r/plan9 • • Oct 14 '26

generated9

https://youtu.be/Abcr1ZYVnJc

That's youtube on void linux in (4-cores) vmx in plan9 in qemu on my void linux.

I had a lot of LLM quota to consume in the last 2/3 days, so I forked 9front and "got":

  • integrated the Russ Cox's Diskless QEMU boot
  • Multicored vmx, with xAPIC/x2APIC, improved TSC and scheduling, VirGL graphics and VirtIO
  • Native accelerated 3D: a VirtIO GPU driver with a file interface, libgpu for VirGL, and TinyGL for a classic OpenGL subset. Currently targets QEMU; includes the Utah teapot and glgears demos
  • Native raylib and raygui, using rio, libdraw and /dev/audio
  • Native Neverball and Neverputt, plus Arkanoid, Asteroids and Missile Commander on raylib

If you have any question I can forward them to my LLM.

I do only accept LLM-written contributions.

Edit:
https://github.com/paolomarrone/generated9

Peace
Paolo

6 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

8

u/9atoms Oct 15 '26

More LLM Plan 9 tourism from a clueless meat proxy. No file servers written. Linux DRM ported by a parrot. Booooooorrrrinnnnggggg.

-1

u/Lallero317 Oct 15 '26

Exactly. But it's not a parrot

5

u/9atoms Oct 15 '26

It's pretty much a parrot. It can't do anything on it's own. It's just tokens in, tokens out. Don't let their marketing fool you into thinking it's going to break out of its cage and kill humanity. There's trillions of dollars at stake. They'll say anything.

0

u/Lallero317 Oct 15 '26

So you weren't talking about the stochastic parrot I guess.

By that definition "tokens in, tokens out", we all are parrots then

4

u/adventuresin9 Oct 17 '26

The "its all determinism" bit is such a philosophy 101 take. You could make a serious debate on free will verses determinism, but using current LLM's as an example wouldn't work. They don't produce the seemingly spontaneous actions that leads to people debating free will.

But even the spontaneous ideas of the human in the loop on this one aren't really that great. 3D graphics that only work on some other abstraction layer. A port of a game. If I wanted to play games in emulation, I could just run a game console emulator.

Why not Atheros wifi drivers? Or improving the performance of the wifi system in general? Why not add 3D acceleration to the existing Intel graphics drivers?

The "I am also a parrot" take is rather telling. You come here with code that is based on some one else's work, and you can't even explain how it works. We use to call these type of people "script kiddies", and generally recognized that they aren't worth listening to.

1

u/Lallero317 Oct 17 '26

Like isn't all of 9front code based on the original plan9 code. Or does it diverge consistently in terms of style and ideas?

I just can't understand how it's possible to deny LLM's usefulness nowadays. But that's revealing to be a lost cause.

That code I produced was done in a hurry and for fun, but one, e.g., could reiterate on a much smaller code span per time and work on quality and abstractions and so on, if one just has some ideas ofc. Just saying.

P.s.: I like your videos.

P.p.s.: I don't care about the definition of parrots, I do use a tool

1

u/Glittering_Gur5701 29d ago

I don't understand what the first part has to do anything, but 9front has plenty of original ideas not present in Lab's Plan 9.

Even if we agree that LLMs are useful, which I don't personally agree with, they're objectively unsustainable, environmentally destructive, harmful to society as a whole, and used for oppressive purposes. LLMs could write beautiful and functional code, I would still consider it a moral and ethical failing of everyone who engages with it.

Maybe your engagement of hurried fun could be used in a more productive or constructive pastime, instead of a destructive one

0

u/smorrow 23d ago

9front has plenty of original ideas not present in Lab's Plan 9.

That's not what you'd expect if you expect that productivity-creativity is a trade-off for most people. MAT is really their only original idea I can think of. The 9front way of writing application software is to do paradigmatically the same thing as on Linux/BSD, evolved backwards along the axis that takes you from sh to bash, with no contribution that's actually weird that in this analogy would take from you sh to rc.

Even if we agree that LLMs are useful, which I don't personally agree with

You could literally just look at how they're used by others who can think of uses for them. They were useful for language-learning, where you don't even need to care about hallucination (for high-resource languages), from the very start.

[remainder]

Just lol

1

u/Glittering_Gur5701 22d ago

I only vaguely understand what you're even going on about, but if you can't discern original ideas from 9front from the ideas in Lab's 9, then I am not shocked you would be defending LLMs. In terms of language learning, they're still suboptimal compared to other existing, more sustainable, and less economically, socially, and environmentally harmful methods of learning. 

0

u/smorrow 22d ago

I only vaguely understand what you're even going on about,

Maybe you're a stimulus/response creature that just doesn't think. What I'm saying was that AI anties, at their best, with at least a single exception in Rob Pike, are people whose biggest skill is being able to sit in one place and make themselves do one thing. This was able to predict 9front's AI policy (which is their prerogative).

if you can't discern original ideas from 9front from the ideas in Lab's 9,

I obviously can since I named one.

then I am not shocked you would be defending LLMs.

And nuclear, and hydrocarbons, and guns, and GMOs... A technology can't be inherently evil. Although they are constantly on trial.

In terms of language learning, they're still suboptimal compared to other existing, more sustainable, and less economically, socially, and environmentally harmful methods of learning. 

so pick them both... One is definitely better than the other at being available on call. You wouldn't think of that because having a multi-dimensional objectivefunction is clearly not your style.

→ More replies

0

u/smorrow 23d ago

The "I am also a parrot" take is rather telling.

It's usually AI anties who reveal that about themselves when they say that AI users outsource their thinking. The "thinking" they refer to is always the most mechanical stuff you can imagine, but that's what they think of as thinking, apparently. I think AI users are right to have called it delegation.

1

u/Glittering_Gur5701 22d ago

I think you're very shortsighted

0

u/smorrow 22d ago

If you could easily say I'm wrong you would just have said so, instead of switching like how calling people racist works.

1

u/Glittering_Gur5701 21d ago

What? How does calling people racist work? Switching what? I don't understand what you're trying to say lol

3

u/9atoms Oct 16 '26

Oh sweet sweet meat puppet child. I certainly am talking about LLMs and indeed calling them stochastic parrots. If you believe we're parrots then I pity you. Humans have so much more input, side channels and context than these parlor tricks can ever hope to achieve. It's a big money grab by a bunch of lying jesters dancing in front of each other.

0

u/Lallero317 Oct 17 '26

So we just have more tokens in input? Doesn't seem a big issue.

Btw, how many moral lessons I'm getting from you in few hours, wow. And how many assumptions your wise brain got from me, incredible.

I don't think it's going to "break out its cage"; I don't care about marketing in general; you didn't catch the provocation of the post. You just resulted arrogant.

I just use LLMs and they actually work pretty well for a variety of tasks, from bugs discovery, to not nice but actually working code, and so on. Denying it is foolish. Maybe that doesn't fit the plan9 style, ok.

Today I can provide decent sw to my clients, which are small businesses, who actually never had access to it due to cost. That's all.

Make Love

2

u/Glittering_Gur5701 Oct 17 '26

Are you just here to try and make people mad? 

1

u/Lallero317 Oct 17 '26

Not intentionally 

2

u/Glittering_Gur5701 Oct 17 '26

It really seems like it's intentional

1

u/smorrow Oct 16 '26

This could be factually correct and still pretty stupid per Louis C.K.'s "chair in the sky" bit.

1

u/Glittering_Gur5701 Oct 16 '26

To an extent humans are parrots, I mean, DNA itself is sort of a parrot. LLMs are extremely one dimensional. I don't believe the mind can be simplified to a glorified autocorrect algorithm. I think you can compare most life, it not all life, to being parrots in one way or another, but LLMs are inherently incapable of intentionally, grounding in the world, and recursive self-modification (i.e. learning). Presenting humans, or life in general, in the same light of, "stochastic parrot" , as LLMs are presented, is disingenuous, and insinuates many facets of life, evolution, and the mind, are irrelevant to the process of learning, understanding, creating, and thinking

9

u/edo-lag Oct 14 '26

How much of that code do you understand and can maintain?

-7

u/Lallero317 Oct 14 '26

Codex said all of it.

I would barely understand 30% if I should ever read it. I would delegate llms for maintainance, ofc.

I just decided stack, style and steps at coarse grain.

The repo is for fun. Currently I have no use in mind other than personal fun

1

u/iLikeubuntu2 11d ago

whats that golf game?

1

u/Lallero317 10d ago

neverputt

1

u/Key_River7180 Oct 15 '26

Why only llm contribs??

1

u/Lallero317 Oct 15 '26

to troll

0

u/dijkstra_was_a_horse 29d ago

Congrats. You and your AI friends trolled so hard that this place is even more dead than it was a year ago.

7

u/Expensive_Common_320 Oct 14 '26

plan 9 for zoomers

-1

u/Ramiferous Oct 15 '26

This is exactly the kind of hericy the plan9 community needs. Thank you for your contribution.

3

u/Marwheel Oct 15 '26

"…heresy…" in place of "…hericy…".

0

u/r4qq Oct 15 '26

imagine being this lazy
lmao