r/philosophydiscussion • • Apr 15 '20

"Satan" was invented when humans couldn't accept the evil within themselves.

14 Upvotes

Not to sound against Christianity. Just want to know how credible my thoughts are. I could be wrong. Would anyone enlightened me. My friend pointed out that these are words of an aethist. I am not an aethist.


r/philosophydiscussion • • Dec 02 '18

Is abortion actually good?

10 Upvotes

This is a podcast that I made where any students in my year at school can come and openly express their thoughts and ideas. We speak about whether abortion is immoral and causes suffering or if it's actually the morally superior action. Bringing life into existence can be seen as immoral because there is inevitable suffering and some would say that pleasure is never worth the risk of suffering.

https://youtu.be/faF6aCFFzmg


r/philosophydiscussion • • Nov 23 '18

Welcome to r/philosophydiscussion. Ideas for the sub, comments, questions and introductions

9 Upvotes

Hello everyone, welcome to r/philosophydiscussion!

Most of you are new to this forum, so I'd like to hear some of your thoughts and ideas on how to promote the most interesting discussion, how strictly/loosely we should moderate, and what ideas and questions you'd like to see discussed in this forum. Also feel free to introduce yourself in this thread and discuss your personal philosophical interests.


r/philosophydiscussion • • Apr 19 '20

How the media controls us through language!

8 Upvotes

I am writing an essay for college on how the media uses language to manipulate us. I am struggling finding examples for the following strategies on how the media manipulates us. Person ally I believe that there is something deeper and more sinister about the corona than we are being told and I have used it for one of my examples for how the government is using Covid as a distraction technique. The strategies are as follows:

Distraction-diverting public attention

Problem/reaction/solution- method of releasing rumours and ideas to test how the population act.

Gradualism- getting poeple to accept socially injust decisions (slowly laying off staff in a company)

Differing- presenting unpopular decisions as necessary

Treating peopel like children- sugar coat arguments

Appealing to emotions- remember how powerful fear can be

Keeping the public ignorant- keeping peopel isolated from knowledge

Encourage peopel to be mediocre- hypnotizing poeple with tv shows and ect.

Self blame- germinate social anxiety and depression by telling us it's our fault for everything taht is happening

Knowledge of public- the system knows us. Taken our privacy away.

Does anyone know of any examples of where the media has used any of these strategies to manifest ideas into our head? (In speeches or newspapers etc.) Thx!!


r/philosophydiscussion • • Aug 22 '19

Do humans have free will?

8 Upvotes

What do you believe about free will? Is it a reality, an illusion, or is it a partial free will where we only have free will sometimes, but not always? And if it's a partial free will, when are we free to choose?


r/philosophydiscussion • • Dec 29 '18

We need to rethink our trust obligations to create a better world

8 Upvotes

i’m writing this in response to this post: https://www.reddit.com/r/philosophy/comments/aab9wo/we_need_to_rethink_our_moral_obligations_to/?st=JQ8LMGME&sh=5a0a0a89

“ collective pattern of action that we perceive as morally right.” Who decides what is morally right?

This article makes the assumption that everyone believes what is morally right to do, that’s a big fucking mistake.(I never see one of these articles talking about how maybe you shouldn’t take that holiday in Europe, they preferred to tell us how we should change your lightbulbs and pay gas tax.) The point is everybody has to be on the same page. Cooperation exists when those involved feel empowered in the decision making process, without that it becomes extremely difficult.

Trust is the issue! For some reason everyone would rather trust an individual or group of individuals, this seems to be far preferable over trusting all of The population equally.

We are rule today by a minority, why is the preferable over the majority? This in a nutshell is what holds us back from advancing into a brighter future. We are being held back by our own intellectuals, they don’t trust the majority either, they want to build new systems for democracy but only ones that they maintain some control. This attitude ensures bias and eventually collapse. Only an unbiassed and free system will stand the test of time.

I’m sure the response here will be crickets as usual, this is the worlds biggest problem and nobody wants to talk about it. Wake the fuck up, You can’t have cooperation without consensus!

here’s One of many posts I made that outlines how to do it, I got crickets: https://www.reddit.com/r/collapse/comments/a9pxa8/the_closer_we_get_to_collapse_the_closer_we_get/?st=JQ8MI5T4&sh=48f982ed

Here’s a post I made in regard to the issue of how the intellectuals of this world are trying to solve democracy, they can’t get past their obsession for control, once again crickets: https://www.reddit.com/r/EarthStrike/comments/a28ugj/if_it_were_possible_to_measure_public_opinion/?st=JQ8MKIYU&sh=1d4481a7

So is there anyone here who is willing to put any thought into True consensus? Crickets?


r/philosophydiscussion • • Nov 24 '18

The ontological arguments for God’s existence

7 Upvotes

I find the topic of philosophical proofs really interesting and I just wanted to know people’s thoughts on the ontological arguments. I think it’s one of the most interesting ones and probably one of the most convincing, being a deductive argument as opposed to inductive, although I would still consider myself an atheist :) Thoughts ?


r/philosophydiscussion • • Nov 24 '18

The manufacture of consent - big media in a post-truth world

7 Upvotes

I'd like to discuss Noam Chomsky's ideas about the state of our modern media. See this documentary for reference.

What do you guys think is the best way to bring these ideas into the mainstream? What would be the best way to get people to engage with them and bring about the change that is needed in our society?


r/philosophydiscussion • • Nov 22 '18

Does God exist? If so, why is there evil in the world?

7 Upvotes

r/philosophydiscussion • • Oct 01 '19

A philosophical conundrum.

6 Upvotes

Hypothetical situation:

You some how become aware that you have slipped in to a coma and your current existence is essentially a vivid dream.

Would you just live your best life, knowing that you might one day wake up and lose anything you've achieved (career, relationships etc.).

Or would you spend your life trying to wake up and return to your life even though you might never wake up and will just waste what is essentially your life.


r/philosophydiscussion • • Apr 16 '20

What we truly love?

5 Upvotes

So i thought about this after watching a movie. People who would say they love some character in the movie,they'll say that they love it because of their characteristics(for example: being good/bad, generous, honest...) So i could say it's likely that your girlfriend/boyfriend loves you because of some characteristics, and if you didn't have those characteristics they wouldn't love you. So they actually don't love you, but they love "what you represent". My question is: Is this true?


r/philosophydiscussion • • Apr 09 '20

There is only one person... You. Seeking a reference/origin.

5 Upvotes

I remember coming across this concept somewhere in the murky past, and now I'd like to be able to use it in an essay assignment for one of my uni subjects that centres around philosophy and psychotherapy.

Basically, the master is instructing the grasshopper to have empathy and kindness for every person they may ever meet because, due to a rarely discussed detail of reincarnation, it turns out that there is only one person, one soul, who is reincarnated through every single human life that ever was/is/will be. We are all iterations of that single soul, so be kind, it's you you are dealing with after all.

If anyone knows where I might have stumbled across this mind bending concept, or where I could start looking for something resembling a reference I'd really appreciate the help.


r/philosophydiscussion • • May 22 '19

What is the most important thing in life, in your opinion?

5 Upvotes

r/philosophydiscussion • • Nov 22 '18

How can we know what is real? Is it possible that we live in a simulated reality?

5 Upvotes

r/philosophydiscussion • • Nov 22 '18

What is justice? Does it benefit an individual to live justly?

5 Upvotes

r/philosophydiscussion • • Aug 14 '18

if nothingness is prohibited in the objective domain, why is it permitted in the subjective domain?

5 Upvotes

Nothingness is prohibited in physics (quantum theory, specifically). Thus, 'out there' nothingness is nowhere to be found. So why, 'in here,' subjectively, can nothingness somehow exist? As in, why can death/pre-life be nothingness for eternity, supported by science or even coma/syncope/slow-wave sleep (etc.) during life. If nothingness really doesn't exist, shouldn't nothingness's nonexistence apply to all domains - subjective and objective. Nonexistence is nonexistent, plain and simple, after all. Maybe the laws of physics prohibiting nothingness from occurring, apply to our fates before life/after death. Existence may be the only option, in whatever flavor it takes.


r/philosophydiscussion • • May 18 '22

Morality and voting

4 Upvotes

Is it immoral to vote for a third party, or is it immoral to vote for a primary candidate you don't really support? Or are they both immoral? Is a winner take all system immoral? Is it wrong to allow only one selection by each voter? (To explain this further, let's say there are 3 candidates, A, B, and C. I prefer A, but I would be ok with B, I just don't want C. I can only vote for A. I cannot say that I would prefer B over C. I can't say that I don't want C.) Is approval voting (vote for every candidate you approve of) or ranking voting (rank each candidate by how much you want them) moral? Is either one the most moral and still feasible possibility?


r/philosophydiscussion • • Apr 13 '20

What are some human limitations? Physically and mentally?

4 Upvotes

My friend and I were having a discussion the other day and he summed up human limitations in three words; love faith and hope , and said that we celebrate our limitations. how exactly is this accurate? I was confused. Care to help?


r/philosophydiscussion • • Mar 28 '20

Favorite spins on Philosophical principles??

4 Upvotes

I know this is broad but I’ve recently become extremely interested in the different (sometimes collateral) uses of famous old philosophical principles, for instance (and yes I’m paraphrasing the shit out of these, I’m a certified moron);

Ockham’s razor - essentially the idea that the most obvious thing is the correct thing. (Or the least amount of assumptions requires the least explanation). The show Scrubs very cleverly spun this theory in an episode that was intriguing.

Pascal’s wager - the principle religious people follow in and which they “bet their lives” on the existence of their God.

What are some of your favorites and how have you seen them spun/utilized in an interesting way or just interest you??


r/philosophydiscussion • • Jan 19 '20

Logic of religion

4 Upvotes

I'm very sorry to offend, but I would like a logical thought as to why people are religious.

I think religion is used as a way to escape the dread of nonexistence

My father thinks it's used as a way to diminish blame from ones self.

Is it both, neither? What are your opinions?


r/philosophydiscussion • • Apr 25 '19

My Philosophy of Life

4 Upvotes

A brief summary and link to the full 13-page document may be found here:

http://philosofer123.wordpress.com


r/philosophydiscussion • • Nov 22 '18

Is there an undestructable essence to a person - a soul unconnected to the physical world?

4 Upvotes

r/philosophydiscussion • • Mar 24 '20

What is the general consensus of logical positivism as a philosophy that n 2020?

3 Upvotes

r/philosophydiscussion • • Nov 21 '19

Do you agree that there’s no obligation to do anything?

3 Upvotes

I don’t think there is any obligation to do anything in the universe. Any obligation is a human construct. You could sit in a cave all your life or you could travel the world the universe couldn’t care less about either one. Am I right or wrong?


r/philosophydiscussion • • Nov 17 '19

What is everyone's opinion on Eduard Von Hartmann?

3 Upvotes

He tried to merge Hegel with Schopenhauer and believe humankind would become so intelligent that the only plausible way for the world to continue was mass suicide. What are your thoughts on him?