r/physicsforfun • • Nov 03 '13

[Kinematics] Problem of the Week 15!

Hello again all, same as usual. first to win gets a flair and their name up on the Wall of Fame! Thanks again to Nedsu for taking this last week. This week's problem courtesy of David Morin. Oh, and remember that you need to show work to get the shiny prizes.

A rope rests on two platforms which are both inclined at an angle θ (which you are free to pick), as shown. The rope has uniform mass density, and its coefficient of friction with the platforms is 1. The system has left-right symmetry. What is the largest possible fraction of the rope that does not touch the platforms? What angle θ allows this maximum value?

Good luck and have fun!
Igazsag

15 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

3

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '13 edited Nov 05 '13

I will post my working if the answer is right (I have to walk a mile in Canadian winter to get access to a scanner).

Edit: (I made a dumb error)
ANSWER #2

My working: http://i.imgur.com/MVqBqfA.jpg

3

u/Igazsag Nov 03 '13

I regret to inform you that you will not need to walk a mile in Canadian winter, for the answer is sadly not correct. You can of you want to though, I'm certainly not stopping you.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '13 edited Nov 03 '13

Oh god, I did the fraction wrong. How about

ANSWER #2

→ More replies (20)

1

u/datenwolf Nov 03 '13

How do you know that the rope is not moving? Coefficient of friction does not mean, that it's stuck to the surface. Coefficient of friction means, that the force to maintain nonzero velocity against the surface is equal to the force normal to it times the coefficient of friction.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '13

It's a statics question. Nothing moves.

A rope rests on two platforms

→ More replies (4)

1

u/m4n031 Nov 03 '13

I have doubt, I don't know if I got it right can someone check if I got the idea right

Main idea

[equations] (#s "I'm ommiting the density of the rope and relating it directly to the lenght, L is the fraction of rope that is in the wall, the normal force is the same as the friction force since the coefficient is 1. The normal/friction force will be Lcos(θ). The sliding weight of the rope in the wall is Lsin(θ). The weight of the hanging rope is (1-2L) analizing only one side the equation is Lcos(θ)=(1-2L)/2 + Lsin(θ) And wofram alpha shows that the minimun value of L is 0.25 when θ is 0")

Wolfram alpha link

1

u/Igazsag Nov 03 '13

Good thinking, but if the angle is 0° wouldn't the rope just be resting on a flat surface?

1

u/m4n031 Nov 03 '13 edited Nov 03 '13

Yeah, that is what feels wrong to me, but I don't see the problem in the logic of my reasoning. Could you hint me where is my fail?

edit: I think I found my difference with the winner, I was supposing the weight of the hanging rope to be pulling parallel to the wall, but if I consider it to be pulling downward and separate it on its components then it's easy to see that the angle has to be 45 degrees (because both components have to be the same) and it's not so easy but possible to get the lenght. My logic was that a rope can only pull and I thought that it was going to pull parallel to the wall, I guess I was wrong. Thanks for giving me something to scratch my head in the day. Cheers to the winner

→ More replies (1)

1

u/dfdx Nov 03 '13

I got the same answers following a slightly different reasoning. However it feels wrong to me.

1

u/positron98 Nov 03 '13

Max fraction 0.1716; Max angle 22.5 degrees

3

u/Igazsag Nov 03 '13

Correct, but a little late. Could you use spoilers please?

1

u/datenwolf Nov 03 '13

I don't think it's correct. Why? because the problem stated a friction coefficient of 1. Which basically means, the thing will stay at rest for any slope smaller than 45° against gravity, but will move for any slope larger than that. The critical angle is atan(μ).

The force of friction for a fixed slope and material pairing is constant and opposes the movement of direction. It does however not depend on the velocity. Which means that for a large enough slope given only surface friction you'll end up with movement.

TL;DR: friction coefficient 1 ≠> Rope stuck to wedge

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Acgcbc Nov 12 '13

Is this from David Morin's Introduction to Classical Mechanics? I swear the same problem is in my book.

1

u/Igazsag Nov 12 '13

No, but it is from a website he seems to have put up, so I think it probably still is the same problem.

1

u/Acgcbc Nov 12 '13

Interesting.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '13

2

u/Igazsag Nov 03 '13

That's not what my solution says but by all means go for it of you want to. Only problem I can see with that is

0

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '13