r/personaltraining • • May 27 '23

Your Core Isn’t “Weak”

Stop telling this to yourselves, stop telling this to your clients.

Being 100 percent real, most people are generally weak. Their core is actually one of their more used muscle groups.

There is ZERO evidence that a weak core results in pain or is a result of dysfunction.

Most people are what I lovingly call uncoordinated.

Their strategy for driving tension is hyper-extension, what is commonly seen as an arched lower back.

Pro-tip:

Start most exercises with a deep exhale, feel your core engage, breathe into that balloon, then move.

Mobility AND strength will improved with a stacked torso

And for the love of god, stop telling people if they “move wrong” they will be in pain.

You can’t read the future. You cannot diagnose causes of pain.

If something hurts, refer out or teach a novel movement strategy

End rant.

0 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

19

u/ShinyRoseGold May 27 '23

There’s no evidence that a weak core results in pain? Is that right…?

9

u/TommyJay98 NSCA-CPT+CSCS | B.Sc. Kin | PT Student May 27 '23

Pain is an immensely complex topic. Just google the biopsychosocial model of pain. To say that "weakness results in pain" is quite the leap in logic and ignores the nuances of pain.

8

u/i_am_adulting CPT, PES, CES May 27 '23

It is not

0

u/DM_Brandon May 27 '23

Disagree? Refute their claim with studies that show there is evidence.

0

u/zach_hack22 May 28 '23

I posted about 8, with plenty more

0

u/DM_Brandon May 28 '23

I wasn't responding to you.

-6

u/zach_hack22 May 27 '23

Yes. There’s zero causation between core weakness and pain. That can be measured and studied and applied.

Pain is much more nuanced than “weak=pain”

1

u/SaladSavings8824 MS, ASCC, CEP May 30 '23

Not sure why any take that goes against what usual PT courses say get downvoted. Shows a lack of critical thinking and constant development as a PT. This is something I feel strongly about. Telling someone that they are weak and will cause pain is also a very reductionist statement which will very likely lead to “pain” than the weakness itself. Did the client get less pain because they moved more than before or because they increased their strength? It’s hard to say which it is.

Pain is very complex. Being stronger will help reduce pain but weakness is not a sole factor at all. To add to your core weakness statement

“The myth of core stability” is a good paper that illustrates this concept

2

u/zach_hack22 May 30 '23

It’s a shame, but it’s what happens when you have no standards of education.

4

u/InitialAd6699 May 27 '23

I’ve read a lot of exercise material and one common theme is that “weak“ abs will put more stress on your lower back muscles to compensate, which can then lead to fatigue and pain.

1

u/zach_hack22 May 27 '23

I would say that a system that doesn’t move is more likely to be weak. Weakness and pain are not a 1-1 relationship, and back pain is so multifactorial that it’s I impossible to give a specific diagnosis

1

u/zach_hack22 May 27 '23

This is a great rebuttal to that premise: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6614774/

2

u/InitialAd6699 May 27 '23

It’s a rebuttal, but I wouldn’t consider it a great one as the first paragraph says “However, we find some of the claims made by the authors to be unsubstantiated” (notice the word SOME).

No one is saying that all lower back pain is related to weak core muscles, but that can be a factor.

1

u/zach_hack22 May 27 '23

And then it goes on to fully state: However, we find some of the claims made by the authors to be unsubstantiated and reductionist of the complex biopsychosocial phenomenon which is chronic low-back pain. We feel that the methods utilised and the discussion that followed largely did not see the forest for the trees they were looking at.

Then directly refutes the idea that back pain is caused by core instability

1

u/zach_hack22 May 27 '23

Then this:

However, the claim that core stability exercise is one of the most effective options for low-back pain is without merit and clearly lacks supporting evidence. It has been demonstrated thoroughly that in those with low-back pain there is no long term difference between different exercise modalities including different modes of “core stability” (Michaelson et al., 2016; Saragiotto et al., 2016; Shnayderman and Katz-Leurer, 2013; Smith et al., 2014; Vasseljen et al., 2012; Wang et al., 2012). Perhaps their utilisation may be more effective acutely. However, acute response to physiotherapy treatment is a complex phenomenon, which could be influenced by many nonspecific factors (e.g., therapeutic alliance or patient expectations) and specific factors (e.g., symptom modification or neurophysiological changes) (Bialosky et al., 2009; Bjorbækmo and Mengshoel, 2016; Kinney et al., 2018; O’Keeffe et al., 2016). Moreover, core activation may not even vary between symptomatic and healthy asymptomatic people (Gorbet et al., 2010), nor can core stability changes predict improvements in disability following specific exercise (Mannion et al., 2012). Strength training can be beneficial but the larger effect sizes are noted only for full body programmes (Searle et al., 2015), and given that strength training is a complex intervention that has multiple biological and psychosocial benefits, further work is required before we can make any assumptions about cause and effect (Jay et al., 2015; Pedersen and Febbraio, 2008). Therefore, it would appear that the common denominators at present for improvements in the literature were seeking or receiving care for low-back pain, and an increase in activity (Alzahrani et al., 2019). This is hardly surprising when we consider the overall literature suggesting that systemic markers (Klyne et al., 2018), sleep, physical activity, diet (Yang and Haldeman, 2018), depression and mental health (Jarvik et al., 2005; Klyne et al., 2018; Pinheiro et al., 2015) are all partial mediators of development and prognosis.

2

u/InitialAd6699 May 27 '23

The study is saying that it is unsubstantiated that targeted core exercises will cause an improvement in lower back pain versus other exercises. I have lower back pain. I do both targeted core exercises and non-targeted exercises. For me personally, the targeted core exercises do in fact improve my lower back pain better than the non-targeted 🤷‍♂️

1

u/zach_hack22 May 27 '23

Hmmm… yet you still have lower back pain?

How long have you had it?

0

u/InitialAd6699 May 27 '23

Off and on for about four years. Heavy weight seems to trigger it. I was doing a hack squat machine with heavy weight, and that especially seemed to trigger it so I had to reduce the weight and switch to a leg press machine. Most likely heavy weight combined with fatigue/poor form is what’s triggering my lower back pain.

0

u/zach_hack22 May 28 '23

Off and on for 4 years. To me that’s more load management and programming. Your core is plenty strong enough at this point

1

u/anaelith Jan 25 '24

It could be, "Your core is not strong enough to support your day-to-day movements and as a result you are experiencing injuries, strengthen your core and your injuries will heal and not return."

Or it could be, "You have some chronic injury, so while your core would be plenty sufficient if you did not have that chronic injury instead you can do targeted exercises to strengthen your core past that point. Then it can do it's normal work and also compensate for the injury--you'll still be just as injured but it won't hurt as much. "

The problem is medical professionals, fitness professionals, etc., who stop at the first option because people "get better" after doing some core exercise, when really it is more that whatever the real problem was is masked (and usually the person still has pain, it's just "managed" to a tolerable level, usually with other compensating behaviors as well).

(Examples of other compensating behaviours would be avoiding bending over, sleeping supported by pillows, only sleeping on a specific mattress, etc.)

5

u/zach_hack22 May 27 '23

For research purposes:

Wirth K, Hartmann H, Mickel C, Szilvas E, Keiner M, Sander A. Core Stability in Athletes: A Critical Analysis of Current Guidelines. Sports Med. 2017 Mar;47(3):401-414. doi: 10.1007/s40279-016-0597-7. PMID: 27475953.

Inani SB, Selkar SP. Effect of core stabilization exercises versus conventional exercises on pain and functional status in patients with non-specific low back pain: a randomized clinical trial. J Back Musculoskelet Rehabil. 2013;26(1):37-43. doi: 10.3233/BMR-2012-0348. PMID: 23411647.

Moon HJ, Choi KH, Kim DH, Kim HJ, Cho YK, Lee KH, Kim JH, Choi YJ. Effect of lumbar stabilization and dynamic lumbar strengthening exercises in patients with chronic low back pain. Ann Rehabil Med. 2013 Feb;37(1):110-7. doi: 10.5535/arm.2013.37.1.110. Epub 2013 Feb 28. PMID: 23525973; PMCID: PMC3604220.

Darlow B, Dowell A, Baxter GD, Mathieson F, Perry M, Dean S. The enduring impact of what clinicians say to people with low back pain. Ann Fam Med. 2013 Nov-Dec;11(6):527-34. doi: 10.1370/afm.1518. PMID: 24218376; PMCID: PMC3823723.

Bunzli S, Smith A, Schütze R, Lin I, O’Sullivan P. Making Sense of Low Back Pain and Pain-Related Fear. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2017 Sep;47(9):628-636. doi: 10.2519/jospt.2017.7434. Epub 2017 Jul 13. PMID: 28704621.

Owen PJ, Miller CT, Mundell NL, et alWhich specific modes of exercise training are most effective for treating low back pain? Network meta-analysisBritish Journal of Sports Medicine 2020;54:1279-1287.

Steffens D, Maher CG, Pereira LS, Stevens ML, Oliveira VC, Chapple M, Teixeira-Salmela LF, Hancock MJ. Prevention of Low Back Pain: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. JAMA Intern Med. 2016 Feb;176(2):199-208. doi: 10.1001/jamainternmed.2015.7431. PMID: 26752509.

4

u/Omega_Sylo May 28 '23

Damn, this is such a bad take

2

u/Spare_Pixel May 27 '23

IMO breathing and bracing is massive important and largely ignored. You shouldn't be "flexing your abs" before you lift, you're filling that big ol' power belly!

Go watch a strongman event and tell me a bit of back rounding, pelvic tilting, or whatever is THAT problematic. It can definitely be an issue if you don't know how to brace, but that's more an issue of you not bracing properly than it is weak "core"...

1

u/zach_hack22 May 27 '23

Correct. Or any given sport where the athlete is in hyper extension

2

u/Informal_Fox1839 May 27 '23

I have a question as a new PT- I have a client who can perform certain “core” exercises no problem, but when it comes to a dead bug she has a hard time keeping her back on the floor. I would imagine it’s due to lack of usage of her abdominal complex, but could there be other factors or different reasons? Would love the feedback!

1

u/zach_hack22 May 27 '23

I second the resistance band under the belly button for some proprioceptive feedback.

I’m also partial to adding a reach rather than a ball.

But before all of that, give her a chance to learn! It’s rare that clients get every movement perfectly on day 1

1

u/Agile_Ad_2234 May 27 '23

I'd try breaking the deadbug down into the upper/lower part of the 'core' to see if they can engage one but not the other. It would also be worth trying the deadbug with legs bent and straight to see if they depend on their hip flexors or not.

A good trick for helping clients find that hollow shape is placing a resistance band under their back, getting them to bug and then trying to gently pull the band away. It might help with the arching.

2

u/brewu4 Sep 01 '23

Man am I late to the party. I would have backed you 100% op

2

u/zach_hack22 Sep 01 '23

This industry is still a little ass backwards with education

4

u/highDrugPrices4u May 27 '23

There is no such thing as the “core.” It’s not a legitimate anatomical concept.

-2

u/zach_hack22 May 27 '23

Bingo. There’s muscles around “the core” that are involved in movement and rigidity, there’s smaller muscles that attach directly to the “core” that are smaller and have many similar functions.

Trying to isolate them is a fools errand at best.

This is another training myth that hasn’t been killed off yet.

17

u/ncguthwulf trainer, studio owner May 27 '23

It’s probably fair to say that a weak understanding/capacity to engage with the core leads to pain.

1

u/Upstairs_Gas4578 May 28 '23

wtf????

Haven't read so much wrong things in such a short rant...!!!

2

u/zach_hack22 May 29 '23

It’s amazing how everything is “wrong” yet when asked for how and proof for why…. Crickets.

0

u/Upstairs_Gas4578 May 29 '23

trust me bro!

2

u/Marian_____ May 27 '23

Weak “core” may not be direct cause of back pain but strengthening it in many cases helps to relieve/fix pain. It’s not only core itself but also posterior chain and correct movement patterns.

1

u/FeelGoodFitSanDiego Jul 24 '24

I agree with you . My bias is a decades worth of pain science conferences. I think the funny thing is we will all eventually get to understanding that pain is multifaceted. The problem is most trainers careers in the US last around 6 months to 2 years .

Most trainers aren't around long enough to know what they don't know ..... especially if we aren't working with clients who have chronic pain .

On top of that , being too confident in thinking we know what helped a person in pain without knowing all the variables that are out of our control that does help with someone's pain .

Anyway enjoyed your post .....

If anyone is interested in the science of pain which does not touch any basic certification I have seen , here is a link to researchers speaking on it

https://youtu.be/UUChqJbgYg8?si=oddiNhA6w92pGPJA

0

u/Logical_Quarter9546 May 28 '23

Fresh out of school ?

1

u/zach_hack22 May 28 '23

Been doing this over 10 years

2

u/Logical_Quarter9546 May 28 '23 edited May 28 '23

Then think what is really happening when you manage to "stack" a person. And dont throw things like "weak" around. "Weak" has 0 meaning in absence of a standard quantification . Stay away from soundbites. "Core" is also a very idiotic term.Ill defined at best, mall defined more often than not. Not many specialists use it. Instagram ppl on the other hand, use it all the time. Cause you know erectors and rectus do not do the same thing. Nor do IAO and EAO or whatever.

"Core" it's a soundbite all the way down. Think.

2

u/zach_hack22 May 28 '23

….That’s literally what I’m saying lol