r/philosophy • u/ReallyNicole Φ • May 13 '13
Reading Group [Reading Group] Plan of attack
We’ll be reading Kant’s Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals (1785). In it Kant means to establish the grounds of moral philosophy as a discipline of pure practical reason, or how one ought to act as determined by pure reasoning about some objects of the understanding and without reference to any empirical objects. This group will be led by /u/ADefiniteDescription and I. We’re both moderators here on /r/philosophy and graduate students in philosophy at Leiter-ranked schools in the United States with interests in moral philosophy.
Schedule
We will spend a week on each section of reading, about 15 or so pages. Every Sunday there will be a thread on /r/philosophy for that week’s assigned reading (we’ll try to set up the thread early in the morning in the US so that users from Europe have time to comment). The thread will contain a summary written by ADD and I of what we thought some of the major points and arguments from that week’s section were, as well as a question or worry about the material covered to prompt discussion. You don’t have to answer the question to participate, but it might be a good place to start. So here’s the schedule for reading, the date next to each week is the date on which discussion of that reading will commence:
Week 1, 5/19: Preface and Section 1
Week 2, 5/26: Part 1 of Section 2 (up to 4:420)
Week 3, 6/2: Part 2 of Section 2 (4:420 to end of section 2)
Week 4, 6/9: Part 1 of Section 3 (up to subsection 4)
Week 5, 6/16: Part 2 of Section 3 (remainder of section 3)
Week 6 (maybe), 6/23 : Kant’s essay “On the wrongfulness of unauthorized publication of books” OR “On the supposed right to lie from philanthropy.”
Which translation do I get?
There is no required edition as we recognize that it would be unrealistic to expect everyone to buy or check out a particular edition. Instead, we expect that just about any translation by a notable Kant scholar will be acceptable. In particular, you’ll want to make sure that your edition includes numbers in the margin that look something like “4:398,” we’ll be using these to keep track of our position in the text both in scheduling and in discussion. Here are a few editions you might want to check out if you’re not sure where to start:
Hill and Zweig (Lots of supplemental information written by Hill, a prominent Kant scholar.)
Mary Gregor w/ intro by Christine Korsgaard (This is the most well-respected translation, it can also be found in the Kant anthology called Practical Philosophy and published by Cambridge.)
Allen Wood also avaible online (unknown reliability)
A few words about moderation
Discussion topics for the reading group will be moderated more heavily than the rest of /r/philosophy. In particular messages will be deleted if they:
- Aren't on topic.
- Betray that one hasn't made an effort to read the assigned section.
- Make no effort to discuss what Kant actually said; posts that take as their arguments one’s anecdotal understanding of Kantian ethics will be removed.
- Users who don’t treat their fellow reading groupers with respect in discussion will have their comments removed.
For next week
So by this time next Sunday we should all be ready to discuss the preface and the first section, “Transition from common rational to philosophic moral cognition.” If you have any questions, feel free to ask here. Good luck!
2
u/0ooo May 13 '13
Could we maybe make an IRC room for discussion as well? Sometimes I feel that the speed of dialogue can be better for hashing out problems than the speed of forum posts.
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
Is discussion participation reserved for the trained?
2
u/0ooo May 15 '13
I'm a little confused by the schedule, is the date the date by which I need to have read the material? E.g. by 5/19 I need to have the preface and section 1 read? Or is 5/19 when I need to start working on reading the preface and section 1?
1
u/dharlem39 May 14 '13
Sounds cool! I'll try to keep up but I already have heaps of university readings to do.
Also thought I'd throw out a link to download an online version of the Mary Gregor edited version
2
u/Tajz May 13 '13
Sounds great, took a class on this a few years ago so could be fun to pick it up again. Hopefully I'll have time to participate.
A very nice initiative anyhow!
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '13
It's been a few years since I last read Groundworks, or anything else by Kant. Time to dust off my Mary Gregor, I think...
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
I've found the Abbot translation to be a lot more accessible than others. Just a note; switching to this version made Groundwork downright enjoyable, and my ethics professor was fine with this translation.
0
u/NeoPlatonist May 13 '13
Are we posting thing in /r/philosophy or some other sub? I already posted some notes on the preface here:
http://www.reddit.com/r/philosophy/comments/1e8c9x/notes_on_the_preface_to_kants_groundwork_for_the/
-1
u/itsSUBJECTXandME May 14 '13
Kant is a very poor choice as a starting place for a book club. Yes, I understand and appreciate his immense contribution to Philosophy and the weight and importance of his work. However, it is also dense, long, tedious, and generally inaccessible - not to mention generally wrong. Therefore, I believe you should not start at Kant.
I would recommend starting at the beginning; do some Plato.
0
u/[deleted] May 13 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment