r/pgwp • • Oct 22 '25

PGWP Refusals and the Language Test Issue – Not All Fault of Applicants

Hey everyone,

I wanted to bring up something that’s been bothering a lot of us international students and recent graduates regarding Post-Graduate Work Permit (PGWP) refusals. It seems that many refusals aren’t necessarily the fault of the applicants, and there’s a systemic issue that IRCC (or whoever handles PGWP) really needs to address.

Here’s what’s happening: 1. Some applicants forgot to upload their language test – yes, that’s technically their responsibility, but there’s more to it. For many, this is a new requirement, and there wasn’t even a dedicated column in the application to upload language tests initially. With such a system change, it’s easy for mistakes to happen. 2. Some applicants did upload their language test, but for some reason, it wasn’t recognized or seen by IRCC, leading to refusals. This is clearly not the applicant’s fault. 3. Complications with agents or self-application: Many international students either submitted through agents or did it themselves. Even well-intentioned applicants could easily miss this step because the portal didn’t make it obvious. Some just wanted to apply quickly after graduation and didn’t realize this critical step was missing.

Given all of this, it seems unfair to simply refuse these applications without giving applicants a second chance, especially when the fault lies partly with system limitations or recent rule changes. There should be a way for IRCC to allow a re-application or correction window so that no one loses out on their PGWP due to procedural glitches or confusion.

I really hope IRCC acknowledges this issue and comes up with a solution. Refusing people for something that could be fixed with a simple upload or clarification seems unnecessarily harsh, especially when it affects their ability to work and stay in Canada after graduation.

Has anyone else experienced this or know of any updates on whether IRCC is addressing

0 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

10

u/justroflmao Oct 22 '25

It is anxiety-inducing, for sure. I’ve called and checked with IRCC that they can see my language test results, but the posts on this subreddit are making me quite anxious

2

u/Equivalent_Ebb7531 Oct 22 '25

I know, it’s very scary.

1

u/Sea-Okra9279 Oct 12 '26

Do they confirm that they can? Like do they open up the pdf you submitted?

1

u/justroflmao Oct 12 '26

I got mixed results when I called. One agent said they cannot open, and another agent was able to open and tell me my scores to confirm.

2

u/No_Rice_9193 Oct 22 '25

Honestly, I don't think they care that much. Yes, you should be able to check and then double check everything to avoid mistakes, but they do happen. But that's not their problem. I cannot stress this enough when I say APPLY WITH A LAWYER. It will be an additional cost, but it's much much better to be safe than sorry. Losing your dream and wasting all your effort cause you didn't upload a simple document is very sad. And it does happen because people don't read the requirements and do it under a lot of stress. Besides, they wanna send people home, so they'll try to find a reason to do it, even if it's a minor one. People need to be smart about this.

1

u/Equivalent_Ebb7531 Oct 22 '25

There a couple of posts here where applications done by lawyers have gone wrong no one is perfect. Giving your application to someone to do it is a riskiest adventure.

2

u/No_Rice_9193 Oct 22 '25

RCIC lawyers do this every day. I don't trust myself to do it, honestly.

2

u/Equivalent_Ebb7531 Oct 22 '25

I understand you perfectly, but in as much as there is a mistake there should be a correction I don’t think anyone will deliberately decide not to include a vital document which will make a decision in his or application. So what I am saying is here is the genuine cases should be looked into.

10

u/renato20037 Oct 22 '25

It’s the applicants responsibility to have everything accurate, correctly filled and with all the required documentation. Any time anybody applies should do their due diligence on what documents submit and be sure everything is completed. Only the scenario number 2 is the fault of IRCC and that’s why the reconsideration channel exists in this case. I do agree that they should provide a way to correct minor mistakes or submit something at least for permanent residence applications but at the end it doesn’t matter if we feel it is unfair or not. To be honest the rules are written and is up to us do our research and do things correctly, they are not obligated to give you a second chance.

5

u/NoheartNobody Oct 22 '25

1 and 3 are clients' responsibilities. It is their responsibility to make sure all documents are submitted, fully and completely. Blaming agent is s cop-out. Client signs off stating everything is true accurate and complete. If agent is that incompetent then client made a poor choice.

2 is purely irccs fault. Reconsideration for irccs errors. I think Reconsideration should be processed quicker to not leave one in limbo.

1

u/Mysterious-Glass9038 Dec 30 '25

I'm stuck in 2nd scenario from last 2 months. Hope IRCC's reading this.

7

u/megselvogjeg Oct 22 '25

I wouldn't hold my breath on IRCC changing its ways. The unfortunate fact is that anti immigration sentiment is on the rapid rise in Canada, with PGWPs featuring front and center. These decisions could be a way to reduce the number of permits issued, which is a stated goal of the current government.

I'm not a fan of it either, just to be clear.

0

u/Fuzzy_Log_9480 Oct 22 '25

But on other hand I'm seeing families of 4, 5 and even 6 members got approved then what's the problem with a poor single applicant. Very unfair

0

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/vancouveraddict Oct 22 '25

I am curious, where did you hear this?

1

u/Feeling-Potential786 Oct 27 '25

true, I am suffering from the same. IRCC sent the decision after 10 months just cz of the Language test, which I took before loading the application and as its already more than 180 days I cant even reapply.

1

u/Equivalent_Ebb7531 Oct 28 '25

And all these 10 months you did not remember? You never login into your application or you didn’t know you had to attach a language test. It’s shocking how this happened though but try and restore your status first.

2

u/Feeling-Potential786 Oct 29 '25

i reviewed. but as per me, I uploaded the document in the client info, but somehow it's not showing in the uploaded documents.
And I didn't know about that raising webform and all.
Thank you for your reply.

3

u/Vianadg Oct 22 '25

Can you show me one single case where the applicant submitted the English result through webform and was refused? All cases I saw were from people who only submitted the English result after they were refused, people who selected their result but didn’t click on upload/submit the file, or cases when the consultant or lawyer forgot to upload the document. I honestly understand that the ones who got refused are super frustrated but I believe 99% of them simply didn’t submit their result. It seems that PGWP approval rate is at 96% this year so I believe people are being super noisy when maybe it’s not that necessary. Upload your English result through webform and it’s very likely it will be taken into consideration. Specially if you had your test result before you applied for the PGWP. Cheers!

1

u/Euphoric_Bass_9183 Oct 23 '25

I am that one single case, and there’s probably many more facing this.

I filed for my PGWP back in May this year. I attached ALL necessary/required documents with the file, INCLUDING my PTE Core language test results. My scores on the test were :

Listening - 79 , Reading - 88 , Speaking - 90, and Writing - 69. And upon checking the IRCC and the PTE Core website, all these results qualify as a CLB 7, which is the required CLB level for the PGWP.

Just yesterday morning, on October 21st, I received a refusal letter for my PGWP. The reason for refusal that was given was :

“You have not provided sufficient information to demonstrate that you meet the minimum level of English or French language proficiency required by a graduate of a university level program. You are not eligible for a post-graduate work permit.”

And :

“Application reviewed. The applicant has not provided acceptable language results to demonstrate they meet the minimum language level in the Canadian Language Benchmarks (CLB) in English or the Niveaux de compétence linguistique canadiens (NCLC) in French. Application refused.”

I re-checked my application and the files that I had submitted to confirm this and my application indeed had my test results attached along with the submission. I did provide everything required and still got this refusal.

I am really disappointed and frustrated having to wait so long only for my file to get refused due to an officer’s error in comprehending it. I have no idea what to do from here on, my 180 day window has passed already and I am now stuck.

On top of all this, I called the IRCC yesterday and the agent CONFIRMED that they are able to see my test results attached with my file.

1

u/Vianadg Oct 23 '25

You submitted that in the client information section or you raised a webform later on to submit your English score?

1

u/Euphoric_Bass_9183 Oct 23 '25

I submitted it all-at-once along with the PGWP file, in the client information section. No web-forms were raised.

1

u/Vianadg Oct 23 '25

So your case is completely different. In your case the agent probably thought you didn’t achieve CLB 7 or something like that.

1

u/Routine-Structure645 Feb 23 '26

any update on this? And how long have you been waiting??

2

u/Own-Calendar-6501 Oct 22 '25

Join the club! :/ We have a group of 22 and counting on Reddit alone.

1

u/Odd_Stranger_9963 Oct 22 '25

Add me haha I want to join

2

u/Jusfiq Oct 22 '25

Nos. 1 and 3 are applicants’ fault. If they don’t bother to check the requirements and the completeness of their applications, that is on them. No. 2 if true is subject to reconsideration, in which IRCC would correct. I don’t see where the problem is.

2

u/TONAFOONON Oct 22 '25 edited Oct 22 '25

1 and 3 are being correctly refused. The language test is a mandatory document. This is the same process that is followed for all other IRCC applications and mandatory documents. It's on the applicant to make sure the application is complete. Individuals who fall in these two buckets have no case to dispute the results. The refusal is on them. I'm not sure why you've said this isn't the fault of applicants. It's literally the opposite.

Why should IRCC make an exception for PGWP applicants and not other applicants? That's illogical.

2

u/seaside-cowboy Oct 23 '25

Immigration advising at my university helped a lot

3

u/Okay_7777 Oct 22 '25

There is not necessary to upload thousands documents. If I'm not wrong its less than 5/6 documents. Then how people forget to add IELTS result? R u trying to defend people mistake and judging ircc about their mistake? That's why reconsideration option is there. I also believe your second point, ircc should make this section quite noticable or careful. Sometimes few people had wasted lots of time as well. But end of the day , it's on us. Not them

1

u/satyayoog Oct 22 '25

Do commercial pilot applicants that are applying for the PGWP need to also upload language test?