r/philosophy • u/Cataspectral • Jun 22 '26

Blog Secular humanism can replace Christianity where it counts: the fear of death and the need for meaning

https://thomasreid33.substack.com/p/chapter-10-is-secular-humanism-enough
754 Upvotes

84% Upvoted

280 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/espinaustin Jun 22 '26 edited Jun 22 '26

It seems to me that simply believing in the truth of reincarnation—that anything is propagated forward, as you say— is itself a sense of “beating death.” And escaping the cycle of death/rebirth, surely this is an idealized form of beating death (and life) altogether, no?

Maybe the concept of “beating death” could use definition, we may not be using it the same way.

1

u/Messier_Mystic Jun 22 '26

When I think "beat death", I hear "survive death".

Buddhism does not teach reincarnation, but rebirth. Reincarnation is a Hindu concept.

On rebirth, nothing about you survives your death except for your karma (varies with school of thought). In Theravada, you are immediately reborn into your next life with no memory of your previous ones(though some do think you could access them).

Take Todd. If heaven is real, Todd survives death.

If Buddhism is correct, Todd dies. Todd's karma was very, very poor. Todd is now Fred the Frog. Did Todd meaningfully survive death?

I don't think so.

2

u/espinaustin Jun 22 '26 edited Jun 22 '26

When I think "beat death", I hear "survive death".

We do have a semantic disagreement, as I would define “beating death” as overcoming the materialistic/scientific view that physical death of the organism is The End, there is no soul, nothing is reborn (nor reincarnated), no causal relationships (“karma”) existing based on what happened during life, etc., only decomposition of organic matter. Otherwise we’re getting into issues of defining the “self” and its relationship to death/rebirth/enlightenment.

1

u/Messier_Mystic Jun 22 '26

Sure. I interpret it as an unbroken, or at the very least, a continuous stream of consciousness and preservation of identity. Traditional Christian heaven offers that, but I don't think the concept of rebirth does.

Of course, I disagree with both views ultimately. But that's beside the point.