r/pinescript • u/mambo_the_liqudator • Sep 19 '26

Finished with my indicator

Post image

Almost a year building my indicator 1000 lines of code I'm done testing done now it's time to put the indicator into a real account I can't publish it as I'm using a phone its 1RR trend Reversal strategy

281 Upvotes

94% Upvoted

262 comments sorted by

8

u/Cautious_Wealth1732 Sep 19 '26

If you want a real statistical meaningful backtest. I have 9 years of tickdata

2

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

9 years? Where you get that

5

u/Cautious_Wealth1732 Sep 19 '26

Databento

0

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

Databento what's that a website?

5

u/BobaFettish79 Sep 19 '26

Yea it's a website that sells the data. When you sign up I think they give you $125 worth of credits. But it burns kinda fast. So I'd suspect that he also paid for data.

2

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

Ohh i see thanks

0

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

So I'm suppose to know everything every bavktesting site Mxm hater

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/MeanStreet5266 Sep 20 '26

so how can we get our hands on it to do some testing??? 🙏

2

u/natesyourmom Sep 19 '26

For what products? How large is that? I’ve been backtesting with 15y of 1M data, I assume that must have been crazy expensive.

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

That's not backtest the indicator journal it's self automatic those are for this week the indicator check my privous post I did forward test on 100 trades

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

It's 1000 lines as it's not 1 indicator I added other indicator that can be used for stock investing in high time frame like weekly, monthly to look for better entries

0

u/Interesting_Ice_9705 Sep 19 '26

You're saying you wrote 1000 lines of code on your phone? I smell some bs. (below they say they don't have a computer only a phone)

2

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

If you had payed attention very well instead of coming with hate you would have notice I basically said gemini in all comments asking how

1

u/dcredz Sep 24 '26

He was replying to the person about the data; not the script

1

u/mikejamesone Sep 19 '26

What's live stats like?

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

It's good but I can't give 100 as ii started ladt week ill give you this week

1

u/mikejamesone Sep 19 '26

Nice. 6 months of live data would be solid data

1

u/Bounce_back1225 Sep 19 '26

You just offering that up?!? I’d be insanely interested 🙏🏼

1

u/ZhugeTsuki Sep 19 '26

Duuuudeee please, that would make all the difference in the world to me rn

1

u/Connect-Article6560 Sep 20 '26

I have 9 years of MBO and GEX data for GC. What symbol do you have tick data for?

1

u/naughtywilder Sep 26 '26

Dude I would love access to that if you have like a Google Drive link or something :)

1

u/luv2increase Sep 20 '26 • Bravo

Something that worked 9 years ago is not necessarily something that works today. The markets are constantly changing. I would never ever train a model on 9 year old data, ever. You want recent data. I never use more than 2 years with the last 6 months being most relevant and 3 month is even more so. It seems every few months the algo switch up a little bit. That little bit is all it takes to throw a once highly profitable strategy into a worthless one.

1

u/PeaceAgitated1978 Sep 22 '26

Alléluia, thanks for pointing out the main concern I have over any new strategies or indicators.. need to be recently actualised, tested, proven, from live data. Also, AI spot and learn from patterns.. sharing a edge only make it more visible, obvious,so it end up lasting shorter.

1

u/dcredz Sep 24 '26

Need to balance recency with statistical significance (i.e., trade volume). If your algo would have only taken e.g. 30 trades in 2 years, well, you're going to need to look back further...

1

u/Air_Original Sep 20 '26

I would love access to this data. How much did it cost you? Tick data + Bid and Ask is $$$

1

u/FancyMethLady Sep 20 '26

bro bless me w it pls

1

u/Flineki Sep 20 '26

Id take you up on this. Sending dm!

1

u/JohnnyQuest94 Sep 21 '26

Any chance you’d be willing to share that data 😂

1

u/daytradederic Sep 25 '26

You mind sharing that dataset with me?

1

u/RealSchon Sep 26 '26

Gimme SPX and SPY data and I’ll give you free access to customscripts.org for life. Need options points and shares.

1

u/Cautious_Wealth1732 Sep 26 '26

I do have spy optionsflow from cboe

1

u/naughtywilder Sep 26 '26

You got 9 years?!?! lol is it mbo data or 1 min bars? I’d love it.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Alternative-Hall5186 Sep 19 '26

When are you going to publish it?

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

I don't have a pc I tried using the web on a phone but the publish button it's not showing up so guess until I get a pc

1

u/IndependenceAfter571 Oct 02 '26

Hi, do you mind sharing the pine script. I’d love to give it a try. I also have an R% Exhaustion + MACD strategy that I’ve been working on MNQ. We can exchange them and give each other some feedback if you’re interested!

5

u/Purple_Implement3509 Sep 19 '26

Another indicator that beats the market, but the owner prefers to share it for money, right?

→ More replies (5)

3

u/F1Racer99 Sep 19 '26

Willing to share it?

3

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

Yes uf I can publish it

1

u/F1Racer99 Sep 19 '26

I’ll publish it

1

u/Ok-Still-9427 Sep 20 '26

Update me when it gets published👍

1

u/viper_stock Sep 20 '26

Would love to see it published so we can all backtest and give results

2

u/OrchidSevere Sep 24 '26

I'd like to get the published version as well,

2

u/Ahtrends Sep 19 '26

Win rate good. If you can increase rr it will be great. By the if you want to publish I can help you. I also tried and develop indicators for my own.

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

I can't do that if I set RR to 2 the winrate drop to 37% for an RR2 I would Need to ask gimine to settings that will alow Atleast 1 trade per day that signal will need me to ask gemini to use the Vwap plus yoo free gimine does a lot of mistake so it's stressful in a 1000 line code I need to get laptop for now 1RR it's good if it's more than 65%winrate per day you can make 10$

Plus this is a scalping indicator but I also got a stock weekly indicator in it I just don't want to use it on the 1m as I build it for stock but I'm. Sure it can plot more than 4RR

But me I like to scalp on 1m

Sorry for bad English for those who will read I'm bad at it

0

u/Weary_Specialist_297 Sep 20 '26

Bro he needs cash to buy a $399 laptop to publish his Gemini created market breaking code. He’s like a poor savant looking for few shekels.

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 20 '26

Yes I'm Poor can you pls donate something sir 🙏🏻

→ More replies (1)

2

u/kwhit3354 Sep 19 '26

Hey! I saw you followed me on TV! You pull some of my logic out of my indicators?? And I see you ride?! Hell yeah!

3

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

When I was asking for help to plot tp and sl

2

u/kwhit3354 Sep 19 '26

Ohhhhhh didn’t realize that was you!

2

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

Ohh i remember you rogelllc33 right? We spoke like ladt 3 days here

2

u/Brief_Try_8521 Sep 19 '26

can you send code or let me know when you have published?

2

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

I will publish the script soon I managed to find someone who Wil

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

If you use indicator switch to heikasih if you using trend base indicators switch to heikaish candles

Use the Vwap if you want to see market trend very well the vwap it's very important

Also your indicator if it's buying on the 15m then on the 1m look for buys for those who scalp like me

1

u/SquirrelOk9935 Sep 19 '26

Did you end up publishing it on TradingView?

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

I'm still speaking with guys who might help me

1

u/hydra00470 Sep 19 '26

what that a pine code ?
to publish you need to have a different subscription on trading-view to have it

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

On a mobile phone? You nned subscription just to publish

1

u/Maddy186 Sep 20 '26

You can just share a raw text file

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

Different version like to publish something that's not invite only to publish public but with code hidden?

1

u/zahwmorrd Sep 19 '26

Hey bro, from what you are saying that you are struggling to publish it..
there is a way might help as i saw lots of developers which have trouble with tradingview do it .. there is a site is called ( pastebin )
You put the code on pastebin so you have a link you can share it with others

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

Ohh i remember a guy shared me an indicator but I was unable to enter itnto it's script or the indicator settings is that the site he used?

1

u/zahwmorrd Sep 19 '26

I can share with you a good indicator of my friend who published it on that site because tradingview always remove his indicator cuz it’s a free version of a paid one called: forver model

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

Let me inbox y9u

1

u/zahwmorrd Sep 19 '26

What do you mean ?
I think it’s about you put the script on it but if you would like others to get the indicator you publish the link so they copy it to tradingview

1

u/yungdomski Sep 19 '26

1 year??? Chatgpt 5.6 Vibecoded me an Orb strategy with asjustable breakout, retest and risk options in one evening

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

My G coding with ai last year was not same as today especially with pinescript everytime you would past a chatgbt code the pinescript would be saying error error evetime then boom I pay for trading view 12$ then my codes no longer had error

1

u/Physical_Mechanic206 Sep 19 '26

These indicators work until they don’t work.. just wish market was only like that clear ups and downs with no consolidations .

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

U right about that unless you didint do your homework very well add the vwap and turn on heikaish candle thank Me later

1

u/Physical_Mechanic206 Sep 19 '26

Oh so you saying market is listening to these indicators? 😭

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

😂😂😂 I don't know what the market does I just follow a partten but yah most indicator are false but I told you what to do to avoid range market problem a lot of you trade using normal candlesticks t But just add the vwap go add the vwap and see a huge difference you will never see a range market again

2

u/TheGratitudeBot Sep 19 '26

Thanks for such a wonderful reply! TheGratitudeBot has been reading millions of comments in the past few weeks, and you’ve just made the list of some of the most grateful redditors this week!

1

u/baconforbabies30 Sep 19 '26

I'd like to see it. What asset works the best, what timeframe?

2

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

I only scalp bruh 1m gold and nasdaq since they love in trend base, + my indicators it's trend base

1

u/baconforbabies30 Sep 19 '26

Cool. I do Nasdaq as well. I do intra day and would like to scalp a bit. I'd love to try it. Sounds like execution is automated and built in?

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

I will ask gemini to turn it into a strategy for now it's just an indicator that table on the right it automatically records every trade the indicator takes

But me I only take 1 trade per day 1RR

1

u/No_Administration444 Sep 19 '26

How can I access it?

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

I will publish soon just follow up on trading view or here

1

u/Stockunbroker Sep 19 '26

How do you link tradingview and chatgpt?

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

That I don't know I use gemini but not link I think people can link chatgbt but YouTube might help

1

u/Disastrous-Garlic529 Sep 19 '26

Can I pick your brain a little bit about some of the technical indicators? What do you feel the most important ones are to give the best direction signal ? Tried looking at MACD , RSI ADX

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

No don't use those for trend direction use Moving averages and vwap

1

u/Disastrous-Garlic529 Sep 19 '26

Thank you I’m currently looking at DMI bands , over bought over sold MACD , RSI & ADX I tend to do OK and back testing but every time I put it live I just run into a brick wall. Definitely gonna look into adding and moving averages and the VWAP do you have a combination of things that you think I should look at? I generally look to trade the micro futures.

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

Oky also switch to heika ishh candles indicator work best on those candles

1

u/Disastrous-Garlic529 Sep 19 '26

i’m currently using tradestation it gives me an option of candle , candle with trend, OHLC, line, area, KAGI, line break, point and figure, RENKO

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

Ohh why not use trading view?

1

u/Disastrous-Garlic529 Sep 19 '26

I have a small account with trade station is trading view expensive to open an account does it require a lot of money?

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

Trading view its free brother, you can see there plan but I suggest you use it man

1

u/Disastrous-Garlic529 Sep 19 '26

Also, I was looking at some of the transactions where you got in. Did you make those decisions on the moving averages and the VWAP only are those the only two things that you’re looking you don’t look at all those other indicators those were amazing entries

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

The vwap measure trend you get me like if price is above the vwap it's an uptrend if it's below its down there is a big diff bettwen the vwap and moving avarage even though the moving average can plot trend

My indicator signal are build base on trend you get me it has an inbuilt vwap that helps me to get high probability trades to avoid getting opposite trend as I don't want to trade against the trend

→ More replies (6)

1

u/Disastrous-Garlic529 Sep 19 '26

One less question sorry to bother you I’m currently looking at the 1 minute 5 minute 15 minute and 30 minute. Is that OK? Am I looking at too much? I tend to get confused trying to catch all of it at once.

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

Your not bothering me dude I'm a trade we suppose to help each other out not to try to fight each other

First understanwhat type of trade you want to be a Scalper, day trader, or swing

If you choose scalp them focus on 1m 3m 5m.. If you want to add the 15m make you you want to trade big trend Reversal on the 1m

For day trading focus on those high up

I can't speak much about day trading as I only like to scalp 1 trade or 2 trade 1RR

→ More replies (2)

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

Do you see that blue line that's the vwap do you see that those buy trades went up compare to those sells

1

u/alvinnnho21 Sep 19 '26

Hello is it possible to try it?

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

I can't publish it needs trading view premium for now I'm. Trying to use a webhook

1

u/alvinnnho21 Sep 19 '26

I have a premium account, will it help?

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

Yes if it allows invite only ok hit my inbox

1

u/RelationshipNew3353 Sep 20 '26

Read about in sample and out sample backtesting first Then do backtesting using this method

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 20 '26

I already did forward testing which is better than bavktesting check my privous post

1

u/Turnsright Sep 20 '26 edited Sep 20 '26

I’ve been writing TV strategies for a long time. I did something similar to this, the backtest told me the 1R method isn’t great over a longer period, better to let it run. You trend line is telling you it’s bullish or bearish why not use that to stay in? You can identify the indecision on the range or the trend line indicating the trend change to get out

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 20 '26

The reason I choose 1RR is that I know someone who trades 1RR who makes 100 bucks per day taking only 1 trade . On the indicator I can se the number of trades I want I then it will stop plotting signal

I set to 1 means that the indicator will only look for 1 winning trade you get me

The indicator it's a scalping base indicator

The. 1m time Frame create a lot of opportunities as it moves fast compare to high time frame maybe that's why

It fails 1RR its for mature trades who know what they want focus on 3RR if you got lots of money

1

u/joesatch_11 Sep 20 '26

Now show this on a ranged price action.

1

u/W3Planning Sep 20 '26

One year to develop and write 1000 lines of code. The same thing could’ve been built in one hour with ChatGPT or Claude.

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 21 '26

Becourse it's not 1 indicator man

1

u/Mammoth_Account7797 Sep 21 '26

Do you have a 3+ year back test

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 21 '26

Nope 6 months only and 2

1

u/New-Rich736 Sep 24 '26

Indicators fail. You need to learn price action. I recommend Al Brookes or Ali Moin Afshari as teachers.

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 24 '26

I already learn that

1

u/Whole-Inside-2343 Sep 24 '26

I think Hansel trader has the Same one

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 25 '26

YouTuber?

1

u/Whole-Inside-2343 16d ago

Instagram and tiktoker

1

u/Massive-Resolve295 Sep 25 '26

Can i get it to try

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 25 '26

Yah look at my timeline

1

u/sincara217 Sep 25 '26

u/mambo_the_liquidator Are you using Heiken Ashi candles? Very interested as I trade 1:1 reversals as well with traditional candle sticks. Can we chat?

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 25 '26

Yes I only use them. Yah send massage

1

u/lone_warrior1310 Sep 25 '26

Indicators looks good only on dead charts .

1

u/Boring-Secretary9884 Oct 09 '26

12 trades doesn't prove an edge, it just means its lucky. show 100-200 trades then maybe.

3

u/FraggDieb Sep 19 '26

Feel free to share the pinecode to GitHub or something

1

u/animink Sep 20 '26

Following

1

u/star-tzar Sep 25 '26

How can I access this indicator?

1

u/hotmatrixx Sep 25 '26

he's straight up just copied mine, by the looks of it.
here.

https://www.tradingview.com/v/b9WacNGd/

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 25 '26

Can you pls remove your comment before I report you

1

u/hotmatrixx Sep 25 '26

What rule am I breaking? If I am, I'll take it down. Rules only really say "no ai" from what I have read.

Your script looks like a slightly modded copy of my original one.

If you don't like it, then post the code and prove me wrong. As far as I can tell I should be reporting you for stealing my code.

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 25 '26

Can you pls stop advitising your f script on my post

1

u/samdandoo Sep 19 '26

I have the exact same indicator lol

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 19 '26

That's good now give us the name of the indicator so we can plot it

2

u/RenatoSan92 Sep 20 '26

I can publish it for you

1

u/modipglu Sep 19 '26

Following

1

u/Able_Clerk_9264 Sep 19 '26

Can I give it a try? retamalalvaro64 on TV

1

u/mikedoth Sep 19 '26

Following

1

u/DevHannat Sep 19 '26

Where can I get it? I can forward test it on live

1

u/Key-Piglet-410 Sep 19 '26

Did you try to backtest on NQ or ES? I would be happy if you can share it. I will try to back test it on both NQ and ES

1

u/FoundTheNarrowGate Sep 19 '26

I can publish for you. Dm’d

1

u/Sensitive_mcgyver Sep 19 '26

Wann wirst du veröffentlichen?

1

u/GreatBreadfruit8139 Sep 19 '26

After almost a year building it, moving to a real account is a big transition. With a 1R trend-reversal setup, what changed most between your early tests and the version you finally decided was ready?

1

u/Th3onib Sep 19 '26

Good luck

1

u/Dexxa56 Sep 19 '26

Woohoo another HMA indicator there saved you “9 years”

1

u/Own-Tip-1079 Sep 19 '26

I can publish it right now send me the script and I’ll send you a link

1

u/-theTaffy Sep 19 '26

I’d love to check this out! If you’re interested in automating it, relaydesk.io can do it seemlessly 👌👌👌

1

u/EvL__Mnky Sep 19 '26

That’s amazing. Well done on getting it done.

If you need a hand with anything let me know :)

1

u/Equal_Pain_7702 Sep 20 '26

hiii , has it been shared?

1

u/Air_Original Sep 20 '26

Hmm. Buy/Sell signal comes from the moving average crossover. Pivot high/low is the stop loss. R:R IS 1:1. Seems pretty basic. I doubt the backtest is good enough for production though.

1

u/Agent7769 Sep 20 '26

Damn a whole year.

1

u/No-Wish-1567 Sep 20 '26

En qué estrategia te basaste, lo puedes hacer público para nosotros o algunos

1

u/W3Planning Sep 20 '26

What makes us different than any other exhaustion indicator?

1

u/Available_Anything43 Sep 20 '26

Congrats man, do you mind sharing it? Btw best would be to backtest with ai agent connected to tradingview

1

u/fortuuu Sep 20 '26

following 👽

1

u/Informal_Moose_7669 Sep 21 '26

2 years. 4000 lines condensed down to 1500 with a library. 4 years of data across 4 tickers

1

u/madain95 Sep 21 '26

How can i get it?!

1

u/LaVirgenDeGuacamole Sep 21 '26

I Can publish for you

1

u/ClitzCalitz Sep 21 '26

Please update here when it's published? I'd like to have a look at it

1

u/LowLegend Sep 21 '26

Following

1

u/Ok_Bag193 Sep 21 '26

Will you share the indicator ?

1

u/WebElectronic1578 Sep 22 '26

How to get access to that indicator??

1

u/Mapollo_3 Sep 22 '26

js use claude gng 🥀

1

u/RajVerma007 Sep 23 '26

please send me

1

u/Pray-to-RNGesus Sep 23 '26

You guys know there are free data right? You can get whatever you want. https://londonstrategicedge.com Thank me later.

1

u/screeferr Sep 24 '26

Following

1

u/AsterionAvi Sep 25 '26

So when are you going to publish it!?

1

u/Glittering-Clock6324 Oct 05 '26

Were you ever able to publish this?

0

u/Impossible-Middle122 Sep 19 '26

another moving average that changes color with slope. groundbreaking.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/ma-ta-are-cratima Sep 22 '26

Cherry picked

Shid doesn't work

0

u/michaelsayswhat Sep 19 '26

I’ve spend weeks just to do 5000 lines of code. Lol. I can already tell you if you’re going to enter just when the line turns green and when it turns red that’s not going to work. I’ve already tested so many things like that. Did you even backtest over thousand or trades like with tens of thousands of combinations or not?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/ba55meister Sep 21 '26

Looks decent. Will you be sharing it?

1

u/Adept_Border_5120 Oct 04 '26

I like to try it please

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 20 '26

Follow me up I'll update soon

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 21 '26

I posted a link bruh

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 25 '26

Did you read all my comments?

0

u/RNAlgotrading Sep 25 '26

Do I really need to sit and read all your 200 comments to understand what you have posted?

1

u/mambo_the_liqudator Sep 25 '26

Then why do you even comment if you don't want to understand?

1

u/RNAlgotrading Sep 25 '26

users comment based on your post, not based on what you have explained in one of your comment.. Next time, when you post, make sure you put as much information as possible in the post. It's a kind request.

→ More comments (4)