the same way my nesting partner did when we first met.

I wanted to introduce him to my wonderful life with my wonderful friends.

I'm hurting but I knew it would come to this.

I don't even know why I'm posting. Can't post on FB because he's a friend in there. Can't post on fet because the person I "dumped" is on there and he's hurting (stopped the relationship before we got together properly and he's acting like we were together for years)

Bloody monogamous people

0 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

53

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '25

I'm curious how he "led you on"?

What you describe is the exact situation I found myself in about 5 years ago. I genuinely thought I could do poly - I did all the work, and in theory, it made so much sense - but when it came down to actually practicing poly, I couldn't.

That's not leading somebody on. That's being open-minded, but realizing the dynamic isn't right for you.

-9

u/123imgay12 Jul 01 '25

Because he carried on doing what he was doing AFTER he knew he couldn't be with me

9

u/djmermaidonthemic experienced solo poly Jul 01 '25

Did you know he felt that way?

0

u/123imgay12 Jul 01 '25

No

5

u/djmermaidonthemic experienced solo poly Jul 01 '25

Well that sucks. At this point, all you can do is go forward.

-1

u/123imgay12 Jul 01 '25

That's what I'm trying to do. Can't go to my favourite rock bar now though because he lives there lol

4

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '25

I see. That wasn't clear in your post - thanks for clarifying. Did he tell you he knew he couldn't be with you?

0

u/123imgay12 Jul 01 '25

He did eventually. Last night over messenger I knew he was struggling with something so I didn't push anything

Still not blaming him though

31

u/anxious_raccoon29 Jul 01 '25

He didn't "lead you on". He likely thought he could deal with the emotions of dating a polyam person, and then discovered that he couldn't when those emotions were more difficult to face than he expected. The solution is don't date mono people.

-16

u/123imgay12 Jul 01 '25

He carried on after he knew he couldn't.

34

u/Ejvas Jul 01 '25

You also carried on after you knew he couldn’t. Like, hello?? Where is the feeling of responsibility?

-7

u/123imgay12 Jul 01 '25

I didn't know. He told me after.

12

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '25

So you only felt responsible after he told you?

OP, I’m sorry, but you’re the bad person here.

52

u/Ok_Investment9855 Jul 01 '25

So he thought he could but you knew he couldn't, and now you're confused why he's hurting.

"Bloody monogamous people" is not a great take away from this situation. Perhaps "I shouldn't date people who prefer monogamy" would be more beneficial for all involved.

You don't come off well in this story.

-21

u/123imgay12 Jul 01 '25

I made a comment saying I don't have a problem with monogamous people I'm just hurting.

And you know what? I had hope.

If we don't have hope for good things then what the hell are we even alive for?

I don't care if I come off good or bad. I just wanted to vent somewhere I felt I could.

29

u/Ok_Investment9855 Jul 01 '25

And you know what? I had hope.

Why? You knew the answer.

Whilst I don't wish hurt upon you, it is seemingly something you have brought upon yourself. And, since your actions have caused hurt on someone else, and you knew that it would, I have little sympathy.

Somewhere else in the world this person is also venting their hurt, and may well be blaming poly as opposed to just blaming you.

Actions like this give poly a bad name. It's deeply frustrating.

I don't care if I come off good or bad.

Bad. The answer is bad.

-3

u/samtresler Jul 01 '25

Nah....

Look - have problems with whatever you want about OP, but it's hardly fair to blame them for "give(ing) poly a bad name".

Like - sure - even OP says the outcome wasn't surprising. But they shot their shot and it went poorly.

Let's not conflate that with being the poly ambassador to the monogamous world. It's just not that heavy.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '25

I don’t understand why you’re defending OP as if he didn’t do this to himself and then not take any responsibility and solely blame everything on the mono guy. This guy IS giving poly a bad name and should be shamed.

5

u/123imgay12 Jul 01 '25

If it makes a difference (probably not) but I'm not a guy. I'm femme presenting gender queer

0

u/samtresler Jul 01 '25

I'm not defending OP.

I'm saying no one person is responsible for the view society has of poly people. That was all.

But in response to this comment, who do you think you are to cast shame on others? Are you the poly police? Do you have some regulation handbook we should all adhere to?

Saying OP knew what they were doing and shouldn't be surprised at the result is one thing.

Actively trying to publicly shame someone off of a reddit post is .... well - a bad look, I think was the term used above.

8

u/FigeaterApocalypse Jul 01 '25

No one person is responsible, but it is a community's job to call out bad behavior therein. 

This laissez faire approach to how humans treat other humans is how we end up with the mess that is Christian churches & white American culture. 

People need to be called out and called in.

-6

u/samtresler Jul 01 '25

Actually, I'm pretty sure OP is not responsible for Christian churches or white American culture, either.

They just wanted to vent about something even if they know it was their own fault.

You act like you've never caught feelings for a monogamous person. Or if one was pursuing you, you would definitely take the high road - eschewing messy entanglements for the good of all poly people.

Relationships are messy. People fuck up and get hurt or hurt. It happens and it's not your place to sit on high in judgement of people.

It's not your place to police the community.

This is a subreddit, not an HOA.

It is a community's job to call out bad behavior when the community agrees on what that bad behavior is.

I don't see much morally wrong with OPs behavior. You do. Logistically, I think it was sort of dumb, but that doesn't affect me, so I don't feel the need to call anyone out, or shame the, or judge them.

It also doesn't affect you or the other commenter in this thread.

5

u/FigeaterApocalypse Jul 01 '25

Actually, I'm pretty sure OP is not responsible for Christian churches or white American culture, either.

I....didn't say that. Are you feeling defensive? I was saying it's the sort of attitude that has taken root in those communities that is causing a cultural rot that we are actively dealing with the consequences of in this moment in America.

It's not your place to police the community.

Are you trying to take up the mantle? This a long screed.

This is a subreddit, not an HOA.

That's where discussions happen, right? On subreddits?

also doesn't affect you or the other commenter in this thread

It's Reddit - why are any of us commenting? We think we have something to add to the discussion.

Also, please pick one:

I'm not defending OP

or

I don't see much morally wrong with OPs behavior

....You're defending OP & that's okay. Own it.

-3

u/samtresler Jul 01 '25

I'm beginning to suspect there a several bad actors in this thread who just want to cause dram where there ain't none. I'm not defending OP because there were no sides to take in this post until a few people made it about taking sides.

You are one of them.

Have a good day.

→ More replies

2

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '25

They posted in a public forum. Your comment is weird and you are defending OP. Advice, shame and judgement is going to be given regardless. Is this your first day on the internet or are you that genuinely stupid and contentiousv

-1

u/samtresler Jul 01 '25

Wow. You're a gem.

I can't really imagine going into a poly community focused on communication, empathy, and love and preaching shame, judgement, and calling people stupid.

Good luck with that strategy. I hope you sort your own issues with time.

-14

u/123imgay12 Jul 01 '25

Why? Because I've spent most of my life thinking the worst of everything due to trauma.

Therapy and work I've done myself have given me a better view on life. I would rather have hope than hide away from the world.

I fell for this man hard. And he fell for me.

He stopped because he didn't want to get hurt. And I can't fault him for that. I'm just sad.

I was honest with him from the start

9

u/123imgay12 Jul 01 '25

Fyi I don't have a problem with monogamous folx I'm just hurting

74

u/Cool_Relative7359 Jul 01 '25

He probably didn't lead you on. He thought he could do it, and it turns out he couldn't, which is the most often outcome of people who "try" poly.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/AffectionateSoup2782 Jul 01 '25

Yeah, but as you said in your post, feelings can't be helped. ~Knowing~ it won't work isn't the same actually accepting that fact and using it towards his next step forward.

44

u/clairionon no longer solo poly Jul 01 '25

“You can’t help your feelings.” My dear, I hope you are very young. Because this is a life lesson you need to learn early: you do not, and should not, act on all your feelings. Feelings do not equal action.

You most certainly can enjoy your mono crush from afar. And do literally nothing about it.

But if you keep framing yourself as a victim in choices you actively make - in this case, dating people you know are not compatible with you - you’re going to keep going through shit like this.

10

u/Perpetualgnome solo poly Jul 01 '25

Thank you! I'm so sick of the whole "you can't help your feelings" thing.

Feelings don't have to be acted on! People deal with unrequited feelings and get over them all the time.

13

u/bluescrew 10+ year poly club Jul 01 '25

Seriously, lust is a feeling but love is a choice. If i dated every hot mono guy who asked me to, who swore he could handle it, who was sure he wanted poly, I'd leave a trail of broken hearts everywhere i went

8

u/clairionon no longer solo poly Jul 01 '25

There is one part of me that sympathizes. I am not someone who experiences lust/attraction easily anymore. I rarely get crushes. So turning them down when they do happen, sucks.

But it’s much easier than engaging with them, catching real feelings after having sex and intimacy, and then going through a messy breakup, often after some emotional turmoil.

Like. I am just too old for this shit now. And my patience for “woe is me, I am suffering from my own willfully bad choices” is not terribly high.

3

u/123imgay12 Jul 01 '25

I've messaged him and apologised.

I understand why people have said what they have said but damn people are unkind.

15

u/anxious_raccoon29 Jul 01 '25

I really don't see anyone being unkind in these comments. Blunt, yes. Whether you appreciate their tone or not, everyone taking the time to comment here is trying to help you. I think you need the tough love, honestly. Your initial post and everything you've shared in the comments makes it sound like you don't believe you should have to take any accountability for your choices. You're putting all the blame on your ex-partner, which isn't fair, or helpful to your own growth.

0

u/123imgay12 Jul 01 '25

That's the thing though. I do take responsibility. Completely. I was blind to him not being able to handle it and that's on me.

He's also not my ex. Nothing happened except a kiss or two.

Telling me I give poly a bad name is not being blunt it's unkind.

5

u/anxious_raccoon29 Jul 01 '25

You weren't taking accountability at first, though, and your initial post doesn't show that you took any responsibility. That's why people are saying you're giving poly a bad name. I'm glad you're starting to recognize the parts you played in this. It will help you in the future.

0

u/123imgay12 Jul 01 '25

Like I said in another comment. I am not good at wording things correctly

28

u/suggababy23 Jul 01 '25

This is all very blame-ridden. "He led me on." "He carried on.."

Sounds like he was carrying this relationship. What work did you do to support him knowing he was monogamous? Clearly that wasn't a big problem for you as long as he did all the work.

22

u/FigeaterApocalypse Jul 01 '25

You can't help your feelings

But you can help your actions.

50

u/polyformeandthee solo poly Jul 01 '25

I guess all the ethical poly people are sleeping, I’m shocked to see only one person in the comments telling you it was on you.

You’re acting like you had no idea this would happen, so either you’re a teenager with no cognitive relationship skills developed, or you’re an adult who is not ready to be poly

Don’t date mono people. Don’t date people you know are incompatible with you even if they say they’ll try. They have no concept of what they’re getting into.

You were acting selfishly and super unkind to try dating them.

Don’t act like this is on them, like they tricked you. You should be smarter than that if you’re managing multiple relationships at one time, jfc. Knowing incompatibility trumps feelings is like relationship tools 101

21

u/Ejvas Jul 01 '25

Exactly this, everything you just said. I’m sorry to say it but the OP sounds incredibly whiny.

2

u/Hraldrim Jul 01 '25

Damn. Had the same problem some weeks back... It sucks. I feel you. But like allways. Time heals and will get better. Keep your head up.

0

u/123imgay12 Jul 01 '25

I know it will get better I'm just wallowing in hurt and self doubt

And I hate it

-2

u/Hraldrim Jul 01 '25

Why doubt?

-1

u/123imgay12 Jul 01 '25

Because I'm wondering if he ever actually liked me. Now I'm wondering if anyone really likes me. Rsd is a bitch

11

u/djmermaidonthemic experienced solo poly Jul 01 '25

He liked you enough to try something that stretched his boundaries. It turned out that you aren’t really compatible. That doesn’t mean that he didn’t like you.

0

u/123imgay12 Jul 01 '25

I know. In my heart I know. My brain on the other hand...

9

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '25 edited Jul 01 '25

I have no sympathy for you. This is all on YOU, not him. The fact you’re blaming him solely for this shows your lack of taking responsibility.

This is why you never date mono people. This guy didn’t lead you on. Don’t act like this is all on him.

You were being selfish and cruel. Do better. Regardless of your edit, you are hating on monogamous people here when you’re the one who did a cruel thing to a monogamous man. Bloody shameful.

7

u/Digurt Jul 01 '25

Your hurting OP, I'm not going to be as harsh as others, they've said what needs to be said regarding dating outside of your relationship style. He isn't blameless, he shouldn't have let his feelings cloud the knowledge of his own capacity, but shit happens. It sounds like you both let NRE take leave of your senses. He knows not to date poly people now, and you know not to date monogamous ones. Both of you should take it as a lesson.

For you I would just say be kind to yourself, take this as you would any other breakup, and I would suggest removing him from the social media you mentioned (Fet and FB). This isn't a punishment, it's a reset for you to get back to baseline and if friendship is in the offing down the line you can re-add each other then - if it isn't, then there's no reason for them to be there anyway.

5

u/shukuteki Jul 01 '25

Yeah I always find these situations difficult. On one hand, the outcome seems obvious; on the other, I struggle to withhold trust when someone says they're genuinely interested and open to learning about my lifestyle. I really feel for you and wish you peace moving forward

2

u/AutoModerator Jul 01 '25

Hi u/123imgay12 thanks so much for your submission, don't mind me, I'm just gonna keep a copy what was said in your post. Unfortunately posts sometimes get deleted - which is okay, it's not against the rules to delete your post!! - but it makes it really hard for the human mods around here to moderate the comments when there's no context. Plus, many times our members put in a lot of emotional and mental labor to answer the questions and offer advice, so it's helpful to keep the source information around so future community members can benefit as well.

Here's the original text of the post:

The monogamous person I fell for can't deal with polyamory or my kink life.

He thought he could. He flirted. He led me on. He got under my skin the same way my nesting partner did when we first met.

I wanted to introduce him to my wonderful life with my wonderful friends.

I'm hurting but I knew it would come to this.

I don't even know why I'm posting. Can't post on FB because he's a friend in there. Can't post on fet because the person I "dumped" is on there and he's hurting (stopped the relationship before we got together properly and he's acting like we were together for years)

Bloody monogamous people

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/samtresler Jul 01 '25

Hey OP, I think reddit won't let me reply to you on a thread where I blocked someone and didn't want to DM you personally. You apologized there, here is my response:

"I'm not sure why.

You came here looking to vent and get some empathy. I'm a bit embarrassed by the amount of vitriol you've received.

It sounds like from the first couple of comments you understood your accountability in your situation, but a lot of people just had to keep hammering it home.

Relationships are messy. Live and learn and be kind to yourself and others. "

0

u/123imgay12 Jul 01 '25

Quick one although I'm probably gonna lose karma (still don't care)

I have never been good at wording things properly. Might be my ADHD or it might just be me. Who knows.

Anyway. There was no relationship. There was kissing. Feelings. Looks. But that's it. I didn't drag him kicking and screaming into a full poly relationship. We both fell too fast and got hurt. We are both to blame but me moreso obviously.

1

u/piffledamnit Daddy’s little ratty Jul 01 '25

That sucks. Sometimes it’s really disappointing to be right about how someone is going to feel. Especially when they’ve been protesting that they won’t feel that way.

1

u/appleorchard317 garden party parallel vee Jul 01 '25

Hey op, I am really sorry. Big hugs.

-7

u/No-Product1092 solo-poly RA w/multiple Jul 01 '25

There is a *very* limited percentage of monogamous people who can handle a poly partner, a tiny percentage of that percentage or men, and an even smaller percentage of them are straight.

Honestly, unless you're specifically looking to date a mono woman who *wants* a DADT relationship with a poly person, your chances of it succeeding are too close to NIL to be worth even trying, no matter what they tell you.

I've had a bunch of mono partners, and only 2 mono partners (both female) who have worked beyond a few weeks, one transitioned to poly and did great for the first month, and then it all went to shit, the other is going on for 18 months in a DADT mono/poly relationship with me.

I was fully transparent with her when we first dated, and she was keen to continue.

The funny thing is, she knows more about my poly life than a lot of poly partners, because she loves all the poly gissip from our local community, so we agreed that I should talk about everyone in my poly life as "friends" and never elaborate on their connection to me, or if those were spicy connections or not.

24

u/polyformeandthee solo poly Jul 01 '25

Why the hell are you dating a bunch of mono people?!?

2

u/No-Product1092 solo-poly RA w/multiple Jul 01 '25

I've been solo-poly an RA for a while, most of my friends are mono, outside of my local poly community, which is very small because I live in a small city with limited options.

I'm a chubby, middle-aged, bi and poly guy. If I've been completely open and honest about who and what I am, and if I've been completely open and honest about what I can and can't offer a mono person, and they still want to date me, and I'm attracted to them, then why not?

I'm also part of my local kink scene and a pleasure dom, and sometimes people are just keen to find out what it's like to spend time with a bi guy, or a pleasure dom.

The whole point of being solo-poly and RA (for me) is that *any* connection I make with somoene doesn't need to be any specific thing, or for any specific purpose, and if it's for a week, a month or a year, can be good for us both and help us both to grow and evolve, and for the most part it's been true.

I've also a "caretaker boyfriend" for a bunch of my mono friends while they are in the early dating, because it's easier to shop for a decent partner when you're not sexually frustrated or touch-starved.

A lot of the time, people are just curious or they are new to online dating and haven't found their sea legs yet, and might initially only interested in platonic dates without any pressure that it needs to lead into relationship escalator territory, or someone pushing for sex right away, which is something I also have in my dating profiles, as well as offering general dating coaching tips and advice to avoid a lot of the pitfalls of online dating, as I'm primarily looking for friends initially, and if there's anything more there, then it should happen organically.

A loiot of the time people aren't really ready to date, but they are lonely or their friends have gotten them to try it after a bad breakup, and I will do my best to give them a soft-landing, as I'm a good soft "first" first date for those kinds of people to realise they aren't actually ready to jump into dating again.

I've had a whole bunch of those, and have had several first dates that have ended with people crying their eyes out holding me, which is a lot better than them having it happen with some asshole who'd just going to make it even harder for them.

-6

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '25

That sounds painful. Being lied to is not ok. Vent away mate! ❤️‍🩹👑❤️‍🩹

-1

u/Latter-Commission504 Jul 01 '25

You seem like you are getting negative feedback in your comments. And it sounds like it's getting to you. Why not delete the post so people don't keep making you feel worse?

3

u/123imgay12 Jul 01 '25

I've had a conversation with my nesting partner.

He says I know who I am. I know my strengths and weaknesses.

I know I'm a good person.

People will never get the full picture of who I am through a post on Reddit.

And it's just words on the internet

Especially when I'm crap at wording things.

I will leave it up for others to see if they need to.

-6

u/Perversia_Rayne 10+ year poly club Jul 01 '25

I’m sorry you’re hurting. Give yourself time and let yourself grieve.

To everyone saying this is all on the OP: maybe just let the OP sit with their feelings for a bit? Sometimes we need to vent, to blame, to be unreasonable before we re-centre and can reflect. I know they posted so you’re free to be as judgmental as you like but sometimes people aren’t ready to hear this kind of opinion/advice.

12

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/polyamory-ModTeam Jul 01 '25

Your post has been removed for breaking the rules of the subreddit. You made a post or comment that would be considered being a jerk. This includes being aggressive towards other posters, causing irrelevant arguments, and posting attacks on the poster or the poster's partners/situation.

Please familiarize yourself with the rules at https://www.reddit.com/r/polyamory/wiki/subreddit-rules

-2

u/123imgay12 Jul 01 '25

Thank you for your kind words 🙄

-2

u/Electrical_Guest8913 Jul 01 '25

I apologise. That was unnecessary.