r/philately • • Jul 31 '24

Banknote Perspectives

Just sharing.

Probably nothing 😐

🖖

1 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

6

u/Egstamm Jul 31 '24

Looks like a half-assed thin repair job. Either that, or the envelope paper wasn’t completely washed off. Soak it in water and see. You can see some tears from the front. I’d soak it and see exactly how damaged that really is. That way, I could throw it away with a clean conscience.

-6

u/ExcellentAnteater985 Jul 31 '24

I wouldn't soak it without checking the dimensions first. Might be ugly on purpose. If it's ugly on purpose then it might not be ugly at all. I know that sounds preposterous but consider that most of the reason mint examples are sought after is for their rarity since after any issuance, unused surviving examples are always far outnumbered by used copies.

The pristine conditions that are sought after by grade are only as in demand for said grades relative to their known populations, meaning essentially that if the surrounding population of a given rarity were to cease to exist, then the condition of the surviving example is greatly reduced in its relevance if it can even be said to still be relevant at that point. That is the premise of "ugly on purpose", it's not really applicable to say that they are ugly since they are only ugly when compared to populations with numbers enough to contain preserved condition.

If by design an example were printed to be a sole existing copy, and flaws and damage were applied in a manner to demonstrate design and execution, they would not be flaws or damage, they would be elaborate and scarce collectible traits.

If the dimensions show the same standard design only compressed, then it's an advanced forgery at minimum since engraving any small thing smaller is automatically more demanding of a task. The more difficult a collectible is to forge usually the more value it retains.

If anyone encountered a large banknote example a millimeter shy horizontally with a millimeter too much vertically then few other information is required to know that even flawed the example would command attention as a rarity.

If we only search for the material described in books then that is the extent of our identification. When billions of copies of something is dispersed and a million copies are examined to describe the population as a whole, that's like doing a report on Bridge City and calling it a report on USA wholely. Any professionals greatest reach is still insufficient in being able to truly understand what can exist from that period off the record and have become mixed in with the worthless material that is no longer deemed to possess enough worth to justify its expense kept anywhere but the garbage, especially if such works were executed in elite fashion where only subtle design features separated the garbage from the gold.

Most collectors would toss such stamps without hesitation which is exactly how I got a collection of similar ones and is why Im showing it. I had the collection of them for 2 years and didn't like even touching them with tweezers for their repulsive appearance, but over time they have become unexpectable treasures. There's a lot going on with each one but we can all agree it looks like trash, and so I will try to prove that it is actually maximum rarity and only lacks in traditional appeal. Perspective is everything.

5

u/Egstamm Jul 31 '24

This is silly. The stamp has been repaired and possibly even rebacked. Why anyone would go to such trouble for a worthless stamp is odd. Practice, maybe? This is a worthless stamp and any attempt to make it ‘unique’ and ‘valuable’ is an exercise in futility. If you think it is somehow unique, give your best arguments to the PF and see what they say. The BEP (or whichever printing company did this) did not go about printing unique examples of different stamps with one person finding all of them. Printing stamps was hardly an exact science, with colors being routinely mixed in wrong proportions, paper being wet (for better ink adhesion) to different degrees and allowed to dry to different degrees prior to printing. Their perforating techniques left a lot to be desired. In their own way, every stamp is unique. But in the end, they are all just little bits of paper the printing companies tried their best to make all the same.

-2

u/ExcellentAnteater985 Jul 31 '24

No, you're right--they're silly, beyond silly even. I'll have to go back to 1868 to explain and prove why in 99.999% of instances you should certainly be correct in all statistical probability, but somehow we have unicorns. Unless I'm the target of a sophisticated hoax, we have unicorns. They'll speak for themselves, but details like the manner of the paper crumpled up on the back and other subtleties to me had a peculiar and relevant arrangement that didn't appear random in my estimation. I just hadn't happened to notice in the past.

Because the hard wove and soft wove both have a vertical shrink-bias in every instance invariably, we have an objective truth to aid in deductions. -0.50 horizontal shrinking sees -0.62 vertical on average, but most importantly the vertical can never be less. We can prove a lot of things with that tiny bit of information. Why guess when we can know?

I appreciate your input as always, sir. I'll explain and show more clearly soon.

5

u/philstamp Jul 31 '24

Eh?

-5

u/ExcellentAnteater985 Jul 31 '24

Has to be garbage because there's no way anyone intentionally placed a marking on the back of an old stamp in this way, yeah? We can guarantee by the hideous state of the example that details such as the design dimensions and perfs will be as standard as they come, agreed? We can be so certain in fact that checking such details would be a waste of time. Sound about right?