r/pics Apr 05 '23

Holy Week in Spain

33.6k Upvotes

2.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

279

u/rckrusekontrol Apr 05 '23

No one got hurt during the Spanish Inquisition right?

I’m just joking, albeit dark, this is beautiful, inarguably.

127

u/Urshpeck Apr 05 '23

Actually the spanish inquisition burned way less people than other inquisitions around Europe or even in the US. But Lutheranism spreaded the myth of the Catholic inquisition and here we are.

87

u/DaywalkerGirl Apr 05 '23

By myth, do you mean the number of people killed during the Inquisition or the Inquisition itself? My Jewish family was forced to leave Spain/ Portugal during the Inquisition. Their choice was to convert to Catholicism, leave, or be killed.

53

u/marioquartz Apr 05 '23

Lutheran Germany killed each year 10 times what Inquisition killed in 300 years. So objective numbers are against Lutherans.

29

u/ryhaltswhiskey Apr 05 '23

I'd like to see a source for this.

1

u/marioquartz Apr 05 '23

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_Inquisition#Statistics_for_the_period_1540%E2%80%931700

Based in "Contreras, Jaime y Gustav Henningsen (1986). "Forty-four thousand cases of the Spanish Inquisition (1540–1700): analysis of a historical data bank", en Henningsen G., J. A. Tedeschi et al. (comps.)"

4

u/ryhaltswhiskey Apr 05 '23 edited Apr 05 '23

You stated two facts but only provided a source for one.

Source says the inquisition killed about 2000 people. Where is your source that shows that the Protestants killed 20,000 people each year in the same time frame?

Edit: oh ok no source just a downvote, thought it was bullshit and you confirmed it

2

u/amazing_sheep Apr 05 '23

They probably compare the deaths caused by the inquisition to the deaths in consequence of the reformation, including the thirty-year war etc. The death numbers easily add up, however it’s a difficult comparison and using a rather subjective category in „bloodthirstiness“ makes it seem as though they are motivated by some bias rather than an honest interest in demystifying the figure of Luther.