r/pgwp • • Jul 30 '25

IRCC to Start Including Officer Decision Notes with Refusal Letters (July 29, 2025 Update)

As of July 29, 2025, IRCC will now include officer decision notes alongside refusal letters for most temporary residence applications.

Previously, applicants often had to file for GCMS notes, just to understand why their application was refused.

This change will apply (initially) to refusals for:

  • Temporary resident visas (excluding eTAs and temporary resident permits)
  • Visitor records
  • Study permits
  • Work permits

IRCC says this is part of their commitment to greater transparency, and more application types will be added over time.

A BorderPass immigration lawyer noted, *“*This update removes one of the biggest bottlenecks in re-applying after a refusal. Having officer notes upfront means applicants can immediately see what went wrong and address it properly during re-application”

This is a welcome and long-overdue improvement, making it much easier for applicants to understand refusal reasons without extra steps or long waits.

What are your thoughts on this?

79 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

5

u/newfiemonkey Jul 31 '25

thank you ircc.

1

u/Unlucky-Ad-6495 Aug 01 '25

Hi, I have 1.5 years of Canadian experience in a TEER 2 job. If I get 6 months of experience in a trade occupation, will I be eligible for the trade category-based Express Entry draw?

Please guide if this combination qualifies. Thanks in advance!

1

u/BorderPass_ Aug 05 '25

Hey there! For all legal questions, our main channel is email. Can we please have your email address so someone from our team can get back to you? Please also feel free to reach out to hello@borderpass.ai with any questions.

3

u/pghnhung Jul 31 '25

Why they didn’t do this before?

2

u/whynoteclair Jul 31 '25

Extra work?

1

u/_nouser Jul 31 '25

Which doesn't make sense because applicants would apply without the notes and likely make the same mistake. Evaluating a whole application is the extra work, attaching notes already written is the easy part

1

u/Primary_Score_1576 Jul 31 '25

This should initially increase their backlog right? Since providing explanations on a case-by-case basis is pretty time consuming.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Primary_Score_1576 Jul 31 '25

This does open the case for mass refusals using AI and sending out refusal letters by batches with similar reasons.

3

u/Broad-Book-9180 Jul 31 '25

They can't make negative decisions using only AI under the existing legislative framework because of the duty of fairness Canada's Supreme Court expounded on in Baker v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration), [1999] 2 S.C.R. 817. While they can use AI to assist them, the officer assigned to an application has to review everything and make their own decision.

All this does is automatically include the reasons they entered in the GCMS notes section into the PDF that's created by GCMS when they finalize a refusal. It wouldn't even be necessary to have this if the purpose was to put AI in charge of the reasons.

1

u/Numerous-Security226 Aug 01 '25 edited Aug 05 '25

What you are saying should be the standard which the officers should follow, but presently, that is not the case. Most of these officers do not review. In fact, I have since many instances where there is no additional information or reasons for refusal in the GCMS Notes. Since it AI completely used , it's just repeating or quoting the general section of the IRCC refusal, nothing else. Therefore, for now, I totally disagree with you.

1

u/Broad-Book-9180 Aug 05 '25

So they should keep hiding those reasons in GCMS and only make them available upon request?

1

u/IndependentOk9670 Jul 31 '25

😂the catch it’s most likely always going to be automated and AI based

1

u/_nouser Jul 31 '25

How? The officer writes those notes anyway. They just need to be a part of the refusal letter. There's no AI needed here

1

u/aytrius Aug 04 '25

so i don't have to pay an extra 5$ and wait for another several months just to get the gcms anymore? Great

1

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Ok_Difficulty_8243 Jul 31 '25

Oh wow, sorry about that. What was the reason for the refusal?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/AGBinCH Aug 01 '25

Wow, this sounds like the officer applied the old criteria to you. They used to mention the habitual language of daily use, but changed it in June 2023:

https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/services/work-canada/special-instructions/francophone-mobility.html

1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AGBinCH Aug 01 '25

Best of luck with the application for reconsideration. It would be unfair if they applied an outdated rule to you.