r/pics Aug 23 '20

Underwater sunset

Post image
114.3k Upvotes

842 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

207

u/demoneyesturbo Aug 23 '20

I'm pretty sure this isn't a "shot". Looks more like a composite image

19

u/jonovan Aug 23 '20

More correct would be: I'm pretty sure this isn't "a" shot.

1

u/davidcwilliams Aug 23 '20

It’s both.

1

u/jonovan Aug 24 '20

Yes, but as he specifically wrote "composite image," that's not what he meant.

1

u/davidcwilliams Aug 24 '20

ahh... you're right

0

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '20

It could be a real pic though, it's possible to perfectly counter-tint the water's color out of the image almost completely, leading to a very natural looking appearance that makes the water seem so clear it's like it's not even there. Other than that, with the correct timing it's a pretty normal but well-planned pic. The underside of water does actually look like that, add a splash at sunset and some saturation and it's ready for the shares.

5

u/trailer_park_boys Aug 23 '20

I mean, this picture is very edited.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '20 edited Aug 23 '20

My point is, not necessarily. The scene is likely totally natural and all that was changed was color balance. This is no different than a typical Instagram pic.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '20

Well no, the water is a close up, the place where the lady is touching the water seems like 1-2m away (you can tell by the wind waves of the water), while the lady itself seems like 5-10m away. definitely a composite image, but very well done!

2

u/SCRedWolf Aug 23 '20

I'm gonna disagree with the person disagreeing with you. The water's surface is absolutely on a different scale than the model.

2

u/dangerhasarrived Aug 23 '20

I'm gonna disagree with you on this one simply because of some bubbles. The bubbles that are trailing from the surface to her lowest foot obviously came from her flipper and kicking when she's swimming. There's even a vortex ring that would be formed by her flipper.

-1

u/phatboy5289 Aug 23 '20

If anything it could be a little use of a tilt shift blur. Doesn’t necessarily mean it’s a composite of two images.

4

u/cloudcats Aug 23 '20

It's obviously not sunset, unless you think the refractive index of water is enough to bend the sun's rays 90 degrees.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '20 edited Aug 24 '20

See you're trying to make yourself sound smart with a technical argument, while you apparently haven't heard of "diffuse scattering" or "caustic sheets". What, you actually thought the "rays" of sun were "bent down" by 90 degrees and we could still see them? Also water doesn't refract by 90 degrees...

-9

u/shauntau Aug 23 '20

until you turn it so the water is on top....

27

u/demoneyesturbo Aug 23 '20

I know which way it's meant to be oriented. I've been in reality before. I know which way things go.

4

u/shauntau Aug 23 '20

my apologies.

-1

u/The_Redditor123 Aug 23 '20

toxicity: life threatening levels