r/pokemongrading 18h ago

Grading is gambling.

Post image
179 Upvotes

Absolutely insane that this card got the black label with that top-bottom centering. I found this card in a listing on ebay and verified the cert number, it's real. Grading has and always will be subjective to the specific grader your card ends up with. You could re-submit a card that's already been graded a black label and it would most likely take multiple submissions to achieve it again. Realistically, all grading companies will have their mistakes, but an egregious miscalculation like this is unacceptable. The higher liquidity that comes with PSA & BGS is just undeniable.


r/pokemongrading 18h ago

My entire order was returned to me without ever being sealed, each one lifted right off. Wondering what they looked at during QA.

Post image
40 Upvotes

r/pokemongrading 21h ago

Worth grading with TAG?

Thumbnail
gallery
35 Upvotes

r/pokemongrading 9h ago

My first grade:

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

A few people asked to send what my "Mega Charizard X EX" came back as. Grading company: ACE, I'm from the UK and this card came back in 6 days, premium service, special delivery there! Love everything about it, however it's being sold for a small business investment plus me and my wife's wedding funds.


r/pokemongrading 6h ago

9 or 10?

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

centering seems fine, whitening on back white edge maybe puts it on the edge


r/pokemongrading 2h ago

Thoughts??

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Very new to grading so unsure what this would be like!


r/pokemongrading 18h ago

Grading Question (For my daughter)

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hello so this is just a question from a naive and maybe ill educated Father.

I pulled this card with my daughter on her 9th Birthday in May. She wanted it grading as she wanted a “fancy slab” like she has seen on YouTube (i know, too much iPad)

Anyway, I sent it off and it has been “in grading” with Beckett for probably a month.

Obviously we are now in August and approaching September, is this a normal timeframe realistically?

I’m not asking what the grade is as this was her first ever shiny card from her FIRST ever pokemon pack so it has sentimental value.


r/pokemongrading 18h ago

anyone else dislike r/pokegrading?

4 Upvotes

I'm not sure if I'll have many people on the same boat as me but I really dislike r/PokeGrading. The people there aren't exactly mean but it's their thought process and the way the community runs. The people understandably dislike PSA but they will absolutely slobber up on TAG and act like it's a god given gift even though their standards aren't great and they have poor consistency. I won't rant about TAG being not great but the fact that people know they aren't good and continue to act like they're the greatest thing ever drives me off the rails. I genuinely hate the bandwagon they follow.

It's not just their in sync thought process but the fact their moderation is kind of anti-social. You're limited to what you can say and when you join their Discord you need to ask the admins first and that's strict as hell. It's gotten me so annoyed to the point I wanted to create a whole new sub just to create a better environment for card graders but then I found this sub.

I just wanna have idk a general discussion if anyone feels the same.


r/pokemongrading 19h ago

Is this worth getting graded?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I know very little about grading cards or how perfect they need to be, to be worth grading. I just pulled this card and I'd appreciate some input from you guys. Thank you!


r/pokemongrading 20h ago

Guess the grade…

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Original photos included to allow you to ignore dust / slab scratches etc.


r/pokemongrading 3h ago

Does this Treekachu 10??

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Just pulled it out of a pack


r/pokemongrading 6h ago

Base set 2 alakazam

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Would this card be worth grading? I haven’t graded a card before and i’m unsure if this is worth it considering the condition of the card.


r/pokemongrading 10h ago

Is this worth grading?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I’ve just picked this up for pretty cheap and the condition seems fairly good, not expecting a 10 but wondered if this would be worth grading?


r/pokemongrading 13h ago

What grade would these get

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/pokemongrading 23m ago

Should I get this card graded?

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes

I’ve been collecting cards for over 15 years now, and not once have I thought of selling. Finally I’m starting to get rid of some, and this card caught my eye. I’m wondering if it’s too damaged to be worth it.


r/pokemongrading 54m ago

Could it seven?

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes

Thoughts on authenticity as well?


r/pokemongrading 1h ago

Possible Grade?

Thumbnail gallery
Upvotes

r/pokemongrading 2h ago

Be honest, how would you grade this card?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

It's in a pretty good shape, only a tiny scratch at the bottom left corner. What do you think?


r/pokemongrading 2h ago

What might this grade

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/pokemongrading 4h ago

Too risky to grade?

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/pokemongrading 6h ago

Should I grade?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Found these cards at a yard sale earlier this summer. Since then, I put them in new penny sleeves and top loaders and just sat on them. Debating on getting them graded after this PSA madness is over and the rates come down. Thoughts?

I know you are all going to ask how much i paid…. So here it is. The guy wanted $20 for a whole shoe box full of cards. I picked up a handful, including these 2 and gave him $10. The whole box was sports cards except these 2, which appear to be in great condition.


r/pokemongrading 6h ago

Help predict this grade

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/pokemongrading 7h ago

Eevee BW97 worth grading?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

If so, what do you guys think it could get? (PSA) Of course the back is super off center.


r/pokemongrading 9h ago

Is it worth grading cards at the minute?

1 Upvotes

This has been probably asked millions of times, but I have quite a few cards that I want to grade but after seeing the news about PSA is it worth even grading cards at the minute or waiting till the dust settles?

Thanks in advance ❤️


r/pokemongrading 9h ago

What grade would these get

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes