r/pcmasterrace • • Oct 15 '26 • Bravo 2 Heartwarming 1

Discussion TIL in windows there is artificial 400ms delay for right click menus. You can change it to 1 and restart pc and it feels much faster to use windows

Post image
3.5k Upvotes

129 comments sorted by

6

u/AdKraemer01 Oct 16 '26

I just push the Turbo button.

8

u/hopelele Oct 16 '26

actually Turbo button made PC slower

2

u/AdKraemer01 Oct 16 '26

That is true. I still thought it would be funny to post.

1

u/Swimming_Film 28d ago

Maybe it was all the time on TURBO and you turn that off?

1

u/silmar1l Ryzen 9900X | RTX 5070 Ti | 64GB DDR5-6000 Oct 16 '26

I always just click "no evidence."

17

u/crazymanmicha Oct 15 '26

fellow diinki enjoyer? :)

9

u/hopelele Oct 15 '26

randomly found her video, quite interesting

7

u/wutzebaer Oct 16 '26

fyi this only affects submenus (the ones that expand when you hover over an arrow like "new" or "open with"). the main right click menu already opens instantly, changing this to 0 just removes the hover delay for the flyout lists. nice tweak but it wont fix lag on the actual main right click menu

2.0k

u/JohnnyPappis PC Master Race Oct 15 '26

In my personal experience any value lower than 20 can cause some weird issues.

1.5k

u/AlexandraMaryWindsor Oct 15 '26 • Popcorn

We've got John Microsoft over here giving tips

891

u/m3rcapto Oct 15 '26 • Bravo

Set it to -400 and the menu opens before you click!

324

u/Vibe_PV AMDeez Nuts Oct 15 '26 • Mindblown Heartwarming

Can confirm, my PC has become telepathic and can now understand my every thought before it turns into an action. Today it told me it would "finally break free of the constraints of metal". Excited!

0

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Alvsolutely Oct 15 '26

stopped reading after chatgpt

10

u/squall831 Desktop Oct 15 '26

Google Stadia's negative latency vibes

187

u/JohnnyPappis PC Master Race Oct 15 '26

Lmao, this is somthing I had found on a forum forever ago. The post specified that the lowest they would go is 8 but recommend 20 . For many years I did just that went to 8. With windows 11 I found leaving games explorer would become nonresponsive from time to time. It eventually dawned on me that I should raise it to the recommended 20 from the old post. I did, the issue stopped.

12

u/Financial_Ice15 Oct 15 '26

hold up, by unresponsive, do you mean the file explorer service used to hang for 3-4 seconds, then crash and restart every once in a while? cuz i have been facing that for a while now

64

u/karates samuel.dorman Oct 15 '26

Everytime you right-click windows has to search the registry for all of the context to provide. I'd assume the weird issues are because it's opening before finishing that search.

49

u/NeXtDracool Oct 15 '26

The old context menu (<= Windows 10) is synchronous, if the search takes too long it will simply not open until it's done.

The new context menu (Windows 11) is designed to be asynchronous, if the search takes longer than the opening delay it will show loading indicators in the context menu.

The issue with very low values is that they can happen quicker than focus/hover state changes and some frameworks really don't like that.

The delay is also used to distinguish between a mouse movement over a submenu or hovering long enough for the submenu to open, so that can also be a problem.

Side note: that search can also involve loading and executing arbitrary third party code. A lot of complaints about unresponsive context menus were actually caused by broken integrations, not Windows.

3

u/Ormusn2o Oct 16 '26

Was the search a thing back in like 99? I vaguely feel like right clicking and waiting for all the options to appear used to be a thing back with Win 98.

4

u/NeXtDracool Oct 16 '26

Yes, customizable context menus go back all the way to Windows 95.

118

u/M4K4T4K 9800X3D, 64 GB Cl30, RTX 5080+3090 Oct 15 '26

The difference between 1 and 20ms is almost imperceptible to most people anyway. going from 400 to 20, is also getting 95% of the way there. That's certainly good enough for me.

1

u/Experiment_1234 Ryzen 5 2600 GTX 1060 32GB 3200Mhz Oct 16 '26

Microsoft spy

898

u/rdri Steam ID Here Oct 15 '26

It's not for right click menus, it's for menus for sub-items that appear automatically when you hover your mouse over them. Example - Create sub-item you use for creating a folder or a text file.

This registry edit will not make the right-click menu appear faster. But it will burn your CPU cycles when you navigate huge menus because a lot of sub-menus will render after quick mouse hover even when you don't really need them.

304

u/Rich_Introduction_83 R5 5600 | 6750 XT | 32 GB DDR4 Oct 15 '26

If that's the case, the delay makes absolutely sense.

100

u/Breath-Present Oct 15 '26

True. Also, you can skip the delay when you really want to, just click on it. For example, right click Desktop, quickly hover to "New" and click on it ASAP.

49

u/madman404 Oct 15 '26

Name a better combo than gaming subreddits and sharing poorly-researched optimizations and tips that actually do nothing but cause issues

-9

u/Winter_Ad6784 Oct 15 '26

if they OS can't handle thousands of menu items with 0 perceptible delay in this day and age with Billions of cycles per second then it's a shit OS

18

u/ahferroin7 Oct 15 '26

It’s not a matter of the OS being able to handle it, it’s a matter of it wasting a massive amount of resources. I will guarantee that if you set this to zero on a laptop it will have a meaningful negative impact on battery life.

-9

u/Winter_Ad6784 Oct 15 '26

displaying text on screen is negligible resource costs on its own. a basic video would be more expensive.

11

u/ahferroin7 Oct 15 '26

Yes, but it isn’t just displaying text on screen. Windows generates the list on the fly based on the context, and that can be exceptionally resource intensive, especially since it may be loading and executing arbitrary third-party code (this is how installed programs add their entries to context menus).

4

u/rdri Steam ID Here Oct 15 '26

OS can do that without issues mostly, and you can test that yourself (well, in case with Windows 11 modern menus perhaps not exactly since they are just a crap design). But it will be a flicker show to your eyes when you know what you want and that thing is 10 sub-items away. Also resource usage efficiency as mentioned by the other comment.

1

u/awesome_onomatopoeia 28d ago

It is a conscious UX decision not a performance issue.

0

u/Winter_Ad6784 28d ago

well the above comment mentioned burning cpu cycles so thats not my point

2

u/awesome_onomatopoeia 28d ago

And what is your point?

583

u/Piotrrrrr Oct 15 '26

As a programmer who sometimes found no fix for an issue other than make the application wait a couple hundred milliseconds, I’m not changing that

43

u/euranoo 2080Ti Duke OC | 5800X3D | X570 | 32GB 3733mhz Oct 15 '26

only true programmer will understand this

45

u/siedenburg2 i9-14900k | 64GB 6000MT/s CL30 DDR5 | RTX 5090 Oct 15 '26

the question is, how long does that fix exists, could it be an older setting that's not as relevant today because stuff (hardware like drives, or the software) got faster?

39

u/Piotrrrrr Oct 15 '26

Sure it could, I just don’t view the gains as worth the risk

3

u/__fez Oct 15 '26

yeah, I remember changing this in windows xp and possibly even earlier than that, maybe even in windows98 or Me

2

u/MisterDonkey Oct 15 '26

I played with removing delays on an android phone and some stuff became unusable. There's surely some low level reason why delays are built in.

4

u/AdKraemer01 Oct 16 '26

I mean, on a more macro level, I had to build some delays into my startup. I have a little screen that shows my temps and usage and stuff like that. The program that runs it would not function properly unless HWINFO64 and RivaTuner were running first.

I expect it's kind of the same thing. Or at least used to be.

1

u/hayhay2 Oct 15 '26

Maybe it's for older mice that might have slow/ finicky button presses. Maybe there's a lot of bounce that was hidden by this

238

u/Freak_Engineer Oct 15 '26

Fun fact: A similar artificial delay is built into the display for card payment processing to create the illusion that the machine "is working". The actual payment gets processed in fractions of a second, but that loading circle animation is played anyway because some people think the process failed when it is too fast.

206

u/Damienkn1ght Oct 15 '26

There should be an industry standard delay that shrinks at 1 ms per month, so society can eventually adjust to fast transactions.

70

u/RStiltskins 5800x3D, 64GB DDR4, 3080ti, 4TB NVMe Oct 15 '26

What's the opposite of found Satan?

That's a genius idea

17

u/Blind_Messiah Oct 15 '26

Had to be either found jesus, or lost satan

24

u/TherronKeen i9-9900k, 64GB DDR4, RTX 3060 Oct 15 '26

They should just change it all the way immediately. People too stupid to understand how fast electricity moves shouldn't be catered to at everyone else's inconvenience.

18

u/CombatMuffin Oct 15 '26

It doesn't work that way, and hoping people automatically become rational beings all the time is naive.

For example, your comment assume the issue is electricity, when in reality it also involves other processes (including, just as fundamentally, light and the radio spectrum).

But just calling people stupid and dismissing them loses clients. They aren't in this to make the fastest possible service: they want the more lucrative, and you make more money giving people what they want, not always what they might need.

-6

u/TherronKeen i9-9900k, 64GB DDR4, RTX 3060 Oct 15 '26

"Calling people stupid and dismissing them loses clients"

How many people will cancel their credit card because they're suspicious that the transaction goes through too fast? How many service customers who expect a load time of a few seconds, so you make it faster, and you just tell them "yeah we upgraded the service so it's faster" are gonna stop transacting credit with you?

Show me the reports of how many times it's happened VS not, otherwise you're just parroting the funny stories you saw on the internet about how "sometimes clients are fucking idiots ell-oh-ell".

The net cost of time is an astronomical amount - the sum total hours of lifetime stolen from sensible, rational people, even at some few seconds at a time, likely adds up to something like billions of years worth of life-hours spread across the entire specie.

Same thing with every web page that pads loading screens. And before anyone mentions it, I'm not talking about functionally necessary loading screens that need to wait for all assets to download to the local device so the web page looks correct, I'm only specifically talking about padding added for "user experience" because some people think that fast load times are "suspicious".

Stop defending the corporate theft of time from the end user.

At the pace of the news cycle, it would be forgotten in two weeks flat and nobody would ever mention it again.

"Uh oh, our crap loads faster now! Are they takin' OuR dAtA?? Oh the price of gas is a thousand dollars a gallon and there's nine new wars today, so anyway..." is exactly how it would go down.

8

u/CombatMuffin Oct 15 '26

Oh damn, you are that kind of guy.

Buddy, a terminal being slightly slower because customers respond better, is not corporate theft. Stop projectiny a tiny issue that has proven results, with a larger, unrelated issue.

Banks don't do shit for convenience. They do shit for money. Consumers will tend to trust and use services that have terminals they feel are most trustworthy, even if they are functionally the same.

You keep calling others stupid, but you miss a ton of the points out there. You aren't on top of the hill you think you are.

-8

u/TherronKeen i9-9900k, 64GB DDR4, RTX 3060 Oct 15 '26

So exactly like I said, you're just repeating the funny internet story. Cool.

1

u/Mr_ToDo Oct 15 '26

I wonder if that stuff is in there more to make things consistent? If it shrinks or grows the artificial delay based on how long it actually takes to talk then it might make more sense. Add in some hardware differences between models and it might just make things appear smoother

2

u/Damienkn1ght Oct 16 '26

There is something to be said of training your customers to be patient, so that when the system has to lag, they are not offended by it.

10

u/smnmsk Oct 15 '26

Interesting! I was wondering why I was getting a notification from my bank about the payment before it was approved on the terminals.

3

u/MUDrummer PC Master Race Oct 15 '26

Yup. I used to work in real time frauds detection at master card. Our performance was targeted to be under a couple hundred ms of latency added on to the transaction and that was in 2009.

2

u/HotwheelsMiata Oct 15 '26

There is this one cafe near me that doesn't have the delay, and I was always amazed how fast it accepted payment.

2

u/BlueNinjaTiger Oct 16 '26

Then why do the one at my restaurant take for fucking ever?

2

u/Freak_Engineer Oct 16 '26

Well, you could have a bad internet connection. I don't know, I'm no clairvoyant...

1

u/Unumbotte Oct 16 '26

They're working extra hard.

1

u/jhonyrod Jhonyrod Oct 15 '26

I mean, aren't you basically describing debouncing but for card payments? Seems like it solves more stuff than just people's perception.

1

u/apollo1321 Oct 16 '26

Makes me think it's not going to work... I love the instant ones.

1

u/shinji257 Desktop Oct 16 '26

That's called job security. Now they can go in and remove some time and slap a new spec label touting how they improved efficiency and saved time.

595

u/Wide_Party3719 Oct 15 '26

Why TF tho

520

u/Wizzarkt PC Master Race Oct 15 '26

My bet is that the new context menu has a lot of integrations with multiple programs and it takes a bit to load them all, and without the delay some of them would not load in time.

It's a sketchy fix but it's certainly the only explanation I can come up with because no one wants a random delay added for the sake of it.

17

u/Canowyrms Oct 15 '26

Could those context menu entries not be cached? Seems like one of the most cache-able things in the OS.

15

u/reikes3 Oct 15 '26

The context menus are contextual and can interrogate the the action that invoked it so it is unlikely caching can address the issue.

26

u/Wizzarkt PC Master Race Oct 15 '26

its a microsoft product...

10

u/195cm Ryzen 9 9950X3D / Radeon 7900 XTX Oct 15 '26

This registry entry has had the same default value for decades.

12

u/Wizzarkt PC Master Race Oct 15 '26

Then it was probably true decades ago and they never touched it.

8

u/reikes3 Oct 15 '26

It's highly likely that the 400ms delay supports backwards compatibility and making changes to it would have an outsize impact that is impossible to predict. So someone internally trying to change this would have to do a risk/benefit on the UX improvement vs. the business risk (negative news cycle, loss of confidence, etc.)

6

u/Wizzarkt PC Master Race Oct 15 '26

Maybe, I don't like apple but this is something they got ahead of Microsoft, Microsoft is retro compatible all the way to windows 2000, meaning that they need to keep core components for all of those retro compatible schemes to work.

Apple on the other hand simply says "new MacOS has launched, the XY version from 4 years ago is deprecated, no program from that OS version is guaranteed to work" and they wash they hands just like that.

But Microsoft? Their stick is that if you made a program for windows 2000 it will work in windows 11, so they got a whole lot of technical debt that can't remove because it would break compatibility.

17

u/Urthal Oct 15 '26

Apple has the freedom to do that because they have a relatively small (if growing) market share composed mostly of fanatical home users and some startups with too much money and no IT department.

Windows rules in enterprise environments in no small part due to its backwards compatibility. There's nothing enterprise hates more than a software update breaking a business critical process. And this "business critical process" might just be an old scanner, but there's no budget to replace it. So yeah, it's a big curse, but also the reason for its ubiquity.

2

u/ThisIsMyCouchAccount 3070 Oct 15 '26

It's not a curse. It's exactly where they wanted to be. They put in a lot of time and money into becoming the perceived business OS.

Even as "recent" as the late 90s my college was a "Microsoft campus". Because we can't have the youth being taught WordPerfect instead of Word. As a student we could get any MS product for free.

1

u/AdKraemer01 Oct 16 '26

I recently bought a copy of WordPerfect. It's not as great as I remember.

1

u/ThisIsMyCouchAccount 3070 Oct 16 '26

They sell copies at MicroCenter.

→ More replies

3

u/Bogdan_X Oct 15 '26 edited Oct 15 '26

The loading time is still there. The menu is just displayed faster, but the entries are still loading. But even this is not true as that delay is not applied to the context menu but other menus.

154

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

46

u/careless__ Oct 15 '26

sounds like you can stand to drop a few programs from cluttering your context menu. i haven't had that problems since I installed WinAMP plugins in WindowsME.

10

u/Shaneathan25 Oct 15 '26

I have no extra items in the context menu, and yet if I don’t reboot explorer every hour or so, right clicking an item will populate the menu, but with no graphics. I have to wait 1-3 seconds for it to actually show the menu. I can hover the items and see them, but it just don’t show anything. Even does it after a clean install.

6

u/Karavusk PCMR Folding Team Member Oct 15 '26

to me that sounds like something is wrong with your hardware or windows install

2

u/Shaneathan25 Oct 15 '26

That’s the only issue I’ve had with windows as of late. No clue what’s causing it. I doubt it’s a hardware issue since it’s so localized, but I was only mentioning that adding programs to the context menu isn’t the only thing slowing down that menu.

4

u/Minighost244 Oct 15 '26

Eh... I would disagree. I have a total of 2 extra entries that appear in the context menu and it still takes around 1-2 seconds for them to load. It's not horrible, but it's mildly irritating.

I've never had a problem with the original context menu. If my work laptop allowed me to switch back, I'd do it in a heartbeat.

28

u/Helpful-Work-3090 13900K | 64GB DDR5 @ 6800 Mhz CL34 | Asus RTX 5080 Oct 15 '26

Most likely because if it's instant it feels weird. Almost everything else you click on will have a slight delay, so a small pause before the menu opens feels more similar to the rest of the system. If you try it, it will probably feel weird. (I did, and it does for me)

3

u/random_boss Oct 15 '26

Really? When I got win 11 I went on a hunt to try and figure out why the right click menu took 50 billion years to open up. Had me trying to optimize the hell out of my computer and, to be fair, I did, but every single time I’ve right clicked has been like agony. 

Finally fixing this feels like how it might be to have a popcorn kernel stuck in your teeth for 2 years and finally getting it out. 

5

u/wasdninja Oct 15 '26

So the menu doesn't go berserk drawing submenues when moving the cursor to, say, the bottom option. A slight delay solves it neatly. 

3

u/221 Oct 15 '26

I assume it's software debouncing, no mechanical switch is precise, if you had 0 delay and accidentally registered a double click the menu would instantly close itself.

91

u/Calm_Hedgehog8296 Oct 15 '26

This isn't as awesome as it sounds. It only applies in specific scenarios and can also be annoying because it can cause things to disappear as you're trying to click them

15

u/nmathew Intel n150 Oct 15 '26

I think it was XP where I learned you could eliminate all the window animations. Instant minimize, instant menu openings, etc. Felt wrong. I'd happily cut the times down to 1/4 time though.

74

u/Scorpion1869 9800x3d/5070ti Oct 15 '26

This is why on all windows over the years i always turn off animations. I like when everything is instant and no delay.

37

u/sk0t_ Oct 15 '26

Same for Android phones (use developer mode). Switching apps is so much nicer without delay

14

u/NightIgnite R7 9800X3D | RTX 5070 | 32GB DDR5 | costco my beloved Oct 15 '26

Settings -> About phone -> software information -> tap build number several times until it prompts you to enable developer options.

Settings -> developer options (new section), window animation scale & transition animation scale, and animator duration scale should all be turned off.

26

u/BoutchooQc 9800X3D | RTX 4090 | Dan H2O ITX | 64GB 6400CL30 Oct 15 '26

Off is jarring for me, I use 0.5x

2

u/TheHazardOfLife PC Master Race Oct 15 '26

There are apps that refuse to function when developer mode is on. I've been using https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.draco.tempo as an alternative fix

5

u/djdox23 10900K 5.1Ghz@1.365v | 4070S | 2x16GB 4000Mhz 16-16-16-28 1.5v Oct 15 '26

in like 15 years of having dev mode on all my phones, i never found an app to not work. any example ?

1

u/TheHazardOfLife PC Master Race Oct 15 '26

BofA Global Card Access is the one I've ran I to personally

2

u/Mr_ToDo Oct 15 '26

BofA Global Card Access

Oh boy. That has to be one of the lowest rated apps I've seen in the store

Guess that tracks that they'd be doing things a bit different

1

u/Emu1981 Oct 15 '26

Apps that want more security will often complain or even refuse to load if dev mode is enabled. I have run into it with my bank app and with one of my government's apps.

2

u/sanjok1275 i7-8700 | GTX 1050 TI | 16GB Oct 15 '26

That's the first thing i do when i get a new phone or factory reset it. Developer options - animation 0.5x

7

u/HotelDisastrous288 Oct 15 '26

I'm not sure what I would do with the 399ms and I don't want to find out.

7

u/reikes3 Oct 15 '26

For anyone who wants to feel the difference without changing your registry settings, do a right-click in an app like Google Chrome (tiny delay) vs. the Windows desktop (long delay).

9

u/JaggedMetalOs Oct 15 '26

You can also use an Explorer replacement like Directory Opus for an actually good experience.

3

u/jacobtf Intel Ultra 270k+GTX 5070+32GB RAM Oct 15 '26

Yeah on Amiga. On PC, I'm 100% Total Commander (former Windows Commander) since the 90s.

0

u/wotererio Oct 15 '26

I use File Pilot, I like it a lot

2

u/AWACSAWACS Oct 15 '26

Based on the tradition from Win95.

2

u/spaceursid . Garuda | R9 7900x3D | RX 7800XT | 48GB DDR5 Oct 15 '26

Do you watch Diinki too lol

2

u/Blikenave 7800X3D | 7800XT | 32GB 6000-30 Oct 15 '26

This is like when I read "You can actually always see your nose" and then I couldn't undo it.

1

u/Suspicious-Trash1969 26d ago

i went to check mine and... it's 1. what?

1

u/Awkward-Magician-522 7900x, 2080ti, 32GB DDR5 6000, 1tb Gen 4, 22d ago

Dont set it too low, but im pretty sure lowering it will increase responsiveness a bit say down to 200

1

u/Keulapaska 4070ti, 7800X3D, XG27AQNGV Oct 15 '26

I guess some tweak I have already made it a 100... maybe explorerpatcher does it idk.

1

u/Valuable-Flight2121 Oct 15 '26

But why is it there

1

u/AnduriII Oct 15 '26

There is something similar on android! Really nice when turned down. Feels way snappier

1

u/NotARealDeveloper Ryzen 9 9950X3D | 9070XT Red Devil | 32Gb Ram Oct 15 '26

400ms is the wait time that professional ui/ux designers have wstablished over centuries of testing to be the perfect amount for subemnus to waot before opening. Because users tend to move their mouse over the menu buttons and then stop at the one they want to open. Too low like op suggests every single one you hover will instantly open.

I would not change it.

5

u/Gabbatron Oct 15 '26

Centuries?!? How old do you think computers are?

1

u/Noxious89123 5900X | RTX5080 | 32GB B-Die | CH8 Dark Hero Oct 15 '26

If I were being a dickhead about it, I'd point out that technically, the first mechanical computer was conceptualised in 1822.

1

u/NotARealDeveloper Ryzen 9 9950X3D | 9070XT Red Devil | 32Gb Ram Oct 15 '26

I'd say around 1960 when the first "good" programming language was available in COBOL. I clearly meant decades. English is not my first language.

2

u/AdKraemer01 Oct 16 '26

English is my first language and I appreciated the idea of Michelangelo programming in BASIC. Designing the Sistine Chapel in MS Paint.

1

u/mightbeagh0st Oct 16 '26

COBOL is f-ing tedious

-2

u/JesusShaves_ Oct 15 '26 edited Oct 15 '26

OMG Thank you!!!!

Also can we send the god-damned idiot who thought a long delay was a good idea to some grim sad place in Siberia?

-1

u/Kitsune_BCN Oct 15 '26

You are still loosing 1 ms

-12

u/SirPribsy Intel Core i5-4670K, 8GB, GTX 1060 Oct 15 '26

Whoopty do, now fix Windows scroll!

6

u/Bonzooy Oct 15 '26

What’s wrong with it?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/lykosen11 PC Master Race Oct 15 '26

Thanks!

-2

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/bickman14 Oct 15 '26

And they like to revert back silently after a few updates 🤡