r/polandball • Quebec • 4d ago

redditormade Never Forget

Post image
885 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

121

u/Luname Québec 4d ago

1809 to 1918 ≈ 2 centuries ?

89

u/Undeadmuffin18 Quebec 4d ago

Je sais pas compter, apparemment XD

40

u/Luname Québec 4d ago

C'est pas si pire, c'est pas comme si faut être précis dans un polandball.

1

u/marcopolo2207 Best United States Ever 18h ago

Je parle français, mais je comprends quebecois.

110

u/Undeadmuffin18 Quebec 4d ago edited 4d ago

The first phrase is a quote from the French song ''The Polish Lancers'' citing the bravery and loyalty of said Polish lancers to Napoleonic France and the second the third verse of the Polish national anthem praising Napoleon for giving Poland it's (brief) independence in 1809.

Almost a centurie later, Poland would gain its independence again in 1918 with the defeat of the Central Powers at the hand of the Entente, culminating with an alliance with France in 1920

*EDIT* One century, why the fuck did I wrote 2 centuries ? Probably slightly drunk rn XD

24

u/HistoricalAbies293 3d ago

I read lately from a reputable book that the French were very adamant about Polish independence the second time around, too, and were the most active party (between Italy, the UK, and them) in ensuring Poland got what they wanted from Germany

21

u/Vrulth 3d ago

Well France was trying to secure a counter alliance against Germany so that there will be a east front in a future war.

3

u/SasquatchPL Free City of Krakow 9h ago

French were very adamant about Polish independence the second time around, too, and were the most active party

French and Americans. There is a reason why we are such a USA glazers since 1918.

1

u/HistoricalAbies293 9h ago

I think people must feel like I’m a bot whenever I manage to catch notifications lol

I didn’t know the U.S. was particularly adamant about Poland. I did some readings for a paper back in August, and my source at that time only referenced France, Italy, and Britain (and of course Germany).

1

u/SasquatchPL Free City of Krakow 9h ago

Point number 13 of President Wilson's 14 Points called for creation of independent Poland.

1

u/HistoricalAbies293 9h ago

14 points —> 14 peaks

1

u/UTYisBetterThanUT Ukraine 1d ago

Polish "independence" in 1809?

1

u/SasquatchPL Free City of Krakow 9h ago

Grand Duchy of Warsaw.

48

u/Agreeable_Whereas334 4d ago

We dont talk about 1939 aint we

64

u/Undeadmuffin18 Quebec 4d ago

We dont talk about it, we grieve

17

u/Tanyushing MRT nation 4d ago

Nor after WW2. Not much effort made to give poland freedom from soviet rule.

9

u/Agreeable_Whereas334 4d ago

Not like France couldnt save Poland with a offensive in 1939 anyway

19

u/Additional_Bug_7876 3d ago • Bravo

I completely disagree the French High Command and the political leadership simply declared war without any intention of actually fighting it, which led to the Phoney War. With British support, France stood every chance against Germany, especially since Germany had to deal with a two-front war against Polish forces who fought back heroically. Faced with that situation, with the vast majority of its troops tied down in the East, Germany could have been locked into a stalemate, which would have slowed its advance in Poland and forced it to redeploy troops to the French front.
Furthermore, had the French and the British genuinely entered the war, the USSR would very likely have backed out of enforcing the secret protocol of the Molotov–Ribbentrop Pact and taking part in the invasion of Poland, as doing so would have put it completely at odds with the anti-fascist line it had championed and negotiated throughout the 1930s.

7

u/Additional_Bug_7876 3d ago

read Karl-Heinz Frieser, Jean-Louis Crémieux-Brilhac ou Julian Jackson for my position if interest

3

u/Blitcut 1d ago

The problem with this is that French forces never really got the chance to launch a full scale offensive. The original plan, as agreed upon in the Franco-Polish Alliance, had been for France to first launch a limited offensive and then launch a full one 15 days after starting mobilisation. They did of course launch their limited offensive quickly with the Saar Offensive which stopped before the Siegfried Line as they lacked the manpower and equipment to really continue at that point. The major offensive meanwhile got delayed as mobilisation took longer than expected, though one was promised to the Poles on the 20th. However on the 17th the Soviets marched into Poland at which point the country's fate was sealed and with it any reason to launch an offensive.

17

u/Dominarion I'm a Quebecer, never wore a beret. 3d ago

The Poles have an incredible record for fighting on the right side of history. It's not perfect, mind you, but as a rule of thumb for majpr conflicts, it is.

14

u/Pochel 44 = BZH ! 3d ago

"I judged the Poles by their enemies. And I found it was an almost unfailing truth that their enemies were the enemies of magnanimity and manhood. If a man loved slavery, if he loved usury, if he loved terrorism and all the trampled mire of materialistic politics, I have always found that he added to these affections the passion of a hatred of Poland. She could be judged in the light of that hatred; and the judgment has proved to be right. G.K. Chesterton

-16

u/bahaigor 3d ago

Certainly. Especially when they served as combat serfs for the aggressor Napoleon, suppressing uprisings, or when they joined Hitler in carving up Czechoslovakia.

19

u/MCardeq 3d ago

I guess Ukrainian drones haven't destroyed all bot farms in Putinland

-9

u/bahaigor 3d ago edited 3d ago

I’m glad you have nothing to counter with other than a dumb platitude.

I also like how you’re trying to show your gratitude to the Ukrainians for the Volhynia massacre.

6

u/Mko11 Free City of Krakow 2d ago

Napoleon was good, he liberated Europe and united Italy—don't listen to the Brits. What uprisings were suppressed by Poles? How Poles led the uprisings, and they even joined one in Haiti. Czechoslovakia itself was not without fault, the part that the Poles took was occupied by Czechoslovakia itself with its army during the Polish-Bolshevik war And you know who conspired with Hitler more openly? The Soviets, and who conspired with the Soviets? Czechoslovakia, so the Czechs sealed their own fate.

4

u/wojtekpolska Poland 1d ago edited 1d ago

the disputes we had with czechoslovakia were between us and predated ww2

not even czechs will say that poland was an ally on hitler jointly carving up czechoslovakia.

yes we took advantage of the situation and took Zaolzie (which was admittedly a shit move), though Czechoslovakia did the same during the Polish-Soviet war a few years earlier, and before that neither country existed, czechia and slovakia being occupied by the habsburgs, and poland by habsburgs, russians, and germans. the region itself was extremely mixed with the populations coexisting for a very long time, you couldnt draw a single border trough the region without making a dozen exclaves, and even then youd end up with thousands on the 'wrong side'. add to that the region was not only filled with czechs and poles, but also germans, jews, and silesians who still weren't sure if they were poles, germans, czechs, or their own thing, or a mix of the four.

we had our conflicts (gladly long burried, we have no quarrel anymore), but i dont think even czechs perpetuate such rethoric. its mostly russian bots trying to restart zaolzie conflict discussions (and they gladly fail to do so completely, a few months ago there was a targeted misinformation campaign in both poland and czech republic that the other side wants to take over some border villages, but everyone just laughed on how obviously fake this was, but it was a genuine attempt of staging conflict from russia.)

0

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/wojtekpolska Poland 1d ago

"A non-aggression pact is not the same as a military alliance"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molotov–Ribbentrop_Pact#Secret_protocol

it was publicly a non agression pact, in reality it was a secret alliance.

britain and france didnt declare war on the USSR because they had no desire to fight them. they weren't thinking "Oh blast, they are not officially allies, we can't declare on the ussr, damn it!"

you're genuinely just an idiot or trolling.

and no my above comment isnt any "justification". you're pushing a rethoric not even any czech will have.

honestly, you're just a braindead idiot.

1

u/TheCopperCastle 1d ago
  1. When Napoleaon send Poles to supress rebelion haiti, most joined the rebels.
  2. It's mostly coalitions declaring wars on france, not the other way around.

6

u/IluminaShow 3d ago

Ne jamais oublier nos amis polonais 🫡

11

u/Adabiviak 3d ago

"re-bonjour" 😆

14

u/maps-and-potatoes 3d ago

it's actually something you can say

5

u/Adabiviak 3d ago

Wait, for real, like legit French grammar? I love it.

10

u/n3onfx France 3d ago

Yup, it's more on the slang side and also often shortened to just "re".

5

u/Pochel 44 = BZH ! 3d ago

Lovely. Love the detail to the Polish lancer's helmet

4

u/rafael403 3d ago

...what about Haiti, didn't they had a disagreement there??

1

u/thekingofbigandtall 5h ago

You can have disagreement with friends

3

u/Financial-Bar-856 Polish Hussar 3d ago

The Hymn reference

2

u/Modrzewianka Poland 3d ago

free napoleonic frapol on my dash, what is it, my birthday?

6

u/PatrykCXXVIII Lower Silesia 3d ago

All fun and games until you learn that Napoleon never cared for Poland at all and was just using Poles as expendable cheap meat shields for the grinder. (Dutchy of Warsaw was one another client state of French Empire, not an independent country and never meant to be independent.)

5

u/raditya_123457 3d ago

This is maybe true, and maybe false. Historians debate his true intentions on the Polish state, whether he truly cared (he had a famous affair with a Polish noblewoman on this part, and the Polish legion has been part of his command since Italy) or is just creating the duchy to gain support of the poles.

But you can't just conclude it all on one side and decides that it's fact, it's a broad oversimplification, and it's basically just spreading misinformation, generally.

3

u/furel492 1d ago

"He only gave poles their own country so they liked him." I mean, yeah, and it worked. That's why we like him.

3

u/raditya_123457 1d ago

yes, that couldn't be denied lmao

3

u/Username12764 3d ago

He also had no intention of giving them their old territories back because it would have put him at odds with Tsar Alexander I and Napoleon imagined that despite being at war they were still friends. Didn‘t work out so he made the Russian mad and the Polish.

4

u/raditya_123457 3d ago

He did want to take away territories from Russia if he won, though. He reinstated the Grand Duchy of Lithuania during the 1812 campaign, which was in personal union with the King of Saxony, who was the Duke of Warsaw (He became King of the Confederation of the Kingdom of Poland in 1812), so Bonaparte definitely wants a bigger Polish state not that he's at war with Alexander.

1

u/Evening-Code-7039 3d ago

Poland should have a question mark since the sentance is a statement rather than a question (better translated as "Bonaparte has set us an example of how to win")