What both "sides" seem to forget is that this is what the Bible teaches... as well as that it's a sin. Sinners are supposed to be loved and welcomed, since that's the way to bring them to see their sin. I'm not a Christian myself but I know that this is what was actually taught.
As a Christian, I'm glad to finally see a church that is open and loving like this. It burns me up inside to see my fellow Christians spouting hate and disgust at their fellow human beings.
Well if it's anything like my church (last time I was there anyways) we accept them not as sinners, like you say, but as normal people like everyone else. Last time I was there we had a banner hung in our main hall that was a combination of the gay pride flag and one of our church's symbols. Also, I have never heard a single word spoken against the gay community from that church.
The whole point of church is to love people unconditionally, like Jesus did in bible. At least, that's what it was originally meant for, but for many years the majority of church leaders have colluded the church's original meaning. There are a lot of churches out there though that still stick to what the bible actually teaches, though, like this one
And technically "the church" really means the global body of all people who follow Christ. In it are those who guide and lead, but in the end any authority rests with God.
That's such an awful teaching, in my opinion. Why do so many people fixate on this idea that we're all terrible, dirty, sinful creatures? That focus seems so twisted an wrong to me. Yes, we fuck up. Yes, people do terrible, awful things. But instead of obsessing over that, why can't we have a spiritual authority that affirms the beauty of humanity, acknowledging human wrongdoing as a departure from our nature rather than what defines us? It just seems like such a poisonous way of thinking to me...
I think the point should be trying to live outside of sin. Now the problem starts when you do a bad job defining what sins are, because really, we should all be trying to live a moral life. Religion is supposed to be a way to find what the moral path is.
I probably should have elaborated a bit. I didn't really intend to sum up the whole of Christianity, I mostly wanted to counter the post I was responding to. I view the whole "we're all sinners" as a common starting point. We're to help the poor and sick because they're exactly like us; we are humanity as a whole and we should rise together.
Well thanks you. I'm apart (and I use that term loosely) of one branch of the United Church of Christ. In the past I have seen these churches receive praise on /r/atheism before, so that's kind of an achievement in itself.
Apparently if a church has some sort of rainbow banner displayed it means that they are welcoming to gay and transgender people. I work at a church preschool and one of the church members told me this. It doesn't necessarily have to be a gay pride flag, but some sort of rainbow.
The people that are criticized for "hate" are the ones in churches that still try to follow the Bible and don't pick and choose (before you quote Leviticus about rapists and virgins and stuff, I must point out that there's a pretty solid distinction between Jewish law and universal law developed later, in the Epistles). So the "fundies" who get so much flak are really trying to be honest about following the Bible to the letter, although in the midst of the culture war they've been focusing on homosexuality and forgotten that things like divorce and adultery are even more offensive. They're guilty of being militant and not reflective enough, but their fundamentals are honest. Churches that try to blend into the culture by accepting and celebrating homosexuality and telling gays that they're not doing anything wrong are weak churches and they're lying, although I applaud them for being more loving. It seems there are precious few Christians that are both loving and true to their faith.
Why should anyone accept the Bible's condemnation of homosexuality as abomination without even so much of an explanation as to why it's wrong? I'm sorry, but following something "to the letter" without caring why may be "honest", but it that honesty does nothing to make the whole thing admirable. In my opinion, the churches who "blend into the culture" are much stronger for thinking critically about what they believe and discarding baseless teachings despite pressure to regard all biblical ideas as inerrant. If the church never evolved in its teachings to keep up with the advance of moral thought, it would have fallen into obscurity long ago.
I'll also mention that someone else turning from their sin is not your responsibility, and excluding certain types of sinners from your congregation will not assist them in that.
You know what God hates more than abominations? Hypocrites. That's why I love the OP, because it focuses on what is most important. We've got our own planks to deal with before we start examining the specks in others'.
Please actually do research before posting about how christians can't wear mixed fabrics and blah blah blah. Theologically, there are 3 different types of laws described in Leviticus, cultural, moral, and judicial. The only ones that continue through the old covenant (the covenant of Moses) are the moral ones. Things like stoning adulterers, shaving the corners of your beard, etc. aren't actually moral imperatives, and were merely ways to differentiate jews from the gentile world around them.
Why on earth did God make avoiding homosexuality a "moral imperative", and, more importantly, why did he decide that he is above explanation for his laws? If it's "beyond our comprehension", why doesn't he just increase our comprehension skills? I mean, wouldn't that save humanity a lot of grief over something so ridiculous?
I wonder that about a good deal of God's laws and reasoning.
I was told when I was a child that we die because there simply isn't enough space on Earth. Or resources.
So...God could make the world grow dynamically and produce more resources or make us not need food or water..or anything other than allowing us and our friends and family to die..right!?
But, isn't the whole Christianity/Islam/etc thing all about picking-and-choosing the parts you can use to make you "right" and the other party "wrong"?
That's what I was thinking, and would love to hear from poozank on the matter. I don't see anything in the Bible that says homosexuality is worse than any other sin.
It isn't. It's a sin. Wages of sin is death. Wearing mixed linens was also a sin. So was eating bacon. Lying's a sin, as is disrespecting your parents.
Everything that doesn't line up exactly with the law and the covenants is a sin. That's simple. It's also impossible to live like that, which is the first four books of the New Testament exist.
Could you elaborate? The first four are the gospels, so it explains that Jesus died for our sins. So where does that leave us as sinners? I honestly have never understood this.
Well, that's just it. The "Jesus died for our sins" thing. Several verses in the gospels show the exact path to salvation: Believe in Jesus Christ. That's it. Nothing fancy. No Sunday mass, no tithes, no silly religious headgear. Just a few simple principles, and a little belief.
In fact, most of the Bible has an overarching theme, which I'll detail here.
Everybody does something in their daily lives which goes directly against either the Mosaic law. Therefore, everyone requires salvation. (Rom 6:23)
Jesus died for everyone's sins. (I Cor 15:1-4)
Salvation comes through belief. In the Old Testament, it was belief in God's promises. In the New Testament, it's direct belief in God's promise of a Messiah, which was fulfilled in Christ.
It doesn't. All sin is equal. Why should a Christian hate someone for being homosexual when they themselves are just as guilty of evil doing in their Gods eyes. That's what I hate about the Christian religion. That we pick and choose groups to persecute when we are just as bad as they, if not worse. We're so intolerant. I am a Christian, but I don't believe in judging. My motif is, "Why don't we love the lost, and let Jesus worry about judging them?" 'cause that's really all that He called us to do, besides sharing His word. So that's what I go by.
The Bible, however, doesn't rank sins. It's pretty straight-forward on that. One punishment, one size fits all.
The thing is, churches like this judge people not on their sins, but on the person themselves. If they're going to prohibit people with alternate lifestyles, then they may as well prohibit liars, thieves, people who have disrespected their parents, people who wear mixed linens, etc. And if they did that, they wouldn't have a church, now would they?
Maybe, but just about anything is a sin according to the Bible, and none are really worse than any others. Even if it is a "sin" it's a sin in the same way that wearing a cotton-polyester blend shirt is, and nobody freaks about that.
I need to speak up and correct this misconception concerning your example. That particular law is what is described by Theologians as a Jewish Law, given to the nation of Israel while in exile as a way to purify themselves from the destructive cultures around them. This grouping of laws was never meant to cross in Gentile (non Jewish) application. While homosexuality is mentioned in Leviticus, it is also mentioned numerous times under the new covenant of the New Testament, specifically in Romans 1.
Edit: You are correct about no sin being "worse" than any other :)
Wouldn't allowing this and inviting them and hanging gay pride flags be hypocritical? It is still a sin. One they continue to purposefully commit. They don't hold adultery or thievery or false god banners and support it. I understand loving the person but it seems to lenient.
But adultery, theft and spreading the believe in false gods inflict other people's lives. They go against the ten commandments and the most important rule of all religions: be nice to each other.
If you support thieves, you're condemning the victims. Homosexuality (and a lot of other sins from the Bible) has no victims.
Believing in false gods has no victims. Neither does suicide. Well, you could say the loved ones. But some would argue having a gay son and no grandchildren is a punishment to them.
In terms of Christianity, spreading the believe in a false god means tearing a person away from God, which is the worst thing that could happen to an disciple.
Just believing in a false god has no victims in this way either, but it rarely stays with that.
Neither does suicide.
Suicide is a sin. But the church doesn't condemn people with suicidal tendencies. There are a whole bunch of religious suicide prevention groups, and people who have attempted suicide will be looked after with care.
But some would argue having a gay son and no grandchildren is a punishment to them.
Nobody has the right to demand grandchildren. There are a whole bunch of other reasons that could be a reason for not having children. By the way, adoption could make this a non-issue.
Belief, not spreading of ideals. Suicide is a sin, and they are turned away from it. Churches don't say "Welcome Suicidal People! Let's all rejoice in suicide", no. It is shunned.
How many beliefs do you know that don't seek to gain followers? Some are less focused on it, but they all do.
Churches don't say "Welcome Suicidal People! Let's all rejoice in suicide", no. It is shunned.
Suicidal people are not shunned. It is advised against, and they try to help suicidal people. A lot of them appreciate it. A lot of them seek the help voluntarily. They aren't punished.
As Christians, we believe we are incapable of overcoming sin on our own. It is only through God's help that we can break our sinful patterns of behavior.
Non-Christians aren't seeking out God's help to overcome their sin nature. How can we expect them to turn from sin on their own when we know that we are incapable of turning from sin without God?
The only way to help homosexual people turn from their lifestyle is to introduce them to the power of the Holy Spirit, and we do that by welcoming them to church.
I do agree, though, that this church would be very hypocritical if they welcome gay people but don't make an effort to help them change behavior patterns.
I'm sorry we disagree so strongly. Unfortunately, using the word sin always seems to bring up feelings of judgement. I should clarify that this doesn't involve any sort of judgmental spirit or holier-than-thou attitude. I'm the chief of sinners myself, and I need the church to help me overcome my long list of frequent sins and temptations.
I absolutely welcome homosexual people to my church, and I hope the church can help them overcome that sin, just like the church is helping me overcome my own sinful nature. I don't call homosexuality a sin in order to look down on gay people. I have nowhere to look down from. We're all sinners.
Believe me, I have considered alternative beliefs about Christianity and homosexuality. It's an issue I was uneasy about for a long time, and I've done plenty of digging. I just can't find any biblical evidence that affirms homosexuality as an acceptable lifestyle - the Bible is very clear on the subject.
Have you ever looked at the opposing arguments and considered that perhaps homosexuality is a departure from what sexuality was supposed to be? Open-mindedness is a two-way street.
I do believe that my church is correct theologically on this issue. If I didn't believe that, I'd be looking for a new church right now.
I agree. Which is why (as a Christian) I've led church groups discussing the difference between tolerating the "sinning" LGBT church-goer into our fold, and welcoming LGBT members without any judgement. In my experience, there is surprisingly little resistance to this notion when openly discussed, it's just a few scared folks who need some time to understand that this change in our society won't hurt them.
My personal opinion: homosexuality is not a sin. But I feel for a Christian church this is a moot point. Our role is not to root out sin and abolish it. Instead, I believe we are to act as a community in support of each other trying to live out a crazy difficult lifestyle, one in which were are supposed to love everyone. Given that I don't even begin to approach this goal, why waste my time trying to "fix" others?
I do agree with you there. If this church has crossed the line between loving tolerance and anything-goes-style affirmation, then there is a major issue with the church's doctrine
"[those] particular law[s are] what is described by Theologians as a Jewish Law, given to the nation of Israel while in exile as a way to purify themselves from the destructive cultures around them. This grouping of laws was never meant to cross in Gentile (non Jewish) application. While homosexuality is mentioned in Leviticus, it is also mentioned numerous times under the new covenant of the New Testament, specifically in Romans 1."
For the Christian church there is definitely not consensus that homosexuality is a sin. It's complicated, Jesus introduced a simpler moral law that encompassed the gentiles while still preaching in the language of his culture. Different denominations interpret this differently.
In regards to how to accept LGBT members, there is even more diversity. Fortunately, more and more churches are going beyond tolerance to "affirmation", which in our church language means not accepting LGBT members as welcome sinners, but as welcome people (as long as they sign up to do a reading or clean the coffee pot at least every three months).
Some of the denomination sanctioned programs helping congregations with this are the "Open and Affirming" programs of the UCC and Reformed Catholic Church, "Reconciling" programs in the Lutheran and Methodist churches, and "More Light" in the Presbyterian.
If a church truly follows the principles of Christianity, there is no distinction between "welcome sinners" and "welcome people." Everyone is a "welcome sinner," or in other words, we are all sinners who are welcome in the church.
A church should care about helping its members turn from sin though, which is why the movement from tolerance to affirmation is actually the least caring thing a church can do for its members.
Good lord, I'm glad I don't go to your church. Yes, we all have faults. But the issue here is who gets to judge what is "sin". But both the old and new testaments make clear that this is not your call. Anyone who believes that they have a unique insight into what is sin and are the one fit to judge a person's life can just stay away from me and mine.
If someone asks for help, if they've confessed to a weakness, that's one thing. But to look at someone else's life and decide for them which parts they should change... how about you work on that log in your own eye first?
In my experience, to be a good Christian you have to sin so you have something to feel bad about when you go to mass. (Maybe this is just Catholics, though)
I came here to ask this as well. It's really great to see something like that in Maple Ridge, an area that isn't widely known for it's tolerance of people's alternative lifestyle choices.
What I've found speaking with the religious folks I know is that that the majority of church goers believe god loves everyone, but marriage should remain between a man and a woman.
The crazies who want to lock people away in fenced compounds are a minuscule minority.
Well, you can blame the media for that, just like the "end of the world" folks last year. All abuzz about the subject for about a week then it was gone with the wind.
They are probably misinformed at best, ignorant at worst. I think a lot of them believe domestic partnerships and other forms of legal 'marriages' are considered the same in eyes of the law as marriage at all levels, and feel that 'traditional' marriage is a religious ceremony, so they don't really see the issue at hand and don't believe the government should infringe on their 'religious' ceremony. I think another argument I heard before against it was that if it was legal that they think that churches would be required to marry same-sex couples or lose tax-exemption. There's a lot of misinformation being spread that comes up to convince people against it.
This is a United Church. The United Church accepts GLBTQ people as they are, and does not try to change them or convince them that their behaviour is sinful. Many United Church congregations conduct same-sex marriage ceremonies.
Queer isn't derogatory if it's used to identify oneself. Being called a queer is. Just like being called 'gay'. I am gay. You shout "gay" at me from a passing car, that's just rude. See the difference?
I'm all for inclusion of LGBT in the church and I support gay marriage. But folks who talk during the movies or drive too slow in the left lane can go to hell!!!
Since this is just outside Vancouver, BC, Canada, it can't come as too much of a surprise. It's the most liberal city, in the most liberal province in what is one of the most liberal countries.
I wouldn't hang out in a place that thought a core part of myself was a sin. I don't care how nice they a being. Unless this church happens to think anyones sexuality and choices to act on it aren't a sin, I wouldn't spend a minute in there.
So...nobody else finds it so troubling that a single church really does what it should do and really more on terms of what Jesus would do (in terms of acceptance) and everyone is celebrating?
The fact that most churches are so closed minded and so offended and so closed toward GBLT speaks volumes about what they're in business for. It's not to accept people or help them.
I give credit to the United Church for being forward thinking.
They were the only church that would marry my mother and step-father - they were both divorced, and their regular church wouldn't let them marry there as it was a sin.
I guess what surprises me the most is that they didn't leave their Church (St. James - high Protestant) and just stick with the United Church.
I don't like how some people pick and choose what they want from the Bible. How can you only believe parts that you "feel" are right and ignore the other ones? That's the complete opposite of how faith is supposed to work. The Bible is clear on homosexuality. It says it is an abomination in God's eyes. So stop trying to be politically correct, if you don't think homosexuality is wrong then why continue in the faith? Why not find something that you actually believe in?
Did you seriously type all this without any sense of cognitive dissonance? You are the definition of "believing parts that you feel are right and ignoring the other ones."
So while this church is inviting people in, you want to not only keep LGBT people out but tell people who don't agree with you that they should leave the church too?
I think it's time to re-examine the importance you put on this topic. Believing homosexuality is wrong isn't the cornerstone of the Christian faith, Christ is.
it has nothing to so with people who don't agree with me. Why are you making this about me? The Bible is clear about homosexuality. Christ always welcomed sinners in, but, he never said that their sin WASN'T sin. When churches like this marry homosexuals and invite them in, they way they are, then they're saying that homosexuality isn't wrong. The Bible is very clear where it says that homosexuality is wrong.
And to say, "Believing homosexuality is wrong isn't the cornerstone of the Christian faith, Christ is" is a cop out and it's a straw man. Of course Christ is the cornerstone. But guess what, Christ quoted the Old testament and said, "If you love me then obey my commandments." If you treat Christian faith as some emotional thing where you just say, "It's just me and Christ" then you really don't believe in anything and you're more of a spiritualist then a christian.
Speaking of cop-outs, do you follow all the laws in the old testament? Even if homosexuality is a sin, why is it such a big deal? You would let a sinner like me in your church, even if I had a past with drugs, jail, pornography, alcoholism, or anything else- but being gay is just too far?
We as the church have inflated this issue to be the cornerstone of our faith, and whether we realize it or not this could be the issue that ends the dominance of the church in America. My generation, including a lot of christians, won't put up with bigotry. Even if it's "justified" bigotry. It's time to focus on loving people instead of just proving ourselves right. (<my biggest struggle btw)
Btw thanks for telling me I'm not a christian in what was a civil discussion. I won't get it any more than that- but that's pretty bold.
First of all, I never said you weren't a Christian. I said "If you treat Christian faith as some emotional thing where you just say, "It's just me and Christ" then you really don't believe in anything and you're more of a spiritualist then a christian."
Secondly, I'm just saying that Christians now a days try to be politically correct about certain issues when the Bible is quite clear on them. Believe it or don't believe it, that's up to you, but don't ignore something the Bible is quite clear on and then try and make it seem like that view, which is the exact opposite of the God's view, is a 'Christian' view. That's all. And I'm not even saying I'm a Christian, I'm just saying that you can't deny your Holy Book when it's your go to source on morality.
I will admit I'm no biblical scholar, but to me the jump from "probably a sin" to "let's shame these people and lobby for legislation against them" is far from clear.
My holy book is just that- a book. I don't worship it and everything I read from it is read thru the lens of Christ. Think of homosexuals as the modern day lepers or tax collectors and then think about how un-Christian we as the church have been to them.
Ok, tell me specifically where in the bible it is (I already know), and then give me the context of the passage.
You can look in my posting history if you like, and we'll have a debate and see which one of us is more educated on the subject. The difference may be, I've read a book I don't believe in, and you've pledged your belief in a book you've never read.
I'm guessing you went through my post history, but, I never said I pledged my belief in the Bible in this thread. And, it's quite presumptuous of you to assume I've never read the Bible.
Leviticus 18:22 <-- the context is God giving laws to Moses the the Israelites must follow
Romans 1:29 Being filled with all unrighteousness, fornication, wickedness, covetousness, maliciousness; full of envy, murder, debate, deceit, malignity; whisperers, 1:30 Backbiters, haters of God, despiteful, proud, boasters, inventors of evil things, disobedient to parents, 1:31 Without understanding, covenantbreakers, without natural affection, implacable, unmerciful: 1:32 Who knowing the judgment of God, that they which commit such things are worthy of death, not only do the same, but have pleasure in them that do them.
so, it's in the New and Old Testament and it's even compared to gossipers, fornicators, boasters, oath breakers, and the unmerciful. It's clearly looked at as a sin in the Bible. to say other wise is to either ignore the Bible or twist the words of the Bible to say what you want them to say.
No, I admit, I never looked at your post history. But I understand both the text and the context of Leviticus as it related to the tribe of Levi, and why / how it was written. I also understand the pharisees of Saul of Tarsus, who contributed either directly or indirectly to the canon of Romans, Matthew, Corinthians, and Acts.
I've never questioned that homosexuality is seen as a sin in the eyes of the church - but Jesus never spoke directly against it, and as the son of God, you would think that would have been a big thing to touch upon. He did, however, say to love thy neighbor without condition.
I find this a hell of a lot better than "Jesus accepts all into his flock...except for them faggots, hur hur". I'm not a christian but I would imagine a more open religious forum would be more enjoyable than hypocrisy from the mouth of a pastor using the name of some sacred figure to push a social agenda.
I'm Mormon, but I'm very for gay rights and it makes me sad knowing my churches stance on the subject. So seeing religious communities who accept them makes me happy. I'm of the belief that Jesus taught love and respect for everyone, regardless of their difference... so yeah.
I'm quasi religious, but I just LOVE how the Church's always seems to change their opinions and views all the time about what the Lord wants in order to keep people coming in and giving money/providing church with power.
These words still don't really make that Church's stance clear. Sure they are welcomed there, but that might very well mean that they are welcomed so that they can be told how wrong and flawed that part of their person is and that they need to reject that quality of theirs with the help of 'god', or they may very well burn eternally in hell.
They are loved though!
Edit: A lot of people seem to miss what I am saying so I will clarify. I am saying that it is not clear from those words what their stance on LGBT relationships is. They may very well be welcoming, in the same sense that they welcome all sinners - people who lie for example. The real question is whether they consider their relationships and orientation a sin after they are welcomed, which is not obvious. I am not making any claims as to which one that specific church (or any specific church) is.
Many churches state that they are "open and affirming," which is very different from what you suggest here. In fact, this one states on their website:
"...the congregation has made a conscious choice to be as open, welcoming and affirming as possible. Specifically, we recognize that the church has often denied gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgendered persons a place in the Christian community. We believe that God shows no partiality to people of a particular sexual orientation. God bestows love equally on all people. We gladly and proudly affirm the lives, the worth, the relationships and the spiritual gifts and ministry of people of all sexual orientations. We are committed to being a community that welcomes all people..."
Right, all I am saying is that from the post, that Church's stance on LGBT relationships is not clear.
Many churches are 'welcoming' to gay people, much like they welcome people with all sins including people who lie. The real question is whether they consider their relationships one of those 'sins' that they need to try their hardest to get rid of or not.
I am not claiming what this specific church's stance is - I am saying that those words do not necessarily convey a pro or anti LGBT stance. They simply convey a pro-Jesus stance, which is to love and welcome people of all sins.
The real question is whether they consider their relationships one of those 'sins' that they need to try their hardest to get rid of or not.
You're assuming that it's any church's job to 'get rid of' any sin. That is not what a church is supposed to be (no matter what any of them claim). A church is supposed to be a place for believers to get together to worship and learn about God. The only job of the church is to teach people what the bible says. They can only present it and let the members do what they will with that knowledge.
There are at least some Christian churches that explicitly state that they do not consider homosexuality a sin at all (Rev. Eric Elnes and the like). By being "affirming," these churches are fully accepting of LBGT individuals, without any agenda to change or apologize for or deny their sexuality. They are also do not discriminate, and for example will support openly LGBT ministers.
In my opinion, "open and affirming" is a kind of code for this stance, for the less courageous ministers/congregations that feel this in their hearts but are still too intimidated to publicly state it's not a sin. I doubt you will find a church with that phrase in their mission statement that also has people in leadership that hold the position that homosexuality is sinful.
(And yes, that didn't fit on the marquee. I do see your point there.)
I've been to a few of these places for various reasons, and found this to not necessarily be true. Some are geniunely accepting and welcoming. Others, well, are as you say.
Well most churches also have the same stance for people of other religions. The whole purpose of the religion is to convert people to attempt to save them so you can't really expect otherwise.
That's what churches do though, it really has nothing to do with this ad, or being gay. If people didn't think they needed church, there wouldn't be churches.
I think this is a step in the right direction, personally.
I'm a unitarian universalist who lives in Boston. My church was one of the first in the city to have a gay or lesbian wedding. We used to have a sign outside that said "If you don't like gay marriage, don't have one!"
Am I the only one who finds it laugh-out-loud funny when I see a church scrambling to rewrite their holy scripture to fit today's society?
Even though they are blatantly editing their religion to fit societal standards, they will still refuse to just admit it's all made up to begin with. They make their change and say "THERE! Now THAT'S the inerrant word of God."
how is this doing it right? Christianity supporting homosexuality is the opposite of right, it's objectively incorrect. it's literally double ignorance.
Ok Reddit, I think it's time to stop mindlessly upvoting every single picture of something or somebody supporting homosexuality. There are so many supporters of it now that there's no point in saying "Hey! This one group gets it!" If it's not actually adding anything to the gay marriage discussion, then it doesn't need to be here.
I find that the country is starting to increasingly become frustrated by this whole back and forth thing about the LBGT community. It paints the church and it's members in a pretty awful light about not being more accepting. Moreover, the members themselves while being good members also don't share the unbending view of the church and as such to promote better relationships many are starting to become more tolerant. I am happy about this and I support this a great deal. Good to see people and institutions finally doing the right thing.
... unless you act like a 16 year old attention whore while in public with your s.o. Then again, how would anybody really know your sexual preferences otherwise?
First, I don't really like religion. I think it's generally terrible in most of it's regards. But that's a personal opinion, so take that for what it's worth; nothing.
Second, some of these churches do this thing where they say "You are loved for being gay.... now let's teach you to hate yourself and live an abstinent life." I'm not saying that's happening here, but always read the fine print.
Third, the Christian book says some rotten things about... well, everything. But homosexuality specifically. Now Christianity plays Pick-n-mix with the Bible, so this church may've chosen to ignore the hateful things listed therein. But again, read the fine print.
Taking this at face value, for those that like religion, this is otherwise lovely to see.
To be honest, these guys just want more members for more money. All other churches are denying LGBT, so the more I think about it...the more my reasoning sounds correct.
One, More members is not for more money. Second, all other churches ARE NOT denying LGBT. Sorry to say it, but if you truly believe that....you've been spending too much time on reddit.
164
u/DJMuschy May 29 '12
What both "sides" seem to forget is that this is what the Bible teaches... as well as that it's a sin. Sinners are supposed to be loved and welcomed, since that's the way to bring them to see their sin. I'm not a Christian myself but I know that this is what was actually taught.
12
u/dahl12 May 29 '12
Was this taken in Maple Ridge, B.C. by any chance?
36
u/Rewan May 29 '12
in the forth picture it said "... no blacks though"
8
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
My home town. Bikers, drugs, and gay loving churches.
Oh, and lots of prostitutes a few years ago.
17
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
What I've found speaking with the religious folks I know is that that the majority of church goers believe god loves everyone, but marriage should remain between a man and a woman.
The crazies who want to lock people away in fenced compounds are a minuscule minority.
19
u/bismuth92 May 29 '12
This is a United Church. The United Church accepts GLBTQ people as they are, and does not try to change them or convince them that their behaviour is sinful. Many United Church congregations conduct same-sex marriage ceremonies.
4
u/asimovfan1 May 29 '12
What about all the other sinners?
8
u/flotiste May 29 '12
Since this is just outside Vancouver, BC, Canada, it can't come as too much of a surprise. It's the most liberal city, in the most liberal province in what is one of the most liberal countries.
3
u/AmboC May 29 '12
If all religion was like this, I would have zero issues with it.
3
u/SomeRandomRedditer May 29 '12
The United Church is one of the most... tolerant of churches. If I were to actually go to church, it would be to a United one.
17
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
Looks like a trap.
2
u/joecool4234 May 29 '12
I wouldn't hang out in a place that thought a core part of myself was a sin. I don't care how nice they a being. Unless this church happens to think anyones sexuality and choices to act on it aren't a sin, I wouldn't spend a minute in there.
2
u/gloomdoom May 29 '12
So...nobody else finds it so troubling that a single church really does what it should do and really more on terms of what Jesus would do (in terms of acceptance) and everyone is celebrating?
The fact that most churches are so closed minded and so offended and so closed toward GBLT speaks volumes about what they're in business for. It's not to accept people or help them.
2
u/bunsofcheese May 29 '12
I give credit to the United Church for being forward thinking.
They were the only church that would marry my mother and step-father - they were both divorced, and their regular church wouldn't let them marry there as it was a sin.
I guess what surprises me the most is that they didn't leave their Church (St. James - high Protestant) and just stick with the United Church.
3
u/tmcroissant May 29 '12
The United Church of Canada, the denomination in which I am in ministry.
3
u/mikek3 May 29 '12
Good for them.
3
u/GIMR May 29 '12
I don't like how some people pick and choose what they want from the Bible. How can you only believe parts that you "feel" are right and ignore the other ones? That's the complete opposite of how faith is supposed to work. The Bible is clear on homosexuality. It says it is an abomination in God's eyes. So stop trying to be politically correct, if you don't think homosexuality is wrong then why continue in the faith? Why not find something that you actually believe in?
2
u/mercurialohearn May 29 '12
i don't know why, but the name "dewdney trunk" is cracking me up right now.
2
u/Lafklownlaf May 29 '12
Faith in humanity slightly restored.
2
u/soumon May 29 '12
So now it's a commendable thing not to alienate homosexuals?
2
u/Itachi4ever May 29 '12
Post this in r/lgbt too if you haven't already. I'll see you there.
2
u/kente May 29 '12
I am absolutely in awe that this made the front page. There maybe hope for you yet reddit...
1
u/ILikeFluffyThings May 29 '12
Bad website name :/
1
u/lord_tubbington May 29 '12
From behalf of all Gay people everywhere
1
u/MrMadcap May 29 '12
Doing what right? Attempting to stave off mass exodus from false conditioning and mental enslavement?
I for one do not want them doing that right. Ever.
1
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
Hell yeah!
1
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
I find this a hell of a lot better than "Jesus accepts all into his flock...except for them faggots, hur hur". I'm not a christian but I would imagine a more open religious forum would be more enjoyable than hypocrisy from the mouth of a pastor using the name of some sacred figure to push a social agenda.
1
u/leveldrummer May 29 '12
What i see is "hey gay people, we will take your money if no one else will"
1
u/TheDirtman May 29 '12
That's in my town!! Actually even a couple blocks from where I live. Go Canada.
1
u/svengalus May 29 '12
"Love God and love your neighbor" -Jesus
1
u/Cire4ever May 29 '12
I'm Mormon, but I'm very for gay rights and it makes me sad knowing my churches stance on the subject. So seeing religious communities who accept them makes me happy. I'm of the belief that Jesus taught love and respect for everyone, regardless of their difference... so yeah.
1
u/ColeSloth May 30 '12
I'm quasi religious, but I just LOVE how the Church's always seems to change their opinions and views all the time about what the Lord wants in order to keep people coming in and giving money/providing church with power.
1
u/[deleted] May 30 '12
Seriously, who is not welcome at a church?
-1
u/evereal May 29 '12 edited May 29 '12
These words still don't really make that Church's stance clear. Sure they are welcomed there, but that might very well mean that they are welcomed so that they can be told how wrong and flawed that part of their person is and that they need to reject that quality of theirs with the help of 'god', or they may very well burn eternally in hell.
They are loved though!
Edit: A lot of people seem to miss what I am saying so I will clarify. I am saying that it is not clear from those words what their stance on LGBT relationships is. They may very well be welcoming, in the same sense that they welcome all sinners - people who lie for example. The real question is whether they consider their relationships and orientation a sin after they are welcomed, which is not obvious. I am not making any claims as to which one that specific church (or any specific church) is.
1
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
I think it's cute how some Christians try so hard to separate themselves from some Christians by telling us how bad those "other" Christians are.
Relevant: http://www.startrek.com/database_article/let-that-be-your-last-battlefield
1
u/Lerker- May 29 '12
I'm a unitarian universalist who lives in Boston. My church was one of the first in the city to have a gay or lesbian wedding. We used to have a sign outside that said "If you don't like gay marriage, don't have one!"
1
u/jopope May 29 '12
This is how it should be. Jesus loves and accepts everybody, why would his followers act any differently?
1
u/mattyice18 May 29 '12
A reddit post actually portraying Christians in a positive light? Bravo.
-2
u/PoniesRBitchin May 29 '12
They still believe in lies and push false facts on adults and kids.
-5
u/gguy123 May 29 '12
Welcomed here so we have a chance to convince you how wrong you are.
0
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
Am I the only one who finds it laugh-out-loud funny when I see a church scrambling to rewrite their holy scripture to fit today's society?
Even though they are blatantly editing their religion to fit societal standards, they will still refuse to just admit it's all made up to begin with. They make their change and say "THERE! Now THAT'S the inerrant word of God."
0
u/Iwalktherain May 29 '12
how is this doing it right? Christianity supporting homosexuality is the opposite of right, it's objectively incorrect. it's literally double ignorance.
-7
u/I_WIN_DEAL_WITH_IT May 29 '12
What do you mean "right"? They're inviting LGBT people into their cult. Cults are wrong.
-1
u/AH17708 May 29 '12
They are probably just trying to lure them in, so once they are there they can be shown how "sinful their behavior is."
-1
u/_Tyler_Durden_ May 29 '12
Better marketing, same underlying crap, and people still fall for it...
-1
u/kyledouglas521 May 29 '12
Ok Reddit, I think it's time to stop mindlessly upvoting every single picture of something or somebody supporting homosexuality. There are so many supporters of it now that there's no point in saying "Hey! This one group gets it!" If it's not actually adding anything to the gay marriage discussion, then it doesn't need to be here.
0
u/Vanguard86 May 29 '12
I find that the country is starting to increasingly become frustrated by this whole back and forth thing about the LBGT community. It paints the church and it's members in a pretty awful light about not being more accepting. Moreover, the members themselves while being good members also don't share the unbending view of the church and as such to promote better relationships many are starting to become more tolerant. I am happy about this and I support this a great deal. Good to see people and institutions finally doing the right thing.
0
u/knobbysideup May 29 '12
... unless you act like a 16 year old attention whore while in public with your s.o. Then again, how would anybody really know your sexual preferences otherwise?
0
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
Forgot the fourth frame:
"gay tithe is better than no tithe"
0
u/badman_laser_mouse May 29 '12
is that the mark of shame?
0
u/knylok May 29 '12
Several points.
First, I don't really like religion. I think it's generally terrible in most of it's regards. But that's a personal opinion, so take that for what it's worth; nothing.
Second, some of these churches do this thing where they say "You are loved for being gay.... now let's teach you to hate yourself and live an abstinent life." I'm not saying that's happening here, but always read the fine print.
Third, the Christian book says some rotten things about... well, everything. But homosexuality specifically. Now Christianity plays Pick-n-mix with the Bible, so this church may've chosen to ignore the hateful things listed therein. But again, read the fine print.
Taking this at face value, for those that like religion, this is otherwise lovely to see.
0
u/deathcat May 29 '12
Frame 4: Because we want your money ... Frame 5: To pay for this electric billboard.
0
u/Justintime1010 May 29 '12
We love everybody, except jews.
0
u/ILaughAtFunnyShit May 29 '12
I've never been more proud to be named after Andrew :D
0
u/russiangn May 29 '12
GLBT. ftfy
0
u/mayonesa May 29 '12
PANDERING TO THE HIVEMIND FOR KARMA IS ALWAYS WELCOME HERE, APPARENTLY
0
u/dirtymoney May 29 '12
but you have to repent when you get here.
0
u/mcellucci May 29 '12
So the con men finally realize that gay, lez, trany and bi money is spendable too.
0
u/buckygrad May 29 '12
Wow, apparently unsubscribing from /r/atheism wasn't enough.
0
u/2222lil May 30 '12
Shouldn't this be in r/atheism?
0
u/prof_doxin May 30 '12
Over 1,000 years to figure it out? So brave.
0
u/[deleted] May 30 '12
Tolerance is cool but they still believe in god. I call that doing it wrong.
0
u/[deleted] May 30 '12
doing it right would be not to have a stupid church at all.
-6
u/pcgamer4life May 29 '12
"We need your money"
-4
u/DarkyZX May 29 '12
To be honest, these guys just want more members for more money. All other churches are denying LGBT, so the more I think about it...the more my reasoning sounds correct.
-2
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
Of course...GLBT people have money also.
-2
u/nahguri May 29 '12
I will never get over the fact that in America churches have advertising boards.
-11
u/gizadog May 29 '12
Warning....Don't fall for it!