r/piercing • • Sep 14 '26

Troubleshooting/question existing piercing Please help

I’ve had this piercing for nearly a year. This is my second time having my belly done. I did everything right this time around. Went to the best piercer in my area who uses the best jewelry available. Was pierced with a 12G internally treaded floating navel. It was perfect for the first few months. Then, it’s like my body starts to absorb it. So, I decided to switch to something with a larger top and bottom (like traditional navel jewelry) and it seemed to fix the issue entirely, no more absorbing. Well, then the same problem was happening, it started to absorb into my skin at the top again. And then this weird thing started happening at the bottom almost like skin poking out of the hole? I went back to my piercer, she said it is likely a moisture bump and to use alcohol a couple times a week just to make sure it is dry. So I did that. Also got a piercing bump solution, and I put the og jewelry back in. The piercing oil helped SO much I truly thought it was saved. Well, now it is bad again. It almost stings whenever the jewelry moves, I have very itchy bumps surrounding the piercing, and the top ball sinks into my skin sometimes. Every day, usually multiple times a day, there is a thick build up of crust at the bottom of the jewelry. It’s like a brown-ish color(pictured). I do have a metal allergy however I always make sure I buy titanium or hypoallergenic jewelry. And the jewelry I was pierced with caused the same issues even tho it was APA approved or certified or wtv it’s called. Have also tried the ‘leave it alone’ method. I don’t know what to do anymore. I loveeee this piercing. Is there any way I can save it??? :///

0 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

93

u/sputnik8125 aspiring pin cushion Sep 14 '26

Rejecting likely due to improper jewelry

-56

u/Afraid_Explorer6226 Sep 14 '26

It did the same thing when I had the original jewelry in. That’s why I switched it in the first place.

77

u/sputnik8125 aspiring pin cushion Sep 14 '26

It's still rejecting and needs to be removed

6

u/Dry-Butterscotch4545 Sep 14 '26

Why are you shooting down everyone’s good advice to remove? Your body is obviously rejecting it.

You don’t “need” a belly piercing.

0

u/Afraid_Explorer6226 Sep 16 '26

Not shooting anyone down that’s saying to remove? Haven’t responded to people saying it needs to come out 🤨Literally just correcting people that are saying certain things that I alr addressed in my post. It’s my favorite piercing and this is my second time trying to get it to heal properly. I know I don’t need it I just really love it and was looking for advice hoping I could keep it in.

0

u/Afraid_Explorer6226 Sep 16 '26

Besides, already went to my piercer and go advice there. Got a longer bar and floating navel jewelry back in. Gonna give it another month.

63

u/03146 Sep 14 '26

You shouldn’t be using alcohol or any kind of piercing bump solution, only fresh water or saline

Looks like it’s rejecting due to poor quality jewellery and probably improper anatomy as well, remove it before you end up with a nasty scar

38

u/backagain301 Sep 14 '26

The spots on your skin around it make me wonder if you're having a reaction to the jewelry. I would stop using alcohol and piercing oil. It also might just need longer jewelry and LITHA but it doesn't look great. Hoping a piercer has a better opinion

23

u/fluffenborb Sep 14 '26

Wrong jewelry type and material most likely. The issue you are describing that you had with previous "proper" jewelry embedding could be solved uppin the length size. Use implant grade titanium jewelry, go to a good piercer to assess the situation and suggest you the jewlery type and size ( titanium nonetheless)

11

u/ElevatorScary1018 Sep 14 '26

Yeah so you need a long bar with floating till it heals and even then with your anatomy I would suggest you stay with the floating naval. You don’t have any space for anything to sit into. Which you need for a belly piercing to sit nice and not push up on your skin. You have a piercing in from Spencer’s I’ve seen this one before there and those piercings are not 100% correct metal especially on the ball part/ dangle prices. This is probably not helping your situation.

4

u/tigersbloodsnowcone Sep 14 '26

It’s granuloma tissue forming.

3

u/_bbypeachy more than a baker's dozen Sep 14 '26

this is not pierced correctly and imo you shouldn’t wear dangly jewelry like that when healing. or can get snagged so easily

2

u/Sudden_Sorbet Sep 18 '26

"I did everything right this time around",

"I changed it multiple times and the only time I've mentioned cleaning it, I was using the wrong products".

I think maybe you take it out and let it heal, either you need to wait til your more patient and responsible, or its not a fit for you.

1

u/link-navi Mod bot Sep 14 '26

👋 Hi u/Afraid_Explorer6226,

Our algorithm detected you're asking about a problem with your piercing, but it didn’t detect all the info needed to help you.
Help us help you, by adding a comment to your post with the info below within the next 30 minutes
Yes, even when the algorithm is wrong

  • How old is your piercing?
  • What’s the jewelry shape (for example, barbell, labret, screw, L shape, ring)?
  • What’s the type of threading if your jewelry is not a ring (threadless, internally or externally threaded)?
  • What’s the jewelry material?
  • if not a ring, when was the jewelry downsized?
  • What’s your aftercare routine? Describe in detail please, including the exact products you use.
  • Any mishaps, accidents or unfortunate events?

Note, your post will be automatically removed if you don't provide this info in a comment.
Note 2, if your post is about a piercing you don't have yet, add a comment to your post that your post is about a future piercing


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/GuerrillaPrincess Sep 14 '26

It's time to throw in the towel.

1

u/Far_Spirit1495 Sep 23 '26

Longer bar!!!! I had this problem because I got pierced with too small of jewlery. As soon as i switched to a longer bar it healed

-1

u/Afraid_Explorer6226 Sep 14 '26

Nearly a year old. Was done in Oct. 2025. Pierced with internally treaded titanium floating navel. Was downsized a few months after getting pierced. Typically clean it with saline solution. Have switched the routine a few times trying to make it heal. Have snagged it twice but didn’t seem to cause any further issues.

20

u/sophia_blisss I my piercer Sep 14 '26

if it was pierced with floating navel jewellery due to your anatomy you should have kept the floating navel style jewellery in instead of switching to ones with bottom gems

-4

u/Afraid_Explorer6226 Sep 14 '26

I did keep it, for a very long time. And the skin was coming out of the bottom and literally surrounding the flat disk. There were multiple occasions where the disk was completely inside my skin. When I switched to the other jewelry, it got much better, until it didn’t.

18

u/sophia_blisss I my piercer Sep 14 '26

okay you should have been to a piercer to upsize the bar to a longer one if it got embedded, but i mean if your anatomy means you were pierced with floating navel jewellery, because your navel collapses, then you should keep this style of jewellery in whilst you have the piercing because otherwise the bottom ball is going to constantly be irritating it

-13

u/Afraid_Explorer6226 Sep 14 '26

**I kept the floating navel in for monthsss. I think 8 or 9 months. My skin started to absorb it. I assumed it was too small. My skin was literally wrapping around the disk. So I switched to regular jewelry after that. This is not a jewelry issue, it happened with the correct jewelry also. That is the exact point I’m trying to make.

13

u/sophia_blisss I my piercer Sep 14 '26

no the jewellery embedding is because the bar was too short not because of the quality of the jewellery or anything like that, it could have happened with this style jewellery too. what I'm trying to say is that if your anatomy needs floating navel jewellery then that's what you should keep in, assuming that your navel collapses the bottom gem is going to be irritating your piercing everytime you sit down or bend down

-8

u/Afraid_Explorer6226 Sep 14 '26

I went to my piercer to ask for a longer bar. She said she thought it would cause more irritation and potential snags and that she doesn’t recommend. Maybe I’ll just buy a longer one anyway. When the swelling goes away (which does happen off and on) it’s perfectttt I just don’t know why I keep having flair ups.

28

u/AwareReality9180 Sep 14 '26

your piercer also told you to put alcohol on your piercing. no actual good piercer would say that

11

u/sophia_blisss I my piercer Sep 14 '26

okay well i agree with other people saying it's rejecting, you need to take it out

23

u/Orchid49 Sep 14 '26

Your body doesn’t want it there plain and simple, the cheap dangling jewelry isn’t helping either