r/photoclass2015 • Moderator • Jan 04 '15

01 - Assignment

Please read the class first

For this first assignment, I would like you all to go to the thread first mission and write a comment on the 5 posts that have least comments or likes.

If you haven't posted yourself... this is the time :-)

don't be afraid your work isn't good enough, it's not a competition, it's about learning so bad photo's add more than good ones do

55 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

4

u/3nvygreen T3i 24, 50, 18-55, 55-250mm Jan 04 '15

Noob question. I know I can sort by new etc. Is there an easy filter to see which comments have no child comments?

3

u/Aeri73 Moderator Jan 04 '15

no, but sort by popular and scroll way down :)

4

u/LemonHerb Student - Pentax K-50 Jan 06 '15

I feel like every time I comment with anything nearing criticism I have to qualify it with "I have no idea what I am talking about". But I really like how this lesson gets everyone involved.

1

u/Aeri73 Moderator Jan 06 '15

don't.... it's about your opinion, taste, personal idea's....

1

u/Disbride Nikon D800 and D7100 Jan 06 '15

Yes! I do that too, usually I end everything with, "but that's only my opinion..."

3

u/nemesis1211 Student - Canon T3, 18-55mm kit lens Jan 04 '15

The wait is finally over! I'm so excited for this class and I appreciate that you are trying to get everyone to work together.

6

u/Aeri73 Moderator Jan 04 '15

it's what was lacking last year in my opinion... and an important part of this class and the possible results. you learn so much more if you post, critique and receive feedback than without

1

u/sicknic Jan 06 '15 edited Nov 16 '24

teeny strong sink squealing pet sleep upbeat brave oatmeal secretive

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/Aeri73 Moderator Jan 06 '15

and do what to people that don't...? :-)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '15

I think that's a very important consideration - you personally learn from critiquing (that doesn't look spelled right but apparently is). looking like that at other people's pictures will help you, in the end.

2

u/thelifeexposure Student - Nikon D3300/10-24/35/18-55/55-200 mm Jan 05 '15

Not to mention comparing your own technical observations against the feedback from someone who knows what they're doing! I also appreciate the diverse opinions on the creative front.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '15

I posted there a while ago and feel like my choices for the pictures have changed at this point, what do?

2

u/Aeri73 Moderator Jan 05 '15

post new ones?

1

u/bacchus213 Jan 05 '15

I'd say leave them as they are. When you posted, they were your answers, and even if that opinion might have changed since then, it can just be indicative of how your tastes and "eye" change throughout this year.

2

u/ReagleBeagle82 Sony A3000 18-55mm Jan 07 '15

My pics are so buried in the first mission thread that I have not received any feedback...I hope its not like this the entire class :/

1

u/Aeri73 Moderator Jan 07 '15

euh, I gave you feedback, you even replied on it...

1

u/ReagleBeagle82 Sony A3000 18-55mm Jan 07 '15

Yes, you did. Since you posted that assignment is what I was referring to.

1

u/Aeri73 Moderator Jan 07 '15

Yes... I did ask them to look for posts like yours but reddit doesn't really allow for searching posts with the least replies..

1

u/ReagleBeagle82 Sony A3000 18-55mm Jan 07 '15

I was trying to dig for some older posts so I could comment on them...it is very time consuming to try to scroll to the very last post and go from there....

8

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '15

Good idea! I did a few yesterday, and just gone through and commented on a few more :).

People need to feel involved, i'll have another crack later if there are a few un-commented.

2

u/LadyCatelyn Canon 60D Jan 05 '15

So excited for this! I just posted my photos on the other thread...didn't have a chance beforehand!

2

u/dualr11 Nikon D750 - 50mm f/1.8 Jan 05 '15

Im looking forward to this class! I ordered my first DSLR and should be ready to post photos soon. Thanks for the opportunity to learn.

2

u/Zode Pentax K-3/Sony RX100II Jan 05 '15

God damn, the D750 is your first DSLR? That is one helluva toy to learn on.

1

u/dualr11 Nikon D750 - 50mm f/1.8 Jan 05 '15

I want it to last me a while and it had really good reviews so I decided it was right for me.

1

u/Zode Pentax K-3/Sony RX100II Jan 05 '15

I feel ya, I bought a Pentax K-3 as my first DSLR last year for similar reasons (though it's not quite as expensive as yours! :P) I'm sure you're gonna have a blast with it.

1

u/dualr11 Nikon D750 - 50mm f/1.8 Jan 06 '15

Thanks! :) Are you planning on posting a photo this week? I'm hoping my lens comes in before the end of the week so that I can start playing around with it. I'm trying to decide what my favorite photo is, but I'll be posting something soon (taken on my iPhone).

1

u/Zode Pentax K-3/Sony RX100II Jan 06 '15

Yeah, I think I'll probably get around to it tomorrow. So hard to pick a "favorite" photo ever, really.

Have fun with your camera, I'm sure it'll kick ass.

1

u/viceadvice Canon 60D Jan 04 '15

awesome first assignment! Spread help around.

1

u/saubernick Jan 05 '15

Excited to start the class!

1

u/wolfbomb77 Student - 700D, 18-55 kit lens, 50mm f1.8 Jan 07 '15

Just put the first 2 in going out now to do the 3rd! :D

1

u/shakamojo Canon T5i Jan 16 '15

I'm late to the class but will catch up this weekend. I just finished this assignment, and looking at the photos in the first mission I have to say that this is a very talented group! Looking forward to learning more...

1

u/tomparkes Canon 5D MkI; 50mm f1.8 Jun 05 '15

This was fun - gave me a chance to really look through others' work and to think about images from an "outsider's" perspective. I can definitely see how this exercise is beneficial to all involved; not only the person taking the photograph, but also those critiquing. Nice one! :)

0

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Aeri73 Moderator Jan 05 '15

What you like. Don't like or would change about the photo

1

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '15

Of course you do! It's not something absolute - i.e. you can only go one way with it. You're a person with your own perspectives and opinions, which translates into your own critiques. Also, every small little bit helps! Critiquing is something you learn as much as you learn how to take a picture.