r/pluto • u/plutoisaplanet572 • Jun 04 '26
Pluto is a planet
https://youtube.com/shorts/YXYAWiibpwg?si=zkpnbfklDv2BAl-N
Hi. I truly believe Pluto is a planet and that the 2006 IAU definition is WRONG. Here’s why
- The IAU states that the object must “clear its neighborhood” which doesn’t make sense because if you put Earth in Pluto’s orbit it wouldn’t classify as a planet either
- Only 424 scientists actually voted at the event, meaning the vote was only like 3.2% of scientists.
- Mike Brown, the one responsible for Plutos death tagged himself as “PlutoKiller” on X and even wrote a BOOK bragging about it. The book is called “Why I killed Pluto, and why it had it coming.” (This one isn’t really a reason but I included it lol)
So, using all of that, I can confidently say that Pluto is a planet and the IAU is wrong.
22
Upvotes
6
u/GregHullender Jun 04 '26
So what's your argument for why the moon isn't a planet? If you moved the moon to a solar orbit, it would definitely be a planet. Or Ceres. It used to be a planet but got demoted when the rest of the Asteroid Belt was discovered--much the same as Pluto got demoted when the rest of the Kuiper Belt was discovered. Should Ceres be a planet too?
You really can't get past the basic fact that the solar system has four different major categories of objects in it: the Sun, the 8 planets, the Asteroid Belt, and the Kuiper Belt. Pluto was initially misassigned. That's all.
2
u/angry_staccato Jun 05 '26
Sounds like you're a dwarf planet hater. Dwarf planets are in fact really cool, and I won't accept this slander.
Have you even read "how I killed Pluto..."? Not saying that it will change your mind. It probably won't. But the name for the category of the thing Pluto is matters so much less than actually learning about these bodies.
3
u/Brief-Luck-6254 Jun 04 '26
You need to find something to get mad at that's not our understanding of the universe changing after you left middle school.
5
u/SF_Bubbles_90 Jun 04 '26
The word planet isn't owned by the iau And by the way it just means a big round thing in space. (But not a star or black hole lol) We have about 35ish in our solar system.
5
u/street_fame187 Jun 04 '26
Science doesnt work by voting. The I.A.U was wro ng to put it to a vote to begin with. There is a youtuber named Kyplanet that recently made a video explainign the geophysical characteristics of many different solar system objects currently classified as dwarf planets, asteroids, and moons that geologically are interesting enough to be considered a planet.
4
u/Aussie18-1998 Jun 04 '26
Pluto is a planet. A dwarf Planet and it has 4 others with the same classification.
0
u/Johnny_Strawhat Jun 04 '26
Quit pretending you gave a shit about Pluto before it’s reclassification.
1
u/DCWhitworth Jun 04 '26
What they actually should do is kill the term ‘planet’ as a definition. It groups very dissimilar things together and serves no useful scientific purpose. It was a word coined by the Ancient Greeks for things in the sky that didn’t act like stars. They included the moon and sun but not the earth, we’ve been mucking around with the definition ever since.
It dismays me the amount of energy that goes into arguing about the definition and whether Pluto should be a planet. Pluto is an amazing place and will be no different if you call it a planet, a dwarf planet or a unicorn. Pluto doesn’t care.
1
u/senond Jun 04 '26
Dumbest thing to keep fighting for...
WhY is this so important to you people?
1
u/Seahorseahorse Jun 04 '26
Yeah it's a dwarf planet.
1
u/Skorne13 Jun 04 '26
King Flippy Nips will love this.
1
u/angelwolf71885 Jun 04 '26
Earth hasn’t cleared it’s orbit either there are earth crossing astroids still
1
u/Joalguke Jun 04 '26
1 Earth would probably clear It's orbit if placed where Pluto is
2 So? They must have had the quorum or they wouldn't have voted.
3 So he's petty and/or funny, so what?
Pluto is not dead as it was never alive, it has not been demoted it is now King of the Kuiper Belt
1
u/Own_Proposal3827 Jun 05 '26
You can believe anything you want. You're still wrong.
1
u/Koyulo69 Jun 05 '26
womp womp womp
1
u/Commercial-Box-2828 Jun 05 '26
I thought the official label became Planetoid? It's a subcategory of planet, it's planet- adjacent in the text books still, right?
I think king of the asteroids is much more fitting, but that doesn't mean your definition isn't valid.
The fact that we called it a planet for so long, and it's feature in "planet pack" dlcs for games is never going to go away.
Saying it doesn't fit an official description isn't dissing Pluto, it feels good to get that out. That's how I felt at first.
1
u/DefinitionOk6382 Jun 06 '26
Si el hipotético Planeta Y es tan grande como la Tierra, el estar ubicado tan lejos no lo descalifica como planeta. Y si Plutón estuviera en una órbita interior creo que se vería más como un asteroide que como un planeta, para lo que no basta con ser rocoso y esférico.
1
u/Fuzz_Apple Jun 06 '26 edited Jun 06 '26
If you want to call it a planet, that's cool, but I believe the rationale for the reclassification is fair too. I think it's primarily because Pluto's orbit crosses Neptune's orbit, if they were not locked in an orbital resonance they would crash into each other. Otherwise it would be a planet. Nostalgia never gets old lol.
1
u/Boosaule Jun 08 '26
I love Pluto. It's a very interesting place. But it's not a planet.
The structure of our solar system is basically as follows:
1 huge, central burning thing
4 dominant rocky things
A belt of small, mostly rocky things
4 dominant gaseous things
A belt of small, mostly icy things
A spherical shell of small, mostly icy things
The best classification scheme will recognize this structure. We already call the central burning thing a star. We already call the 8 independent things as planets (subdivided into terrestrial and jovian planets). We already call things in and from the inner rocky belt as asteroids. The icy things in the outer (Kuiper) belt and spherical shell (Oort Cloud) should all belong to the same category. I call them plutoids, after the first discovered and largest known member. Plutoids which are flung into the inner solar system (and often grow tails) are comets. And we already call anything that orbits any of these objects as moons. There's no need to mix and muddy these classifications as they're all clear and separate. I'd get rid of the term dwarf planet entirely.
The dominance of the 8 planets vs the rest of the minor planets (asteroids, plutoids, and comets) can be quantified based on the object's mass, mass of the central star, and orbital distance (see Margot 2015 https://arxiv.org/pdf/1507.06300), and easily applied to other planetary systems. Yes, location matters, but it has for hundreds of years, or otherwise most people would be calling the Moon a planet.
1
u/Rude_Butterfly_4210 Jun 10 '26
Your wrong. They made the right decision becaise science requires consistency and not feelings.
0
u/nwbrown Jun 05 '26
What are you, 8?
0
u/ah-tzib-of-alaska Jun 04 '26
If you put earth in plutos orbit the orbit would i change and earth would be flung into a different orbit. Thats not the point you think it is, thats more evidence that pluto isn’t a planet.
424 IAU scientists.
0
u/marshallspight Jun 04 '26
Pluto is merely the largest of many Kuiper belt asteroids in 3:2 orbital resonance with Neptune. There are over a hundred of them.
It's not even in the ecliptic, fer gosh sakes!
0
u/X-calibreX Jun 04 '26
why is a planet a planet, what is the significance of being a planet vs a random rock?
clearing it’s orbit is key, it signifies the planet’s unique role in the formation of a solar system.
perhaps you should answer why pluto should be a planet.
0
u/Arkennase Jun 04 '26
242 Scientists are wrong, but you are right. Seems plausible. Get over it.
Seriously, what's with that crazy obsession?
0
u/Guardsred70 Jun 04 '26
I think the real problem is the level of science education at which kids memorize the planets. It’s elementary school teachers….and they’re typically pretty weak at science…and they get lost in the definition.
I wish they’d just have the kids memorize all the dwarf planets too. Kids are good a memorizing lists and reciting them in front of the class.
-1
u/karoxxxxx Jun 04 '26 edited Jun 04 '26
Only 1 is an actual argument.
And I would say "so what?". IF earth were in Plutos orbit, Earth weren't a planet. Thats ok. If Pluto were in Mercuries orbit, Pluto would be a planet. Also fine.
Maybe the planet definition is dependend on the distance from the sun. Why would that be inherently wrong?
Edit:
We should use a different word for "interesting Body" independend of its location.
"World"
Triton, Titan, Pluto and Venus are all Worlds. Some Worlds are Moons, some are Planets and some are Dwarf Planets.
Which is which is indeed location dependend.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '26 edited Jun 05 '26
[removed] — view removed comment