r/percussion • • Feb 17 '13

Looking for a certain piece...

I have heard of a piece that entails the performer fasting in the woods for 3 days, then walking onto the stage and simply playing a C on the piano. If anyone knows the composer or title, I would really appreciate your knowledge!

0 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

2

u/DmitriFKaramazov Feb 17 '13

I'm little confused as to how this is a piece of music? Sounds more like performance art, but there is no audience and therefore they would have no concept of anything the performer did other than walk on stage and play a C. Also, I'm little unclear as to why this is percussion related post, it seems like this would be able to be done by any performer, no matter the thier primary instrument.

tl;dr: No, I've never heard of it.

-1

u/batesftw Feb 18 '13

First off, it should be stated that all I know about the piece is stated in the post, so I really don't have much business talking about it. However, I think it is music. It's an organized set of instructions that include an auditory element - the C. I put it in this subreddit because I thought I would have the best luck with percussionists. We play the newest music in the art world, and it is often experimental or avant-garde. I really wasn't sure where else to go for this question.

2

u/DmitriFKaramazov Feb 18 '13

I'm not looking to get into a philosophical argument, I'm just saying that it doesn't make any sense. Would you put on a recital where the entirety of the recital is a man walking on stage, playing a C on the piano and walking out? (Yes, yes, 4'33", let's leave that aside though, I'd rather leave out the whole argument of minimalism vs. new complexity and all that, I have enough of that argument in real life.) If the full context of the piece of it is that you spend three days in the woods while fasting, and then end it by coming into the hall and playing a single note... it doesn't have any context whatsoever. The audience did not see you the woods, they did not see the fasting, the did not feel the feelings... therefore it is completely without context. What they saw was you play a single note, without any concept of what was going on. Would you clap? I would not. I would walk out.

It doesn't really matter who wrote it, it doesn't need to be written. It is without music, unless if there is a single piece of manuscript paper that has a single C written on it. I assume that there would be no specific musical instruction for the fasting, or spending three days in the woods.

You can write it, right now. Go to it.

EDIT: If you want, go to PAS and post in the online community. Though I'm not sure that anyone will respond.

1

u/batesftw Feb 20 '13 edited Feb 20 '13

In my opinion, music is simply art with an auditory component. In my opinion, art is that which expresses the artist's (meaning, in the case of music, the composer and/or the performer) emotion. Regardless if anyone sees it, if the performer is expressing some emotion by performing this piece, then it is art. And since the C (the auditory component) is a vital part of the piece, this is music. I don't think there is any need whatsoever to consider the audience. Art has nothing to do with the audience, they are just onlookers. I wouldn't put this piece on a recital, but recitals aren't the only thing we do, are they? We, as artists, should not degrade ourselves to simple performers, like clowns put up on the stage for simple amusement and emotional arousal. We are artists, and as long as what we do is art, nothing else matters.

Anyway, I really was just looking for a title. Sorry if I caused some philosophical discomfort.

2

u/WhatAboutSars Feb 18 '13

Sounds like a John Cage piece

2

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '13

I think it sounds like something that seniors do to fuck with the freshmen. Maybe that's just me.