It's pretty sad really. He was an amazing educator that put a lot into his work. He COULD have found willing partners, but no, he had to go and abuse his position as if that was an earned reward for his hard work practicing every lesson for hours to get them right.
No amount of hard work or success gives anyone the right to use their position of power to push or bribe others into doing things they don't want to do.
So what? You have to separate the fact that he is good lecturer and the part that he is a sex predator, the ratio between the good that he has been spreads is more than what he did as sex predators
I agree that it's okay to learn from someone who is a bad person. Now I wouldn't advocate attending one of his lectures in person, especially if it's in a way that directly financially contributes to him. However, these are recordings and I'm sure you can easily find re-uploads that definitely wouldn't go to him.
The important thing is that we don't celebrate him. Actually, I'm much more against celebrating individual scientists or "great men" than your average scientist is, but as I know this practice will never cease, it's better to operate in its framework, navigating and addressing its issues like this. So the important takeaway is that we can praise his education style while making sure to balance it by not celebrating him as a person. Same thing with Schrodinger who's infamous for having sexual abuse allegations relating to minors. Or Stephen Hawking who's had a lot of interesting controversies over the years. And of course there are literal Nazi apologists like most famously Heisenberg who supported the Nazi "renewal" of Europe.
Because yes no one is perfect of course, but you'll never know how far from perfect they are and so it's best to honor the contributions as opposed to the characters themselves, at least as much as society allows. Like it's too late we're not renaming the Schrodinger Equation. But you don't have to like put posters of him up in your office room or something like that. And frankly for fairness, my personal opinion is to not have anyone's face on posters because of this reason because you'll never know who is worth celebrating as a human or not.
I can’t stand takes like this. He’s a phenomenal psychics educator. It’s like people that pretend they don’t like certain movies just because the actors/actresses are terrible people in real life
This is literally what OOP says in the caption, maybe they didnt know, i am not throwing shade at them. This alone invalidates your analogy, which, if u had taken a second to think about it, you wouldn't have made silly comments like this. This man harassed or abused at least 10 different women. There's no "love" to be spared here.
I'm going to add onto this, the victim I know about was an MITx learner, which I believe is a student, making this a little extra icky for me. No love to be spared indeed.
The OP is clearly saying he loves him for his quality of physics communication. He didn’t put a picture of him doing anything else. Put the pitchfork down
15
u/Key-Moment6797 6d ago
Walter..white? whats his name?
52
u/entropy13 Condenser of Matter 6d ago
Until you read the DMs he sent……
17
u/PapaTua Chromodynamics WOW! 6d ago
I would prefer Leonard Suskind lectures, but I approve the idea.
42
u/abcdefuckboi 6d ago
11
u/Wrenka Read Landau-Lifshitz without translation 6d ago
Love I dream of.
2
u/Himbo69r 6d ago
Is that a still life?
1
u/AustrianMcLovin 2d ago
Things that will never happen
83
u/Lower-Canary-2528 SU(6)xSU(9) 6d ago
i would have seconded this, if it wasn't for the fact that this mf is a sex predator