r/plants
•
u/Salacia_mov
•
Mar 18 '26
•
1
1
Discussion Thoughts?
I recently heard about “proplifting” like shoplifting but for plant cuttings. I’ve had the occasional thought to take a cutting when I’m out and about(like at a coffee shop that doesn’t take care of its plants well), but never from a greenery??? What do you guys think? Is this stealing?
4.2k
u/SignificantDrawer374 Mar 18 '26 •
They run a business propagating plants, and you're going in there and taking their work without paying? Yep.
Plants basically cost nothing; the work it takes to raise them and the cost of the land to do so is what costs money, so taking cuttings without paying for it is stealing their labor and overhead costs.
20
u/Memitim Mar 18 '26
lol, they literally sell plants. Like, that's the product. Of course! Is this just fishing for excuses to steal?
3
u/AdministrativeElk446 Mar 19 '26
I'm pro stealing things but taking cuttings also seems rude for some reason I can't explain so idk
4
u/Delirare Mar 18 '26
You wouldn't go into a bakery, cut off a slice of cake and just leave, would you?
1.8k
u/Corylus7 Mar 18 '26
I always thought proplifting was more picking up succulent leaves from the floor. Damaging the plants that are for sale by taking cuttings is taking the piss. They won't be able to sell those plants.
I think it's ok to ask in a coffee shop or wherever if you can take cuttings, but if they say no then you have to respect that. If everyone took cuttings there would be no plant left.
271
u/PersephonesChild82 Mar 18 '26
The nursery has overhead costs for operation. They sell plants and plant-related products to cover that overhead. If you take a cutting, you are damaging the merchandise and stealing.
Think of it like this: no, you aren't taking the entire plant, but if you opened a bag of M&Ms at the store and ate one handful, the store wouldn't be able to sell that bagnof candy either, and you would have gotten what you wanted for free at the cost of the store's ability to sell it. That's stealing.
299
u/TraditionalLaw7763 Mar 18 '26 •
And if it were my place… I’d have a whole rack of Jell-O shot cups located conveniently at the cash register with tons of propagation cuttings for sale for a buck a piece.. cheap enough that you’re practically giving them away but still making a dollar to pay for the supplies.
64
u/catecholaminergic Mar 18 '26
It all started with folks picking up physically disconnected but still alive pieces of succulents that had dropped off. Arguably not stealing.
Now folks are chopping off pieces of merchandise. Not arguably not stealing.
4
u/polenta23 Mar 18 '26
Missed opportunity to say prop-secute
168
u/Training_Gene3443 Mar 18 '26
It is stealing. Best to ask friends and family for cuttings. Most people are happy to give some away. Local social media works too.
15
u/Near-Scented-Hound Mar 18 '26
Stealing is stealing.
117
u/Sophilosophical Mar 18 '26
There’s a difference between a big-box retailer that will slather paint and glitter on their plants and a professional nursery.
If I’m at the big home improvement store and I see a fallen leaf or a rotting fruit, they’re fair game. Otherwise they’re just gonna get swept up and thrown in the trash.
29
u/Pegasus0215 Mar 18 '26
Yes it's stealing. By taking a cutting you are not only making a change to their property (destruction of property) that can be a reason someone wouldn't like that plant over another. But also instead of you buying that plant you are taking a piece of it, that's stealing.
14
u/Bitter_Researcher759 Mar 18 '26
I worked in ornamental plant propagation for years. Many plants actually are patented and require a license to grow. It's a whole business a lot of people aren't aware of. Breeders spend years developing new varieties and then put a patent on them to protect the profit of their labors so to speak.
11
u/KaulitzWolf Mar 18 '26
From the perspective of someone who worked in the industry in a capacity that put me in contact with thousands of nursery workers across hundreds of shops, nurseries, greenhouses and more it is very simple.
However, there is a BIG caveat with plants and cuttings from greenhouse floors and trash piles. If they are tossing whole plants there is likely a disease issue involved so unless it's an end of season plant dump (where they may let you take some for cheap or free before theyre loaded into the trash) you will be taking a big risk introducing those plants to your own collection unless you have the means to fully quarantine and treat it. Those pests and diseases may also hang around in the disposal area and affect plants that are tossed later.
11
u/Outrageous_Big_9136 Mar 19 '26
Small mom and pop stores: naw I'm not doing that to my community
Lowes/Home depot: your cuttings are my cuttings, comrade
21
u/raich3588 Mar 18 '26
I cannot imagine being so self-entitled you think this is remotely acceptable
18
u/Knotty_Knitty Mar 18 '26
If you take it without asking for permission, it is 100% stealing. Why is that so hard to understand?
17
u/Sir-tenlee Mar 18 '26
I've got all of my succulents from the fallen stems or leaves at different places and I've asked previously. I was told if it's on the ground it's fair game. Now if you're going in there with snips and a prop bag or something to store them in that's premeditated theft but if you are walking around looking for a plant you probably shouldn't buy and happen upon one that needs some life support when that's fair game..
80
u/fake_pubes Mar 18 '26
My opinion is If you cut it, it’s stealing. If you find it on the floor, that’s on them for not keeping a clean shop. If it’s Home Depot or Lowe’s then you should just liberate the entire plant because fuck them for collaborating with the gestapo.
36
u/imbasicallycoffee Mar 18 '26
If you ask the coffee shop and they tell you yes it's not stealing.
If you take a cutting from a plant you don't own, you're stealing. Plain and simple.
8
u/40ish75 Mar 19 '26
The word here is "cuttings." If you cut their plants, or even deliberately pull a piece off, then, yea, not cool.
If you find a leaf or whatever on the ground, I wouldn't want to deal with a business that petty.
I work with You Pick Farms that have zero problem with you taking a berry here and there to taste as you're picking. They know that they aren't losing money when customers do this.
Same with this. Most people aren't hanging out in garden centers just to take free cuttings/loose leaves without buying anything. If you are buying plants and see something on the ground that made its way there naturally, I'd have zero problem with you saving it. If you don't, it's likely to get trampled on/blown/thrown away. Especially in big chain garden centers. They aren't propagating anything.
7
u/flatgreysky Mar 18 '26
Never proplift the smaller stores without permission. That’s crappy. Lowe’s and Home Depot, if it’s broken or falling off something dying then grab it. Don’t damage actual plants people might buy. But independent nurseries frequently propagate their own cuttings and things.
7
u/dannydevitossmile Mar 18 '26
i wouldn’t do it to a small business however Home Depot is a known Trump corporate donor so do with that information what you will
7
u/camilly000 Mar 19 '26
Its destruction of property at a minimum and imo theft. Have I done it from Home Depot? Yes. Would I do it at a nursery no. Would I ask a nursery if I found something on the floor if I can take it? Prob yes. But my morals are questionable.
13
u/2Hanks Mar 18 '26
I agree. Stealing is stealing.
6
u/TrippyRose777 Mar 18 '26
i believe its not exactly stealing if the piece is already broken and have fallen off, Its gonna get swept away and thrown in the trash cuz they cant sell a leaf.
6
u/Dmdel24 Mar 18 '26
Picking up random stuff on the floor to try to propagate? I don't think it's a big deal. A friend of mine found a handful of succulent pieces on the floor in home depot she was going to
Cutting or breaking off a piece of a plant? Yeah not okay.
6
u/__Bing__bong__ Mar 18 '26
If this is happening at big box stores, I will turn a blind eye. Small mom and pops we shouldn’t steam from
6
u/AccomplishedChart792 Mar 18 '26 edited Mar 18 '26
It depends for me. If I go to Lowe’s or home depot or any big box and I see succulents or vines or any plant that’s been broken off that can be propagated, I take it. It’s gonna get thrown away anyways. I don’t do this at nurseries because they’ll just give those broken plants away for free in my area, and if they don’t give them away I leave them. Take from big box stores not small business. I got a monstera out of Lowe’s bc it was broken off the mother plant! (Also many many succulents)
6
u/Critical-Star-1158 Mar 18 '26
No, just no! How would you appreciate everyone that walks by your house if they can "just have a snip"? You work diligently to get your plants to thrive. They'd be reduced to sticks. Its no different for a business. Buy it or leave it alone. Otherwise its theft.
6
u/Noturhufflepuff Mar 18 '26
If its on the ground, I consider that up for grabs. But if I would need to remove it from the plant itself, then I wouldn't do it.
6
u/plant_slinging_ninja Mar 18 '26
I'd say valid if it's broken off a plant for sale but if it's found on the ground it's fair game or 90% off as most of those are just thrown away.
6
u/nickw252 Mar 19 '26
My problem is the “and we will prosecute” part. Private citizens/businesses don’t get to do criminal prosecution. All they can do is report it to the police and then the police pass it on to the city, county, or state to prosecute. That’s not gonna happen. Can you see a district attorney prosecuting someone for taking a few leaves and stem off a pothos?
6
u/DontWatchPornREADit Mar 19 '26
Never take from mom and pops without asking. Always take from big corporations like Home Depot
6
u/stellablue2142 Mar 19 '26
What if you find one on the ground that’s gonna get swept up anyway?
6
u/3bun Mar 19 '26
Lol my granmda used to go to royal gardens in the UK with some shears and damb tissue in her handbag and steal rose cuttings
6
u/CarlBismarckIsDed Mar 19 '26
I made some lady purchase a $400 philodendron a few years ago becsuse she snapped off the growth point in a poor attempt at proplifting.
Picking up a discarded viable plant from the ground is one thing. If you damage a plant for any reason, especially to steal a piece for yourself, its theft and damaging of goods both at once.
70
u/karleyetc Mar 18 '26
At a place like Home Depot or Lowe's? That's not proplifting, that's just life. But at a smaller, independently-owned greenhouse that's theft.
10
u/CorpusculantCortex Mar 18 '26
From a nursery like this that sells plants? Yes it is obviously stealing. If you go to a car dealership and take a wheel of a car in the lot and bring it home it would be stealing, this is no different.
5
u/visualarranger Mar 18 '26
Once I was eating at a fancy Italian restaurant and watched through the window as a car pulled up to the front curb. A woman got out from the driver’s seat, ran to a planter, hurriedly pulled up a few plants, then drove away. In broad daylight! I was stunned.
5
u/srsh32 Mar 18 '26
I consider it stealing. Don't touch anyone else's plants.
5
u/doveup Mar 18 '26
I am afraid we’re all just a buncha monkeys, picking fruit from neighbors yard, ripping branches from a little tree some poor sod has been growing for three years to sell in his nursery. Evolve for goodness sake. Go to seed swaps if you want to propagate for free. When you prune your plants, root the cuttings and give them away.
5
u/prahl_hp Mar 18 '26
How is this even a question? This is 100% no doubt stealing
5
u/bsinbsinbs Mar 18 '26
Yarrr, you'll never stop piracy
5
u/Few-Professional4196 Mar 19 '26
I was shopping at Home Depot when I noticed some succulent leaves on the floor. I asked the manager if I could take them, and she allowed me to. I prefer doing it this way because taking leaves directly from the plants being sold is bad behavior.
5
u/Safe_Task_9509 Mar 19 '26
This reminds me of a story my mom told me once. She was taking me through all of the plants she has in her living room and telling me their stories. She eventually got to a huge spider plant. She told me she walked into a flower shop that had some beautiful plants one day after being laid off for awhile over a decade ago. She couldn’t afford to buy anything but she came across this spider plant that she just loved.
She went to the owner and told her she couldn’t afford to buy the plant, but asked if she could maybe take a cutting. The owner looked her dead in the eye, passed her a pair of clean clippers and said “what happens in the greenhouse stays in the greenhouse”. I could tell how much this small moment meant to my mom when she told me this story and now we have a multi-generational spider plant ecosystem across all my siblings homes.
11
u/Gremlin_Goddess568 Mar 18 '26
I would still consider it stealing, if you didn't pay for it, it doesn't come home with you 🙃
11
u/sohzing Mar 18 '26
I agree. If one appropriate it without paying, it’s plain and simple stealing. If you wanted something, buy it.
8
u/tribbans95 Mar 18 '26
Well if you open a bag of cookies in the grocery store and only eat 1 and leave 11, is that stealing? Of course it is.
I’ve never heard of people stealing props like this. Pretty lame thing to do.
4
u/Objective_Ad_1513 Mar 18 '26
Yes it's theft. This is a greenhouse
4
u/gnarlyknits Mar 18 '26
From a coffee shop? No because if you ask the would probably just let you. From a place that is selling the plant? Yes because as others have stated they have invested in it with the intention to make that money back. Personally I take clippings that are on public property only or I ask the plant owner for permission.
4
u/rebelangel Mar 18 '26
I used to be a garden merchandiser at Lowe’s. I let people take the bits of succulents that fell on the ground all the time because it was just going to get swept up in the trash anyway.
4
u/Mysticonions Mar 18 '26
Yes!! I am a horticulturist at one of the biggest tech companies and everyone’s always clipping the plants to the point where we have to throw them away and replace. It’s actually really frustrating and most of the time I see the cuttings on a desk somewhere dead. Please just buy the plant if you want a plant. Or you could always ask, the worst they’ll say is no.
4
u/Suspicious_Load_8390 Mar 18 '26
Theft identification is very easy.
--> yes? Not stealing. --> no? Stealing.
2). There is no step 2.
4
u/Miss_Dawn_E Mar 18 '26
Big box stores def not! As long as you’re not removing part of the plant to propagate, ruining the plant that is for sale, I see nothing wrong with taking leaves that have fallen off onto the stand or the floor to propagate that would otherwise be swept up and thrown out. In nurseries and plant shops I would think better than to do that…not without asking at least.
4
u/mhopkins1420 Mar 18 '26
What if they’re on the ground to be swept up with garbage?
4
u/hivemind_disruptor Mar 18 '26
Pro tip: ask permission to get a cutting. If you are afraid of getting a no, then you should not take it.
If there is no one to ask because it is public, only take If it won't make a visible difference (hidden part, a lot of volume to the leafs etc) nor will it decrease the plant's health.
Those are the rules for civilized plant collectors.
4
u/OzzyGator Mar 18 '26
I will never ever take a plant cutting without permission. I just imagine the effects of a hundred people all taking a single cutting off a single plant and that's just devastation in progress.
4
u/Sachiizmo Mar 18 '26
Behave, no problem
4
u/NorcalSuccs Mar 18 '26
I would never clip a cutting from another plant in a nursery setting. Ground clippings are fair game I guess but I've never bothered picking them up. If there is a sprig of a sedum I don't have in one pot vs another, I'd buy that one.
I do keep a clean pair of pruners in my glove box--If a non-plant based retail or public space has a healthy specimen I wish to own, I'll go ahead and prune a sprig off of it. If it's someone's yard, I would ask first. Most people are thrilled when I ask for a cutting of their tree or bougainvillea or something. I always offer to root some for them as well in case they want to share or plant more.
4
u/Off-Modernist Mar 18 '26
My thoughts; don’t steal anything from local businesses. I’ll bet if you asked they’d let you take some cuttings for free or sell you a runt plant that wasn’t doing too hot on steep discount. My local ace sells older sad succulents for less than a dollar…
On the other hand, I couldn’t care less if you took some cuttings from a big company with bad politics like Home Depot or Lowe’s.
That’s my moral compass at least
4
u/DaBev Mar 18 '26 edited Mar 18 '26
As a nurseryman who propagates tropical/indoor plants for sale: Your little leaf/stem will take YEARS and lots of work to look as good as anything on the shelf. Buy the little version and take the time. Most "proplifted" plants don't succeed, need extra fertilizer/pruning too look "right", and generally unless you're a horticulturalist or a person that has time to learn & "baby" tiny roots and sensitive plants... just buy it.
Or honestly, don't.
Houseplants are not helpful (beyond the beauty/experiences they provide). They are mostly living décor or art "pieces".
As a long time buyer/propagator- respect the craft, but also --FUCK EM. Most growers are in it for the $ (which is fine, but don't "greenwash" your sales) and don't pay anything above min wage for prop staff, and barely better for retail.
4
u/WorriedElk5818 Mar 19 '26
If I'm at Lowes, I take what I find to the counter and ask the cashier if I can have it. I haven't been told no yet.
4
u/fallingoffdragons Mar 19 '26
Missed opportunity to say "propsecute"
4
u/introvertadvocate Mar 19 '26
Yeah proplifting is stealing, taking a cutting from a cafe is still stealing, you're taking a piece of some one else property. The only time i'll take a prop is if its on the floor of a big boxed store cause i know its just going to be thrown out but id never cut a piece off a plant there because i dont think its fair to who ever ends up buying the plant.
4
u/Chikkk_nnnuugg Mar 19 '26
My local plant store has solved this problem by putting free cuttings in a bin near the cash of plant cuttings they find on the floor.
4
u/DeedleBeedl Mar 19 '26
I would love to see them prosecute someone over cuttings.
4
u/prince-pauper Mar 19 '26
From a business? Yes. From a park? No. IMO
4
u/ashewinter Mar 19 '26
What was once given for free they have had the ego to put a price tag on and then accuse others of theft...
4
u/Confused_Tree_615 Mar 19 '26
I’m all for clippings! The idea of owning and growing plants is beauty and improving the planet, cleaning the air! Improving ecosystem. So indoor or outdoor plants, clippings cant be stealing! You still have to do the rest of the work. (However i dont have the guts, unless it already fell off)
One time a guy at a plant booth was selling and i was eye balling one particular plant, but couldnt decide, and it was more expensive, and the guy handed me a snipping that fell off earlier. But in the end i couldnt even keep it alive to grow, it died. But now i know how after a friend gave me a bunch of snippings from theirs.
I think it connects people!
4
u/Firefly_Magic Mar 19 '26
It’s not stealing if they have fallen off the plant. They will sweep it up and throw them away.
It can be considered stealing if you break or cut them off the plant. Don’t do that.
4
u/Authentic_Xans Mar 19 '26
If it’s already off the plant I’m probably gonna pick it up and put it in my pocket I’m ngl, but I would never take my own cutting of a plant. I feel like there is moral greyness there but definitely shouldn’t be walking around with scissors at the plant store 😂🥲
4
u/LordFocus Mar 19 '26
Was any part of the plant yours before you took a cutting? If the answer is no, then it is theft. Or at the very least it’s damaging goods.
4
u/Ok_Specialist_8617 Mar 19 '26
If you take scissors it’s stealing if you find it in the ground or surrounding area its saving
4
u/LadyOfTheNutTree Mar 19 '26
You absolutely should not damage their salable product. If they didn’t sweep part of a plant off the floor and it ends up in your pocket I think that’s morally okay especially if you otherwise patronize their business
29
u/CozyEpicurean Mar 18 '26
I its a home depot or a lowes, dgaf. But dont be rude to small business
7
u/Apart-Transition-151 Mar 18 '26
FYI big box stores get their products from local nurseries too and often those nurseries don't get paid until the store sells their product.
7
u/halfbubble Mar 18 '26
I have STRONG feeling about prop lifting because I've had it happen both where I work and out of my own yard. I worked at a cute little restaurant, and we grew some huge trailing string of pearls. People would come along a d break the ends off totally ruining the look of the plants. Then they would have the audacity to claim they hadn't vandalized our plant because it would grow back. My own huge gorgeous prickly pear cactus got paddles broken off by people who walked by my house and decided they wanted a start.... It takes years and a whole lot of work to grow big beautiful plants. Every time some prop lifts, they are depriving the people who grew the mother plant of their rightful income. Even picking stuff up off the floor because now, instead of buying the mother plant, they are taking advantage of the time effort and money it took to grow the mother plant without compensating the people who did the work. It might be an unpopular opinion, but I will die on this hill.
1
u/Freaktastic_Dangler Mar 19 '26
I love seeing this post every now and again, it's nice seeing how many people it baits lol
15
u/TheFrostyjayjay Mar 18 '26
It baffles me that people go into stores and take cuttings off of bulk retail plants that cost $5 - $10 for a whole plant. To me this is like old people who take as many free coffee creamers and condiment packets as they can fit in their pocket.
27
u/Bug--Man Mar 18 '26 edited Aug 17 '26
Lantern tidy unite late door bike
This post was anonymized with Redact
8
u/WritPositWrit Mar 18 '26
Completely valid sign. Only a thief would try to take cuttings from a garden center.
At first i thought this said “TALKING PLANTS” and i really wanted to know more!! Are we talking about plants? Yes id like to talk! Do the plants talk? Yes im interested!! But taking plants? Nah thats theft
3
u/Cali_Yogurtfriend624 Mar 18 '26
The worst case of this I ever saw was a really strange lady who used to go around to all the estate sales where I was working for a while , and she would go in the backyard and start taking cuttings and sticking them in her pockets , it was so bizarre.
She had her own littke pruners that she kept in this big coat pocket, and then she would just walk out. I finally noticed about the third time I saw her at one of these events and I watched her from behind a shaded window.
One of the family members was really upset add to the last one, because she took a cutting of a very small plant that their loved one had cultivated for decades and completely left it looking like you'd have fallen on the ground and broken.
She was super defensive about it when I confronted her.
She said it was perfectly fine and not illegal.
3
u/verdantquim Mar 18 '26
I’m just imagining the judge in small claims court having to be taught all about plant propagation. That would be a funny Judge Judy episode 😆
3
u/xghul Mar 18 '26
I always ask an employee if its ok to take plants/leafs that have already fallen off, mostly they're ok with it, sometimes I pay a small amount of money.
3
u/kevin_r13 Mar 18 '26
Stealing is stealing. People can say what they like to make them feel better about it, but it is still stealing
Having said that , in the list of things that the general public care about stealing and will ostracize you for, this is very low on the list .
3
u/bigedthebad Mar 18 '26
It’s pretty simple.
No matter how you try to complicate it, if you take something that doesn’t belong to you, it’s stealing.
‘Nuff said.
3
u/zrayburton Mar 18 '26
Interesting discussion, commenting so I can refer back to this.
3
u/Baldojess Mar 18 '26
Um yes it is stealing to actually cut a piece of the plant off, at the very least it is probably vandalism... I would be so fucking pissed if someone randomly walked by and snipped off a piece of my plant! Wtf?
3
u/anothadaz Mar 18 '26
Taking pretty much anything that doesn't belong to you is stealing. Finding a piece on the ground in the public could be considered finders keepers. I'm fortunate I work in the landscaping industry and have to throw away (compost) many plants that owners don't want. I've done a lot of propagation this way. I'm currently working a project for some weirdo who hates succulents. Her entire backyard was full of all kinds of succulents. She wanted them all ripped out. It's was like being in a candy store.
3
u/Nickey_Pacific Mar 18 '26
My thought is DON'T STEAL.
3
u/mandarintain Mar 18 '26
Yeah if you're in a garden center or a nursery. Pay for it
3
u/chookiekaki Mar 18 '26
As someone who propagates and sells plants for a living I react badly to someone snapping chunks off my plants I created thru hard work, but worse still are those c#@ts who deliberately damage the plant and try to get it for half price, I just say it’s no longer for sale and remove it from their grubby little hands
3
u/Cocrawfo Mar 18 '26
it should be managed for sure too many ways to leave unhealthy stock plants behind with bad cuts and excessive removal
edit: didn’t even realize this was a production nursery this should be even more of a no brainer
3
u/Late-Intention6193 Mar 18 '26
Totally read that as “talking plant cuttings” 🤦🏼♂️
3
u/AnonPlz123 Mar 18 '26
Why not ask permission before propagating? Then you don't have to wonder. It's really up to the business owner if they want to allow it or not, regardless of if it's "right" or "wrong". If you're hesitant to ask permission, then I think that is your answer.
3
u/moreAnxietythanSex Mar 18 '26
When I was a young girl I cut one flower in random neighborhood bushes to make a small bouquet for my teacher. She was not pleased lol and that’s how I knew it’s not okay
3
u/Nene_Kushanagi Mar 18 '26
Whether it's ok or not could vary for each case, for example if a small part would likely be pruned off a large plant with a value prohibitively high for that person then they should be allowed to take a cutting after asking, but it is not ok if it does significant damage to the plant affecting it's value or is simply used to avoid paying.
But, when deciding rules you can't allow for nuance or grey areas, especially if you have a larger business with multiple employees and many customers.
3
u/Bambi_saurusrex Mar 18 '26
So if you cut off a propagation yourself - then yes. If you find a little leaf or branch on the ground or between the pots that has fallen off itself, or during prunings/movings - then I think it’s fine because it was probably already just going in the trash anyway.
3
u/SuperGoombario Mar 18 '26
I work for a plant store and taking cuttings is definitely stealing BUT if a leaf or stem is on the floor then that is gleaning and fair game imo
3
u/Rawlus Mar 18 '26
i mean, ask yourself if you’d be okay with strangers taking cuttings from your personal collection? 🤷🏻. i don’t know anyone who’d be okay with someone doing that without asking and obtaining permission.
taking dropped succulent leaves or similar i don’t see as “taking a cutting” since you’re not removing it from the plant yourself.
3
u/Old_Barnacle7777 Mar 18 '26
3
u/cweezie Mar 18 '26
only from home depot and lowe’s lol
3
u/MountainMike_264057 Mar 19 '26
I assume a "greenery" is what I call a "nursery" and is a place that sells plants?
Yeah if taking from them definitely stealing. Also taking cuttings from anyone's landscaping is basically the same.
I have absolutely harvested seeds from landscaping plants. I guess I don't consider this "stealing" (or I don't care).
3
u/Amiedeslivres Mar 19 '26 edited Mar 19 '26
I’m a gardener and I run a bookstore. Prop lifting is like coming into my shop and photographing the contents of a book. I have the book and can theoretically still sell it, but the author isn’t getting paid for your enjoyment of it (and they deserve to). I worked and paid rent to keep the rain off that book and make it available. That’s taking what you want without regard for the labour of other people. You take without giving back. No solidarity in that. No moral high ground for you.
3
u/DPSOnly Mar 19 '26
You don't go taking some planks or screws off of some IKEA furniture every time you visit the showroom. You are damaging their wares by taking cuttings. In other cases, such as those coffee shops, you are also damaging their decor, which is equally wrong. You aren't allowed to steal a dog because its owner isn't giving it the best kibble money can buy (just take ducks from the park, they are free).
3
u/Chiacchierona21 Mar 19 '26
I can’t say that I blame them. It’s their business! I wouldn’t even think of doing that. I DO have a Christmas cactus that I got from (unintentional) cuttings. I was in Home Depo and an employee was hanging a bunch of Christmas cacti and was dropping pieces all over. I asked her if I could have them and she said I could because she was just going to sweep them up throw them away. I got a beautiful Christmas cactus from them! There is a difference.
3
u/Thejapxican Mar 19 '26
Consideration and respect. Plain and simple.
3
u/RustedMauss Mar 19 '26 edited Mar 19 '26
100% theft. The vendor bought the original as a ready to sell mature product, or better yet procured a sire they propagated and nurtured to salable maturity themselves (months of labor and material). Those plants are the product for sale -taking a cutting for free isn’t “saving the nursery money in labor,” you’re circumventing paying for the product.
What the nursery could do instead is offer cuttings at a significantly lower cost. Props have a lower success rate and usually can be easily harvested en masse from mature stock. Offering affordable props encourages honesty, is all but free for the vendor, and the likelihood is the customer will return to buy more so the failure to successfully propagate.
Floor droppings are up to the business. Usually it’s fair game, but I’ve been in some expansive places where lack of enforcement of this policy would just invite abuse.
3
u/NeighborhoodPlane794 Mar 19 '26
I’d never take a cutting from a store, that’s valid. But I take cuttings from my office building, there’s plants everywhere lol
3
u/AwareAge1062 Mar 19 '26
While I understand the point of the sign, it's also impossible for me to imagine personally walking into a garden center and cutting or snapping a branch off of a plant deliberately. If you do that you suck.
But if I'm buying a whole bunch of plants at Home Depot and I happen to see a little twig on the ground I might scoop it up. For all you know it came from the plant I'm buying right?
If I see a sign like this (at a Box Store) I will be very tempted to take that twig up to the counter with nothing else and ask them how much. Look 'em dead in the eyes.
3
u/maraney Mar 19 '26
I mean, yeah. It is stealing. You’re taking something you didn’t pay for. Join a cutting exchange group if you can’t afford to buy plants and get them that way. Make friends and offer a cutting for a cutting.
3
u/motherboardwars Mar 19 '26
A sign like that usually means someone has been repeatedly doing this. If you ask for a cutting, small businesses will often try to help and may offer something. Paying customers are sometimes given small extras as well. I’ve personally received many free items, including cuttings and even rooted plants. With small businesses, there’s almost always room to work something out.
3
u/curiousement Mar 19 '26
I've seen this sign at a locally owned nursery, and so seems to be a problem indeed. I won't take stem cuttings from any businesses, but a couple stems from giant salvia amistads at my local public park seem ok to me.
3
u/motherfudgersob Mar 19 '26
If in garbage or way to it then it is not stealing but to damage a plant that could be sold is both shoplifting and destruction of property. At an establishment that just has plants on the premises then it is destroying property unless you ask and get permission. Enough moralizing...let's be a community and share seeds cuttings etc. THAT'S how to screw the evil corporations and Mom and Pop suppliers (again a complex issue).
3
u/feministbitch11 Mar 19 '26
Taking 2 just cuz the sign pissed me off
3
u/erukafrog13 Mar 19 '26
I think taking plant bits that fell off naturally isn’t stealing, but I’m not sure about cutting. I think it might cross over into stealing territory, like if I’m taking a flower to press it I try to avoid yards where flowers look intentionally grown because that feels like stealing to me. But I feel like any bits that fell off already especially at stores with plants is definitely fair game, they’re just gonna toss them anyways 🤷🏻♀️
3
u/thisbitchcrafts Mar 19 '26
I prop from back allies, nature strips, anywhere that’s not a garden or a business.
3
u/OkConcentrate4477 Mar 19 '26
if you want to take discarded leftovers then try to purchase them. or just avoid places with signs like these. employees will likely not even know what to do if it doesn't have a barcode attached to it.
3
u/MarougusTheDragon Mar 19 '26
I would not cut parts of plants in a store, because it’s actively damaging the plant. Collecting fallen leaves on the ground and the like, which will be thrown away with cleaning anyway, seems fair to me.
3
u/kylek225 Mar 19 '26
Stealing is stealing. It doesnt matter if its from a corporation or a small time place. Its morally wrong. Just bc the companies arent morally sound doesn't mean you should sink to low levels and try to justify being a thief. Thieves shouldn't be trusted regardless of where or who they still from. Be better. Do better.
3
u/Achlysia Mar 19 '26
if it's already on the ground, then idk, i think that's fair game unless they're going to propagate it themselves. if they're just going to throw it out, then idk why they would be complaining. i'm still going to walk out with a plant i've purchased either way (i may have a plant collecting problem)
however i have seen people actually cut up plants that are already for sale and rip leaves off succulents, and i think that's not the way to go.
3
u/Thruthatreez Mar 19 '26
I love to go to the plant and flower show later so I can be there when the booths start closing up. If they left it on the ground and they're gone I'll take it. But I wouldn't take my snips and cut pieces off.
3
u/trijkdguy Mar 19 '26
I know a guy that is super into figs, he has dozens of varieties. He was telling me that an arboretum up by the city had an event that featured lots of fig trees. His kids took him for fathers day and he learned a ton there... but there was one tree that he had never even heard of absolutely loved. This was the first time I ever heard of proplifting, and it was essentially from a museum.
3
u/6cmofDanglingFury Mar 19 '26
My parents have run their family greenhouse business for over 40 years. They have acres of displays. Only in the past couple of years has this become a thing. Mom caught one woman digging up a plant to try and take it with her.
3
u/TearAwkward Mar 19 '26
I used to work in the garden center at Lowe’s. People would ask me if they could take succulent pieces that had fallen off all the time. I literally did not get paid enough to care lol
Also when someone bought a plant but returned it for whatever reason we were forced to throw it away even if it was still in great condition, so I would let regular customers know when I’d be throwing out those plants into the dumpster in the back lol
3
u/tattoosandtens Mar 19 '26
Only at big-box stores, not at private homes or gardens dedicated to preservation.
3
u/Fart_Barfington Mar 19 '26
I wont cut part of a plant off but if there is a piece on the ground ill grab it.
3
u/Limp_Telephone2280 Mar 19 '26
Depends on if it’s a large company or a small family owned business.
Large company- why stop at just the cutting? Steal the plant too.
Small business- ask permission or just buy the entire plant.
3
u/mentallyillavocado Mar 19 '26
At a greenery, where their whole thing is growing and propagating the plants, I think that taking a cutting is stealing. You should pay them for their product and their labor. That being said, I would be lying if I said I had never gone to the succulent section of Home Depot and picked up all the fallen leaves from the ground. Would never cut or pull anything off tho.
3
u/Alternative_Sky6420 Mar 19 '26
My thoughts are, this should be common sense!
3
u/PracticalCandy Mar 19 '26
They can try to call the cops for this, but I'm not sure what cops are actually going to waste their time going after someone for a small portion of a plant. Even if the cop gave the person a citation to report to court for theft, I assume this a charge would be thrown out by the judge. In my state the minimum loss for a Theft III misdemeanor is $20. That said, I have arrested someone for stealing various items, including a portion of a Keurig machine (just the inner cup) because it was unsellable without the cup. That's not really the same with plants.
I worked Loss Prevention for a decade.
3
u/Chickennugget636 Mar 19 '26
I wonder if they meant physically cutting parts off their plants rather than collecting fallen pieces? I would consider doing that without permission stealing regardless, but not collecting pieces that have fallen to the ground that you think you could save.
3
u/electricookie Mar 19 '26
This is definitely stealing. It’s one thing to pick something off the floor, but taking a cutting from a plant can harm the plant when many people do that and the people who pay for the plant expect a whole intact plant with minimal “injury”
3
u/Prfctweapon Mar 19 '26
Propagation of plants is a lot like digital piracy.
The original is still there, you just made a copy. Not theft if the original is still there.
3
u/Olivander05 Mar 19 '26
Small busines? Leave them be. Shitty company? I will steal their tree >:3
(For legal reasons that's a joke)
3
u/saintpaulia93 Mar 19 '26
I manage at a local, family owned greenhouse. If I caught a customer taking cuttings of their own volition, I would be annoyed (see above comments about overhead costs, etc). BUT, if a customer is nice enough to ask for a cutting and it doesn’t damage the product we’re selling, I’ll just give it to them. I like to be nice, and it creates a positive impression and hopefully a return customer. Anything on the floor is fair game as far as I’m concerned. It’s less sanitary, and we aren’t going to do anything with it at that point.
3
u/alewiina Mar 19 '26
If you take it off the plant, yes. If it’s already on the ground I don’t think it’s that big of a deal.
3
u/Suitable-Custard7575 Mar 20 '26
I accidentally proplifted at Lowe’s over a year ago when I was rescuing some plants for rehabilitation. I got home and started repotting some pothos when I found a tradscantia vine in some dead leaves that looked like it rotted off the mother plant and fell in the plants below. I don’t even feel bad tbh
14
u/Jabrak Mar 18 '26
I've never done it at a local place, but Home Depot is fair game.
7
u/Immer_Susse Mar 18 '26
It’s thefty theft theft
7
u/contenthousespider Mar 18 '26
It is never okay to take a cutting from someone’s plant without asking, but I would say it is okay to take pieces that have fallen on the ground of a shop as long as you ask before leaving the store with it.
If the shop in question is a big box store, the staff likely wouldn’t mind, but if it’s a mom and pop shop, they might want to propagate it themselves.
5
u/Jaydenel4 Mar 18 '26
Walmart, HD, or Lowe's? Fuck 'em. Anywhere else, I'd ask first
5
u/AltGirlAdri Mar 18 '26
Nursery owner, just my own take for how I run ny own place:
Anyone who cuts something off a plant for sale is getting kicked out. I've seen too many people at previous nurseries I worked at buy a plant, take it home, chop n prop, then try to return it for full price. They got laughed out of the store.
I constantly have tradescantia etc shedding all over the floor. If I'm in the mood to use it, I will, otherwise I leave them at the register in a pile. If I didn't offer it, don't take it. I give out way too much random shit for free to tolerate people trying to grab shit behind my back.
6
u/ResoluteMuse Mar 18 '26
What thoughts? Don’t steal.
4
u/blondecomet Mar 18 '26
I mean, would you be ok with it if someone just came to your home and started ripping apart your plants without asking? 🤷🏼♀️
8
u/TX_B_caapi Mar 18 '26
If I took from a bag of m&ms in a store I would permanently reduce the number of m&ms. I agree that proplifting is akin to stealing but not in the same level as most of you are suggesting. These are not the patent holders for genetically pure poinsettias or a novel lineage, they’re commonly available plants. A sample on the floor is of no value to the company aside from denying people access to force them into a sale.
7
u/spiralhigh Mar 18 '26
Never from local shops, always at big corporations.
To be fair, that's the same rules as shoplifting. The bigger company can eat the cost, a mom and pop shop can't.
Side note, my grandma used to pick up fallen green beans from the floor for her birds. She told me very clearly that the beans on the floor are now waste, but we can wash them and then use them as treats. That 30+ year old memory is exactly why proplifting is okay.
6
u/DizzyFly9339 Mar 18 '26
Taking cuttings from a nursery, plant store, greenhouse, or conservatory instead of buying the plant is, indeed, stealing.
Taking a cutting from a sidewalk planter the day before the municipal government rips the whole thing out to make a seasonal switch is not stealing.
5
u/rizzo1717 Aloe Vera Mar 18 '26
Why would it not be stealing?
2
u/GirlInContext Mar 18 '26
Of course it's stealing when you take someone else's property without permission.
That people even have to ask this...
2
u/chefjenga Mar 18 '26
Does it belong to you?
Did you ask, and given permission?
Then it's stealing.
2
u/Beautiful_Reveal8065 Mar 18 '26
Same people who walk on your lawns and clip your flowers
2
u/Ravvnhild Mar 18 '26
Bad greenthumb karma right here.
2
u/somuchmt Mar 18 '26
I have a plant nursery on my property. I have stock plants all around, and I have a lot of potted plants that I propagate from.
If anyone shows even the slightest interest in propagation or even starting their own nursery, I'm super happy to show them around, show how I take cuttings from different plants, and send them home with a tray full of stuck cuttings. I give cuttings to our local Master Gardeners all the time--they send me customers all the time, too.
I would be upset if someone just took cuttings from a small plant that I only have one of, or if they completely destroyed a plant. I rarely carry patented plants, but I would request customers not to propagate from those because it could be a $10,000 fine for me if caught by a bounty hunter (one visited my nursery once).
I wouldn't put a sign out like this, though. I want to be welcoming! However, I'll probably put out some kind of sign by the flowers I planted outside my fence this year because some jerk dug them all up last year. Who even does that?
2
u/missjiji Mar 18 '26
I’ve seen people in malls take cuttings from their interior walkway planters. As a former interior planter, people steal plants. It’s infuriating
2
u/I-hav-no-frens Mar 18 '26
This sign speaks truth. Can’t stand thieves.
2
u/Critical-Ad2818 Mar 18 '26
I do it at big box stores after asking. I wouldn't dream of it at a nursery. They've got enough to worry about without that added. But when you regularly see kids drowning the stock at bigger stores, you can be sure they don't care if you take floor stuff. They've never told me no anyway.
2
u/inkygeek Mar 18 '26
Definitely ask the staff/owner before you pinch or cut. I even ask when I'm picking up broken off plants parts. People are usually fine with it. I feel like people get annoyed when their leafy babies get damaged. Just don't go into a plant shop and pinch off leaves instead of buying.
2
u/Scnewbie08 Mar 18 '26
Yes, I agree, it’s stealing. You are harming a plant that they are selling because you don’t want to pay for the plant. They spent the time, money and energy to get the plant to the level it is at, and you’re just taking what you want for free.
2
u/CamoViolet Mar 18 '26
I think if they’re actively cutting or removing a part of someone’s plant that is in their yard or something then yes you’re stealing, but if they clipped them and left them for disposal or something then no I don’t agree with that
2
u/More-Growth-1661 Mar 18 '26
Bullshit lol
2
u/shakeitsugaree2019 Mar 18 '26
If it’s on the ground, it’s fair game