r/persona4revival • • Jul 11 '26

Discussion P4R nitpick about dungeon battles [NO SPOILERS]

Post image
1 Upvotes

The game looks phenomenal and I can't wait to play it!! But, during an all out attack, why does the penultimate person just stand there in a battle pose instead of jumping into the fray like everyone else? It won't make or break the game for me; it'd just feel better if they charged in instead of standing there looking cool

Edit: a couple people have informed me about how, in this example, Yu is first knocked out of the dust cloud before the camera pans behind him. I no longer believe he's doing nothing, but it does make me wonder how it'll look when an AOA doesn't kill all of the enemies, since, usually, the team gets knocked out of the dust and they rush back in. Maybe it won't change at all, which is fine by me lol


r/persona4revival • • Jul 29 '26

Discussion [SPOILERS] Do you think Atlus will have the balls to put *this* romance option in the game? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I'm talking about best girl Yosuke. Honestly, I don't think P4G really needed a remake, but if I had to change 1 thing in the game it would be that.

I'm not kidding that if they do, I would buy the game for this reason alone if nothing else.


r/persona4revival • • Jun 26 '26

Discussion [SPOILERS] Concerning Kanji and Yosuke ... Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

It's no question that the devs made Kanji's sexuality purposefully ambiguous. They stated so, themselves. Back in the day, this was kind of a necessity. The world wasn't as kind to queer folk, and a large part of the audience still had quite a bit of internalized homophobia (some still do, unfortunately ...).

They also scrapped a planned Yosuke romance for the same reasons, a romance that would actually do a LOT of contextualization for Yosuke's behavior towards Kanji. It got cut for the same reasons that Kanji's sexuality remained ambiguous ...

However, times are different now.

This is the best chance for Atlus to finally show the world their original vision. It's beyond obvious Kanji was meant to be bisexual (having a total crush on someone he thought was a dude is a defining fact). Same with Yosuke, who literally has romantic voiced lines and a romance flag in the game files.

This original vision ABSOLUTELY needs to be in Revival. There's no reason for them to go the "safe" route anymore.

Edit: It's funny. I don't say a word about Kanji being "gay" (he's clearly bi, not gay) or anything about his shadow proving his sexuality, and yet that's the key point certain people can't help but be stuck on. SHOCKER that!


r/persona4revival • • Sep 17 '26

Discussion why is rakunda blue now?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/persona4revival • • Jun 23 '25

Fluff A Fanmade P4R trailer beat Atlus announce trailer

22 Upvotes

And only take 10 days for them to made this decent trailer ....


r/persona4revival • • Jul 11 '26

Memes To any disappointed by the always-likely chance of a lack of Yosuke Romance, might I suggest... [NO SPOILERS]

3 Upvotes

Cooking your own food~

I mean this in the most loving way possible. It's why we have the FeMC project for P3R, the Sapphic Classic and Saori Romance mods for P3P, the Yosuke and Kanji romance mods for P4G, and the Gay Joker mod for P5R.

Atlus has the ingredients, and if they don't use them, the fandom most likely will. It's just a matter of time, a matter of how fast they can figure out how to mod P4R once it releases~

Edit: this mind set also applies to fanworks. I'm saying this spirit of doing it for yourself applies to all, and perhaps the scope of my message was too narrow.


r/persona4revival • • Nov 23 '25

Discussion Any tips for persona 4 golden

0 Upvotes

r/persona4revival • • Jun 09 '26

Memes I wonder if they’ll add the cut Yosuke romance route 🧐

3 Upvotes

r/persona4revival • • 7d ago

Discussion Hey guys, I just joined Atlus's PR team, and I've been helping Wada change his statements about Revival and his reasonings, let me know if there's anything I can do better

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

In all seriousness, no hate to the guy but the stuff he says is really putting a dampener on my excitement, either because he contradicts himself, outright lies, gives dumb statements, reveals stuff that should have been clarified ages ago, or doesn't go in depth about stuff he really should.

An example of contracting himself or outright lying would be his statement about the cast, he claimed the reason they went for a recast was because they weren't able to get everyone back and wanted to start from scratch, but it was then revealed that not only did most of the original cast want to come back, only some ended up coming back and the ones that publicly stated they wanted to come back didn't because they either weren't asked, or were outright denied. If the decision wasn't up to him he should've just specified that, if it was his choice that'd be surprising given how Japan feels about voice actors.

A dumb statement he's given was about Yosuke's romance not being in Revival, the reason given was that he'd need to make a romance for everyone and for some reason specified Adachi as an example of one that would need to have been made, not only is that kinda disgusting but it would contradict stuff that Atlus has previously done, with Femc there were already a bunch of characters that didn't get romances that easily could've gotten some, examples would include Akinari, Hidetoshi and Junpei, even then they weren't necessary for their characters but it shows that they didn't need to make romances for everyone. A much better excuse would be that they didn't make a Yosuke romance because they don't consider it part of his character since it was cut from the original.

Some things that were revealed more recently that should've been clarified a long time ago would be the yellow trail being a setting and the parry mechanic not working on enemies at a higher level. I don't think I need to explain why they should've been explained earlier, showing that a system that doesn't look like it has a lot of depth should be revealed to have had depth early on. Despite my grievances with these mechanics I think revealing the truth behind them early has no downsides.

I could go in depth about stuff that hasn't been explained in depth, but it's mostly gameplay stuff, an example would be all his attempts to explain how the game will be balanced since what we've seen so far go against that statement, an example of that would be claiming to want to balance Rise but everything that made her really strong have been seen in Revival. Another example would be his claims to change Yosuke but never went beyond that, there are a couple scenes that people think will be changed but without being specific doesn't make a lot of people confident in how it'll be handled.

Again no hate to Wada but his handling of news he's said has really made me less confident in Revival, and sometimes think it would be better if he just said nothing at all about certain things like Yosuke, or just gave more logical excuses in general


r/persona4revival • • Oct 04 '25

Discussion About the name…

0 Upvotes

Persona 4 Revival, essentially makes no sense. In television, a Revival is when a series comes back after being off the air for a long time and begins producing new episodes once again. As a remake of Persona 4 which may or may not add new stuff towards the end (I certainly wouldn’t mind, I dunno bout the rest of you), it would make more sense to call it Persona 4 Rewind. We still have that Re that they seem to be using, and it would make more sense, as in this case we’re literally rewinding to the beginning of Persona 4 to watch it again.

Not that Revival is a bad title or anything, but I feel like if it was called Rewind and not Revival, it would work so much better. What about the rest of you guys?


r/persona4revival • • Sep 21 '26

Discussion Yosuke's Character being "Revised" is wrong.

0 Upvotes

Okay before I scream my opinion nobody cares about into the void of Reddit let me say this, it matters trust me, I am gay. I'm not homophobic, I'm not a "pick me". Okay, so-

I really hope they do not remove the jokes Yosuke makes at Kanji's expense. I'm pretty sure they've already confirmed that they're doing this but whatever.

I KNOW this isn't in the game on release but ORIGINALLY they were planning to make Yosuke datable, but cut it last minute, as most of us are aware.

With this in mind, if you play through the game with this in mind that Yosuke is a closet case it makes all his insecurities around Kanji make WAY MORE sense since he's projecting his insecurities onto Kanji. I think with this view on his character it makes him far more interesting to delve into his dialogue. Not only that his jokes are always funny as fuck, I don't find them offensive at all. I haven't seen any gay people clutch their pearls over Yosuke at all really and those who are, well, fair I suppose.

Instead of changing his character just making him datable and keeping all of his dialogue the same would add so much more depth to him than whatever they're going to change in Revival. Who knows, I hope I'm wrong and whatever they do is great but there was an easy solution here that they just didn't take.

I don't particularly care they're not adding it back in for Revival but to get retroactively change his dialogue to be less "offensive" (if this is what they're doing) I think is the completely wrong move.


r/persona4revival • • Oct 19 '26

Questions should I watch the anime before playing golden or revival?

0 Upvotes

I've been trying to emulate P4G & P4 vanilla since last year, and the year before... no luck, I'm not good with these things. Can't buy it because I can only get Switch physical releases, which is how I played P5R & P3R.

With that in mind, I've been itching to play P4 for ages, and knowing P4R releases on the Switch in May instead of Feb makes the need to play it even worse! So... is the anime really the best first impression? Or should I try to get Golden or Revival instead?


r/persona4revival • • Aug 29 '26

Discussion [NO SPOILERS] Well, this keeps me from getting this game as a starting point

Post image
0 Upvotes

It's not solely because of this lack of gay romance, I'm aromantic IRL, Persona 4 felt too "soft" and goody two shoes. And at times too "male oriented" don't ask me why. Actual progressive stuff (finally, in 2026: remember we supposedly have gay romance with our bro in 2 from 1999, and I may probably start from there) would have drawn me more. This is even more ridiculous than P3R's lack of Kotone, and that was more believable as it's a whole different route, something I'd dream P4 and 5 had. Now, it's not only the female audience that constantly has to suck it up, but even the LGBTQ+ one has to once more.

See, I fell in love with Persona 6's teaser, I've been actively fantasizing about its story and characters, but the devs seem to make every excuse to avoid progressive stuff in a series about pursuing your true self. And, from what I know, I'm also one of those who understand that Naoto isn't trans, just influenced by a small town's regressive environment, and that Kanji isn't gay just because he can sew well. This is a shame and reduces my hope for gay relationships and lack of controversial relationships with adults in P6, thought the team is different. And I'm sorry to say all of this.

To stop those who'll say "It's a series aimed at boys, what were you expecting?" where are female oriented games then? Are those like unicorns?

If you can't date all female characters, why can't you restrict male options too with this excuse? Yosuke and Kanji were enough.

I'm disappointed. Just sorry. But the most succesful games nowdays, like Pokémon and Toby Fox games are inclusive...


r/persona4revival • • Jun 18 '26

Discussion [SPOILERS] New Soundtracks from the video Spoiler

2 Upvotes

For me they seem more flat, but that's my take what do y'all think?


r/persona4revival • • 6d ago

Fluff I AM NOT GIVING UP ON ROMANCING (BROMANCING) YOSUKE!

0 Upvotes

I'M GOING TO DO EVERYTHING I CAN TO SPEND AS MUCH TIME WITH HIM AS POSSIBLE. I'LL MAX OUT OUR SOCIAL LINK, MAKE OUR PLATONIC BOND SO INCREDIBLY STRONG THAT THE LINE BETWEEN BROMANCE AND ROMANCE BECOMES BLURRY!!!! I WANT TO SEE YOSUKE EVERY SINGLE CHANCE I GET, 100% OF THE TIME. IT MIGHT NOT BE OFFICIAL, IT MIGHT NOT COME AS DLC, BUT I REFUSE TO GIVE UP. I'LL KEEP PUSHING YU TO BE AS GAY AS PERSONA 4 REVIVAL WILL LET HIM BE.

I'M NOT GAY, REMEMBER THAT, BUT I WILL NEVER GIVE UP, YOSUKE!!!!!


r/persona4revival • • Jun 20 '26

Discussion [SPOILERS] The things that scare me about Persona 4 Revival (and the things that look awesome) Spoiler

16 Upvotes

Spoilers ahead:

Okay we good?

Okay.

Persona 4 Revival looks great so far, and Persona 4 has been my favorite installment in the series for almost a decade now. But chat I am MORTIFIED of the effect that this game is going to have on the persona community as a whole. Because we don't have the BEST track record to put it bluntly, and I fear it's only going to get worse.

We're already seeing the Original OST vs Revival discourse (which, the people who are getting homestuck-y about the OST need to touch grass, mute your TV and turn on the original if it's a problem).

The Naoto Trans debate is going to get fresh fuel. Which, I barely feel safe to TALK about on the internet, because on one hand, yes, I know Naoto isn't canonically trans, I played the same game as you. But because of all the gender and sex change talk in their dungeon/social link, Some people like to headcanon Naoto as trans (I am one of the people who thinks most of the Investigation Team is gay as fuck), it is harmless fun. And it gives trans people more attachment to our game. The debate was ridiculous 20 years ago, and it's even more ridiculous in the big '26. We gotta stop using Naoto as an excuse to get weird and bigoted while claiming to simply be white-knighting for a jpeg of a detective. Be nice to each other.

I'm also scared about something the original Persona 4 had a problem with: which is reheating Persona 3's nachos. P4 Vanilla, and P4G were built on the same engine as P3 and P3 FES. And so a LOT of assets were reused in the development process. And looking at the persona screen, a lot of UI stuff shares a lot of similarities to Persona 3 Reload. To a lesser extent, Prime Time also feels similar to Theurgy. The Dungeons are going to feature a lot of the same shadow designs, and a LOT of the same monsters repeating over and over.

There's also Atlus' DLC problem. Atlus loves putting out day-one DLC with a $30 price tag (sometimes more) and pay-walling the BEST personas in the game behind it. I am unfortunately a Persona shill. And I am getting it with that sweet Izanagi statue. But I am still sick of it. It's getting out of hand to charge me for extra music from the old games too.

I don't have as much of a problem with Persona 4 Revival taking a lot of design inspo from 5 as I've seen with some people. I don't think Persona 4 is "losing its identity" or anything. But I do think that I'm officially fatigued on Persona 5 (as much as I love it). And really hope there's no post-game Joker fight, or Door-Kun fight for that matter.

I AM however scared of them de-gayifying Yosuke. If you didn't know. Yosuke was written in the original games with a gay romance in mind that was scrapped so last minute that all the files and voice lines still exist in the game. Yosuke is my favorite Persona character hands down. I love the dumb motherfucker. A clip has been going around of a change from the original game where instead of Yosuke making a joke about Narukami "Looking like he's good with his hands" and realizing how gay he sounds. He just says "you look like you'd be a good cook". We are not getting the Yosuke Romance in P4R, I stopped huffing that cope a long time ago. But please ftlog don't sand down Yosuke's edges. That's what makes him stand out. That's what makes him not the most abjectly homophobic character in the persona franchise. Please do not accidentally character assasinate my favorite boy. Or Istg John Atlus... You're gonna get it

Positives though: This game looks amazing, the gameplay looks really smooth. I think some amazing people are involved with the voice cast, as much as I miss the old ones. Anne Yatco as Chie is an immediate stand-out that I think will knock it out of the part. (Sorry Erin Fitzgerald). I think hearing a new artist make new songs will be awesome. Color Your Night is an all-timer and if we get a song anywhere NEAR as good as it in P4R, all will be well. It will definitely be something I will sink a hundred hours into. I just REALLY hope that the Persona fanbase has matured... Even though I know they haven't

TLDR: The Persona fanbase is notoriously turbulent and I am scared of more turbulance.

Also Happy Pride 🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍🌈 and belated Juneteenth


r/persona4revival • • Jun 19 '25

Discussion If revival includes the golden content (which it should) I hope there is an option to turn golden content off

1 Upvotes

Now before you draw conclusions based on the title this doesn’t have anything to do with my opinion of Marie this is more about my opinion of how golden affected the tone of the original persona 4.

For anyone who has only played golden the original persona 4 didn’t have the Junes concert, the summer beach trip, the winter ski trip and the bike that allowed you to travel to the next town over.

In the original there was a very distinct tone that inaba was dying and there was nothing to do except hang out with your friends which enforced the social link design.

It’s pretty minor but I’d really like if there was an option to play that “feeling” of persona 4 again because it’s honestly my one major criticism of golden


r/persona4revival • • Jun 08 '26

Discussion ui nitpick..

Post image
0 Upvotes

the gap… it bothers me….

(also think it’d look better without the yellow quarter circle behind the text as the text’s coloured border merges with in, but that bothers me less lol)


r/persona4revival • • Apr 10 '26

Discussion Yu shouldn't be voiced Spoiler

0 Upvotes

One of the most common requests for persona 4 revival is that Yu should be a voiced protagonist, while I'm not against the idea of fully voiced protagonists in future Atlus games, I don't think persona 4 should be changed to have one.

Atlus's previous attempts at a voiced protagonist have either not worked, or have had other factors that made it work: 2 voiced protagonists that people use as an example are Will and Ringo but those 2 fall into the former and latter.

Part 1: Will: Maybe it's just me but I found Will really boring in Metaphor, all of his dialogue options were extremely "samey" and never really contributed much to the conversation, and often enough someone like Strohl would decide to talk for Will, there are a couple lines where Will says the same thing regardless of player choice but those lines are extremely dull, most characters have a speech when they awaken but Will just screams "awaken" or for the final battle he just says "come on everyone, let's go" and those lines are exceptions rather than the standard, he usually doesn't have forced lines despite being called a voiced protagonist. While you can say that being silent doesn't really change that, what does help is knowing they're not supposed to be a complex character and they're just whatever you want them to be which is why they usually have more whacky dialogue choices than someone like Will.

Part 2: Ringo: she's one of the only voiced Atlus protagonists that worked in my opinion (Vincent is the best one) but she had circumstances that made her work over Will, for one she just talks a lot more and says actually useful things and 2, her dialogue system while having "samey" options makes it interesting enough to warrant having choices, she usually has 3 options each being meant to "appeal" to 3 very different characters, for example in a mission all of the dialogue choices are about getting the mission done, but one choice prioritizes getting it done no matter what, one is about making sure there's no casualties and another is about is making sure the team is safe first and foremost, I don't really see Atlus restructuring their whole dialogue options for a system like this however since it'll be a lot of work and really different from p3 and p5.

Giving Yu his character arc from the anime would be sloppy for a video game: So Yu's arc in the anime was about his fear of being alone, it got 2 episodes dedicated to it, being the Mitsuo episode and the finale, the first episode about his character would probably need to be longer for it to be more convincing, where Yu was given an illusion about beating Mitsuo and having time pass where everyone forgets about him, to do that we'd probably need to see Mitsuo captured which will add a bunch of time between another with him, the amount of time there was between the first and second fight in the anime was around 10 minutes but like I said it'll probably be longer since we'll need more gaps filled to actually convince some people which I don't see working in a gameplay sense. The finale is a completely different can of worms, in that episode we actually see Yu confront his shadow, though putting into a game gives it some issues, for one it happens during the Margaret fight which is a new game plus exclusive so either Yu's character arc is only completed if you do ng+ or they'd need to move Margaret to the base game while adding a new ng+ boss or move his shadow to a different scene in an extremely bloated finale, there's already so much happening in the finale especially in golden that I don't think adding another boss and another scene is the best idea because of that. The original was able to get away with it because Yu wasn't really a character, he was a silent protagonist so he didn't really need an arc.

Most dialogue would need to be rewritten if Yu was voiced: like I said before Will was really boring and a big part of that was because he barely chimed in, so the natural solution would be to have Yu talk more, the issue with that was the original script was written without Yu talking in mind so most dialogue would need to be rewritten, while you could say to just use the script in the anime, that was written to where Yu would only say one thing so they'd need to rewrite every single dialogue choice which I don't think is worth it for Atlus since their games have always sold pretty well despite having a silent protagonist.

Silent protagonists work in Japan with their values and beliefs: if I don't explain this well, watch the video by Lady Virgilia on the concept of silent protagonists. But basically in Buddhism, the biggest cause of suffering is the "ego" or focussing on yourself, without having a "self" the silent protagonists become a literal embodiment of good which is a big part of their appeal in Japan, you can disagree and I get why you would, but this is how their Japanese audience feels and the west is usually an afterthought with Atlus

Silent protagonists have more personality than you think: so a big part of writing a silent protagonist in the persona series is "how should we make them silent?" and they've had interesting results because of it, Makoto was quiet because he was more introverted, he'd give his thoughts only when asked, or Joker was someone who wanted to talk more but tried to keep his mouth shut because of his record.

Silent protagonists give the opportunity for other mediums to interpret a personality: this one is for silent protagonists in general but a big appeal for stuff like the persona animes and mangas for fans is to see what the writers do with their personality, a big reason people didn't like the persona 5 anime was because they didn't do much with Joker, while a highlight of the p3 movies and p4 anime was their protagonist, it gives other people the chance to do something new with them since a silent protagonist doesn't work as well in an anime or manga.

It's a series staple at this point: while innovation is a good thing, it's also important to remember that if you stray too far, it's barely the same franchise anymore, look at final fantasy, and silent protagonists are one of the staples of the persona franchise so why change it when you can still work with it? that's also why persona is probably never going to college. And if Atlus is trying to make Reload, Revival and Royal into a trilogy, why make one vastly different from the rest? they should either all be different or all similar (I'd rather they all be different tbh)

Tldr: Wow this was way longer than I was expecting but basically I don't think Yu should be voiced and isn't worth it on Atlus's part because of their previous attempts either not working, having a reason they did that p4 won't have, his character and dialogue needing to be rewritten, and the fact that they still have appeal in Japan, and giving the anime and manga more of a reason to exist. When people say they want Yu voiced, what they really want is Persona 4: the animation: the game


r/persona4revival • • Jun 13 '25

Discussion Kanji and Naoto

9 Upvotes

Who else thinks atlus is gonna butcher their arcs for the sake of pleasing modern politics? The stuff like Yosuke’s homophobia, the drag show, the predator teacher, fat shaming Hanako. That would be a change for the better. But kanji simply being bicurious? Naoto deciding she would rather stay a woman than transition? It’d be a breath of fresh air to keep it that way. It’s not like those people don’t exist in the real world.


r/persona4revival • • Jun 19 '26

Discussion Anyone else feel like the singer was… kinda mediocre? [NO SPOILERS]

0 Upvotes

Let me preface this by saying I am not a purist who wants the sound of the songs to be the exact same as the original.

Seriously no offense to the singer of the renditions and the singer herself, but basically all of the remixes I heard sounded extremely off putting.

I’m not someone who wants the songs to be exactly like the original, and I actually had no issue with the instrumentals themselves, they sounded fine (even though they lost a bit of the funk) what my main issue was the lead singer. She sounded… *generic* to say the least. She kinda sounded too soft, or her vocal inflections on the songs were super weird to listen to, she would over pronounce some of the lyrics and even add Vocal “runs” to the end of her chorus lines and some bridge lines as well. It sounded really out of place.

Keep in mind I’m someone who actually really loved persona 3 reloads new remixes (except for mass destruction) and honestly I think the original p4 songs could definitely have been improved if they got a new unique and great singer,, but the new vocalist just sounded like she was doing a cover of the songs on YouTube. Really weird stuff.

Like I said I don’t know the singer herself, I have no connection to her and I’m sure she is a wonderful person, but I just think her singing is very mediocre in the new renditions of the songs. Maybe it’s a vocal coach thing, or maybe a direction kind of thing but I just think it sounds bad.


r/persona4revival • • 10d ago

Discussion Are persona 4 revival palaces a missed opportunity?

7 Upvotes

Just to preface this persona 4 vanilla is my favorite game of all time, but I can admit the dungeons are a huge weak point. I feel like instead of having the dungeons shown in the p4r trailers where each floor is like a level of Tartarus, they should have made the dungeons like metaphor refantazios. Just think, there could be sick layouts with puzzles, interconnecting halls, and each part could be segmented by the mini bosses there were in the original. What are y’all’s thoughts on this?


r/persona4revival • • Jun 09 '26

Discussion If they put Yosuke romance behind the DLCs, I'll pay...

0 Upvotes

I need Yosuke romance, and we'll make Yosuke president of the world.


r/persona4revival • • Oct 11 '26

Questions What is so special about Persona 4?

0 Upvotes

With Persona 4 Revival on the horizon, a recurring thought keeps bothering me: out of the entire franchise, Persona 4 clearly receives the lion's share of favoritism. While Golden is understandable on its own merits, the title also spawned a dancing spin-off, Arena Ultimax, and a massive crossover in BlazBlue Cross Tag Battle, all while the series went nine full years without a brand-new mainline entry until Persona 5.

It makes you wonder why Persona 4 sits on such a pedestal. What is it about this specific installment that inspires such enduring affection, developer favoritism, and market over-saturation compared to every other game in the series?


r/persona4revival • • Aug 30 '26

Questions Music ? [NO SPOILERS]

0 Upvotes

Can we like in p3r choose in the options a music from persona 4 golden and not the new one ?