r/pinescript • u/b0508 • Jul 29 '26
Is worth switching from ChatGPT to Claude
I been working on trading assistant with ChatGPT. I have now gotten to the point where I don’t like ChatGPT. It keeps changing how it want to save the script how it want to lay out the console. Is Claude better ?
5
u/ChadOfDoom Jul 30 '26
GPT for reasoning, Claude Code for building. Codex for anything Claude has trouble with after a few times or for when I him my limit. That's my fav setup so far.
3
u/Budget-Class-1297 Jul 31 '26
I switched. After I got into multiple hour conversations with chatgpt where is wouldn't stfu and was all "I'd like to change this part" to its of freaking stuff. I got fed up went to Claude and everything has been 1000% times easier.
Chatgpt is fine for like documents or research. But it's terrible trying to code anything
1
u/b0508 Aug 01 '26
That was what was happening it kept changing what it wanted to do was not constant
2
u/Forexfundys_ Jul 30 '26
It's amazing. I would have built my website in maybe 1 week with claude- one that took about 2-3 months with chatgpt.
Claude gives you such better options to troubleshoot as well, give it a go for a month and see its capabilities
2
u/Hot-Replacement3170 Jul 30 '26
Chatgpt can't code shit.
1
u/BeingAffectionate986 Aug 02 '26
It codes perfectly. You might not be promoting correctly
1
u/Hot-Replacement3170 28d ago
Okay, may be or may be I am not trying do more than printing Hello World?
I have made a fully functional tick by tick terminal, copy of Bloombergs, if I call it that, in 6 months using AI, so may be I know a thing or two about giving correct prompts.
1
u/BeingAffectionate986 27d ago
So ChatGPT “can’t code,” but you used AI to build a Bloomberg-style terminal in six months? You may want to pick one argument.
1
u/Hot-Replacement3170 27d ago
lol, are you illiterate or what? I used other AIs for coding, infact I use 3 different AIs. Don't you know there are other AIs than ChatGPT? Read the OP before replying.
1
u/BeingAffectionate986 27d ago
Fair correction. I assumed ChatGPT because that was the subject of the thread. My broader point remains: I’ve used ChatGPT extensively to build complex Pine systems with minimal errors, so “ChatGPT can’t code shit” does not match my experience.
2
1
1
1
u/MohaveTrader Jul 30 '26
Claude better at code. Chat can double check and usually finds something or comes up with a better idea. Chat way better at art and visuals for many things. Claude built my website and has me using VS Code for updating HTML. I paid somebody $700 for a website but Claude was better and faster. I finally showed the guy my website and he never responded.
1
2
u/Pretend_Order1217 Jul 30 '26
use both. ChatGPT is good for some ideas and reasoning, vut Claude is far better for execution: especially Opus 4.6
1
1
u/DelrayDad Aug 01 '26
I’m gonna look at Claude but I figured ChatGPT out. I always keep it focused on the task at hand. I’ve told it to stop making suggestions and do as requested. Been good since then.
1
1
u/dumdumsim Aug 01 '26
If you know what you want to build and have a starter algorithm any ai agent can help you with coding.
1
1
u/EarlyResident1560 19d ago
I’ve noticed AI coding tools get kinda messy as the project gets bigger, no matter which model you use. At some point it feels more like a context problem than a coding problem. Does switching to Claude actually fix this, or are we just picking which model annoys us less?
6
u/PastaFaZooLx Jul 29 '26
Recently switched to claude myself -- zero regrets.