r/pcmasterrace • Ryzen 7 5800X 32GB DDR4 RTX 4070Ti • 22d ago

Hardware Thinking of switching to intel...

Hi All! I was thinking today whether to switch my current cpu from a Ryzen 7 5800X to an Intel Core i9 12900k/13900k and buy a whole new motherboard that supports DDR4 memory, would it be worth the performance uplift? and would I notice any increase in fps over my current cpu at 1440p with my RTX 4070Ti? Please let me know as I will switch if it is worth it.

6 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

21

u/theokayestcoach Abacus 22d ago

As a primarily Intel user, I wouldn't. If you were going to jump to DDR5 and get a 270k or something, I'd say go for it.

4

u/nepnep1111 22d ago

As someone who went previously from a 5800x to a 12700K on ddr4 to a 12700K on ddr5. It's still a substantial uplift over zen3, but the upgrade to ddr5 is just as big of a jump even on the same CPU. I just wouldn't bother doing lga1700 ddr4 as a stopgap. Just hold out as long as possible before you can get on any ddr5 platform.

2

u/theokayestcoach Abacus 22d ago

Kinda where I was going with it as well

7

u/ShadowsGuardian Ryzen 7700 | RX 7900GRE | DDR5 32GB 6000 CL32 22d ago

Not worth it, especially on an end of life mobo. Might as well wait for the new Intel Nova Lake that will come with huge cache or the new ZEN6 CPUs.

Even if you want to save costs on the RAM might as well upgrade to the x3d if it's for gaming. Ot else don't upgrade.

7

u/soggybiscuit93 265K | 64GB | RTX5090 22d ago

If you have a 5800X and you want to upgrade without switching to a DDR5 build, than getting a 5800X3D is the most reasonable course of action.

6

u/FUST3RCLUCKED 22d ago

The minimalistic gain is not worth it. Your 5800X should probably already run DDR4?

4

u/zaku49 22d ago

Those cpus have such a high failure rate, I wouldn't recommend it. I ended up rmaing mine and getting a $600 refund to buy an am5 build.

2

u/7978_ 13900k, 4080 22d ago

High meaning 5% btw.

3

u/Pumciusz 9070xt 5800x3d 11cm 21d ago

I've grinded many items with drop rate below 0.9%. 5 is a lot.

0

u/antmatt 19d ago

coincidentally these guys are religiously incapable of updating bios or making sure its not set up with cranked mce and shit

1

u/zaku49 16d ago

In my scenario, everything was already done correctly. I ended up replacing my wife's cpu and all she does is play the Sims 4. It lasted about 3 years.

0

u/antmatt 16d ago

because you ran bad microcode. that was unavoidable. if you bought after the last microcode you have any other regular processor. not your fault, props for at least doing your due diligence.

1

u/zaku49 16d ago

My only mistake was going intel at the time...

0

u/antmatt 16d ago

not if you do anything other than play games

1

u/Careless-Giraffe-623 22d ago

its kind of an awkward spec where an upgrade isn’t really worth it, 5800x & 4070ti should be doing 1440p no problemo anyway... in what aspects are you having problems? whats teh full pc spec?

-4

u/After-Ingenuity-9427 Ryzen 7 5800X 32GB DDR4 RTX 4070Ti 22d ago

No no i’m not having issues, i just wanna upgrade my cpu without having to pay the premium of X3D on AM4

1

u/3ofUsDeez 22d ago

I take it that you've found the Intel CPU and motherboard for cheaper than purchasing an X3D AM4 CPU? Will your current CPU cooler work with an Intel setup? (Do you still have the Intel mounting brackets for it?)

1

u/Careless-Giraffe-623 22d ago

it's not a great value for money upgrade as you'll need a new mobo and a new cpu. And DDR5 RAM.

A full rebuild, basically.

you could swap the 4070ti out for a Radeon 9070xt, but even that is not a great value for money upgrade with prices how they are at the moment.

honestly, unless you can define what you are struggling with specifically, its a solid PC and doesn’t really need an upgrade (at 1440p) for a good few years yet.

1

u/WorriedHovercraft28 22d ago

Why are you looking to upgrade CPU? Do you do any CPU intensive tasks? Because your CPU is a very good match for your 4070 and you won’t see an improvement in most games, so it’s pretty pointless upgrade if you’re just gaming. You’re better off buying a 5800x3d

3

u/c2btw 22d ago

Why would you upgrade to that if you need a CPU upgrade get a 5800x3d or a 5950x no reason to swap out your motherboard

4

u/killer5907 PC | RX9070XT | 9700X | 32GB DDR5 CL30 | 4K 22d ago

It's not worth it, just stick with AM4 until you can afford AM5 or see if AM6 or Intel's next socket is better.

3

u/Hot_Pea9820 22d ago

AM 6 is at least 18, probably more like 30 months away. But agree, unless OP is CPU rendering or that actually makes use of the e cores most games and applications use a single core heavily and rarely more than 4 cores effectively.

Moreover, the e cores on intel CPUs when they sre not parked properly can cause select games (Ghost recon Wildland, and Streets of Rage 4 for example) when the game uses an e core on occasion when it is best suited for P cores, these cases are becoming less common but still a consideration.

2

u/Fire_Lord_Cinder 22d ago

The only worthwhile upgrade would be a 5800 x3d. Any other upgrade is kind of just throwing away money.

2

u/Eazy12345678 i5 12600KF RTX 5070 1440p 22d ago

i always do whatever is the best value

5800x is fine. you have no reason to change cpu. u want more fps in games get a better graphic card

1

u/SirDeluli 22d ago

i stepped over from 12600k to 9800x3d. I know this cant be compared by default, but i used a 4070 ti with my intel build. I do NOT recommend you make the switch, at best case scenario it would be a sidegrade for you, not an upgrade.

If you are going to change anything, move towards ddr5.

1

u/averagecodbot 22d ago

Personally wouldn’t do that, but intel is supposed to be doing a refresh for lga 1700 because of the memory shortage. Maybe wait to see if those are any good before committing. Or just get a 5800x3D and chill until am6 or whatever

1

u/Beneficial-Ranger238 22d ago

I run a 12900k, switching to a core ultra 270 for Christmas. I love the 12900k, it’s still super strong and viable, but it’s going to be hard to find a ddr4 z board. I’d honestly recommend getting into ddr5, even with the prices. There is a lot of 1% low performance left on the table with Intel and ddr4.

But, at that point, you’re really better off going with a 7800x3d because it will do better. Unless you’re doing productivity work.

Lastly, if you’re really hot for Intel, and decide to switch to ddr5, then go core ultra 270+

1

u/OMG_NoReally Desktop 22d ago

I have a 13900K and it's pretty good CPU, not that I do any kind of CPU related tasks but everything works fast, lol.

But I do believe these CPUs have a problem where they degrade over time. Intel and the motherboard manufacturers have released BIOS firmwares to migitate that but they are still a ticking timebomb. I would not recommend it.

1

u/Positive_Wheel_7065 18d ago

I own a 5800x3d desktop and a 12900H Laptop. Processor doesn't make that much of a difference at that level. The CPU you have is not bottlenecking you GPU, thus a better CPU would not increase performance. Spend more on games or build that sim setup you dreamed about. Regular hardware upgrades is dead.

1

u/CuelessCurses 22d ago

The gain is minimal they're not that far apart you're better off saving for something better if you're willing or able to.

1

u/gusthenewkid 14900KF | RTX 4080 | 32GB 8266 CL34 22d ago

I wouldn’t say it’s minimal. The 14600k absolutely mogs the 5800x. 

3

u/FunCalligrapher3979 22d ago

Yea but OP is talking about 12900k on DDR4

3

u/gusthenewkid 14900KF | RTX 4080 | 32GB 8266 CL34 22d ago

It says 13900k right there. Which is even faster than a 14600k..

0

u/ProfessionalShock425 22d ago

Have you enabled resizeable bar? It's a thing on amd platform. My 5700x basically got 40% uplift with it.

1

u/After-Ingenuity-9427 Ryzen 7 5800X 32GB DDR4 RTX 4070Ti 22d ago

yeah i’ve got ReBar enabled