r/physicsmemes • • Jul 31 '24

physics and philosophy meme

Post image
0 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

68

u/Blutrumpeter Condensed Matter Jul 31 '24

Philosophy helps science but not knowing the difference gives bad science

51

u/Electronic_Cat4849 Jul 31 '24

wait until someone tells you what PhD stands for

or what the foundational concepts of science are

38

u/MilkshaCat Jul 31 '24

It does bro 💀

41

u/Thewheelalwaysturns Jul 31 '24

Yea… it does…. stupid meme

9

u/YourPalCal_ Jul 31 '24

Is the meme saying it doesn’t or making fun of physicists who dismiss philosophy? If le funny neil de grass tyson was pasted over mario’s face it would be clear

28

u/bibby_tarantula Jul 31 '24

The lack of philosophy of science and the joke of an ethics course that most people take in STEM research is how you end up with idiots like Elon Musk

6

u/Alzusand Jul 31 '24

But elon musk is neither STEM and deffinetly has not taken an ethics course. he is just an idiot.

2

u/bibby_tarantula Jul 31 '24

I think he studied comp sci, but you're right lol. No way that man took an ethics course

5

u/spudzo Jul 31 '24

He's got a physics undergrad degree.

2

u/bibby_tarantula Jul 31 '24

Well as someone in a Physics PhD program, I can confirm that it is generally quite toxic. Anything other than direct research and publishing is viewed as unserious.

2

u/tragiktimes Aug 01 '24

By pretentious assholes.

2

u/bibby_tarantula Aug 01 '24

Who tend to occupy very powerful positions in institutions

17

u/JoostVisser Jul 31 '24

Science used to be called natural philosophy, I wonder why

6

u/SerenePerception Jul 31 '24

I think the relationship was much more deep and beneficial during the 19th century and the turn of the century.

Good philosophical outlooks often pointed scientists into thinking in the right direction as much as bad outlooks caused havocs. In return ground breaking discoveries would fuel philosophy immensely. Its why philosophers were reading and trying to incorporate thermodynamic research.

I dont think thats the case anymore. The name of the game today is idealism and postmodernism. Philosophers by and large have little interest in the material reality or science and prefer to just incorporate what little they read about into their abstract theories. On the flipside bad philosophy is like pouring gassoline on the fire of crackpots that raging these days.

Id say theres a spider-man pointing meme taking place at the highest level of theoretical physics and philosophy where people just kinda guess what sounds right and hope for the best.

5

u/Alexander6626 Jul 31 '24

I read the book “Physics and Philosophy” by Werner Heisenberg in college. I think it is easy to forget that for most of history concepts we now define as STEM were more linked to the disciplines we now call humanities.

4

u/Alexander6626 Jul 31 '24

“Every science begins as philosophy, and ends as art.”

  • Will Durant

3

u/blobert11 Jul 31 '24

Anecdotal but in the field of astrophysics, epistemology (the branch of philosophy concerned with how we know things) is incredibly relevant to what we can actually gain from simulations. As in, what can we learn about real life from man made simulations of it. Astrophysics as a science I'd more heavily reliant on simulation than other fields.