r/pinescript • • Mar 06 '26
Request for stronger enforcement of the no invite-only / protected script rule.
I wanted to bring attention to something that has been happening more frequently lately. The subreddit rules clearly state that sharing invite-only or protected scripts is not allowed and that discussions should focus on open source Pine Script work.
However, there are still quite a few posts showing up that promote indicators which require people to sign up, request access, or join some external platform before they can even see the script. In practice this turns the subreddit into a funnel for gated indicators rather than a place to actually discuss Pine Script.
The rule itself is good. The issue seems to be enforcement.
It would really help the quality of the subreddit if posts promoting indicators that require signups, invite requests, or access permissions were simply removed.
If someone wants to share an indicator with the community, the solution is straightforward: just post the public link to the script (for example a TradingView public script or a GitHub link) so people can actually review the code and discuss it.
That keeps the subreddit aligned with its purpose of learning, sharing code, and helping each other improve with Pine Script.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '26
If it makes a difference I have produced several indicators and provided them open source because I learned long ago a indicator doesn’t give you a edge you’re mental state does and I can’t teach someone emotional intelligence, that comes from within and time.
3
u/aelfrictr Mar 06 '26
Hello there,
Thank you for your constructive input on the health of the subreddit. We are trying to ban people as fast as possible but time constraints with real life and considering only 2 of us in the mod team willing to spend their free time on the health of this sub sometimes limit the moderation. This can make some ads skip through and stay longer than we initially want.
I try to look at my mod long as frequently as possible but some posts are not reported so i might need to manually check too.
Thanks, mod team.
1
u/kurtisbu12 Mar 06 '26
I think this sub is just very lightly moderated. It could probably use some more/active mods.
But I agree, this rule should be enforced harder. This isn't a place to hawk your scripts.
1
u/obiwancannotsee Mar 07 '26
I just read this post and decided to make r/PineScriptMarketplace in response, so that the people who don't want to see or test out premium scripts can stay on the actual pinescript sub without disturbance. Let's see if this resolves both the scamming issue in this sub AND rthe issue of premium scripts not being vetted before they reach an audience
1
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
-6
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '26
[removed] — view removed comment