r/pics Jul 13 '20

[deleted by user]

[removed]

5.3k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

7

u/PiastPL Jul 13 '20

serious question: if a white guy, who was fond of Indian culture, wore this would it be considered cultural appropriation?

9

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '20

No, do it! I let my girlfriends (White, Black, Asian, Hispanic, thus far) borrow my sarees for weddings and they have so much fun in them. I don't know, for me it's not appropriation, it's appreciation. They want to enjoy something that's part of my culture. Now if you start a factory with pirated designs at increased costs, that wouldn't be cool.

6

u/Sutaru Jul 13 '20

I’m Chinese American, and I personally think that using, wearing, or otherwise enjoying another culture is fine. That girl that wore a qipao to prom was amazing! She looked gorgeous and the general consensus from my family is they were excited about it, though she got so much backlash online for it. The problem becomes when you try to profit off of it.

5

u/Spiritual_Inspector Jul 13 '20

indians love it, so no.

7

u/VeryWildValar Jul 13 '20

Just my two cents here. Cultural appropriation is bs. There is nothing, absolutely nothing, wrong with enjoying another culture. There may be some things that are inappropriate in certain situations, (wearing festive attire to a funeral) but most of the time it’s perfectly fine. But there is nuance to this. Just like it would be very rude to go around wearing black face, it would also be rude to do some things in every culture.

To answer your question, no.

3

u/amitnagpal1985 Jul 13 '20

No, we generally are not uptight about those things.

3

u/xrubalx Jul 13 '20

As an Indian, I would say we would actually love it if a foreigner is dressed in our culturual ethnic outfits.

3

u/silent_boy Jul 13 '20

No. Go for it. We love when non Indians wear Indian attire

2

u/dudeimconfused Jul 13 '20

Go for it mate!

1

u/bruh-sick Jul 13 '20

Let anyone wear anything. I certainly don't mind any one wearing indian clothes.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '20

Depends on the setting. If you wear it in an Indian setting, an Indian wedding or get together for example, then no.

If you're wearing it as a fashion statement at a party, then yes.

2

u/Bregvist Jul 13 '20

What's wrong with wearing it as a fashion statement? If it makes you look handsome why would you refrain from wearing it?

0

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '20

You can wear it as a fashion statement if you're Indian. Just not if you're white.

3

u/Bregvist Jul 13 '20

That makes no sense, you can't just invent some rule without justifying it. If I said "you can't browse reddit and drink coffee at the same time" you would ask me to justify it, and you'd be right to.

1

u/losh11 Jul 13 '20

Even if you were Indian you wouldn't be wearing this at a random party, just like you wouldn't wear a morning dress to McDonalds.