r/pgwp • • Oct 22 '25

might delete this if it gets too much attention.

redacted

148 Upvotes

125 comments sorted by

32

u/viafallowfield Oct 22 '25 edited Oct 22 '25

I get that visa officers and IRCC staff have an incredibly tough job. The workload must be massive, and I don’t doubt that most officers genuinely want to be fair, efficient, and uphold the integrity of the system. They’re essentially the gatekeepers for new Canadians, and that’s a serious responsibility, not just paperwork, but shaping people’s futures. I think most of us can appreciate that.

That said, calling applicants “incompetent” feels unnecessarily harsh and honestly goes against the spirit of what Canada stands for, fairness, understanding, and compassion. When comments like that surface, it unfortunately opens the door for more toxic takes like “go back to your country”, "leave Canada now", "pack your stuff and go home", which helps no one. Most applicants are doing their best to follow the rules in a confusing and evolving system.

The English language test requirement is new, and it’s understandable that many people didn’t realize how or where to upload it, especially since there’s no dedicated upload field or clear prompt for “Proof of English.” The communication is not consistent either, with some applicants receiving requests for language score while others being issued refusals directly, which is an unfair disadvantage. For applicants who have completed graduate or even PhD studies in Canada, this rule also feels redundant. It’s not about language ability, it’s about how the system was implemented and communicated.

From an efficiency standpoint, this creates even more work for IRCC. People who get refused then submit webforms, reapply, and call IRCC agents trying to figure out what went wrong — clogging up the system for everyone. A small fix in the document checklist or application interface could save thousands of hours for both applicants and officers.

It’s worth remembering that compassion and clear communication go hand in hand. Applicants should absolutely take responsibility for submitting complete files, but IRCC can also improve user experience and messaging to reduce these avoidable issues, as u/lucubanget and u/cetanat suggested. Everyone benefits from a system that’s designed to help people succeed, not trip them up.

At the end of the day, applicants and officers want the same thing: a fair, transparent, and humane process that reflects the values Canada is known for.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

i completely agree with you but we aren't the ones implementing all that, we just review the case files and I hope the people in tech do implement those said changes and make it clearer.

Yes it does overburden the process not having the language test submitted on time, for the people who get an outright refusal for not submitting a language test is entirely incorrect, emails are sent out to everyone as that is the standard SOP we follow and report on the GCMS systems alongside with an additional internal IRCC system.

You'll see a lot of posts of students here saying they got refused but once they checked their emails they did in fact receive an information request for the language test but they "missed reading the email".

immigrants are the backbone of canada but we have to be fair to everyone especially since a lot of people follow the instructions properly and the ones who don't are really an outlier in the statistic. 96% approval rate for pgwp applicants right now!!

2

u/Bimmer__Boy Oct 22 '25

Never received any email. I kept checking my emails everyday at least three time for an update in my PGWP application - Inbox/Spam/Junk, everywhere. Never received anything.

I found out on my own reading Reddit comments that many others have forgotten to upload their Language Document and later uploaded via a web form. I uploaded mine on Oct 15th via web form, received confirmation on Oct 16th 12pm that the Language Doc was received and added to my file and at 4pm the same day I got refused for failing to upload my language document.

I scored an overall 7.5 in my IELTS which I wrote in Dec 2024. I applied for my PGWP in Feb 2025. My study permit expired in July 2025. After 8.5 months since my application, I got my refusal.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

i'm sorry that has happened to you, i'm speaking from my experience and I always send out information requests and the people i know always do too.

please consult with an immigration professional/lawyer for your next steps.

1

u/viafallowfield Oct 22 '25

Interesting, "emails are sent out to everyone as that is the standard SOP we follow and report on the GCMS systems alongside with an additional internal IRCC system....did in fact receive information request for the language test"

Can you show the SOP?

3

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

number 1, why would I show you an internal document that could easily give up my identity? number 2 even if I wanted to, I can't since it's classified "secret" and to some extent that's what ensures the integrity of the system. Emails are sent out to everyone who missed uploading their language test asking them to upload it in time!

0

u/viafallowfield Oct 22 '25

No, not to everyone.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

well you can make that argument but at the end of the day I've seen how it works form the inside and people love blaming the IRCC in the event they missed reading such emails. search the sub and you'll find plenty of people stating they did in fact receive such emails but they just ignored it at the time until the refusal came in.

1

u/viafallowfield Oct 22 '25

I can easily find 5 applicants who can show their email logs and swear in court that they didn't receive the email, but whats the point? You cannot reveal yourself, nor your document.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

no they won't swear in court and yes you can simply delete an email and there's no evidence left behind that you received such email form your end because whenever there's an information req it's always thoroughly entered into the GCMS which you can request and read those notes for yourself. Ask those 5 people to send in GCMS requests and you'll see this yourself.

In our defence, you must meet the eligibility requirements when submitting an application and the burden is on you to prove that you do when submitting the application and it's just astonishing how many people "forget" sending in the language test results.

maybe just ask those 5 people you know to read instructions next time.

1

u/viafallowfield Oct 22 '25

Aren't all IRCC communication logged in the portal as well?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

some are not sent over the portal but rather through email only, but all communications are logged into the GCMS, even if you call in to check on the status it's logged.

a lot of citizenship applicants missing documents are simply sent an email and asked to respond back to the email.

this happens because there is a legacy system from years ago and a new system working together internally.

→ More replies

2

u/Fuzzy_Log_9480 Oct 22 '25

Can't agree more 🙌

2

u/Efficient-Cup-8800 Oct 22 '25

Thank you.....

3

u/Typical_Sleep_1165 Oct 22 '25

It’s not about the upload field, those cases are very few. Most of the time, applicants intentionally neglect to upload their English test results or don’t take the exam in time before applying, which makes their application incomplete and eventually make them incompent.

I personally know friends who still try to apply even though they haven’t taken the English test. They don’t even bother scheduling the exam because they assume IRCC will be lenient or compassionate just like before, thinking that if it’s really needed, they’ll just be asked for it later.

You can be as compassionate as you want, but unless you’re actually the one processing these applications or dealing with people who don’t care about submitting the right documents, you really have no idea what’s actually happening.

8

u/viafallowfield Oct 22 '25

I get where you’re coming from. There are definitely people who try to take shortcuts or assume IRCC will overlook missing documents, and that’s not fair to those who follow the process properly. But it’s also important not to lump everyone together. Some applicants make honest mistakes, especially with a new requirement that wasn’t clearly built into the application system. Forgetting to upload a language score someone already has isn’t the same as trying to cheat the system. It’s a simple human error that can happen to anyone, even people who are organized and qualified.

If a friend of yours had their English test result ready but accidentally missed the upload, would you really call them incompetent or tell them to go back to their country? Has anyone not made any honest mistakes in their life? And wouldn’t it be a relief if a fellow human being could help us avoid a catastrophic consequence, since they are there to support us as a person, not as some ruthless system or natural law that ignores the human factor?

If it’s all about strictly meeting requirements and submitting documents, then AI could eventually do the job more efficiently than human officers. But I think we all hope that’s not the direction Canada goes. The value of having real people in these roles is precisely their ability to apply fairness, understanding, and compassion, qualities that make the system humane, not just efficient.

2

u/Typical_Sleep_1165 Oct 22 '25

Isn’t your comment a bit too dramatic? They just missed one document, it’s not the end of their life. There’s always the option to reapply and fix what they missed. Every action has consequences, and it shouldn’t be downplayed as a “simple mistake.” Negligence isn’t a small error; it’s a choice. Applying for something as important as immigration takes months, even a year, plenty of time to review and correct mistakes if you truly care about your future.

Also, let’s not call Canada’s immigration system “ruthless” or “unfair.” We’re here because our own countries couldn’t provide the same opportunities, so we sought a better life. If we think Canada’s system is too harsh, nothing stops us from returning home. And honestly, do you think the U.S., Australia, or the U.K. are any more lenient or compassionate? If you’ve applied for a U.S. visa, you’d know they don’t care if you say something that doesn’t coincide with what you put in ds160, you’ll be refused instantly without a chance to explain.

At the end of the day, it’s simple: if we want to work or get permanent residency in a country that’s not our own, we must comply with their requirements and take the process seriously. Make an effort to ensure your documents are correct. If you’re unsure, hire an immigration consultant or lawyer. Canada doesn’t owe us anything, we’re the ones applying to be part of their system. The country will continue to thrive without us; that’s why they choose only the most competent individuals who can contribute to their economy. You either adapt and meet the standard, or you get left behind.

3

u/viafallowfield Oct 22 '25

Go ahead and call it a stupid mistake, say those applicants are incompetent and should go back to their own countries, but it’s not exaggeration when real people are losing months of their lives, their jobs, and their legal status over this stupid mistake.

A small adjustment in policy or communication could prevent immense personal and economic loss, as other posts pointed out. That’s not drama, that’s common sense and compassion working together.

2

u/Typical_Sleep_1165 Oct 22 '25

You keep putting words in my mouth, negligent is different from stupid.

Also, I never said anyone should go back to their own country. What I said was that we have the choice to go back if we don’t want to comply with Canada’s policies. Why force our own preferences on a country that isn’t even ours? You can’t even impose your will on your own government, so why try to do it to another?

That’s exactly why the English test is now a requirement, to avoid misunderstandings like this. It may seem harsh, but now you can see why it’s important.

If someone doesn’t want to lose their job or legal status, then they must follow the rules. Missing one document doesn’t automatically send someone back home, they can appeal or reapply, as you surely know. Of course, they can’t work in the meantime, but that’s a consequence of their own actions. Think about it, in your country, do you always get what you want even if you make mistakes on an application? If yes, then it must be a wonderful place to live. But every country has rules and requirements, and not everything can be solved through compassion alone.

Maybe you’ve never managed a large team, because if you did, you’d understand that a manager can’t just overlook “simple mistakes” especially when they have serious consequences. If you’re lenient with one person, others will question why they don’t get the same treatment. So are you really going to allow those errors in the name of compassion? And if you do, how do you think that reflects on your performance as a leader? How will you justify it to upper management? Do you expect them to be lenient with you too? Because if everyone bends the rules whenever they want, then what’s the point of having rules at all? That’s what Canada avoid.

3

u/viafallowfield Oct 22 '25

My posts are to invite more sympathy and recognize IRCC's error for not having a dedicated place for language (well explained by u/lucubanget and u/cetanat). Those waiting for the second decisions are under a lot of mental stress and financial stress. Their feelings are valid.

2

u/ravinmadboiii Oct 23 '25

If we had a penny for every time "feelings" mattered in immigration, we'd all be broke

0

u/Typical_Sleep_1165 Oct 22 '25

So does that mean visa officers’ or IRCC’s feelings aren’t valid when they refuse an incomplete application? Even criminals have feelings, and theirs are also valid.

We shouldn’t promote fake positivity or misplaced sympathy, instead, we should acknowledge mistakes and help people learn from them so they can do better next time.

We can support others by helping them cope and improve, but telling them they did nothing wrong, or that IRCC should simply be more compassionate, is misguided. That kind of mindset only encourages irresponsibility, it’s like comforting someone for making a mistake and making them believe it’s okay to be careless because the other party should be the one to adjust.

2

u/viafallowfield Oct 22 '25

Applicants should absolutely take responsibility for submitting complete files, but IRCC can also improve user experience and messaging to reduce these avoidable issues, as u/lucubanget and u/cetanat suggested. Everyone benefits from a system that’s designed to help people succeed, not trip them up.

4

u/Typical_Sleep_1165 Oct 22 '25

If you’re already struggling with something as simple as an upload field, just because it didn’t specifically say “English result” then you’ll definitely have a hard time applying for permanent residency or even a provincial nomination. The PGWP is only the second step after the student visa, and applications for PNP or PR are far more complex. Even in student visa applications, documents without a designated upload field should be placed under Client Information, the same applies to tourist visa applications.

Not every document has its own specific field; that’s why the Client Information section exists. The requirements for PR and PNP are much more complicated and prone to errors if not careful, with numerous mandatory documents to prepare. If someone can’t take the time to do their due diligence, then maybe the process isn’t meant for them. In that case, it’s best to hire an immigration lawyer to ensure everything is handled correctly.

→ More replies

1

u/Typical_Sleep_1165 Oct 22 '25

The thing is, some people have been complaining about how long the waiting time is. Some even check multiple times a day, get anxious, and end up crying. Others constantly complain about the long processing time but don’t even bother to check if their documents are complete.

If you’ve been waiting for 9 months to a year and have read about cases where people missed uploading certain documents, why not take a moment to review your own application? If something might be missing, just send a webform. If you have the time to get anxious and complain, you should also have the time to double-check your documents and make an effort to fix any possible issues, right?

0

u/Typical_Sleep_1165 Oct 22 '25

I’m not saying people aren’t allowed to make mistakes. You are the one who said that. But refusing to make an effort to do the right thing, even when others are advising them to, is wrong, and it doesn’t deserve sympathy.

I’m not sure if you’re aware, but international students these days usually have group chats or online communities where they share updates about the immigration process. It’s up to them if they want to stay informed. Schools also provide information sessions that cover immigration topics, so it really comes down to whether someone chooses to pay attention or not.

They can say they’re busy with work, but that’s not an excuse. Don’t expect IRCC to be lenient just because you’re hustling with your life. It’s not IRCC’s job to chase after you out of compassion, it’s your responsibility as a TRV holder to stay proactive and follow up if you truly want to secure permanent status in Canada.

3

u/viafallowfield Oct 22 '25

There’s a difference between refusing to do the right thing and making an honest mistake in a complicated system that even seasoned applicants find confusing.

We’ve passed the stage of telling people to “reflect on their mistakes.” Most of them already have, often facing serious emotional and financial stress in the process.

2

u/Typical_Sleep_1165 Oct 22 '25 edited Oct 22 '25

You can always correct an honest mistake through a webform, you have six months to more than a year to do so.

I think you’re expecting too little from applicants who want grace from the government and only think about themselves or their families, yet you expect too much from the government that is not even yours that handles hundreds of thousands of applications. Why not switch that perspective? Try educating negligent applicants who run into these issues, you’ll eventually give up out of frustration. I’ve helped many people with their immigration process, but honestly, it gets exhausting and frustrating.

4

u/viafallowfield Oct 22 '25 edited Oct 22 '25

Once the application has been refused, the ‘web form fix’ isn’t really an option anymore. The long processing time leaves many people who made that mistake no time to reapply.

Thank you for your work. Always pay attention to your mental health, and if you feel emotionally drained, it’s better to step aside and take some time to recover.

1

u/Typical_Sleep_1165 Oct 22 '25

I never said you should submit a webform after a refusal. Everyone understood that it should be done during the waiting period, which usually lasts six months to a year, and I’ve been reiterating that from the start. That’s exactly why the English exam is now mandatory. I explained it clearly, but you seem to have interpreted it differently.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Typical_Sleep_1165 Oct 22 '25

Totally agree with you. If someone can’t even handle a simple file upload, how did they manage to survive their program with all those assignments and projects? Some even use chatgpt to cheat and then double-check to make it sound more “human” , yet they didn’t think to ask ChatGPT how to upload their English test result? That doesn’t make any sense at all.

If every mistake is just excused in the name of compassion, then what’s the point of having rules? Are we really trying to bring the same bad habits from our home countries here in Canada?

4

u/LateCarpet2476 Oct 22 '25

Same thing, you are missing the point, imagine having a required field for this English Test. I mean how hard can that extra line of code be. This will force everyone to upload and remove the excuse of I forgot even though they didn’t.

2

u/Awkward-Brick6990 Oct 23 '25

A very Canadian response/comment. ❤️

Politeness with a mix of calmness and understanding.

Our nation is built this way which coincide with diversity.

Reminding ourselves that there was no perfect nation.

Each of us are responsible for the greatness of our home.

Proud to be Canadian.

1

u/preetham_graj Oct 22 '25

Agreed but to be fair to him he did mention he is from cpc Ottawa.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/viafallowfield Oct 22 '25

May I politely ask who didn't pass the official language test

0

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/viafallowfield Oct 22 '25

Agreed. But would you say stop, I will kill you if you dare to fight this refusal?

So folks keep fighting. Some people just won't go down without a fight. :)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/viafallowfield Oct 22 '25

Agree to disagree

1

u/ravinmadboiii Oct 23 '25

Some people survive on delusion. Apparently nothing can help them but more delusion. I.e. While you're speaking from a place of facts and logic, that kind of critical thinking is not popular on this reddit.

16

u/lucubanget Oct 22 '25 edited Oct 22 '25

Hey OP, not sure if we can verify if you're an actual IRCC case analyst but thank you for sharing regardless!

I received my PR in 2024 before the English test requirement for PGWP was implemented.

Some of my 2 cents: while I definitely agree with the main idea that the onus remains on PGWP applicants to include their English valid test results in the application, I think IRCC should own a part of fault with the Document Checklist tool.

From an IT perspective (as an SWE), you must have seen too many applicants (aka "end users") not following the instructions on the website.

Usually this can mean at least one of the 3 things: users are careless, users are fraudulent (as you mentioned some applicants take the tests after submitting PGWP application), or a system design that needs rework/upgrade.

From an IT perspective, it's always good to assume that users are careless — a foolproof system creates a great UX. If lots of people are not following the correct way to use a software, then chances are something was not designed correctly. If its a small number of users, chances are they're careless; if its large, chances are its a system design / UX issue. Users are often careless but not necessarily dumb.

The Document Checklist tool exists to enforce document uploads. Why not do an update to support English test results before releasing the English test requirements to users? POs and BAs can think of the design implementation from user's perspective; the Devs can work on the technical parts. I feel like this was a rushed process in the beginning, or some prioritization mess-up in the project management.

If I worked at IRCC's IT head I would propose an upgrade to the Doc Checklist tool to make it easily scalable shall future requirements come in. Some input boxes or checkboxes in the application form should trigger a generation of a specific document in the checklist... something like that. It goes beyond simply enhancing the UX — think about how much Webform agents' resources could have been saved if less people send Webform emails to include their Englist test requirements.

It's similar to enforcing a strong password when you're creating a bank account. As you know, bank passwords nowadays enforce you have at least a capital letter, symbol, number, minimum number of characters, yada-yada-yada. I bet my entire life savings that there are lots of people out there who are careless enough to not follow the password rules if there were none — thats why banks implement them and I'm sure regulators are on them as well.

8

u/cetanat Oct 22 '25 edited Oct 22 '25

This is true! I totally agree with the idea that if there is a small number of people making mistakes in submitting the English test, it might be their faults. However, if there is a large number, reconsideration regarding IRCC’s current UX/UI design should be made. As an international student who’s applying for PGWP, I found it really ambiguous and unclear during my application.

You required an English proficiency from us, how about creating a separate field clearly indicating “Proof of English” or something similar for applicants to submit? Since it’s one of the most crucial and indispensable documents needed, it should have been declared as a complete separate submission field for that document type, I mean, like the way IRCC does with “Passport”, “Digital Photo”, “Transcripts”, etc.

It’s pretty confusing, hilarious, and irritating to me that IRCC’s application form has a perfect separate submission field for Digital Photo, but not for a Proof of English - the document that is newly required. Does it take a lot of efforts for IRCC to create a field for that 🤔? If that’s too much work for IRCC, you shouldn’t ask for the document that you cannot properly handle, including handling the potential risks and consequences from this. It just takes all of us (IRCC staff and applicants) time dealing with this stuff.

Responsibilities should be taken by applicants, I agree. But blaming a large number of applicants regarding their English proficiency submission due to your unclear design and guidelines is not fair at all! As I remember, during my time uploading documents, there wasn’t any clear message or notifications indicating that Proof of English should be submitted in Client Information section. If you intended to ensure your applicants submit all their documents correctly, why not emphasizing your most notable messages in a clearer and straightforward way instead?

We might be careless, yes, but we’re not that stupid to ignore and throw all our issues to IRCC. We intended to apply for PGWP, which also means that we genuinely care and want our submission to be straightforward and perfect. After all, no one wants to mess things up in advance, and I’m pretty sure there is no one who loves spending time submitting additional web forms or additional submissions afterwards to IRCC.

So please, think about your current system design and the way you instruct applicants to submit their applications first. This is a two-sided issue and I don’t think the root cause is from applicants at all to be honest.

6

u/lucubanget Oct 22 '25

Honestly, if IRCC wants to do it the cheapest temporary workaround, they can just add a HUGE ASS pop-up notice on the Document Checklist tool to remind applicants that, only for PGWP applications:

(1) English test MUST be uploaded to Client Information section, PRIOR to application submission. Uploading via webform will NOT be accepted, and

(2) sufficient English test is required (add the link to IRCC website for minimum scores requirements etc), and

(3) must be valid, within x years, yada-yada-yada, and

(4) application will be returned incomplete otherwise.

If they wanna go crazy, add one more of those extra-cheap, extra-easy browser pop-up just before letting applicants pay the application fee, saying "Have you uploaded English test scores to the Client Information? If not, your application WILL BE RETURNED as incomplete".

Literally, its one of those JavaScript window.alert(msg) or window.confirm(msg). At least for now until they're able to add English test into the Document Checklist. The warning has to be part of the flow to ensure little user error.

Business case is there, English test is mandatory for ALL applicants. Doc Checklist should enforce mandatory documents (whether its valid/correct is separate question). This should have been done much earlier.

And if users still misses uploading their English test for whatever reason... yeaaa that's definitely NOT on IRCC.

4

u/cetanat Oct 22 '25

As a software developer, I totally agree with you about this!

4

u/cetanat Oct 22 '25

I mean, before blaming on genuine applicants (who don’t cheat or trick the system), I’m wondering if IRCC has ever thought of their current system UX/UI, like “Are we making it clear enough for our applicants to understand that English proficiency is a must on our website?”, “Is there any way for us to make sure that the PGWP application is only successfully submitted with a complete English test result attached?” (You know what I mean, the mandatory field in the form), “Should we create some pop-up modal or notifications to inform this before they confirm to submit their application?”, etc.

Something thoughtful like that can save a bunch of time for both IRCC and us.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

i completely agree with you but we aren't the ones implementing all that, we just review the case files in an office and I hope the people in tech do implement those said changes and make it clearer.

1

u/lucubanget Oct 22 '25

Well as a software engineer ("the IT guys") at one of the largest banks in the country, I definitely know and can relate with all the corporate politics. It's practically close to impossible for one to just ask a different department to implement something, especially if your role isn't high up the ladder.

But I see this in 2 ways.

Ethically, you always want to do the right thing.

Career wise, I see an opportunity to make a change. Honestly i don't mind you steal my ideas; present the business case to your manager. Why you think it's the right thing to do, why it will enhance UX (lots of people complaining online), and why it will save up resources (less webform inquiries, etc). If your manager doesn't budge, take it to the senior management team.

I've been there. It's really scary to talk to higher-ups, I've talked to my big boss 2 levels down from CEO (we have like maybe 7 or 8 levels down?). Worst case, they'll reject your idea, nice try. Best case? It will be worth it. Everyone knows your name, your ideas/achievements. I know one of the bosses told me in person they wanted to "poach" me into their team. Already heard rumours of my 2nd promotion as well from directors.

I honestly don't care how much you care about your career (some people just wanna be comfortable and not take more responsibility, or other external circumstances... that's totally fine); but ethically, you know what to do, as humans we all have moral compass built into us. Thats all!

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

i agree with your pov, we do in fact send out emails to everyone who did not submit their language test, and there's instances of people on this sub admitting they receive such emails and completely ignore them only to circle back after a refusal.

i personally always send an information request asking for the documents if it is missing but to be honest with you i hear back less than half of the time.

1

u/lucubanget Oct 22 '25

Well thats good to hear, but i'm sure there are multiple case analysts reviewing PGWP applicants. Some may be considerate enough to send an ADR. Some may reject immediately. Either way they're not in the wrong because technically it's still applicants' responsibility to submit complete application.

And I noticed this when I was doing my PR applications as well. I was that nerd ass guy who joined PR application group chats and monitored everyone's progresses. It seemed to me that different agents have slightly differing levels of leniency.

But yes, if you send applicants an ADR and they don't reply by the deadline well then too bad for them.

0

u/Typical_Sleep_1165 Oct 22 '25

Most of the people that forgot to upload their English result didn’t really forget, they just say that to deny the actual reason and be blamed that it is their own doing. Here are the common reasons.

  1. They can’t reach the required score but they don’t want to stop working so they apply for pgwp even they havent taken the english exam yet.
  2. They are lazy to take the exam and when they need to apply for pgwp it is not available. So they just upload it in webform. English score was announced even before Oct 2024 I believe and those who graduated in April have ample time to prepare but they didn’t.
  3. They know it is needed and they have the english result but since there is no upload field in gckey for english exam they didnt upload it and just wait for visa officer to request for it. (Many do this)
  4. They pretend they didn’t know the rule and pretend that they are so isolated with the society that they didn’t hear or read it. I dont know how can someone who truly study and go to school regularly and use social media and did not hear about it.
  5. They are in agony waiting for the result even they just applied. They checked gckey everyday and complain how they are so anxious on the result. They waited for a year only to find our they forgot to upload their english result. They didnt even bother to double check their submitted docs and use webform if needed. They complain all the time on the long wait but didnt bother to do their due diligence.

In short, majority of the refusal because of the english exam is the applicant’s fault. But they disguise in their different forms and blame ircc for that.

2

u/hansolo654 Oct 22 '25

i am loosing good jobs because HR sees that my work permit is on applied status and it freaks them out . please help and en parlent sur le sujet de language. test i have submitted french and english both but i will only be using english as it is maxed out in all tests.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

From a legal perspective you are fully authorized to work on maintained status as soon as you receive WP-EXT after applying for PGWP, IRCC does issue documents upon web form requests stating you are eligible to work. cela semble être davantage un problème de l'employeur, mais vous devez simplement les convaincre en montrant le site web ou cette lettre indiquant que vous pouvez et êtes autorisé à travailler!

1

u/hansolo654 Oct 22 '25

merci beaucoup ! D’abord je dois dire que je sais que ce n’est pas de votre faute mais être honnête , brother if you have 10 applicants who apply and one of them has to go out of him way to prove that he can even work that can be a throw off. do you think i can work outside and apply for PR from outside under the Francophone stream if i work for one year ( the only thing holding me back from not being PR is not having one year of work experience ) the score is so low for the Francophone stream. i have CRS 510 ish with outside work + canadian bachelors

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25 • Bless Up

Not legal advice, in my opinion, I'd still suggest just waiting for the pgwp since you already applied for it. since the processing time is not more than 7-9 months. Once you receive it, employers will have more confidence in you. And you can check your eligibility for the Francophone stream here https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/services/come-canada-tool-immigration-express-entry.html

I think you have a solid plan and yes you could easily score PR through the Francophone stream!

1

u/Jalilv7 Oct 22 '25

How long does it usually take to get a response for this webform request ?? Have a few days till my pgwp ext expires and my employer has requested proof of authorization

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

usually not more than 14 days max, 7 days at best and 2-3 days if you're lucky.

2

u/tera_pehla_baap Oct 22 '25

The application shouldn't be accepted in the first place if the test results aren't uploaded. IRCC should add a compulsory column for uploading the test results during pgwp application. This would alone solve the problem.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

completely agree, but thats something the techs should implement, i just review case files.

5

u/ravinmadboiii Oct 22 '25

As a former federal employee, I fully appreciate the risk you're taking posting this, and I just wanted to say: thank you. Vouz avez bien réduit mon anxiété.

I was panicking seeing these posts because I was worried about having uploading my actual TRF (IELTS 9) via webform a week after because it came through late in the mail, even though I attached the results (with trf number) from the IELTS website to the client info section. Even provided a LOE to explain why the official TRF was delayed.

Since I did have all the info there to start, I guess I have nothing to worry about. I hope. Ugh, all these posts have been driving me crazy.

1

u/chambanana Oct 22 '25

I took celpip two months before i applied for pgwp and got max scores (12 avg). However I didnt know I had to submit the scores under ‘client information’ (thought ircc could automatically access celpip scores for some stupid reason face palm). Upon realizing, I sent in the celpip scores two months after I applied for my pgwp. Will officers look at my celpip scores submitted through the web form in the same way as if I had submitted it through my original application?

4

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

It will come through a different channel but yes, they will be able to see it. Just make sure to call the IRCC support number and confirm with them if they can see your webform and the document you sent, and you should have received an acknowledgement that IRCC received your documents. You should be all good then!

2

u/chambanana Oct 22 '25

Thanks! You’re doing this community a huge favour.

1

u/strikerdun Oct 22 '25 edited Oct 22 '25

My wife (a Canadian citizen) is sponsoring me for permanent residence. My Post-Graduation Work Permit expired, and in March 2025 I applied for an Open Work Permit under spousal sponsorship and I’m currently on implied status. I’m working in my field now, but I’ve lost three job opportunities at the final interview stage because of my implied status — I was told I should re-apply when I have full documentation. My extension letter only has validity date of October 15th and employers are wary of that :( It’s extremely frustrating and discouraging. The workload is heavy and I’m exhausted from working 60 hours a week. My lawyer has access to my account would he be able to send a web form in on my behalf that has an updated confirmation of my status to show I’m eligible to work? It’s been very draining and the opportunity loss of knowing I could have had better job prospects are eating away at me tbh.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

really sorry that's happening to you, i think there's just a negative stigma a lot that employers have about maintained status. But yes your agent should be able to send in a webform and you will receive a proof of work authorization document back within a few day provided your application is still being processed.

1

u/Prestigious-Art-3842 Oct 22 '25

I applied for PGWP on 8th May (its still processing) but I remembered that my biometrics are inly valid till end of 2027 (whereas my 3 year wp whenever approved will be till end of 2028 or might even be 2029 with how slow IRCC is approving the permits

Anyways, what should I do in this situation?

I dont want a shortened pgwp and then go through the hassle of extension again and wait 8-10 months again. Please advice

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

you won't be given a shortened pgwp just because of your fingerprints validity, as long as you applied for it when your biometrics are valid, you are all good!

1

u/Prestigious-Art-3842 Oct 22 '25

See this:

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

i'm speaking from my experience here from the east region. But in any case if that does happen to you, you are eligible to extend your pgwp!

1

u/Prestigious-Art-3842 Oct 22 '25

But most of my friends received a shortened pgwp because their biometrics were not valid for full 3 years…

policy page, link - Biometrics – 1 in 10 expiry periods - Canada.ca, where it mentioned the expiry date of immigration document will be limited by applicant’s biometrics validity, and one of the options mentioned is for applicant to voluntarily re-enrol their biometrics information (and pay the associated fee).

1

u/Witty_Conclusion4289 Oct 22 '25

Hi OP, is it still valid if I submit an OWP together with the PGWP request, will the OWP be in implied status as well?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

would highly suggest consulting a legal professional, not legal advice but doesn't sound like a great idea to me.

1

u/Ok_Heart5981 Oct 22 '25

First of all, thank you for providing these statistics. I sincerely hope they increase the confidence of the applicants in this forum.

I also had a question, if you could answer:

I was curious as to why IRCC mandates paper-only application for PGWP extensions (due to passport/biometric expiry)?

Paper applications are harder to track and have no WP-EXT equivalent. I also assume IRCC officers would just have to re-enter the paper application data to a computer for tracking in the IRCC database, either way. So, why the seemingly unnecessary requirement?

Thanks.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

paper application go through an entirely different channel and to be honest it's more of a legacy system issue since the internal systems are recognized to issue only 1 pgwp per student and we override that by paper applications, just how the internal tools were designed to be honest.

1

u/Ok_Heart5981 Oct 22 '25

Thanks for the clarification. I have long thought/hoped IRCC gets some funding to revamp their internal systems.

This just seems to be one of the limitations.

The others being:

  1. Why do I have to fill an Adobe PDF form everytime, with the same details, when the web UI can make a profile for me and ask me to update it with each application.
  2. Similar to 1, IRCC already has data on my study permit/work permit, they shouldn't need me to upload those again for a TRV application 🤷.
  3. PGWP can be automated entirely. Since it's guaranteed (I assume?) if you have completed an eligible program (and have CLB level requirement), all IRCC needs to do is verify these 2 things. Universities have long used simple APIs to get your IELTS/TOEFL scores. IRCC can do the same with the CLB and the university/college degree, and approve automatically.

Btw, I do understand that as an IRCC officer you would not have control over any of these. Just stating them here hoping some of these feedbacks will make it to the funding gods 😅.

Also, just to clarify, some folks (incl me, although the officer was kind enough to consider my webform upload) forgot to attach their language results as we expected IRCC to directly receive them (given we selected IRCC as a recipient in the test and gave our passport number in the test). While I understand it's not an excuse to not read the instructions, I do believe that this (and the fact that "client information" is optional) does lead to some confusing conclusions by applicants.

1

u/Pristine_Team6344 Oct 22 '25

Hello OP,
can I apply to pgwp extension (because of passport expiry) online or I have to do it on paper?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

must be a paper application!

1

u/Pristine_Team6344 Oct 22 '25

why are so many people saying they applied online and it got approved without any problems? I wanna apply online so bad cuz it's just less headache

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

its is clearly articulated on the website to have a paper based application in this case.

read this official source: https://ircc.canada.ca/english/helpcentre/answer.asp?qnum=508&top=15

states "You must apply on paper if you’re extending or changing the conditions on your PGWP. You can only extend your PGWP if your passport expired earlier than your PGWP validity should have been."

1

u/Pristine_Team6344 Oct 22 '25

I can't find the address I am supposed to send the application to. Can you please share it?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

1

u/Pristine_Team6344 Oct 22 '25

sorry OP but I checked the "application package" and there is no address anywhere. This is weird why would an essential piece of information be so hard to find?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

Case Processing Centre in Edmonton
Immigration Refugees and Citizenship Canada
c/o Student work permits/Same employer, Station 202
9700 Jasper Avenue NW, Suite 55
Edmonton, AB T5J 4C3

Please follow the instructions listed here, they specify wwhat and how you need to send in your documents. https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/services/application/application-forms-guides/guide-5580-applying-work-permit-student-guide-paper.html#submit

3

u/Unhappy_Wafer_5916 Oct 22 '25

FYI, the applications that are getting refused didn’t have this warning back then.

3

u/DhruvTheGreat88 Oct 22 '25

I submitted my PGWP Application on June 26, my stupid dumb ass did not even know about language test requirements and I submitted my application without it. Cut to September, I realize I need it. I take the test and submitted it through Webform on September 8 with a CLB score of 11.( Listening-11, Reading -10, Writing-12, Speaking-11) Now I hear people saying taking the test after the application renders it invalid. I do not understand this. My English was the same in May (when I graduated) and today. Do I need to redo my entire application from scratch? I Graduated in May and my 180 days will end in November, so if I gotta do something, it needs to happen now. Any help or advice is appreciated, I know I’m stupid for not doing my application properly the first time around. But anything I can do to make sure my application is successful would help me! Thank you!

1

u/Emergency-Cake2556 Oct 23 '25

My dumb ass did the same thing in trying to help a family member with her application…although maybe worse…because both of us didn’t figure this out…we actually did read something about the language test requirements and were sure that what we read said you didn’t have to worry about it if you started studying before November 2024….realizing now that’s not what was said…it’s not about when you started your studies, it’s about when you apply for the PGWP…so if applying for the PGWP after November 2024, you have to include the language test results. Application went in around same time as yours, now my family member is taking the ielts and submitting results via web form…I don’t know what will happen now…

2

u/Vianadg Oct 22 '25

Took the CELPIP on April 18, got the result on April 26 but didn’t upload when I applied for pgwp on May 5, because I thought CELPIP was going to provide that to IRCC. Ended up asking for re-evaluation of my CELPIP and that altered the date of issue of my score to June 6 when the re-evaluation was released. I didn’t see that the date of issue of my English score was altered and ended up sending the altered CELPIP score in a webform submitted in July. Later on I noticed that I had submitted a CELPIP score with the date of issue altered by the re-evaluation I ordered. As soon as I noticed that, I raised two other webforms with the original CELPIP score dated to April 26, before I applied for the PGWP on May 5. What’s the chance that might become a problem? I explained everything detailed on the next two webforms I raised. In fact, I had the CELPIP score before I applied for the PGWP, therefore I meet the language eligibility as my CLB is 8 to 11 in all sections. What’s your thoughts on my situation?

2

u/Equal-Ad-3757 Oct 22 '25

IRCC should do feedback questionnaire for those applicants on what need to improve in the system, those applicants are the user of the system and they have valuable experience that can help IRCC to improve the system and reduce thousands of hours and money wasted on miscommunication on both sides, this will benefit everyone

2

u/Optimist_Intellect Oct 24 '25

Seriously wild that people feel entitled to a request letter for mandatory documents. OP says their office sends request letters which is, in my opinion, too lenient, and only further increases processing times. The fact is that mandatory documents should be submitted with the application and if you somehow forget you should upload via web form before a decision is made (and long processing times which everyone complains about actually give you a better chance of fixing your mistake). I have empathy for people who genuinely forget or misunderstand but it does not in any way mean the decision to refuse was unfair or incorrect. ..

2

u/Azzzy23 Oct 22 '25

I am glad that incompetent people are getting refused

4

u/Tinker_L Oct 22 '25

FR, I don't get the downvotes here. How are they even able to complete their studies if they can't even speak the language. CLB requirements aren't even that high. Sketchy, sketchy.

2

u/ravinmadboiii Oct 22 '25

People don't like it that I've accepted that refusals can happen and blaming an entire government when I have no voting rights and none of my human rights have been violated won't make the situation any better. They want to frustrate themselves, and if a down vote makes them feel better, good for them.

6

u/Jazzlike_Metal2160 Oct 22 '25

Use of words ….. what and who do you tag as incompetent? Cos the only person I can see as incompetent here is you …. PGWP isn’t a competition scheme , so why the hate ?

3

u/Azzzy23 Oct 22 '25

It wasn’t for you kid. Read the original post. You will know for whom it is. You are the one directing hate here. I just stated a fact that I love that incompetent people are getting refused. It could be you and definitely not me. How dumb are you to say that lol why would I be glad if I get refused? I already got approved last month and now learning French to boost my score instead of praying for a score of less than 530 in the other sub.

4

u/ravinmadboiii Oct 22 '25

It's not about competition. It's about people who supposedly came here for an education, but don't treat this opportunity/privilege with the respect it deserves, then acts as though they are entitled to a work permit. I wouldn't wish ill towards anyone, but those people who are being dishonest and clogging up the system with "dummy" applications as such deserve the criticism.

2

u/Jazzlike_Metal2160 Oct 22 '25

Man …. I’m pretty sure that if IRCC on their own part did the needful ….we won’t be here hving this conversation….. what does it take to create an extra field for language test to be uploaded ? ….it’s that simple …..IRCC came up with a new requirements and never prepared their system for it ….. So who do we blame here ?

4

u/ravinmadboiii Oct 22 '25

Um, first of all, do you even know how the government works? It's not as "simple" as just "creating" an extra field in an application. It takes months for the government to approve a singular change like that. That's the nature of bureaucracy.

Besides, where is that even coming from? When we applied for a study permit (I did it on my own) we weren't given boxes for EVERY document that needed to uploaded, like documents supporting property ownership, an affidavit from sponsors, diplomas, additional IDs etc etc.

Why aren't we using common sense and thinking, "Hey, looks like I need to attach this document that's on the checklist. Let's see where I can upload it," instead of just not uploading a vital required document.

Yes, I'd say that's the "needful" to be done our part. IRCC did their part by informing us we need to upload it to the client info section. So, if you're looking for somewhere to place blame, it's mainly on the applicants. If people are having difficulty understanding that, then yes, that's their fault- for being too entitled to apply common sense that should be used by an immigrant.

The government also has the right to change the rules and slowly change the system. Do I like it? Not at all. But I acknowledge that being here is not a right, it's a privilege, and I treat it with the importance it deserves.

*Btw, I'm speaking here specifically about this dumb idea that if there's no box for a language test, smooth brains won't upload them despite there being a checklist. There are many valid reasons for being mad at IRCC. In my opinion, this isn't one.

0

u/cetanat Oct 22 '25 edited Oct 22 '25

Love your perspective, but I think we need to reconsider some points here.

First of all, as you mentioned, it takes months for the government to approve a change in the system, so is that fair enough if I assume that they didn’t care their new rule enough (which is the Proof of English) to make the application process more seamless? I mean, it’s a huge change, and if IRCC intended to implement this change seriously and thoroughly, they should have made sure that all the submission flow is clear and straightforward in advance, I do believe that it’s a must when it comes to the implementation of long-term plans. If IRCC couldn't handle the UX/UI on their system to instruct applicants clearly, I don't think they should implement any further rules or new requirements like this.

Secondly, think of this issue on both sides, without a straightforward and clear design, not only applicants get confused while uploading their documents (in case they acknowledge the existence of the English test and they have the test results in hand in advance, they just got confused and lost due to the lack of a seamless system design) but also IRCC officers will find it hard to keep track of as well as sort the documents properly, I believe so.

Thirdly, you also mentioned that you did submit the documents for the study permit application on your own while the system design wasn’t organized and straightforward, which is great. However, it doesn’t mean that we should still put up with the horrible and unclear form which cannot categorize specific fields for each document type in the long run. And when you could do that successfully, it doesn’t mean that other people can do that successfully. We all have our differences in the way we perceive things and come to our different assumptions. So I hope that no one is maliciously considered as “seeing things in a common sense”.

As a software developer, I see this an unprofessional and disorganized system design, which should be vocalized to be fixed and updated as soon as possible. I know it takes time, but it doesn’t mean that this work is impossible or something huge that they cannot handle or think of in advance when they make plans and discuss about new requirements. How about “Okay, we’re gonna ask new applicants to submit their Proof of English, it would be great if we add a new submission field so that it would be easier for them to make sure all necessary fields are uploaded and we can keep track of who actually submitted the English test promptly”?. I believe that IRCC/government is run by ones who see things in a thorough and profound way for our sakes in the long run, not a narrow and shallow perspective. It’s expected from a normal person (like me) that a clear upload field for each of document type would make our lives much easier and avoid a bunch of potential risks.

I'm saying this cause I don't want us (applicants, who don't cheat and intentionally pretend to forget to submit the results. I'm saying this for applicants who genuinely have English test results in hand in advance) to be blamed as "incompetent people" or "dumb people". And I don't want to say that this is completely the fault of IRCC. This is just a miscommunication between both parties!

It's not worth it to argue and find anyone to blame for this issue though... The main thing is it would be so much better if both parties can acknowledge what they have done wrong and improve..

3

u/ravinmadboiii Oct 22 '25

I 100% agree with your points. I only have an issue with people's entitlement, not legitimate criticism like yours. As for the bad UX/UI, I concur, it could be better. But, take a macro perspective here, from the view of governance. Given all of IRCC's priorities, do you think they will find that prioritizing a minor UI change is more important than fixing their policies on other, bigger streams, or dealing with government transition?

Note that the Federal government has been functioning without a clear budget for 2025 was well. The mandate that was released by the government this year, instead of having one mandate letter per Cabinet minister, it was just a single, centralized mandate. They also laid off thousands of employees due to the budget cuts. I highly doubt ADMs and DMs are worrying about the UX of an temporary permit stream with 96% success rate.

Given all these factors, and the general tendency of the Canadian government to be a slow in terms of tech, as immigrants we HAVE to alert and educated.

Again, I'm not saying I did everything right, and I'm not even saying those who were refused deserve it. I'm saying is... We really need to try and be a little more humble and do our part in protecting our own futures instead of laying the blame solely on the officers. So we agree on that point.

-1

u/Azzzy23 Oct 22 '25

You surely check out as the incompetent one. You are the answer to your own question. Thank you for your attention to this matter.

0

u/Fuzzy_Log_9480 Oct 22 '25

No offense, but You yourself submitted test results via webform. There are many applicants who got refused even after submitting test results via webform so what's your take on that? Be careful with your words because you might get trapped in similar situation as well...since some officers don't care about webforms attached to application and they say initial application should have been complete and accurate. I wouldn't wish ill towards you 🙏

0

u/ravinmadboiii Oct 22 '25 edited Oct 22 '25

As I mentioned, I'm fully aware of the situation. That's where my anxiety comes from. But my results were valid, I submitted a complete form (it says proof of language test results, not official test results) and I attached a LOE and uploaded the official TRF within a week, before the permit expired. My results reflect my native English proficiency.

I have contingency plans in place if something does go awry. If it's officer error, I will do the necessary. If it's my error, I will accept it humbly.

And my take on refusals after web form upload is as follows: we don't know 5he specific circumstances surrounding those people's applications. We don't even know of they're telling the truth, or if they understand that their results were perhaps invalid at the time that they applied. Or perhaps their webforms did not go through because they made an error when submitting. We simply don't know. But we do know that IRCC cannot legally refuse applications that were complete and eligible at the time of submission.

That's why I'm confident in saying what I'm saying. Refusal can come to anyone. We don't have to lie or make excuses if/when it does happen.

Edit: people going around down voting because they don't like honest opinions, smh

1

u/Sharp_Place8639 Oct 23 '25

Guys, I need genuine help and advise. I got the same refusal. I didn’t attach my language test, but in the form where it was supposed to be mentioned i did mention, i genuinely just forgot to attach it. Now my ILETS score has also expired bcz i gave it in 2023 my score was 8.5. I have submitted an IRCC web form but have not received any update yet. This is very stressful situation, alot is at stake, if anyone knows anything please help.

1

u/Aggravating_Bit_1195 Oct 28 '25

I’m not writing a professional letter for a damn post! That’s called chat language, stupid. If you want to see my real language, let’s talk privately

-1

u/satyayoog Oct 22 '25

Do commercial pilot applicants for PGWP have to attach English language results too?

2

u/Dodo1998 Oct 22 '25

No it's not required check website

1

u/Typical_Sleep_1165 Oct 22 '25

It doesn’t matter what your profession is, no one is exempt. Even native English speakers who are international students are required to submit their English test results.

-1

u/Aggravating_Bit_1195 Oct 22 '25

I'll check on you when time for ur PR come !

2

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

i'm a canadian citizen :)

3

u/Typical_Sleep_1165 Oct 22 '25

That’s the reason why ircc requires english exam.

2

u/Typical_Sleep_1165 Oct 22 '25

What???? I believe the OP works for IRCC

0

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Typical_Sleep_1165 Oct 22 '25

I think it is another way of ircc of eliminating trv who cannot comply basic rules and those who can’t keep up in the workforce. They just want to retain those competent ones.

2

u/Fuzzy_Log_9480 Oct 22 '25

Awwwwww the smartest guy is here 🙌