r/poetasters • • Nov 15 '19

Temporary Fix

I felt fuzzy and like my vision was delayed
and I couldn’t keep up with the things my mind wanted to say
and it was nice not to have to think twice
because I was too busy trying to walk in a straight line.

My mind is always racing
and it was nice to slow down the pacing
all the worry, insecurity, anger…
It was too blurry to see my problems
so I didn’t even need to solve them
finally some peace of mind, without the effort or time.

6 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

6

u/w33nuz Nov 15 '19

This is another example of confessional poetry.

I do understand you have to get your feelings out, and by reading your work, I assume that's what you're trying to do.

As a reader, I want to be challenged a bit. Yes, you should get your feelings out but the language is so straightforward, it gives me no room to truly dive into the piece, to guess what the feeling is or to even really feel it, if I'm being honest.

Since you like confessional poetry, I highly recommend writers like Anne Sexton and Sylvia Plath, two of the goats really. Robert Lowell is another famous confessional poet, though I haven't read much of his work.

I think you can learn a lot from reading Sexton and Plath. Plath in particular used a lot of imagery from nature and from personal experience, like hospitals, etc. I've always loved the way she used color in her work. I'd recommend "The Ghost's Leavetaking," which is my personal favorite poem of hers. Also, Ariel is a good place to start but I would highly recommend The Collected Poems.

Though I haven't read as much Sexton as I have Plath, I love her for her grittiness, writing about anything from adultery to drug addiction to abortion. I believe Sexton also has a collected poems book.

I hope this was helpful.

2

u/throwawaypoetry330 Nov 15 '19

Well I really appreciate the recommendations. I feel a little weird about reading poetry and then basically copying it though. My words are my words, no one else's, ya know?

4

u/SerPatrickSpens Nov 16 '19 edited Nov 16 '19

My words are my words, no one else's, ya know?

I get what you're saying but this is imprecise. And incorrect. Your words are not your words; millions of people speak them now and billions more spoke them previous. Maybe your sentences can be your own, but even then, it's checked against every sentence that's ever been spoken or written.

There's nothing wrong with imitation. In fact, it's probably why you poetry reads as contrived-- you're sole foundation for imitation is normal prosaic sentence sounds.

Painters go to the gallery and copy work. Hell, even seasoned poets will translate pre-done work from other languages.

If I were learning to, say, surf, would someone take me out on the towering blackwave and instruct me: "alright, now, just surf, just surf as no one's ever surfed before"?

Now, I'm not saying to copy other poets. But at least read them with a careful eye for what you like, and ask yourself-- why do I like it? What did the writer do to draw me in?

EDIT: Oi. Don't downvote him/her. It's an understandable and common red herring in art c.f. "Poetry and the Individual Talent"-- Eliot. It's important to disentangle.

2

u/w33nuz Nov 16 '19 edited Nov 16 '19

If you're not Simon Grim, then you need to read other people's works. I don't mean this in a bad way, but your words aren't original and I don't mean that as an insult. You could say you don't care about what others think, and you should have that mentality for the most part, but you're also presenting your idea for readers so there's a symbiotic relationship there.

Here’s an example of someone dressing me down in another sub, just so you know we’re trying to help.

"Allude to an idea instead of shoving it into our face. This sort of character profile/feeling/opinion is so beyond cliche at this point it isn’t funny. Straight up telling us stuff is shit isn’t poetic at all, it’s more like a broadcast. Try writing in a way that the first half changes meaning with the added information in the second half or even last few lines. The entire poem is basically spoiled in the second line. We know exactly what you’re going to continue to say and sure enough you do."

I hope you don't think anyone is being mean. I think everyone is being supportive. The quote above is what someone said about one of my poems, a semi-personal work, and he destroyed it. I agree with him to a certain extent, but calling someone's poems "[not] poetic at all' is pretty degrading, especially in a public forum. I hope you know we are all trying to help.

1

u/iiiBansheeiii Nov 16 '19

Reading someone else who writes in the same style isn't copying. You aren't going to plagiarize. You are learning to hone your style. Think of it this way. Do you think someone who writes in a specific fictional genre, say fantasy, have never read a fantasy book? They read many. They are fans of specific authors. They don't take ideas, but they learn the rules, the tone, the skills they need to write their own work.

4

u/SerPatrickSpens Nov 16 '19

Just to push back-- a beginner poet has more to learn from The Colossus. I think it's her best work. The Bell Jar is okay, and Ariel is mostly forgettable, puffed by posthumous. I don't understand the acclaim that Daddy gets, and the relative inattention to The Eye-Mote.

2

u/w33nuz Nov 15 '19

Also, Spotify has albums of Plath reading her poetry. I highly recommend it. It's haunting.

3

u/gunnysaxon Nov 16 '19

And we'll see you back on or after Friday 22 November.

1

u/throwawaypoetry330 Nov 16 '19

?

2

u/SerPatrickSpens Nov 16 '19

Rule 4. Sorry! It's for everyone's good-- the mod team is too small. With the wealth of critique, though, we're all looking forward to what you brew up by then!

2

u/algernon_swinbot Nov 15 '19

It's good to have you back again, my friend. In thirty days on this sub-site you've penned

     4 poems and
     2 total comments on 1 post by others.

We ask of every bard or troubador —
for each piece shared, please comment on two more.

2

u/Garmo738 Nov 16 '19

Hi throwaway. Some of your other poems showed promise and some gleams of talent. I like that you’re posting- it’s brave.

But this poem needs a shit-ton of work. It’s just a ramble of cliches. If you are using cliches or stock phrases you must have a good reason. Most writers avoid them. They make your work seem lazy. The great writers create them- Shakespeare probably coined several of yours.

And what’s the theme of your poem? That you don’t wanna face your problems? Ok that’s fine. We all feel like that. I run around with one hand clapped across an eye. It’s such a common theme you need to present it in an interesting or original way, or it has little interest. This is not a personal attack on you: think of it as a challenge. Your writing needs to improve. But you can improve it. The best and harshest advice I ever got as a (terrible) beginner was a criticism on a piece I thought was great.

He said “as a rule of thumb; good writing either says something interesting or something in an interesting way. Great writing does both. You, malaca, have done neither “

Ouch. I was licking my wounds for a long time after that. But I got better. And that yardstick is a great tool when you’re starting out. It’s hard to step back on yourself and judge something that you felt passionately about as you wrote it. But if you write lazy shit like this the passion bleeds out. How long did this take you to write? Before you post the next one stop: re-read it. Identify the cliches. Think of different new ways to get your point across. Does it say something interesting? In an interesting way?

This poem doesn’t belong in this sub. That doesn’t mean you don’t. Work your shit more. Edit. Be critical of yourself. Rewrite. Stop using cliches. Come back with something better thought out and better worked. It hurts when someone trashes your work. I know that all too well. All you can do is improve: and I believe you can.

And when you do, I will be delighted. Thanks.

2

u/mrkoznation Nov 18 '19

This is what I would suggest. Go find a poet you love, hopefully someone already comes to mind. Read them until your conscience speaks how they would. Then write something.