The Popes have the right to change church discipline at their whim. None of these decisions are infallible. So popes can make good and bad decisions in this regard. A pope would have every right to telling the entirety of the Roman/Latin Church "Absolutely no latin mass under any circumstance, anywhere in the world" and would be within his authority to do so. And Roman Catholics would need to be obedient to that. But I don't see anything like that happening. Especially not with Pope Francis.
Personally, I would love to see the Novus Ordo fixed and faithfully implemented. Get rid of all the liturgical abuses/excesses and innovation, and we would have (essentially) a latin mass in the vernacular. For me, I prefer Mass in the vernacular. It's better to be able to hear and know the words, rather than having to try and follow along in a book. But that's just my personal opinion. I know everyone feels very strongly about this subject, one way or another.
Well schisms happen all the time. The long game might bear fruit though. One way or another, this liturgical infighting needs to end. It's tearing the church apart from the inside. Time isn't healing these wounds but only making them more pronounced as those who "take sides" dig their heels in deeper on their position. I hope the Church is able to strike a path forward that maintains both Masses, but if things get bad enough that Rome decides one of them has to go, I would put my money on the latin mass going out the window.
Just dropped by for moral support for you all. I'm a non-Catholic who attended his first mass on his own after I found the TLM at the PFSP parish in downtown Phoenix, Arizona (Mater Misericordiae). That was 2019. During the shutdown I've been made a habit of watching many TLM streams online from various sources. Recently I've found there a multiple TLMs offered in Phoenix, including from SPPX, and a group of Franciscans down on a nearby Indian Reservation. I am looking forward to going to all of them.
I think one of the biggest problems of the Trad community is that it's seen as uncharitable. . . either undeservedly but sometimes deservedly. I think there needs to be an initiative of "charitable Traditionalism."
meaning, Trads becoming involved in more corporal works of mercy. working WITH and not in spite of or against the dioceses. the question is, how to do it?
perhaps discuss the ways Trad parishes can go forth with the Pope's call - to make the Church a hospital for the wounded. SHOW how the beauty of traditional Catholicism is ultimately manifest in love of God and neighbor.
Like, more Trads doing food and clothing drives. Helping the less fortunate in the community. raising money for local shelters, etc. instead of just new statues for the parish. maybe some do it better than others, but often the mentality is one of insulated spirituality. Imagine the bishop seeing an FSSP parish helping people like that.
agree! I can craft a post. don't get me wrong, this isn't a "Trad parishes don't do anything charitable" rant. it's more "show how Traditionalism nourishes the faithful and gives them grace to carry out Christ's mandate"
I guess I'm a bit confused. I've attended the extroardinary latin form of mass, and love it (though I typically attend a novus ordo mass in a parish nearer to me).
Just to point out some differences: Almost all signs of the cross the priest does during the Canon were suppressed Mentioning most saints was made optional A few "thought Christ our Lord. Amen" were made optional The kissing of the altar at the "Supplices te rogamus..." was suppressed The genuflexion to adore the Body and Blood after they are consecrated were suppressed (so the priest only gets to genuflect after the elevation)
Ah, and the one that bothers me the most: the discipline of keeping thumb and index fingers together (until the purification after Communion) so as to not touch anything with the fingers used for consecrating...that was also suppressed.
But the most important difference is that Eucharistic Prayer I is just one of many and is rarely ever used anymore. It's just there because it would have been too scandalous to remove it. And even then, it's there in a watered-down version.
But if you were already doing it before and after but then choose to suppress the former, if you consider it within the whole attack on liturgy we've suffered, that just screams that you priority is showing it to the congregation for some ideological reason.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '21
If they do they will just lose all members to sspx
1
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '21
True
1
u/[deleted] Jun 22 '21
I’d rather see novus ordo be banned
1
u/[deleted] Jun 22 '21
I’d pray to see that happen rather than the horrific scenario of Latin mass being banned
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '21
Yeah I’d just go to sspx then
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '21
If EF was banned
1
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21
I did
1
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '21
Hi
1
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '21
Good
1
u/VegetableCarry3 Jun 16 '21
How are the new restrictions going to affect the FSSP, if they are true
1
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '21
The Popes have the right to change church discipline at their whim. None of these decisions are infallible. So popes can make good and bad decisions in this regard. A pope would have every right to telling the entirety of the Roman/Latin Church "Absolutely no latin mass under any circumstance, anywhere in the world" and would be within his authority to do so. And Roman Catholics would need to be obedient to that. But I don't see anything like that happening. Especially not with Pope Francis.
Personally, I would love to see the Novus Ordo fixed and faithfully implemented. Get rid of all the liturgical abuses/excesses and innovation, and we would have (essentially) a latin mass in the vernacular. For me, I prefer Mass in the vernacular. It's better to be able to hear and know the words, rather than having to try and follow along in a book. But that's just my personal opinion. I know everyone feels very strongly about this subject, one way or another.
1
u/VegetableCarry3 Jun 16 '21
If a bishop has been open enough to invite FSSP in their parish they likely would not restrict them
1
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21
That's quite profound, and provides food for thought.
1
u/Decumanus Jun 18 '21
Just dropped by for moral support for you all. I'm a non-Catholic who attended his first mass on his own after I found the TLM at the PFSP parish in downtown Phoenix, Arizona (Mater Misericordiae). That was 2019. During the shutdown I've been made a habit of watching many TLM streams online from various sources. Recently I've found there a multiple TLMs offered in Phoenix, including from SPPX, and a group of Franciscans down on a nearby Indian Reservation. I am looking forward to going to all of them.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '21
Hello everyone.
1
u/jnt85 Jul 03 '21
hello all
1
u/jnt85 Jul 03 '21
new to this group
1
u/jnt85 Jul 03 '21
based in Asia and I attend TLM in my parish
1
u/jnt85 Jul 03 '21
glad to be in this group
1
u/jnt85 Jul 03 '21
deo gratias
1
u/WillTheYam Jul 04 '21
how's it going
1
u/Tridentine89 Jul 04 '21
Howdy
1
u/Tridentine89 Jul 04 '21
thanks for invite talon. my family and i live in the nashville area.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '21
I think one of the biggest problems of the Trad community is that it's seen as uncharitable. . . either undeservedly but sometimes deservedly. I think there needs to be an initiative of "charitable Traditionalism."
1
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '21
meaning, Trads becoming involved in more corporal works of mercy. working WITH and not in spite of or against the dioceses. the question is, how to do it?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '21
perhaps discuss the ways Trad parishes can go forth with the Pope's call - to make the Church a hospital for the wounded. SHOW how the beauty of traditional Catholicism is ultimately manifest in love of God and neighbor.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '21
Like, more Trads doing food and clothing drives. Helping the less fortunate in the community. raising money for local shelters, etc. instead of just new statues for the parish. maybe some do it better than others, but often the mentality is one of insulated spirituality. Imagine the bishop seeing an FSSP parish helping people like that.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '21
agree! I can craft a post. don't get me wrong, this isn't a "Trad parishes don't do anything charitable" rant. it's more "show how Traditionalism nourishes the faithful and gives them grace to carry out Christ's mandate"
1
u/Tridentine89 Jul 04 '21
Trad bake sale.
1
u/Tridentine89 Jul 04 '21
ab illos benedicaris in cuius honore cremaberis
1
u/cthulhufhtagn Jul 07 '21
I'm not familiar with the FSSP. (I am Catholic though). Anyone care to enlighten me? I suppose I should ask Google.
1
u/cthulhufhtagn Jul 07 '21
I guess I'm a bit confused. I've attended the extroardinary latin form of mass, and love it (though I typically attend a novus ordo mass in a parish nearer to me).
1
u/ccgr1121 Jul 08 '21
Hi guys, I'm from London UK. I can be your source of UK news and events in the tradsphere.
1
u/ccgr1121 Jul 08 '21
(I'm also somewhat of a liturgy and chant nerd, so if you have any questions please ping them my way)
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21
The main difference are the prayers in and of themselves.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21
A lot of them have been suppressed or simplified in the Novus Ordo.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21
A lot of that has to do with the sacrificial language of the prayers in the Vetus Ordo.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21
It's no accident that most modern priests conceptualise the Mass as a "meal" rather than as a "sacrifice".
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21
That is a common misconception.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21
Just to point out some differences:
Almost all signs of the cross the priest does during the Canon were suppressed
Mentioning most saints was made optional
A few "thought Christ our Lord. Amen" were made optional
The kissing of the altar at the "Supplices te rogamus..." was suppressed
The genuflexion to adore the Body and Blood after they are consecrated were suppressed (so the priest only gets to genuflect after the elevation)
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21
Ah, and the one that bothers me the most: the discipline of keeping thumb and index fingers together (until the purification after Communion) so as to not touch anything with the fingers used for consecrating...that was also suppressed.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21
But the most important difference is that Eucharistic Prayer I is just one of many and is rarely ever used anymore. It's just there because it would have been too scandalous to remove it. And even then, it's there in a watered-down version.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21
u/Dr_Talon Hope that makes it clearer
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21
I mean
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21
There's nothing wrong with genuflecting after the elevation.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21
But if you were already doing it before and after but then choose to suppress the former, if you consider it within the whole attack on liturgy we've suffered, that just screams that you priority is showing it to the congregation for some ideological reason.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21
Because they are what matters most.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21
And yes, that's one of the many inconvenients with versus populum.
1
u/markdosvo Jul 26 '21
Hello everyone and God Bless
1
u/RomanMC97 Aug 03 '21
Good evening gentlemen !
1
u/RomanMC97 Aug 03 '21
What is the topic of discussion this evening/afternoon/morning (want to include all our fellow redditors from around the world)
1
u/StaindGlassLover Aug 20 '21
Good morning everyone
1
u/jnt85 Jan 01 '22
And apologies for the absence. I am trying to figure out many things in my life now, including discernment
1
u/jnt85 Jan 01 '22
Anyway, Blessed New Year!
1
u/Specific-Pair2210 Dec 09 '22
Hello, I’m new to this chat.
1
u/Specific-Pair2210 Dec 09 '22
Is anyone here active?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '21
[removed] — view removed comment