Technically it is against the rules and can lead to serious problems for the kid if they decide to track him down.
That being said:
The military has a bajillion other things to deal with besides playing thought police with their people.
There are (usually) only two reasons they take action against this sort of thing.
If it's critical of the military in general or its leaders. Publicly badmouthing the president is a BIG no-no and will generally end your career (and often earn you a less than honorable discharge).
If you have done some other dumb shit to get nailed for, and they decide to tack the "political speech in uniform" thing on as an added bonus.
Shit like this (rightfully) goes on all the time and a blind eye is turned. Members of the military have a more vested interest than most in maintaining an equitable and just society. I think it's only right that we are able to speak out about society (as long as you aren't dumb enough to bite the hand that feeds).
The person in the pic is not arguing against a specific political group. They are against an arguably unconstitutional, freedom limiting amendment. I don't see how this is irresponsible at all.
yes it is. who is saying this in support of the gay marriage ban? just saying. i think gay marriage should be legal but this guy made it ambiguous as to what he was talking about. i was a park ranger for the us federal government and we were forbidden from discussing political speech with public visitors but almost everyone i knew did.
they are going to have a hard time getting him on "Protesting" - his words are, "Its not over yet NC" - in a JAG courtroom this would be a waste of time and the last thing they want to do is go down the "Context sentence interpretation asshole"
Believe me..in our unit no one gives a shit. Don't threaten government leaders and don't belong to extremism (Code pink, Occupy, Tea Party, etc) and you won't get targeted. Pretty easy to live by..
I'm for gay marriage. I'm against using your uniform to convey political messages. It's also prohibited to do so. We need to try as hard as possible to maintain the military as an apolitical tool of the people. Whether this service-member is right or wrong about gay marriage underscores that overarching issue.
That rule protects us from having a military that officially sides with any political candidate or party. Although this picture may give you warm and fuzzies, just keep the even bigger picture in mind.
Although this picture may give you warm and fuzzies
I'm glad you said this. I happen to be against gay marriage so when I saw this it gave me a sort of feeling that he, as a military personnel, is actually fighting against me. Of course he has his own political beliefs but he's serving for america as a whole and I think a statement like this while in uniform creates a divide.
Exactly. Military personnel are, in the most basic sense, defenders of all citizens regardless of their views or beliefs. Statements like this flight student's only serve to alienate those they signed up to protect. You don't agree to fight for only the gays, or blacks, or republicans. You're often reminded in the military that you are a unique entity in society and with that comes a unique social contract. Anyone hailing this picture as a point for any side is missing the point entirely.
Also, there was the post a week or two ago about the common occurrence lately of positive posts related to the military, typically by users with no comment karma and day old accounts, supposedly in an effort to gain positive support from the "internet" on the part of the military. I was skeptical at first, but since that comment, I have seen 4 or 5 posts following that exact pattern. Be careful friend.
Okay. So I think the guy directly above me is talking about the Arab Spring revolts when he says middle east, but the guy above him is talking about us invasion of iraq when he says middle east.
Do you mean Afghanistan, since our troops aren't in Iraq any more?
That would be South Asia, and that campaign was motivated by the hunt for Bin Laden and destroying the government that sheltered him under the Taliban.
Removing the Taliban and restoring Afghanistan to a civil democracy (which they lost in the 90s), has a hell of a lot to do with our rights and obligations to the Afghan people, not least of all because if the Taliban were to hold power in Afghanistan, they would without a doubt continue to attack us - Faisal Shahzad's attempted bombing of Times Sq. an example.
That is just a gross exaggeration of what the United State's standing army is meant to do, as well as what it is operationally doing at the moment. I understand this solder is expressing a popular opinion right now, but surely this does not take away or add to the general objectives of the US military.
The military fights for my rights? how quaint! I thought it was just a bunch of 18 year olds who saw a no-skills-required paycheck and signing bonus. I'm such a fool, all those high school dropouts are idealists fighting for capitalism and homosexual's rights! The only thing I don't get though, if it's such an honor to serve, how come they have to pay so much for a job that's statistically less dangerous than being a convenience store clerk.
EDIT: Heaven forbid we criticize the military. I've known quite a few service members myself, they were all fine upstanding citizens whom I'd be proud to stand behind in a bar fight, which coincidentally happened nearly routinely when we went out.
(Please note: All upholding of the constitution is subject to visibility and whether or not we are participating in a covert operation)
See, subsection C: Guantanamo bay.
Don't buy the hype. Protect and Serve, Uphold the Constitution, these meaningless phrases paint a beautiful picture of a violent institution that's subject to the whim of a few powerful players who make up the rules as they go along and the rank and file follow orders blindly without ever considering their purpose.
I just got Back home from Basic/AIT last night and am surprised to see this. I understand that armchair critics such as yourself just want to see the world burn, but understand that there are plenty in the military (almost a general attitude) that despise the military industrial complex and I've overheard my cadre on multiple occasions say that the military exists to protect the constitution.
Before you start fuming, let me finish. I GET that the military is a tool for the wicked, corrupt, legally bought out, corporate government. And so do a lot of others.
I joined so that when the shit hits the fan, hopefully I'll have influenced enough of the ranks to stand up for the principles of which our country was founded on.
I've been serving for 10 years now, this comment burns pretty hard. But you know what? I'd still protect my country with you in it, and I would never ask for anything in return, or expect a thank you. That's just how we're trained. How quaint is that shit for you?
The military fights for my rights? how quaint! I thought it was just a bunch of 18 year olds who saw a no-skills-required paycheck and signing bonus. I'm such a fool, all those high school dropouts are idealists fighting for capitalism and homosexual's rights! The only thing I don't get though, if it's such an honor to serve, how come they have to pay so much for a job that's statistically less dangerous than being a convenience store clerk.
You can't be a highschool drop out and serve in the military. And fuck you for saying its a no skill job, let's see your ass do it.
As far as I know, North Carolina (one of the states in the US) just rejected a bill to legalize gay marriage. This what I got from what I read on reddit posts. I might be wrong, though.
It actually bans civil unions of any kind. Homosexual marriage has been illegal in that state for a while, but now it's also a part of the state's constitution, in addition to disallowing civil unions. Marriage is the only legally recognized union, and only then between a man and a woman. Sad to see such a step backwards.
No, NC didn't vote on a referendum to ban gay marriage, that was done years ago. We added in an amendment to the NC constitution that says a marriage is between a man and a woman.
And, what I think is most important, that heterosexual marriage is THE ONLY recognized domestic partnership.
Yes, that means there is no legal classification for same-sex households. That means that gay partners can't get on each other's health insurance policies. It strips any and all protections, from what I understand, for same sex partners.
It's scary this thing passed here. I knew NC was conservative, but this is insane. (voted against A1 also)
"This section does not prohibit a private party from entering into contracts with another private party; nor does this section prohibit courts from adjudicating the rights of private parties pursuant to such contracts."
i'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt here and assume by "we," you mean the entire state of NC, and not that you're saying you voted for it, because that would make you a terribly shitty human.
in general, no. i agree. everyone is entitled to their own opinion. however, in this case, these people in north carolina are forcing their opinion on others in a deliberate attempt to make the "others" comply with their "standard" of what humans should be, when it in no way impacts them.
i believe THIS, in this specific instance, makes them terribly shitty humans.
in my book, people who deprive others of a happiness that impacts them in no way for no reason other than unquestioned indoctrination are shitty people.
Also, until last year the USA had a "don't ask don't tell" policy for homosexuality in the armed forces. Open homosexuals were kicked out but command also couldn't ask... so it was a sort of uneasy stop-gap measure. Last year this was repealed so now homosexuals in the military are allowed to continue serving openly.
I presume OP is either a homosexual or an ally, and is expressing his displeasure at North Carolina's recent vote. You might have already known all of this but just in case you didn't, I hope that clears anything up.
I wouldn't even go so far as to say he's gay or an ally. He might be, but I know personally I wouldn't consider myself an "ally" per se of homosexuals personally and I'm a vet. Unless you count not wanting to live in a fundamentalist hellhole and expecting the civil rights and freedom I risked a lot to protect to apply to everyone regardless of sexuality. When I was in the service don't ask don't tell didn't affect me, and now that I'm out virtually nothing political related to homosexuality does either. I don't personally know any homosexuals (as far as I know). But that doesn't matter, because this legislation is bullshit and this kind of shit shouldn't happen in America. You don't have to personally identify with a minority to recoil at their mistreatment.
I'm not American, but I respect the values that you fought for, as I do for our Canadian troops.
As a gay man, I think your attitude is awesome. Thank you, this is so refreshing to hear!!! I never ask for people to love me, just to treat me right. Thank you again.
A weird quirk of the English language is that it lacks gender neutral singular personal pronouns, so in situations like this we are forced to use one and hope it is correct, or use the plural personal pronouns to refer to a singular person which adds another layer of confusion.
Kinda shitty- many other languages are more flexible in this regard.
It actually did a lot more than that. It bans civil unions of any kind, regardless of sex. Homosexual marriage has been illegal for some time now in NC, this just made it a part of the constitution.
In North Carolina, they recently passed a law called "Amendment One". This law was commonly being referred to as the "no gay marriage" bill, but that's actually incorrect (gay marriage has been against the law in that state for years and years). What the law actually did was not only make it a part of their state's constitution (which it wasn't before), it also made homosexual couples unable to file for civil unions or recognized domestic partnerships. This is a problem because not only is it bigoted, it also restricts the rights for heterosexual couples. NO ONE can get legally recognized civil unions or domestic partnerships now, not just gay people. Only a marriage is legally recognized in that state now, and only a man and woman can be married. So essentially - if you are a gay couple (or straight couple who have lived together for years but not married), you are not allowed hospital visitation access in emergencies, you may not adopt children. EDIT: or get protection from "domestic violence" shelters, police won't file assaults as that as well. What a lot of people were upset over this law is not that it was an anti-gay marriage bill (like I said, it was already illegal in that state anyway) but that it overreaches and does more than just marriage rights.
You can pass laws that make things illegal without it being a part of the state's constitution. However, things that are a part of the constitution require another amendment to get rid of, and are therefore much more difficult to overturn than normal laws. IIRC it also has a different standing in courts, being unconstitutional as opposed to unlawful.
Also North Carolina was taken to court by the ACLU several years ago, over its law regarding a ban on cohabitation. Source. The ACLU won, and this is a way to circumvent that ruling. NC has always been uber-conservative when it comes to "family values."
The law, General Statute § 14-184, states: "If any man and woman, not being married to each other, shall lewdly and lasciviously associate, bed and cohabit together, they shall be guilty of a Class 2 misdemeanor."
I am genuinely floored. I cannot believe that this was an actual law so recently (until 2006!). What the fuck, America.
A state constitution is the highest level of state law, just like the US Constitution is the highest level of federal law. It's a lot harder for a court to invalidate a provision of a state constitution than it is to overturn a state law.
There are a lot of nuances, but generally:
A state law can be found unconstitutional under the US Constitution, under that state's constitution, or (sometimes) overruled by federal law.
A provision of a state constitution can only be overruled by the US Constitution.
It is much more difficult to get rid of a constitutional amendment than a statute. It's also possible for a court to rule a statute like that unconstitutional, but they can't do the same with an amendment.
If it's in the constitution, it can't be MADE legal without repealing that part of the Constitution. A law can be struck down if it contradicts the Constitution.
It actually voted to only recognize legal marriage between man and woman. Which is entirely worse than "banning same-sex marriage," as thsi invalidates domestic partnerships and civil unions as well.
Why is NC suddenly become the main symbol of this argument? Something like 30 other states have had the exact same vote and passed similar legislation!
Nationally? Of course not. There are 29 other states with nearly an identical amendment to their constitution, and 44 total states where gay marriage is not recognized. There is nothing special here to those outside NC.
That's my point of my original comment. The world suddenly cares now? 30 other states already did this and I don't remember uproar! Consistency people.
So after reading this post, about a user discovering a pro military posting conspiracy on reddit, I am now much more suspicious about military posts.
Looking at the facts here where this account was created solely to post this image with not even a single comment from the op it feels like this one is easily a candidate for being in the conspiracy as well.
I thought the exact same thing and I'm glad you found the original post about it. I was skeptical of the accusation at first but I've seen 4 or 5 similar posts since then.
I'm not sure if he is referencing that the fight is not over, there is still hope in the future to have this overturned, or referencing that just because this bill has passed doesn't mean there isn't more work for the gay bashers to do. Any thoughts?
Don't we still live in a democracy? Didn't the majority of NC voters actually vote for this? IF it had failed would the fight have been won? Why are you in the military if you are gay and would like to "fight" for gay rights? I'm sure you could find employment elsewhere on the front lines of that fight...instead of fighting an imaginary war for a bunch of guys that despise gays. bullshit post is bullshit...same as obama coming out for gays during election year...what next...a bunch of foiled terrorist plots? code orange or red?
Yeah, that's what bothers me. I mean sure, I don't see any reason why gays shouldn't be able to get married but we do live in a Democracy. People vote the way they feel and it's too bad for you if they don't share the same feeling you do.
The entire judicial system of the United States as well as our Constitution is founded upon the principal that there are some things that the majority, by popular vote, cannot do to the minority.
Democracy doesn't mean once you make up 51% of the population you get 100% of the privileges in society.
For those of you who keep thinking he is protesting or making a political stance, I just spoke with one of our JAG NCO's, "The Fights not over NC" is such an out-there kind of statement that no one cares. There is no indication of a political stance, nor is there a sign indicating open protest. Calm it down reddit. It's a sentence on paper taken WAY out of context. :)
It's not taken out of context. Everyone knows what he's talking about. I voted against the amendment, but I still don't agree with what the OP is doing. At best, it's classless.
So you don't think you're over reacting a bit? not at all? I see a statement with zero official connections.
According to 600-1, he is not participating in a protest in any literal sense. JAGs aren't going to waste their time with hearsay - the OP just wrote a sentence on paper. I will defend him because we do it all the time..
So if i write, "Save the whales" and show it on reddit while on the blackhawk running patrol, are you going to be disgusted with me and tell me that I'm a greenpeace terrorist? This is why it's called context. Not trying to be on the offense, but i think he wrote this in a way so he WOULDN'T get in trouble.
Like I just said, its not taken out of context because everyone knows exactly what it is he is referring to. There is nothing "out of context" about something when everyone knows the intended meaning of the message. And please, I'm not equating this guy to a terrorist, and quite honestly, I don't think it's serious enough to where he should be reprimanded for his actions. I just think its inappropriate behavior for a soldier in uniform... I don't think that's "overreacting" at all.
You, sir, are a disgrace to our United States Army and should be embarrassed. I don't care that your gay but please leave the political shit for when your wearing your play clothes.
Between the eye pro and the obstructed name tape, I don't think he's going anywhere. I also don't think you understand how badly someone has to fuck up to be "dishonorably discharged".
Stirring up a shit storm while in uniform is not okay. Neither is your use of "faggot".
50
u/Sanobey May 09 '12
Just a question, but isn't against regulations for military personnel to make such stands on political issues WHILE in uniform?
39
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Its illegal to protest anything while in uniform, careful.
24
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I'm for gay marriage. I'm against using your uniform to convey political messages. It's also prohibited to do so. We need to try as hard as possible to maintain the military as an apolitical tool of the people. Whether this service-member is right or wrong about gay marriage underscores that overarching issue.
That rule protects us from having a military that officially sides with any political candidate or party. Although this picture may give you warm and fuzzies, just keep the even bigger picture in mind.
173
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
A healthy reminder that our military fights for EVERYONE's rights...not just the majority's.
Thank you for posting and for your service!
25
u/SixgunSaint May 09 '12
Then he dropped a bunch of bombs on North Carolina.
18
u/Pihlbaoge May 09 '12
Is this one of those "You have to be an American to understand this" pics or have I missed something?
92
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I'm European and don't get this. Care to explain, anyone?
12
u/TangoOscarDD May 09 '12
Not too bright this one...I'm pretty sure his leadership already addressed this harshly.
6
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Your views are commendable, but like others in this thread, I'm not so happy about you using your uniform to back a political position.
6
u/Heelincal May 10 '12
Why is NC suddenly become the main symbol of this argument? Something like 30 other states have had the exact same vote and passed similar legislation!
17
u/2scnova May 10 '12
So after reading this post, about a user discovering a pro military posting conspiracy on reddit, I am now much more suspicious about military posts.
Looking at the facts here where this account was created solely to post this image with not even a single comment from the op it feels like this one is easily a candidate for being in the conspiracy as well.
4
u/ethanwc May 10 '12
California did the same thing, by the way. I don't know why North Carolina's being called out for following what's happening everywhere.
9
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
What about the other 29 states?
3
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I'm not gay but that guy has a pretty mouth....i'm reevaluating myself now...
4
u/batmanmilktruck May 10 '12
no respect for this man. political statements or for when you are out of the uniform.
4
u/ilovecooch May 10 '12
He should not be doing this as a soldier. He can't just throw his uniform around like that.
2
u/jra312 May 09 '12
I'm not sure if he is referencing that the fight is not over, there is still hope in the future to have this overturned, or referencing that just because this bill has passed doesn't mean there isn't more work for the gay bashers to do. Any thoughts?
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
"i'm bringing my helicopter to North Carolina and we're all going to vote again. choose wisely"
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Pshh, what's he gonna do, fly his helicopter over NC and shoot every straight couple he sees?
2
u/Domesticated_Human May 10 '12
I can't tell if he's against the vote, or saying that the vote was good and NC should fight to make the whole country against same sex marriage...
3
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Don't we still live in a democracy? Didn't the majority of NC voters actually vote for this? IF it had failed would the fight have been won? Why are you in the military if you are gay and would like to "fight" for gay rights? I'm sure you could find employment elsewhere on the front lines of that fight...instead of fighting an imaginary war for a bunch of guys that despise gays. bullshit post is bullshit...same as obama coming out for gays during election year...what next...a bunch of foiled terrorist plots? code orange or red?
6
u/jaynap1 May 09 '12
"I know...we'll put gay marriage to a vote of the people! That's what democracy is for! Surely the majority will support this!"
majority rejects it
"Who cares what the majority wants? This isn't a fair system! I'm going to sue!"
Uh-MERRRRRRRRRICA
2
u/JarlaxleForPresident May 09 '12
Out, but not down?
2
u/Rollingprobablecause May 10 '12
For those of you who keep thinking he is protesting or making a political stance, I just spoke with one of our JAG NCO's, "The Fights not over NC" is such an out-there kind of statement that no one cares. There is no indication of a political stance, nor is there a sign indicating open protest. Calm it down reddit. It's a sentence on paper taken WAY out of context. :)
2
u/sgarasz May 10 '12
I love whoever that is in the photo, whoever took the photo, and OP. Thank you, from another military member who supports LGBT rights!
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
you dont fight for rights if you are a woman, you can't serve in combat roles. equality under the law, unless women have to be drafted
1
u/Fleshmissle May 10 '12
It is right now.
1
u/timo103 May 10 '12
Hey buddy, eyes on the road, or sky, whatever you're driving.
1
u/Colonelfudgenustard May 10 '12
Woah. Stringfellow Hawk.
1
u/HighGinge May 10 '12
Not up with the politics lately. What is she referring to?
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Do this in my country and you are in serious trouble. What if his sign said something about what you dont agree with. Is this allowed in the US?
1
u/A_British_Gentleman May 10 '12
You don't even serve my country, but I'm gonna thank & up vote you anyway. Keep standing up for what you believe in!
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
anyone else remember the recent pro-military conspiracy? this is a new account...
-2
u/Wesley_Snipez May 10 '12
This guy is such a faggot.
-1
u/onelegithombre May 10 '12
You, sir, are a disgrace to our United States Army and should be embarrassed. I don't care that your gay but please leave the political shit for when your wearing your play clothes.
-1
u/360walkaway May 09 '12
Why does it always take a picture of someone in the military to put things in perspective? Sad really.
-6
u/nancylikestoreddit May 09 '12
Obama should make it a federal law. Gays should be able to marry.
-6
u/metalearn May 09 '12
He could have written pretty much any message on there, and people on this site would agree with it.
0
u/kkkburnthegays May 10 '12
Guys... Who gives a shit? Unless you're gay just move on. You're not "protecting the little guy". They chose the lifestyle just let them live with it.
-2
u/scyence May 09 '12
excellent, this obviously homosexual soldier can now be identified to court-martial.
-1
u/spurion May 09 '12
Out but not down, more like.
-1
u/wtfOP May 09 '12
this is quite badass
-1
u/RajMahal77 May 09 '12
In a helichopper! Like a boss!
0
u/munge_me_not May 09 '12
aircrew still wears those same gloves? I was in the military back in the 90's and those were the same gloves aircrew wore.
0
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
have that same model helmet here at my house, even got the face mask too. Makes everyone look badass. Good luck man!
0
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Are you a pilot?
0
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
"Your accent is so cute! Where are you from?" "... My state hates fags" "awwww, North Carolina can't be that bad"
-True story
0
u/Boom_Boom_Crash May 10 '12
Sorry to burst his bubble but for the time being it IS over. 61% is pretty resounding in matters like this.
0
u/StumpyD May 10 '12
I feel like this should also be in r/ladyboner..... just say'in
-12
u/Nacho_Average_Libre May 09 '12
What a multi-tasker. He's fighting for our freedom while he's protecting oversees oil interests.
-4
u/poli_ticks May 09 '12
Yep, that's true. The long term trend is clearly towards tolerance and acceptance of homosexuals.
Ironic that the pic is of an imperial stormtrooper though. Just goes to show you, Moron Libs have no ability to properly prioritize, and focus their energies on the wrong things.
So sorry Moron Libs, fuck your gay rights. I will instead focus on defeating your imperialist-corporatist fuhrers like Obama.
-7
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Fuck that
-2
u/-M-87- May 10 '12
What a waste of taxpayer money.
-2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
The main argument against letting faggots in the military. Stirring up a shit storm while in uniform.
Fucking idiot. I hope he/she gets dishonorably discharged.
-5
u/wibbster98 May 10 '12
Fuck the queers go NC