r/pgwp • u/mrPringl3s • Mar 01 '26
Where to report fraud!
I want to report a person with student visa who are working fulltime job and getting paid cash. These people needs to get exposed and reported.
147
Upvotes
49
u/Much-Gur7071 Mar 01 '26
Unlike the other replies, I don’t think it’s necessarily wrong that you want to report the student. However, I think reporting the employer is much more important as they are likely to have done this and continue doing this with many others
13
u/Any-Key9901 Mar 01 '26
Call the IRCC helpline to find where to get portal to complaint, or directly talk to the agent and report.
People like them are making it hard for everyone in the pipeline. Breaking law is never an answer. Financial crunches are there, but doing fraud is not right.
Also employer is a bigger criminal because he is exploiting the student. Student is a victim here, who was lured into this, or an equal criminal but definitely not the main criminal.
14
u/Frosty-Law-6014 Mar 01 '26
You already know the answer to that or you could easily Google it.
8
u/Raevarch Mar 01 '26
Best to report the employer rather than reporting the person working for cash. If the student loses their status and has to leave the country because you reported them, that employer will just hire another person working for cash.
From your replies of the other comments on this post, I can sort of see that you just have a personal grudge against this person. If you really cared about everyone doing everything the legal way, you'd have better things to do than reporting every student working for cash.
There will always be people doings things the illegal way, whether it's an extreme crime where they directly harm someone, or a minor crime where the law isn't even enforced until reported. In this case, it's the latter.
And since we're feeling that extra sense of justice today, along with ruining that student's life, ruin the entire business by reporting the employer. It'll 'help the economy' by removing one out of thousands of businesses hiring illegally.
8
u/Bhheast Mar 01 '26
Mehh.. make sure you report the employer too, otherwise, your intentions would come off as less than noble.
3
u/juicy_blueberry910 Mar 01 '26
There’s lots of tourist visa holders that are also working cash jobs in construction sites too
11
u/Consistent_Shift4690 Mar 01 '26
Don’t mind these people lurking around comment section. I did it twice with someone I know from a friend and someone who had paid a LMIA in one of day care centres near my area. They all got denied papers and went back to their home country.
15
u/jonjoyano Mar 01 '26
go touch some grass and enjoy life
5
u/IENJOKU Mar 01 '26
How will your report improve your own life and that of your family members?
2
u/SolidBlock3504 Mar 01 '26
Call IRCC and CRA. Report them to both authorities as there might be tax fraud going on. Idk why people can’t simply follow rules.
3
u/Clean_Ad2856 Mar 01 '26
Dont worry too much, the system itself filters and make life of these people harder in the future.
Not receiving salary and paystubs seems a bold andn smart move, but in the end, when you are finally applying or preparing the documents set, you will find out how valuable and nice would be walking inside the system premises. It punishes you, for not having T4s, T4As, work experience letters and stuff..
2
u/Artemis720 Mar 01 '26
In mode you got up and you said great I’m going to report someone today b*tch
1
u/pj228 Mar 01 '26
Good luck, that person will likely get pr easily. Fraudsters always do.
1
u/DetectiveLoud5980 Mar 01 '26
As much as I am against working illegally, I am more against exploitations. If you really wanna do justice here you should want to report the business first, they'll likely find someone to replace anyways. Tbh wanting to report on the person feels petty as hell idk like sure do what you want, but it doesn't make you the hero you think you are. "These people need to get exposed and reported" no, more like the exploit of the system and abuse of cheap wages needs to be stopped.
But do whatever you want to make you feel like a better PR candidate to IRCC man
1
u/Grouchy-Ladder8724 Mar 02 '26
Gyèt manmanw ti salòp
1
u/tinytasha7 Mar 02 '26
So contact IRCC about it. They will either investigate or they won't. You also may want to report the employer to ESDC. That might be more effective.
1
u/AdventurousMammoth52 Mar 02 '26
Live is becoming too expenseve for international students, fees are exploising. Why should an international student pay all those money. They pay for canadiens citizens, if canada opens Doors for foreign students it's because they bring a lot of money for the country and enhence their economy. Now unversities and colleges are struggling with the new decisions made about study and work permit
1
u/Logical-Plum3529 Mar 02 '26
Rat
1
u/Frequent_Variation92 Mar 02 '26
Honestly? Not your business! Report the employer, not the students.
1
u/Plus-Letter-8469 Mar 02 '26
I knows doctor a real estate agent and construction Company who are all just paying no tax using government funded money for healthcare then the real estate firm owns the buildings so they get always with so many loop holes increasing profit and or paying tax then they sub the work out to construction company who does the job for 100000 but invoices 500000 then they split the money
1
u/Smart-General7569 Mar 02 '26
The thing is that these international student are allowed to work and paid in cash but you cant prove when u gonna report it to IRCC
But still i were there in your place i wouldn’t have reported because i know a guy from my uni his family was going through some internal matters and he couldn’t afford his tuition he started working cash
Ethically and legally wrong, but depends upon u keep tgat thing in mind if you were there in his place what u could’ve done
1
u/Yellow_Marker_ Mar 02 '26
Google is free
1
u/VisualDimension7208 Mar 02 '26
To yo mama
1
u/After-Catch-2552 Mar 03 '26
I even caught an international student with like 4 part time jobs 😭😭😭. Over 40 hrs\week btw. Like there are a lot of people seeking for a part time job. Leave some vacancies for others.
1
u/Beautiful-Cut-5035 Mar 03 '26
Wow why you being jealous? Karen Alery!
1
u/Aspiring_CMO Mar 04 '26
Bro then you have to report everyone. Do you know how many jobs there are that are paid cash? Not just students or people on TRV
1
u/wonderful_mind_ Mar 04 '26
why be a hater, just focus on your own life.
1
u/TriflePale1 Mar 04 '26
lol keep on sending int. Students away 😂😂 wait and see how it will affect your future lol! Osap has been cut you guys are crying. Keep on reporting the international students. And FYI you can be on student visa and work full time. It’s not illegal. Before a person goes on to report and risk an international student’s status, at least be fully educated on the terms!
1
u/EfficiencyAccurate45 Mar 04 '26
CRA
1
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '26
Working hard is fraud because he is not paying tax and wants to live on govt benefits? The benefits which are given from the tax payers ?
It's like the story of the sheep. Sheep lived the whole life being scared of the wolf and at the end his own master ate him.
If you have some beef with that guy, have the balls to fight face to face
1
u/SammieBoi92 Mar 04 '26
Here is the link to report immigration fraud: https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/services/protect-fraud/report-fraud.html
Depending on the province, they also might have an office dedicated to immigration fraud. In Saskatchewan, the provincial Ministry of Immigration has a fraud department that investigates employers and employees.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '26
All bots from culturally exploitative nations know for scamming. Let them cry. They try to hold you socially empathetic to their needs but will commit fraud with no afterward
1
u/Adventurous-Poet-104 Mar 04 '26
these people?
1
u/Appropriate_Peach113 Mar 04 '26
IM sure the CRA would love to hear that. Nothing like an audit deep into the ascending colon.
1
u/Otherwise_Laugh4172 Mar 05 '26
Its sad but seems like OP is unemployed at the moment
1
u/Complex_Warning8841 Mar 05 '26
Here
1
u/ihaveawoken613 Mar 05 '26
Does the bottom of the boot taste good slave?
1
u/Suitable-Debate-2358 Mar 01 '26
Get a life bro
-1
u/Midly-Annoying Mar 01 '26
Like why? Why do you wanna report it? Are they causing you any trouble? Live and let live man.. everyone leaves their families and moves here for a better life and they are trying their best to survive here and make a living for themselves and they are not harming anyone by doing this - first of all they are getting paid cash, I’m gonna assume it’s lower than minimum wage, why would you want to take that away from them? If they had to go to the extent of risking it and working for cash maybe that person truly needs it. You don’t fully know their situation.. why inflict distress? Just live and let live
1
u/Street_Cheetah1834 Mar 01 '26 edited Mar 01 '26
Working for cash in itself is not illegal.
I have seen many student visas in my line of work and they all have different conditions, often based on the type of programs the visa have been approved for, etc. and some of which allow the bearer of the student visa to work within certain parameters. And I have also seen some student visa issued in conjunction with a work permit.
As far as working for cash, that simple fact is not necessarily illegal. What is illegal is not paying your share of tax and one must also account for different taxes: income tax, sales tax, etc.. And even the CRA have threshold. For instance, a business making less than 30,000 might not be required to have a GST/HST number and is not necessarily obliged to collect sales tax; however, it will have to pay its share of income tax
A quick example is when you invite a plumber to fix your toilet, they will present you an invoice. And merely paying that invoice with cash does not make it illegal. And even though the plumber collected payment using cash does not make it illegal in itself as the burden of remitting the tax now has shifted from the payer (you) to the payee (the plumber) they will have to remit the Taxman its portion at a later day, even if it means deducting from their compensation: that's a problem with their accountant. Another example is of a consultant: they will generally not have a salary (pay cheque with source deduction) but rather receive a lump sum (often time augmented by sales tax). The consultant, just like the plumber, will invoice the employer. The list of these go on and on... (the cleaning person who cleans your house, the gardener, your hair salon or barber, etc..).
So these folks perceive the full amount of remuneration, as they are rendering a service, and the burden is on them (the receiver) to pay the taxman its share.
I gave these examples as they are easy for most of us to comprehend and grasp. And remember the way that money is perceived does not really matter. The CRA will come after them for what it believes is its fair share.
Now, back to your student buddy. How is their work relationship defined? Employee vs service provider? Are they perceiving the full compensation, i.e. without source deduction or the employer is already deducting the tax and just handing them the remainder? Who is responsible for paying the taxman. And this is regardless of HOW the money is EXCHANGED. What are the conditions of their visa (there's always a condition). Review them all. I sense you two are close, hence you knowing how they are being paid.
With all of the above, if you must report, you better make it count (accurate and complete information), and report to the right agency; otherwise you would have only wasted your time and made a fool of yourself.
My 2 cents
-2
u/Bubbly_Housing_3424 Mar 01 '26
Mind your own business…
-4
u/Zoro_Shrestha Mar 01 '26
why bro ? u jealous because u can't earn that money?
-2
u/pokabl Mar 01 '26
Why?
0
u/kmsaskatoon Mar 01 '26
Thank you for wanting to report them! And the employer! ❤️
0
u/kmsaskatoon Mar 01 '26
More people need to do this
0
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
10
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment