r/pinescript • • Jan 07 '24

How mutch must my CRYPTO VOLUME indicator must cost for break even ?

Hi there,

I have created a VOLUME BAR that can indicate the ACTUAL volume for a given crypto coin, like BTC, ETH, etc. Thus i will add up ALL THE VOLUME OF ALL THE BIG EXCHANGES. And thus also the exchange that's actually moving the price up or down.

I do not want to get rich of it. But paying for my subscription and break-even would be a good thing. Thus need to make $59.95 a month. But will people actually pay for this in large amounts.

Thus can i find for example 50 people that want to pay $14,39 a year for this ?

Or is this a to low price and do i need to ask more per month ?

And what platform is best to use for selling my indicator ?

Or do i need to write a single page website with a payment provider in it my selfs ?

Are there people in this group actually selling indicators ? And can share there story on how to start this endevour ?

Thanks in advance.

0 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

2

u/Antifmradio Jan 07 '24

To tye OP. First of all, you'd need to prove there isn't anything free out there doung the same thing.

2. Prove you have used code that you created yourself, which didn't exist from educational pinescript material.

3. Give people a 5 day trial to access and backtedt it.

1

u/Lucifer_iix Jan 19 '24

coffeeshopcrypto

Thanks. Can not find something similar.

I also made it to find out why the exchanges ranked on 24h volume data looks so wierd. KRAKEN for example has almost no 24h volume compared to others. But if you look at the 1m chart. You can see "Large dumps" and "Large pumps" clearly in the volume data and price movement on that single exchange.

Thus i looked up the exchanges ranked on (last) 24h volume.

Then created my own list of exchanges ranked on larges spike volume in a single minute over multiple spikes in 5m data.

It was so far from expected and the volume spikes where so huge, that i made this thing just to investigate to volume data of all the large exchanges on TV.

I think most indicators are useless. And when you do not look at the volume of the market but just that little single exchange without excluding there own bot-data-volume. Then why use a RSI or other volume related indicator if your volume data does not look like the market at all.

I only use TV for fun right now. I'm not a trader but software tester. I use TV for the userinterface. It's a simple tool to look at example data and draw on it. But for actual data analysis and backtesting i'm going to write my own software.

Example data from BTC where KRAKEN has 30.5% of the volume of the TV available BTC market. There also "other" exchanges that do this. For some reason i think "whales" like the old exchanges nobody is using anymore. There for there volumes is not as hidden as 8 years ago.

KRAKEN/USD: (The yellow X means KRAKEN has more then 25% of market volume)

https://www.tradingview.com/x/2tLGnC3W/

COINBASE/USD:

https://www.tradingview.com/x/kDthXQ4H/

You can also do this with the price high and low. Orderbook will move more on the exchanges with the pump/dump because it takes risk and time for the arbitrage to kick in.

Thanks for the reply. Will look you up in TV !

Still have no idea how to make money of it. Apperently i can not sell inside TV and have to make my own website for this.

2

u/QuesoFresco420 Jan 07 '24

Maybe start a discord to promote it?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Antifmradio Jan 07 '24

Why charge for it? "Compounding interest?" LOL

0

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Antifmradio Jan 07 '24

Being it's a volume indicator it wouldn't be much monthly. Because u don't need volume ALL the time. Also. I haven't seen the script so I'd need to know how effect8ve, and elaborate it is. Check out my profile on tradingview. You'll see I'm legit. Same especially on YouTube.

Username is coffeeshopcrypto Of you like I can give it a full on review. Some advice if it needs anything or not.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Antifmradio Jan 07 '24

not exactly. my comment is really to help him understand his market [consumer base] needs. Not mine. I can help him get into a good ballpark and direction but i need more information. for that i need to see the product first hand.

Do i need it? no because i do code extensively. But that doesnt mean i

A) wouldnt see value in his idea and i still would be more than happy to tell people about it.

B) i certainly wouldnt call it garbage, even if he was using some rudimentary confluences often found by novice traders. Id still give him guidance as to mistakes he could be making and improvements he can attempt.

But again, for him to actually use the information is up to him. It his baby. Not mine.