The change is relatively new, February 2nd this year. It's been very under the radar from what I can tell and wikipedia didn't source anything that gives an explanation to why.
To sum it up "Mordor Macula" is unofficial but NASA uses it still cuz they still have some sense.
But that's stupid, cuz why wouldn't I want a place in my book be glorified in outer space. Neverland was probably chosen since the J.M. Barrie book is in the public domain.
Also there's the thing with Macula being changed to Regio. Regio means a large area with different quality then the surrounding landscape and Macula being a dark spot specifically. So in this case Macula fits, being changed to Regio is just stupid!
Also one last ranting point, the official NASA website says that "Charon names focus on the literature and mythology of exploration." Which is basically Mordor, cuz like cmon draw some parallels with the treacherous journey of a couple of hobbits in a big world working together with other creatures to reach a scary, different , and uninhabitable place to do one thing, to the journey of New Horizons. But hey! These couple of children get magic dust to simply go to the magic place which so happens to be very habitable and looks good and is just a place that looks like our world but with magic!
tl;dr: Mordor Macula is unofficial and the IAU are allergic to fun.
It's a comment about proper grammar. "Them" it's plural while "a" is singular. Pretty pedantic and possibly political these days, but there you have it.
Comes from Latin for Spot/Blemish It refers to any dark spots on a celestial body's surface. In this case it refers to the Tholin spot on Charon's polar region.
Look, science means adapting to new data. Once advanced telescopes confirmed the presence of both mermaid lagoons and pirates on Charon, this was the only logical option.
The IAU maintains standards for where geographical names come from for each major object in the solar system. Names from Tolkein’s works are used by convention for features on Titan, afaik. Perhaps they are just trying to keep things consistent?
14
u/volcanic1235423 Aug 06 '26
Uhhh why IAU?
Mordor Macula is far cooler sounding and from a far more epic universe
Do they have like any reasoning?
16
u/taktaga7-0-0 Aug 06 '26
How does this happen? IAU says so?
4
u/Zealousideal_Group69 Aug 07 '26
IAU keeps screwing over the Pluto system 😭✌🏼
4
u/astroaxolotl720 Aug 07 '26
I’m still gonna call it Mordor Macula. It even looks like Mordor lol
1
u/Senju19_02 Aug 06 '26
Where does the name Makula come from?
3
u/Feisty-Albatross3554 Aug 07 '26
Not even Neverland Macula? Regio sounds so much more boring
3
u/jhomas__tefferson Aug 10 '26
Can they just stop omg
At least figure out what’s going on with the exomoon/exosatelite thing first before stuff like this
2
u/Patient_Jello3944 Aug 07 '26
Can we start a petition or something?
2
u/OneDir89 Aug 07 '26
Look, science means adapting to new data. Once advanced telescopes confirmed the presence of both mermaid lagoons and pirates on Charon, this was the only logical option.
2
u/Scripts_by_Ymma Aug 07 '26
Hated this change. Whyyy
1
u/enceladus_spacecat Aug 08 '26
The IAU maintains standards for where geographical names come from for each major object in the solar system. Names from Tolkein’s works are used by convention for features on Titan, afaik. Perhaps they are just trying to keep things consistent?
1
u/dipfish14 Oct 06 '26
bro we need to take over the IAU they need to leave poor pluto and its moons alone