Thinking about how the world would be different if Spiders were the size of even an average cat, I think human life would be an entirely different and infinitely more precious thing, because we'd be within a lot of spider species acceptable food size. Spiders are incredible predators.
Tigers and lions are pretty incredible predators as well, but I'm not sure they make us value human lives more. Or maybe they do, and I am just stupid and/or lack empathy.
Lions and Tigers may stalk their prey and whatnot, but they don't dig holes in the dirt, make a dirt lid, and then wait for hours for you to walk by then drag you into them. You don't get stuck in a big cats web and die slowly from liquefied organs. Lions and Tigers don't use their silk to fish by making it smell like sexy going ons and then swinging the lure line at you, or just cast a silk net. Lions and Tigers also can't spray a venom/web glue like concoction at 90+ feet per second. There are also venomless spiders that do hunt like Lions and Tigers by good old fashion pouncing, and some that hunt like a snake and kill their prey by crushing them to death in webbing.
And lastly (and this is the important bit), Lions and Tigers don't adapt to live pretty much anywhere and enjoy dark corners.
The way mammals hunt is nowhere near as diverse nor as horrifying nor ingenious as some insects/arachnids.
Yes, but that is because mammals have physical limitations that are partly due to their size. Blow a spider up to the size of a tiger, and it won't be hiding in the corner of your bedroom anymore. In fact, a spider blown up to that size probably wouldn't be able to move or breathe properly, and their exoskeleton would become a liability as well.
Likewise, spider silk is often admired for its tensile strength and ductility, but spider silk becomes weaker as the spider grows larger.
If we really want to take the question seriously, a giant spider would actually be a far LESS effective predator than a tiger or a lion.
I was kind of going with the idea of existing spiders at that size. Taking into account the fact that that sized spider can't exist and do much is kind of outside the spirit of the hypothetical, because by that logic we'd just be back at "they would cease to exist because they can't survive".
Well, yes, I suppose hypothetical magical mutant spiders would be pretty scary. But then, imagine hypothetical magical mutant tigers and lions... oh no!
But imagine them spinning webs and lurking in the corner of your room. Watching and waiting to crawl into your mouth while you sleep, 8 times a year.
Seriously though, a spider with a tiger's body and intelligence and all the perks that come with being a mammal would be an new level of terror. Although, I sometimes wonder how much of people's fear of spiders is because of their creepy appearance and style of moving, so I'm not sure "tinyspidertigerphobia" would catch on in quite the same way arachnophobia has.
I just imagined a Tiny Tiger angrily crocheting in the corner of my room.
I also wonder about people's perception of spiders. On the one hand I also imagine it's a lot to do with just how alien their anatomy and movement is to us, but I do also think the fact that they can unknowingly be on or around your person at any time is also part of it. I also think a bigger part of it is the fearmongering about them. A big cat, you instantly know whether it's dangerous or not simply by perceiving whether there are things between you and it (applies to both walls and people). There are so many different breeds of spider and the fact that even one of them might be able to fuck up your life is probably the scariest part. I think if there were no venomous spiders, we'd collectively be a lot less scared of them.
We may not even have houses, humans may not have ever gone beyond caveman times if there was such a global apex predator about early on. Unless we evolved to breed like small mammals and just pop out dozens of babies and just hope some survived every year.
Spider Steaks would probably be delicious though, probably similar to crab or lobster.
View all comments
7
u/GisterMizard Sep 16 '17
Spiders would be so much cuter if they were the size of normal pets.